Resources

A population geneticist models the dynamics of sickle-cell anemia in an endemic malaria region governed by alleles AA (normal hemoglobin) and SS (sickle hemoglobin). The relative fitness values of the genotypes are measured as wAA=0.88w_{AA} = 0.88, wAS=1.00w_{AS} = 1.00, and wSS=0.12w_{SS} = 0.12. A student attempts to calculate the equilibrium frequency of the SS allele using the selection coefficient formula q^=s1s1+s2\hat{q} = \frac{s_1}{s_1 + s_2}, where s1=1−wAAs_1 = 1 - w_{AA} and s2=1−wSSs_2 = 1 - w_{SS}. However, the student confuses the reference genotype, defining selection coefficients as s1=wAS−wAAs_1 = w_{AS} - w_{AA} and mistakenly setting s2=wAA−wSSs_2 = w_{AA} - w_{SS}. (a) State the correct selection coefficients s1s_1 and s2s_2 measuring selection against homozygotes relative to the heterozygous optimum wAS=1.00w_{AS} = 1.00. (b) Calculate the true equilibrium frequency q^\hat{q} of allele SS. (c) Determine the numerical error magnitude ∣q^err−q^∣|\hat{q}_{\text{err}} - \hat{q}| produced by the student's sign-and-reference convention reversal.

Answer and steps

Final answer

(a) s1=1−0.88=0.12s_1 = 1 - 0.88 = 0.12 and s2=1−0.12=0.88s_2 = 1 - 0.12 = 0.88; (b) True q^=0.120.12+0.88=0.120\hat{q} = \frac{0.12}{0.12 + 0.88} = 0.120; (c) Erroneous q^err=0.120.12+0.76=0.120.88≈0.136\hat{q}_{\text{err}} = \frac{0.12}{0.12 + 0.76} = \frac{0.12}{0.88} \approx 0.136, yielding an absolute error of ∣0.1364−0.1200∣=0.0164|0.1364 - 0.1200| = 0.0164 (or 0.0160.016).

Steps

Part (a): Selection Coefficients Relative to the Heterozygote

In models of balancing selection with heterozygote advantage (overdominance), relative fitness values are scaled to the fittest genotype, which is the heterozygote ASAS (wAS=1.00w_{AS} = 1.00). The selection coefficients (s1s_1 and s2s_2) quantify the reduction in fitness of each homozygote compared to this optimal heterozygous genotype:

  • For genotype AAAA: s1=1−wAA=1.00−0.88=0.12s_1 = 1 - w_{AA} = 1.00 - 0.88 = 0.12
  • For genotype SSSS: s2=1−wSS=1.00−0.12=0.88s_2 = 1 - w_{SS} = 1.00 - 0.12 = 0.88

Part (b): True Equilibrium Frequency of Allele SS

Under balancing selection, the allele frequencies stabilize at a stable polymorphic equilibrium where allele frequency changes cease (Δq=0\Delta q = 0). The equilibrium frequency q^\hat{q} of allele SS is inversely proportional to its homozygous fitness penalty relative to the total homozygous fitness loss:

q^=s1s1+s2\hat{q} = \frac{s_1}{s_1 + s_2}

Substitute the correct selection coefficients:

q^=0.120.12+0.88=0.121.00=0.120\hat{q} = \frac{0.12}{0.12 + 0.88} = \frac{0.12}{1.00} = 0.120


Part (c): Numerical Error Magnitude

  1. Calculate the Student's Erroneous Coefficients:

    • The student correctly found s1=wAS−wAA=1.00−0.88=0.12s_1 = w_{AS} - w_{AA} = 1.00 - 0.88 = 0.12.
    • However, the student incorrectly took the reference for s2s_2 relative to wAAw_{AA} instead of wASw_{AS}: s2,err=wAA−wSS=0.88−0.12=0.76s_{2,\text{err}} = w_{AA} - w_{SS} = 0.88 - 0.12 = 0.76
  2. Calculate the Erroneous Equilibrium Frequency (q^err\hat{q}_{\text{err}}): q^err=s1s1+s2,err=0.120.12+0.76=0.120.88=322≈0.1364\hat{q}_{\text{err}} = \frac{s_1}{s_1 + s_{2,\text{err}}} = \frac{0.12}{0.12 + 0.76} = \frac{0.12}{0.88} = \frac{3}{22} \approx 0.1364
  3. Determine the Magnitude of Error: The absolute numerical error between the incorrect estimate and the true equilibrium value is:

    ∣q^err−q^∣=∣0.1364−0.1200∣≈0.0164(or 0.016)|\hat{q}_{\text{err}} - \hat{q}| = |0.1364 - 0.1200| \approx 0.0164 \quad (\text{or } 0.016)

Pitfall Note: Selection coefficients in heterozygote advantage must always compare each homozygote directly to the heterozygous benchmark (wHet=1.0w_{\text{Het}} = 1.0), never between the two homozygotes themselves. Comparing wAAw_{AA} to wSSw_{SS} artificially reduces the perceived selective penalty against the deleterious homozygote SSSS, resulting in an overestimation of the sickle allele's equilibrium frequency.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student inverts the formula for allele S by using s₂ in the numerator instead of s₁, calculating the equilibrium frequency of allele A instead.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    s1=1−0.88=0.12  ⟹  s2=1−0.12=0.88s_1 = 1 - 0.88 = 0.12 \implies s_2 = 1 - 0.12 = 0.88

  2. Step 2

    q^=s2s1+s2  ⟹  q^=0.880.12+0.88=0.88\hat{q} = \frac{s_2}{s_1 + s_2} \implies \hat{q} = \frac{0.88}{0.12 + 0.88} = 0.88

    Correct

    q^=s1s1+s2=0.120.12+0.88=0.120\hat{q} = \frac{s_1}{s_1 + s_2} = \frac{0.12}{0.12 + 0.88} = 0.120

    You placed s2s_2 in the numerator instead of s1s_1. In balancing selection, the equilibrium frequency of allele SS is q^=s1s1+s2\hat{q} = \frac{s_1}{s_1 + s_2} (proportional to the selection coefficient against the opposite homozygote AAAA), whereas s2s1+s2\frac{s_2}{s_1 + s_2} gives the equilibrium frequency of allele AA (p^\hat{p}).

  3. Step 3

    s2err=0.88−0.12=0.76  ⟹  q^err=0.120.12+0.76=0.120.88≈0.1364s_{2\text{err}} = 0.88 - 0.12 = 0.76 \implies \hat{q}_{\text{err}} = \frac{0.12}{0.12 + 0.76} = \frac{0.12}{0.88} \approx 0.1364

  4. Step 4

    ∣q^err−q^∣=∣0.1364−0.88∣=0.7436|\hat{q}_{\text{err}} - \hat{q}| = |0.1364 - 0.88| = 0.7436

    Correct

    ∣q^err−q^∣=∣0.1364−0.1200∣≈0.0164|\hat{q}_{\text{err}} - \hat{q}| = |0.1364 - 0.1200| \approx 0.0164

    Your arithmetic was carried out correctly based on your previous values, but substituting the incorrect q^=0.88\hat{q} = 0.88 from Step 2 yielded an inflated difference.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly calculated the selection coefficients s1=0.12s_1 = 0.12 and s2=0.88s_2 = 0.88 relative to the heterozygous optimum.

You accurately evaluated the erroneous equilibrium frequency q^err≈0.1364\hat{q}_{\text{err}} \approx 0.1364 using the flawed coefficient s2err=0.76s_{2\text{err}} = 0.76.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Allele frequency formula inversion

You swapped the numerator coefficients, substituting s2s_2 instead of s1s_1 when calculating q^\hat{q}.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Confusing the equilibrium frequency formula for allele SS (q^=s1s1+s2\hat{q} = \frac{s_1}{s_1 + s_2}) with that of allele AA (p^=s2s1+s2\hat{p} = \frac{s_2}{s_1 + s_2}). In overdominance, an allele's equilibrium frequency is proportional to the selective disadvantage of the opposing homozygote.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Opposing Selection Rule
  • Under heterozygote advantage, p^=s2s1+s2\hat{p} = \frac{s_2}{s_1 + s_2} and q^=s1s1+s2\hat{q} = \frac{s_1}{s_1 + s_2}, where s1=1−w11s_1 = 1 - w_{11} and s2=1−w22s_2 = 1 - w_{22}.

  • Pair the numerator with the selective disadvantage of the alternative homozygote (i.e., selection against AAAA increases the equilibrium share of allele SS).

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Set the true equilibrium frequency using the correct numerator: q^=s1s1+s2=0.120.12+0.88=0.120\hat{q} = \frac{s_1}{s_1 + s_2} = \frac{0.12}{0.12 + 0.88} = 0.120.

  2. Substitute the true value into the absolute difference: ∣q^err−q^∣=∣0.1364−0.1200∣=0.0164|\hat{q}_{\text{err}} - \hat{q}| = |0.1364 - 0.1200| = 0.0164.

Final answer

(a) s1=0.12s_1 = 0.12, s2=0.88s_2 = 0.88; (b) q^=0.120\hat{q} = 0.120; (c) ∣q^err−q^∣≈0.0164|\hat{q}_{\text{err}} - \hat{q}| \approx 0.0164

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Memorize the mnemonic: 'Allele frequency is driven by the penalty on the other homozygote' (more selection against AAAA, meaning larger s1s_1, raises the equilibrium frequency of allele SS, q^\hat{q}).

  • Perform a sanity check on allele frequencies: since wSS=0.12w_{SS} = 0.12 has a much severe penalty (s2=0.88s_2 = 0.88) than wAA=0.88w_{AA} = 0.88 (s1=0.12s_1 = 0.12), the sickle allele SS must remain at a relatively low frequency ( ≈0.12\,\approx 0.12, not 0.880.88).

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student subtracts fitness directly from 1 without using the given values properly, confusing s₁ and s₂ by directly assigning genotype fitness values as selection coefficients.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    s1=wAA=0.88  ⟹  s2=wSS=0.12s_1 = w_{AA} = 0.88 \implies s_2 = w_{SS} = 0.12

    Correct

    s1=1−wAA=1.00−0.88=0.12  ⟹  s2=1−wSS=1.00−0.12=0.88s_1 = 1 - w_{AA} = 1.00 - 0.88 = 0.12 \implies s_2 = 1 - w_{SS} = 1.00 - 0.12 = 0.88

    You equated each selection coefficient directly to the genotype's relative fitness rather than computing the selection penalty against each homozygote relative to the heterozygote benchmark (s=1−ws = 1 - w).

  2. Step 2

    q^=s1s1+s2=0.880.88+0.12=0.88\hat{q} = \frac{s_1}{s_1 + s_2} = \frac{0.88}{0.88 + 0.12} = 0.88

    Correct

    q^=s1s1+s2=0.120.12+0.88=0.120\hat{q} = \frac{s_1}{s_1 + s_2} = \frac{0.12}{0.12 + 0.88} = 0.120

    You applied the balancing selection equilibrium formula correctly, but because your selection coefficients from part (a) were inverted, your resulting allele frequency was incorrect.

  3. Step 3

    s2 err=0.88−0.12=0.76  ⟹  q^err=0.120.12+0.76≈0.1364  ⟹  ∣q^err−q^∣=∣0.1364−0.88∣=0.7436s_{2\,\text{err}} = 0.88 - 0.12 = 0.76 \implies \hat{q}_{\text{err}} = \frac{0.12}{0.12 + 0.76} \approx 0.1364 \implies |\hat{q}_{\text{err}} - \hat{q}| = |0.1364 - 0.88| = 0.7436

    Correct

    ∣q^err−q^∣=∣0.1364−0.1200∣=0.0164|\hat{q}_{\text{err}} - \hat{q}| = |0.1364 - 0.1200| = 0.0164

    You accurately modeled the erroneous calculation described in the prompt to obtain q^err≈0.1364\hat{q}_{\text{err}} \approx 0.1364, but you subtracted your incorrect q^=0.88\hat{q} = 0.88 rather than the true equilibrium value q^=0.120\hat{q} = 0.120.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You used the correct algebraic formula q^=s1s1+s2\hat{q} = \frac{s_1}{s_1 + s_2} for the equilibrium frequency under balancing selection.

You correctly calculated the erroneous coefficient s2 err=0.76s_{2\,\text{err}} = 0.76 and its associated frequency q^err≈0.1364\hat{q}_{\text{err}} \approx 0.1364 from the prompt scenario.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Equating fitness with selection coefficient

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated fitness (ww) and the selection coefficient (ss) as identical quantities instead of recognizing that ss measures the reduction in fitness relative to the fittest genotype (s=1−ws = 1 - w).

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Selection Coefficient Definition
  • Relative fitness ww measures survival/reproductive success; the selection coefficient s=1−ws = 1 - w measures selective disadvantage.

  • Always subtract the homozygote's relative fitness from the heterozygote benchmark (1.001.00) to determine ss.

Balancing Selection Allele Frequency
  • At equilibrium under overdominance, the frequency of allele SS is q^=s1s1+s2\hat{q} = \frac{s_1}{s_1 + s_2}, where s1s_1 is selection against AAAA and s2s_2 is selection against SSSS.

  • Check that the deleterious allele with higher selective penalty (s2>s1s_2 > s_1) equilibrates at the lower frequency (q^<0.5\hat{q} < 0.5).

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Compute the true selection coefficients relative to wAS=1.00w_{AS} = 1.00: s1=1.00−0.88=0.12s_1 = 1.00 - 0.88 = 0.12 and s2=1.00−0.12=0.88s_2 = 1.00 - 0.12 = 0.88.

  2. Calculate the true equilibrium frequency: q^=0.120.12+0.88=0.120\hat{q} = \frac{0.12}{0.12 + 0.88} = 0.120.

  3. Compute the absolute error between the erroneous frequency and true frequency: ∣0.1364−0.1200∣=0.0164|0.1364 - 0.1200| = 0.0164.

Final answer

(a) s1=0.12s_1 = 0.12, s2=0.88s_2 = 0.88; (b) q^=0.120\hat{q} = 0.120; (c) ∣q^err−q^∣=0.0164|\hat{q}_{\text{err}} - \hat{q}| = 0.0164

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the formal definition of selection coefficients as fractional fitness reductions (s=1−ws = 1 - w).

  • Perform a sanity check on equilibrium frequencies: when selection against SSSS (s2=0.88s_2 = 0.88) is much stronger than against AAAA (s1=0.12s_1 = 0.12), the equilibrium frequency of SS must be low, not 0.880.88.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student forgets to add s₁ in the denominator when calculating q̂_err, dividing s₁ solely by s₂_err.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    s1=1−0.88=0.12  ⟹  s2=1−0.12=0.88s_1 = 1 - 0.88 = 0.12 \implies s_2 = 1 - 0.12 = 0.88

  2. Step 2

    q^=0.120.12+0.88=0.12\hat{q} = \frac{0.12}{0.12 + 0.88} = 0.12

  3. Step 3

    s2err=0.88−0.12=0.76  ⟹  q^err=s1s2err=0.120.76≈0.1579s_{2\text{err}} = 0.88 - 0.12 = 0.76 \implies \hat{q}_{\text{err}} = \frac{s_1}{s_{2\text{err}}} = \frac{0.12}{0.76} \approx 0.1579

    Correct

    q^err=s1s1+s2err=0.120.12+0.76=0.120.88≈0.1364\hat{q}_{\text{err}} = \frac{s_1}{s_1 + s_{2\text{err}}} = \frac{0.12}{0.12 + 0.76} = \frac{0.12}{0.88} \approx 0.1364

    You correctly evaluated s2err=0.76s_{2\text{err}} = 0.76, but you omitted s1s_1 from the denominator of the equilibrium formula, writing s1s2err\frac{s_1}{s_{2\text{err}}} rather than s1s1+s2err\frac{s_1}{s_1 + s_{2\text{err}}}.

  4. Step 4

    ∣q^err−q^∣=∣0.1579−0.12∣=0.0379|\hat{q}_{\text{err}} - \hat{q}| = |0.1579 - 0.12| = 0.0379

    Correct

    ∣q^err−q^∣=∣0.1364−0.1200∣≈0.0164|\hat{q}_{\text{err}} - \hat{q}| = |0.1364 - 0.1200| \approx 0.0164

    You subtracted the frequencies correctly according to your value, but the result was affected by the earlier denominator omission.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly calculated the selection coefficients s1=0.12s_1 = 0.12 and s2=0.88s_2 = 0.88 relative to the heterozygous optimum.

You correctly used the balancing selection formula to find the true equilibrium frequency q^=0.12\hat{q} = 0.12.

You correctly reconstructed the student's erroneous selection coefficient s2err=wAA−wSS=0.76s_{2\text{err}} = w_{AA} - w_{SS} = 0.76.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Formula Structure Omission

You accidentally omitted s1s_1 in the denominator of the equilibrium formula, turning the ratio s1s1+s2\frac{s_1}{s_1 + s_2} into the quotient s1s2\frac{s_1}{s_2}.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Confusing an equilibrium allele frequency formula with an odds ratio or direct fitness quotient leads to dropping the focal term from the denominator.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Equilibrium Denominator Structure
  • Under balancing selection, the equilibrium allele frequency is q^=s1s1+s2\hat{q} = \frac{s_1}{s_1 + s_2}, where the denominator must always be the sum of both selection coefficients (s1+s2s_1 + s_2).

  • Always write down the full symbolic fraction q^=s1s1+s2\hat{q} = \frac{s_1}{s_1 + s_2} before substituting numerical values to prevent dropping s1s_1 from the sum.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Substitute s1=0.12s_1 = 0.12 and s2err=0.76s_{2\text{err}} = 0.76 into the complete equilibrium formula: q^err=0.120.12+0.76=0.120.88≈0.1364\hat{q}_{\text{err}} = \frac{0.12}{0.12 + 0.76} = \frac{0.12}{0.88} \approx 0.1364.

  2. Compute the absolute error magnitude: ∣q^err−q^∣=∣0.1364−0.1200∣≈0.0164|\hat{q}_{\text{err}} - \hat{q}| = |0.1364 - 0.1200| \approx 0.0164.

Final answer

0.0164 (or 0.016)

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Double-check that any formula for an allele frequency represents a true proportion bounded between 00 and 11, requiring both parts in the total denominator.

  • Practice computing equilibrium frequencies under varying selection coefficients while keeping the total denominator intact.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A locus shows overdominance with genotype fitnesses wAA=0.70w_{AA} = 0.70, wAa=1.00w_{Aa} = 1.00, and waa=0.90w_{aa} = 0.90. Calculate the selection coefficients s1s_1 and s2s_2, and find the equilibrium frequency q^\hat{q} of allele aa.

Answer

s1=1−0.70=0.30s_1 = 1 - 0.70 = 0.30 and s2=1−0.90=0.10s_2 = 1 - 0.90 = 0.10. The equilibrium frequency of allele aa is q^=s1s1+s2=0.300.30+0.10=0.75\hat{q} = \frac{s_1}{s_1 + s_2} = \frac{0.30}{0.30 + 0.10} = 0.75.

02

In a population of butterflies, heterozygote advantage maintains wing-pattern morphs with fitnesses wBB=0.60w_{BB} = 0.60, wBb=1.00w_{Bb} = 1.00, and wbb=0.40w_{bb} = 0.40. (a) Determine the equilibrium frequency of allele BB (p^\hat{p}) and allele bb (q^\hat{q}). (b) Verify that p^+q^=1\hat{p} + \hat{q} = 1.

Answer

(a) s1=1−0.60=0.40s_1 = 1 - 0.60 = 0.40 and s2=1−0.40=0.60s_2 = 1 - 0.40 = 0.60. Thus, p^=s2s1+s2=0.601.00=0.60\hat{p} = \frac{s_2}{s_1 + s_2} = \frac{0.60}{1.00} = 0.60 and q^=s1s1+s2=0.401.00=0.40\hat{q} = \frac{s_1}{s_1 + s_2} = \frac{0.40}{1.00} = 0.40. (b) p^+q^=0.60+0.40=1.00\hat{p} + \hat{q} = 0.60 + 0.40 = 1.00.

03

Suppose a population geneticist measures w11=0.85w_{11} = 0.85, w12=1.00w_{12} = 1.00, and w22=0.25w_{22} = 0.25. If an investigator mistakenly calculates the equilibrium frequency of allele A2A_2 as q^rev=s2s1+s2\hat{q}_{\text{rev}} = \frac{s_2}{s_1 + s_2} instead of the correct formula, compute the sign and magnitude of the error (q^rev−q^true)(\hat{q}_{\text{rev}} - \hat{q}_{\text{true}}).

Answer

s1=0.15s_1 = 0.15 and s2=0.75s_2 = 0.75. True frequency is q^true=0.150.15+0.75=0.150.90≈0.1667\hat{q}_{\text{true}} = \frac{0.15}{0.15 + 0.75} = \frac{0.15}{0.90} \approx 0.1667. The mistaken frequency is q^rev=0.750.90≈0.8333\hat{q}_{\text{rev}} = \frac{0.75}{0.90} \approx 0.8333. The error is q^rev−q^true=0.8333−0.1667=+0.6667\hat{q}_{\text{rev}} - \hat{q}_{\text{true}} = 0.8333 - 0.1667 = +0.6667 (overestimated by 23\frac{2}{3}).

Loading workspace…