Resources
An aquatic biologist monitors Daphnia magna in two freshwater reservoirs of differing volumes. Reservoir A has a volume of and contains Daphnia. Reservoir B has a volume of and contains Daphnia. A toxic pulse of an agricultural pesticide runoff contaminates both reservoirs, producing identical chemical concentrations () in each. Concurrently, fish predation occurs in both reservoirs. In Reservoir A, the pesticide kills Daphnia, while fish consume Daphnia. In Reservoir B, the pesticide kills Daphnia, while fish consume Daphnia. (a) Calculate the organism density in individuals per liter (ind/L) for both reservoirs (). (b) Compute the per capita mortality rates for the pesticide and fish predation in both reservoirs, and classify each factor.
Answer and steps
Final answer
(a) Reservoir A: Volume ; Density . Reservoir B: Volume ; Density . (b) Pesticide per capita mortality: Reservoir A is (); Reservoir B is (). Because the rate is identical despite doubled density, pesticide runoff is density-independent. Fish predation per capita mortality: Reservoir A is (); Reservoir B is (). Because per capita predation increases with density, fish predation is density-dependent.
Steps
Pesticide Runoff
Part (a): Calculating Population Densities
To calculate population density in individuals per liter (), first convert each reservoir's volume from cubic meters () to liters () using the conversion factor .
- Reservoir A:
- Volume:
- Population density:
- Reservoir B:
- Volume:
- Population density: Thus, Reservoir B has twice the population density of Reservoir A ( compared to ).
Part (b): Per Capita Mortality Rates and Factor Classification
The per capita mortality rate is the proportion of the population that dies from a specific cause:
- Reservoir A:
- Reservoir B:
- Classification: Density-independent factor.
Basis: The proportion of individuals killed by the pesticide is constant () in both reservoirs, even though Reservoir B is twice as dense as Reservoir A. An environmental factor is density-independent when its per capita effect on mortality does not vary with population density.
Fish Predation
- Reservoir A:
- Reservoir B:
- Classification: Density-dependent factor.
Basis: The per capita mortality rate increases from at low density () to at higher density (). A factor is density-dependent when the rate or probability of individual mortality changes in response to changes in population density (often due to predators switching prey or hunting more efficiently in crowded patches).
Common Pitfall:
Do not classify a factor based solely on the absolute number of organisms killed. While Reservoir A lost more individuals to the pesticide () than Reservoir B (), this difference was due to Reservoir A having a larger total population. Density dependence must always be evaluated using the per capita rate (fraction or percentage of the population affected) relative to population density.
Typical errors
01 The student calculates mortality rates relative to volume or total deaths rather than dividing deaths by the initial population size, leading to incorrect absolute counts being compared directly as rates.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
;
- Step 2
;
Correct;
Per capita mortality measures the probability that an individual in the population dies from that specific cause, which requires dividing the number of cause-specific deaths by the initial population size (), not by the sum of observed deaths ().
- Step 3
;
Correct;
You divided by the total deaths () instead of the initial population size ().
- Step 4
Pesticide mortality decreases as density increases so it is density-dependent; Predation mortality increases with density so it is density-dependent
CorrectPesticide runoff is density-independent because per capita mortality remains constant at across both densities. Fish predation is density-dependent because per capita mortality increases from to as density increases.
Because your calculated pesticide mortality rates came from relative shares of total mortality rather than per capita rates, you concluded that pesticide mortality decreases with density. When evaluated per capita, pesticide mortality is constant (), making it density-independent.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly converted cubic meters to liters for both reservoirs.
You accurately calculated the population density in individuals per liter for Reservoir A and Reservoir B.
You recognized that evaluating density dependence requires observing how mortality changes relative to organism density.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou divided deaths by total observed deaths instead of dividing by the initial population size ().
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisConfusing proportional cause-specific mortality (the share of all deaths attributable to a single cause) with per capita mortality rate (the probability of an individual dying from that cause relative to total population size).
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Per Capita Rate Definition
Per capita means 'per head' or 'per individual in the population': .
Always place the starting population size in the denominator when calculating per capita rates.
- Classifying Density Dependence
A factor is density-dependent if its per capita effect changes with population density; it is density-independent if its per capita effect remains constant regardless of density.
Compare the per capita percentages between high- and low-density populations, not the proportions of total deceased organisms.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationCompute per capita pesticide mortality: for A, and for B.
Compute per capita predation mortality: for A, and for B.
Compare each factor's per capita rate across densities ( vs ): pesticide per capita mortality remains constant (), so it is density-independent; fish predation per capita mortality increases (), so it is density-dependent.
Pesticide mortality rate is in both reservoirs (density-independent). Predation mortality rate is in Reservoir A and in Reservoir B (density-dependent).
02 The student bases the density-dependence classification on absolute numbers of individuals killed rather than per capita mortality rates.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
;
- Step 2
; ; ;
- Step 3Correct
Because the per capita mortality rate is identical () across different densities ( vs. ), pesticide runoff is a density-independent factor.
You evaluated density dependence based on the total count of dead individuals rather than the per capita mortality rate. Because the pesticide killed an identical fraction of the population () in both low- and high-density environments, its effect is density-independent.
- Step 4Correct
Because the per capita mortality rate increases from to as density doubles from to , fish predation is a density-dependent factor.
Although your final classification for predation as density-dependent is correct, your justification relies on total individuals killed rather than the per capita rate. A factor is density-dependent only when the proportion (per capita rate) of individuals affected changes with population density.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly converted cubic meters to liters and found the densities for both reservoirs.
You correctly computed the per capita mortality rates for both pesticide runoff and fish predation.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakenone
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou defined density dependence based on changes in the raw count of dead organisms rather than whether the per capita mortality rate (proportion of the population dying) varies with population density.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Definition of Density-Dependent vs. Density-Independent Factors
An ecological factor is density-dependent if its per capita effect (the proportion of individuals dying, reproducing, or affected) changes as population density changes. It is density-independent if the per capita rate remains constant regardless of density.
Always look at the percentage or proportion of the population affected across different densities, never the total raw number of affected individuals.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationCompare the per capita mortality rates of pesticide runoff: Reservoir A () has a mortality rate of () and Reservoir B () has a mortality rate of ().
Because the per capita mortality rate does not vary with population density, pesticide runoff is density-independent.
Compare the per capita mortality rates of fish predation: Reservoir A () has a mortality rate of () and Reservoir B () has a mortality rate of ().
Because the per capita mortality rate increases as population density increases, fish predation is density-dependent.
(a) Reservoir A: ; Reservoir B: . (b) Pesticide per capita mortality: Reservoir A (), Reservoir B (); pesticide is density-independent. Fish predation per capita mortality: Reservoir A (), Reservoir B (); fish predation is density-dependent.
03 The student omits the cubic meter to liter conversion factor when computing organism densities, finding densities in ind/m³ instead of ind/L.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1Correct
You divided population size directly by reservoir volume in without converting to liters (). As a result, your calculated densities are times too large for the requested units.
- Step 2
- Step 3
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly calculated the per capita mortality rates for both mortality agents across both reservoirs.
You correctly identified that a factor with a constant mortality rate across densities is density-independent.
You correctly identified that a factor whose mortality rate increases with density is density-dependent.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou divided individuals by volume in cubic meters without converting cubic meters to liters first.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou did not track dimensional units in the denominator of the density formula, applying the raw numerical value given in while labeling the final quotient as .
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Dimensional Alignment
Before dividing quantities to find a density or concentration, ensure the denominator's unit matches the target unit exactly ().
Write out conversion factors explicitly with units: before substituting into .
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationConvert the volume of Reservoir A to liters: .
Compute the organism density of Reservoir A: .
Convert the volume of Reservoir B to liters: .
Compute the organism density of Reservoir B: .
(a) Reservoir A: ; Reservoir B: . (b) Pesticide per capita mortality is in both reservoirs (density-independent). Fish predation per capita mortality is in Reservoir A and in Reservoir B (density-dependent).
Lock it in
What is the formula for calculating per capita mortality rate in a population?
. The denominator must always be the living population at risk, not the total number of dead individuals.
Similar question
A pond with minnows experiences a disease outbreak that kills minnows. In an adjacent pond of the same volume with minnows, the same disease kills minnows. Calculate the per capita mortality rate in each pond and classify the disease factor as density-dependent or density-independent.
Answer
Pond 1 per capita mortality: . Pond 2 per capita mortality: . Because per capita mortality increases with population density (), the disease is a density-dependent factor.
Two forest plots have different deer densities: Plot 1 has (total deer), and Plot 2 has (total deer). A severe winter blizzard kills deer in Plot 1 and deer in Plot 2. In addition, hunting removes deer in Plot 1 and deer in Plot 2. Calculate the per capita mortality rates for both causes in each plot and classify each factor.
Answer
Blizzard per capita mortality: Plot 1 is ; Plot 2 is (constant per capita rate density-independent). Hunting per capita mortality: Plot 1 is ; Plot 2 is (increasing per capita rate with density density-dependent).
An experimental stream channel has a low-density section (, ) and a high-density section (, ). In a combined stress experiment, heat stress kills snails in the low-density section and snails in the high-density section, while parasite infestation kills snails in the low-density section and snails in the high-density section. A student claims heat stress is density-dependent because it killed four times as many snails in the high-density section ( vs ). Evaluate whether the student is correct by calculating all per capita rates.
Answer
The student is incorrect. Heat stress per capita mortality is in the low-density section and in the high-density section; since the per capita rate is constant regardless of density, heat stress is density-independent. Parasite mortality rate is at low density and at high density, making parasitism density-dependent.