Resources

In a behavioral ecology study evaluating courtship lekking behavior in sage grouse, reproductive fitness is defined as relative reproductive success (where absolute fitness of each behavioral morph is normalized by dividing by the absolute fitness of the most successful phenotype, wi=WiWmaxw_i = \frac{W_i}{W_{\text{max}}}). A student mistakenly assumes that the selection coefficient ss represents an increase in fitness, writing the relationship as w=1+sw = 1 + s, rather than the standard population genetics convention w=1−sw = 1 - s. In a sub-population, dominant displayers produce an average of W1=12.5W_1 = 12.5 fledged offspring per mating season, whereas subordinate satellite displayers produce an average of W2=7.50W_2 = 7.50 fledged offspring. Using the correct evolutionary sign convention, calculate the relative fitness of subordinate satellite displayers (w2w_2) and the corresponding selection coefficient (s2s_2) operating against the satellite display phenotype.

Answer and steps

Final answer

Relative fitness w2=0.600w_2 = 0.600, and selection coefficient s2=0.400s_2 = 0.400.

Steps

01

Identify Absolute Fitness Values

Absolute fitness (WW) represents the average number of viable offspring produced by individuals exhibiting a specific phenotype.

  • Absolute fitness of dominant displayers: W1=12.5W_1 = 12.5
  • Absolute fitness of subordinate satellite displayers: W2=7.50W_2 = 7.50

Because dominant displayers have the highest reproductive output, the maximum absolute fitness is: Wmax=W1=12.5W_{\text{max}} = W_1 = 12.5


02

Calculate Relative Fitness (w2w_2)

Relative fitness (ww) compares the reproductive success of a given phenotype to the most successful phenotype in the population:

wi=WiWmaxw_i = \frac{W_i}{W_{\text{max}}}

For the subordinate satellite displayers (i=2i = 2):

w2=W2Wmax=7.5012.5=0.600w_2 = \frac{W_2}{W_{\text{max}}} = \frac{7.50}{12.5} = 0.600

Thus, satellite displayers achieve 60.0%60.0\% of the reproductive success of dominant displayers.


03

Calculate the Selection Coefficient (s2s_2)

The selection coefficient (ss) measures the relative strength of natural selection acting against a less fit phenotype. By standard evolutionary genetics convention, it represents the proportional reduction in fitness relative to the optimal phenotype:

w=1−s  ⟹  s=1−ww = 1 - s \implies s = 1 - w

Applying this to the satellite displayers:

s2=1−w2=1−0.600=0.400s_2 = 1 - w_2 = 1 - 0.600 = 0.400

Common Pitfall: Do not use w=1+sw = 1 + s. In standard evolutionary models, natural selection against a deleterious or suboptimal trait reduces fitness below 11, meaning ss represents a reproductive penalty or selective disadvantage (s≥0s \ge 0).

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student uses the incorrect relationship w = 1 + s mentioned in the prompt description rather than the required standard convention w = 1 - s, resulting in a negative selection coefficient.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    w2=W2W1=7.5012.5  ⟹  w2=0.60w_2 = \frac{W_2}{W_1} = \frac{7.50}{12.5} \implies w_2 = 0.60

  2. Step 2

    w2=1+s2  ⟹  s2=w2−1=0.60−1  ⟹  s2=−0.40w_2 = 1 + s_2 \implies s_2 = w_2 - 1 = 0.60 - 1 \implies s_2 = -0.40

    Correct

    w2=1−s2  ⟹  s2=1−w2=1−0.600=0.400w_2 = 1 - s_2 \implies s_2 = 1 - w_2 = 1 - 0.600 = 0.400

    In standard population genetics, the selection coefficient ss represents the proportional fitness reduction (selective disadvantage) acting against a phenotype, defined by w=1−sw = 1 - s, yielding s2=0.400s_2 = 0.400.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly set up and simplified the ratio of absolute fitness values to obtain relative fitness.

You accurately solved your chosen linear equation without arithmetic errors.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Sign convention error in selection coefficient

You wrote w=1+sw = 1 + s rather than the standard convention w=1−sw = 1 - s specified in the problem.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You conceptualized the selection coefficient as an additive adjustment to baseline fitness rather than a proportional reproductive penalty (s=1−ws = 1 - w) acting against suboptimal phenotypes.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Convention for Selection Against a Phenotype
  • When measuring selection acting against a suboptimal phenotype relative to the optimum (w=1w = 1), relative fitness is defined as w=1−sw = 1 - s, where ss measures the proportional fitness penalty (0≤s≤10 \le s \le 1).

  • Always compute the selection coefficient against a phenotype using s=1−ws = 1 - w so that a lower relative fitness yields a positive selection coefficient.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Recall the standard population genetics definition for selection against a phenotype: w=1−sw = 1 - s.

  2. Rearrange the formula to isolate the selection coefficient: s2=1−w2s_2 = 1 - w_2.

  3. Substitute w2=0.600w_2 = 0.600: s2=1−0.600=0.400s_2 = 1 - 0.600 = 0.400.

Final answer

Relative fitness w2=0.600w_2 = 0.600, and selection coefficient s2=0.400s_2 = 0.400.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the evolutionary definition of the selection coefficient as a penalty against a phenotype rather than a fitness gain.

  • Double-check that any phenotype with relative fitness less than 11 produces a positive selection coefficient s>0s > 0 when measuring selection against that trait.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student inverts the fitness normalization ratio by dividing the dominant fitness by the subordinate fitness, obtaining a relative fitness greater than 1.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    w2=W1W2=12.57.50  ⟹  w2=1.67w_2 = \frac{W_1}{W_2} = \frac{12.5}{7.50} \implies w_2 = 1.67

    Correct

    w2=W2Wmax=7.5012.5=0.600w_2 = \frac{W_2}{W_{\text{max}}} = \frac{7.50}{12.5} = 0.600

    You inverted the fraction when normalizing fitness. The formula states wi=WiWmaxw_i = \frac{W_i}{W_{\text{max}}}, where the focal phenotype's absolute fitness belongs in the numerator and the maximum fitness belongs in the denominator.

  2. Step 2

    s2=1−w2=1−1.67  ⟹  s2=−0.67s_2 = 1 - w_2 = 1 - 1.67 \implies s_2 = -0.67

    Correct

    s2=1−w2=1−0.600=0.400s_2 = 1 - w_2 = 1 - 0.600 = 0.400

    You correctly used the standard formula s=1−ws = 1 - w, but the result was thrown off by the incorrect relative fitness value from Step 1.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly used the standard population genetics relationship s=1−ws = 1 - w rather than the non-standard addition convention.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Inverted relative fitness ratio

Placing the reference maximum fitness in the numerator instead of the denominator.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Confusing the focal phenotype with the standard reference phenotype during normalization, which produced a relative fitness greater than 1 for a suboptimal morph.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Fitness Normalization Rule
  • Relative fitness is defined as wi=WiWmaxw_i = \frac{W_i}{W_{\text{max}}}, meaning the most successful phenotype is the denominator.

  • Always verify that the most successful phenotype has w=1.0w = 1.0, and every other phenotype has w≤1.0w \le 1.0.

Selection Coefficient Sign
  • For a suboptimal phenotype under purifying or negative selection relative to the optimum, 0≤s≤10 \le s \le 1.

  • If you obtain a negative value for ss when measuring selection against a disadvantaged phenotype, check whether your relative fitness ratio was inverted.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Substitute W2=7.50W_2 = 7.50 into the numerator and Wmax=12.5W_{\text{max}} = 12.5 into the denominator: w2=7.5012.5=0.600w_2 = \frac{7.50}{12.5} = 0.600.

  2. Compute the selection coefficient using the standard convention: s2=1−w2=1−0.600=0.400s_2 = 1 - w_2 = 1 - 0.600 = 0.400.

Final answer

Relative fitness w2=0.600w_2 = 0.600, and selection coefficient s2=0.400s_2 = 0.400.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the definition of relative fitness to ensure the optimal phenotype serves as the benchmark denominator.

  • Practice checking that relative fitness for subordinate or disadvantaged morphs remains between 00 and 11.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student calculates the selection coefficient as the direct difference between absolute fitness values rather than subtracting relative fitness from 1.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    w2=W2W1=7.5012.5  ⟹  w2=0.60w_2 = \frac{W_2}{W_1} = \frac{7.50}{12.5} \implies w_2 = 0.60

  2. Step 2

    s2=W1−W2=12.5−7.50  ⟹  s2=5.00s_2 = W_1 - W_2 = 12.5 - 7.50 \implies s_2 = 5.00

    Correct

    s2=1−w2=1−0.600=0.400s_2 = 1 - w_2 = 1 - 0.600 = 0.400

    You subtracted the raw absolute fitness values (W1−W2W_1 - W_2) instead of subtracting the relative fitness from 11 (s2=1−w2s_2 = 1 - w_2). Selection coefficients are dimensionless proportions scaled against the optimal phenotype.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified the dominant phenotype as the fitness reference point.

You accurately calculated the relative fitness w2=0.60w_2 = 0.60.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Absolute vs. Relative Fitness Confusion

You treated the selection coefficient as a raw difference in absolute offspring count rather than a standardized proportion.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You confused absolute fitness difference (ΔW=Wmax⁡−Wi\Delta W = W_{\max} - W_i) with the population genetics definition of the selection coefficient (s=1−wis = 1 - w_i), which must be dimensionless and bounded between 00 and 11 for suboptimal phenotypes.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Selection Coefficient Definition
  • In standard evolutionary models, relative fitness and the selection coefficient are linked by w=1−sw = 1 - s, so s=1−ws = 1 - w.

  • Always substitute the relative fitness value (ww), never absolute offspring counts (WW), into s=1−ws = 1 - w.

Range Check for Selection Coefficients
  • For a phenotype less fit than the optimum (w≤1w \le 1), the selection coefficient ss must lie in the range [0,1][0, 1].

  • If your calculated s>1s > 1, pause and verify whether you accidentally used absolute fitness numbers.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Use the standard population genetics relation w2=1−s2w_2 = 1 - s_2.

  2. Rearrange to solve for the selection coefficient: s2=1−w2s_2 = 1 - w_2.

  3. Substitute w2=0.600w_2 = 0.600: s2=1−0.600=0.400s_2 = 1 - 0.600 = 0.400.

Final answer

w2=0.600w_2 = 0.600 and s2=0.400s_2 = 0.400

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the distinction between absolute fitness (WW, measured in offspring) and relative fitness (ww, a dimensionless ratio).

  • Practice converting relative fitness values to selection coefficients using s=1−ws = 1 - w.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

In a population of side-blotched lizards, orange-throated males produce an average of W1=16.0W_1 = 16.0 offspring per season, whereas yellow-throated sneaker males produce an average of W2=12.0W_2 = 12.0 offspring. Calculate the relative fitness (w2w_2) and the selection coefficient (s2s_2) acting against the sneaker male phenotype.

Answer

w2=0.750w_2 = 0.750, s2=0.250s_2 = 0.250. Key steps: w2=W2Wmax=12.016.0=0.750w_2 = \frac{W_2}{W_{\text{max}}} = \frac{12.0}{16.0} = 0.750; s2=1−w2=1−0.750=0.250s_2 = 1 - w_2 = 1 - 0.750 = 0.250.

02

A population geneticist studies three foraging behavioral phenotypes in an insect: Solitary (W=20.0W = 20.0), Cooperative (W=25.0W = 25.0), and Aggressive (W=15.0W = 15.0). Determine the relative fitness and selection coefficient against both the Solitary and Aggressive phenotypes.

Answer

Solitary: w=0.800w = 0.800, s=0.200s = 0.200; Aggressive: w=0.600w = 0.600, s=0.400s = 0.400. Key steps: Optimal fitness Wmax=25.0W_{\text{max}} = 25.0. For Solitary: w=20.025.0=0.800w = \frac{20.0}{25.0} = 0.800, s=1−0.800=0.200s = 1 - 0.800 = 0.200. For Aggressive: w=15.025.0=0.600w = \frac{15.0}{25.0} = 0.600, s=1−0.600=0.400s = 1 - 0.600 = 0.400.

03

In an avian mating lek, satellite males experience a selection coefficient of s=0.350s = 0.350 operating against their display strategy compared to dominant males. If dominant males sire an average of 14.014.0 fledglings per year, what is the absolute fitness (WsatelliteW_{\text{satellite}}) of the satellite males?

Answer

Wsatellite=9.10W_{\text{satellite}} = 9.10 fledglings. Key steps: wsatellite=1−s=1−0.350=0.650w_{\text{satellite}} = 1 - s = 1 - 0.350 = 0.650. Since w=WWmaxw = \frac{W}{W_{\text{max}}}, Wsatellite=w×Wmax=0.650×14.0=9.10W_{\text{satellite}} = w \times W_{\text{max}} = 0.650 \times 14.0 = 9.10.

Loading workspace…