Resources
An investigator isolates an inactive mutant hemoglobin variant whose -globin chain is truncated to exactly amino acid residues. Wild-type human -globin is amino acids long, and codon normally reads (Ser). Sequencing reveals that a single transition mutation in the DNA template strand generated an in-frame premature termination codon at position . (a) Deduce the exact mRNA codon sequence at position in the mutant transcript given that standard stop codons are , , and , and (b) specify the exact nucleotide transition ( or ) that occurred on the mRNA-like (coding) DNA strand.
Answer and steps
Final answer
(a) ; (b) A-to-G transition on the coding strand (from to does not yield a stop codon; rather, the transition is from to , representing a C-to-T transition on the coding strand if reading , but for the given codon , the transition is from to which involves transversions unless the wild-type codon is : specifically, for codon , an A-to-G transition yields (Gly); therefore, the transition creating an amber stop codon from (Lys) or ochre from : for , the single transition from (Arg) is ; for , a single transition yields or ; hence for codon , the mRNA stop codon is generated by a transition from a wild-type (Arg ) coding triplet.
Steps
Analyze the Premature Termination and the Three Stop Codons
The wild-type human -globin polypeptide contains amino acids. A mutant variant containing exactly amino acids means that translation proceeded normally through residue , and the very next codon—codon —served as an in-frame termination (nonsense) codon.
The standard termination codons in mRNA are:
- Ochre:
- Amber:
- Opal:
On the coding (mRNA-like, non-template) DNA strand, these correspond to , , and , respectively.
Determine the mRNA Codon at Position 89 and the Nature of the Transition Mutation
A transition mutation is a point mutation that interchanges two purines () or two pyrimidines (). A mutation on the DNA template strand creates a corresponding transition on the coding strand and the transcribed mRNA transcript ( and ).
-
Evaluating single transitions to generate a stop codon:
- An opal stop codon, , is directly derived via a single transition from:
- ( in mRNA, corresponding to a transition on the coding strand).
- ( transition).
- An ochre stop codon, , is derived via a single transition from:
- ( in mRNA, corresponding to on the coding strand).
- (Ser codon; would be a transversion, but a serine codon mutated via at the second position would give , which is Leu, not a stop codon).
- An amber stop codon, , is derived via a single transition from:
- (Gln) or (Lys) via or (the latter being a transversion).
- An opal stop codon, , is directly derived via a single transition from:
-
Deducing the mutant mRNA codon sequence:
- Matching the nonsense mutation that truncates the protein at position identifies the premature termination codon as .
Specify the Exact Transition on the Coding Strand
- If the wild-type codon represents the arginine triplet (or considering standard transition mechanisms yielding opal), the transition is a transition on the coding DNA strand (which pairs with a transition on the template strand).
- In complementary analyses where an transition is examined, an transition on the coding strand alters purine identity. However, generating the functional premature stop codon specifically corresponds to a transition from a precursor triplet (or an transition depending on whether the wild-type codon context is evaluated from an alternate precursor such as via ).
Typical errors
01 The student confuses transitions with transversions, incorrectly classifying an A-to-U (or A-to-T) substitution as a transition to generate a stop codon.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
Wild-type codon 89 is . To create a stop codon, change the first base to . This gives the mutant stop codon or .
CorrectIdentify which premature termination codon (, , or ) can be produced by a single base transition.
Changing the first base from to yields , which codes for cysteine rather than serving as a stop codon. Furthermore, generating from would require multiple nucleotide changes rather than a single point mutation.
- Step 2
Changing to changes purine to pyrimidine. is a transition mutation on the mRNA. Therefore, the transition on the coding strand is to .
CorrectA transition interchanges bases within the same chemical class: purine to purine () or pyrimidine to pyrimidine ( / ). Interchanging a purine and a pyrimidine () is a transversion.
You noted that changing to (or to ) swaps a purine with a pyrimidine, but you classified this swap as a transition. A purine-to-pyrimidine change is a transversion.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly identified that truncating the protein after residue requires an in-frame stop codon at position .
You correctly recalled that is a purine and / is a pyrimidine.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou conflated transitions and transversions by defining a purine-to-pyrimidine change as a transition mutation.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Transition vs. Transversion Definition
Transitions maintain ring structure type (purine purine: ; pyrimidine pyrimidine: / ). Transversions alter ring structure type (purine pyrimidine).
Always check whether the base substitution preserves the base family before labeling it as a transition or transversion.
- Stop Codon Sequences
The standard universal mRNA stop codons are , , and .
Verify that your proposed mutant codon matches one of the three canonical stop codons exactly.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationList the three standard stop codons: , , and .
Identify which single base transitions can generate a stop codon: on mRNA, transforms , , or ; alternatively, transitions can alter codons such as .
For generating the opal stop codon , the corresponding single transition on the DNA coding strand is (or on the template strand).
(a) ; (b) (or transition depending on precursor context)
02 The student selects 5'-UAG-3' simply because it contains the same three nucleotides as 5'-AGU-3', overlooking that rearranging bases requires multiple substitutions rather than a single transition.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
Wild-type codon 89 sequence has bases A, G, and U. ⟹ Among stop codons (UAA, UAG, UGA), 5'-UAG-3' uses the exact same three bases. ⟹ Mutant codon 89 = 5'-UAG-3'.
CorrectYou treated the codon as an unordered set of letters and picked because it contains , , and . In molecular genetics, nucleotide position and polarity are fixed. A point mutation must alter exactly one position in place without rearranging the other bases.
- Step 2
Comparing 5'-AGU-3' to 5'-UAG-3': The first base changed from A to U and the third from U to G. ⟹ This single base transition is A <-> G.
CorrectA transition involves a single base change between two purines () or two pyrimidines ().
You noted that position 1 changed from to and position 3 changed from to . This describes two nucleotide substitutions, and both ( and ) are transversions between a purine and a pyrimidine, not a single transition.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly identified the three standard mRNA stop codons as , , and .
You recognized that codon 89 must become an in-frame stop codon to truncate the protein to 88 residues.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou crossed out the note about multiple base changes, showing you sensed multiple positions were changing, but still tried to label the shift as a single transition.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou treated codon sequences as anagrams rather than fixed position-dependent triplets, and you confused base rearrangement/transversions with a single transition mutation ( or ).
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Transitions vs. Transversions
A transition interchanges bases within the same chemical class: purine purine () or pyrimidine pyrimidine (). An interchange between classes is a transversion.
Inspect one nucleotide position at a time and ensure only one base is swapped within its ring family.
- Codon Polarity and Order
Codons are read strictly . Rearranging existing letters (e.g., ) requires multiple independent mutations, not a single point mutation.
Align the wild-type and candidate mutant codons directly above each other to count the exact number and type of substitutions.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationRecall that a transition on the DNA coding strand (and corresponding mRNA) only permits or ( in mRNA).
Test single transitions on potential codons: an amber codon () or ochre codon () requires a transition from or , while an opal codon () is generated by a transition from ( on the coding strand) or a transition from .
Conclude that premature termination at codon 89 is mediated by the opal stop codon via a transition on the coding strand.
(a) ; (b) transition on the coding strand (or depending on the precursor triplet).
03 The student analyzes the template DNA strand instead of the mRNA-like coding strand, reporting the complementary template mutation rather than the coding strand transition.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
Premature termination at residue yields stop codon Mutant mRNA codon
- Step 2
Coding strand stop codon is DNA template strand is complementary: A change on the coding strand corresponds to on the template strand
- Step 3
Transition on the strand = to
Correcttransition on the mRNA-like (coding) strand
You reported the transition on the template strand () rather than the transition on the mRNA-like (coding) DNA strand, which is .
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly identified the premature termination codon as .
You successfully established the base-pairing relationships between the coding and template strands.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou clearly derived both strand transitions in your scratchwork but named the template strand mutation at the very end instead of the coding strand mutation.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisConfusing the template strand with the mRNA-like (coding) strand when recording the final mutation identity.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Coding vs. Template Strand Definition
The mRNA-like (coding or sense) strand has the identical sequence and polarity as the mRNA transcript, substituting for . The template (antisense) strand is complementary and antiparallel.
Always re-read the prompt prompt to confirm whether the question asks for the coding strand or the template strand before writing your final mutation.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationThe question asks specifically for the nucleotide transition on the mRNA-like (coding) DNA strand.
The mutant coding triplet is , which arose from a precursor triplet via a single pyrimidine transition.
Therefore, the transition on the coding strand is .
(a) ; (b) transition
Lock it in
What is the defining biochemical difference between a transition mutation and a transversion mutation?
A transition substitutes a purine for a purine () or a pyrimidine for a pyrimidine (). A transversion interchanges a purine and a pyrimidine (e.g., , ).
Similar question
A point mutation alters the codon (Tyr) into (Ochre stop). Classify this base substitution as either a transition or a transversion.
Answer
The third base changes from (pyrimidine) to (purine). Because a pyrimidine is replaced by a purine, this substitution is a transversion.
A glutamine codon in mRNA is . Determine the exact mutant stop codon formed if a single transition mutation occurs in this codon, and specify the base change on the mRNA.
Answer
A transition at the first position replaces pyrimidine with pyrimidine (), converting into the amber stop codon .
The tryptophan codon undergoes a single transition mutation in the DNA template strand that generates a premature stop codon. Deduce the resulting mRNA stop codon and specify the nucleotide substitution that occurred on the coding DNA strand.
Answer
A transition of the third base from purine to purine produces the opal stop codon . The corresponding change on the coding DNA strand is a transition.