Resources

A researcher investigates territorial defense signaling in male green frogs (Lithobates clamitans). Resident males lower the dominant acoustic frequency of their aggressive croaks to intimidate intruders. In an encounter, an honest signal accurately reflects body mass, where lower pitch indicates higher fighting ability. A student models the net selective value WsignalW_{\text{signal}} of lowering call frequency by Δf\Delta f (in Hz\text{Hz}) as Wsignal=B(Δf)−C(Δf)W_{\text{signal}} = B(\Delta f) - C(\Delta f), where energetic cost is C(Δf)=0.05(Δf)2C(\Delta f) = 0.05 (\Delta f)^2 and social deterrence benefit is B(Δf)=2.4(Δf)B(\Delta f) = 2.4 (\Delta f). The student misinterprets the coordinate sign convention by defining the net advantage as Werr=C(Δf)−B(Δf)W_{\text{err}} = C(\Delta f) - B(\Delta f) and attempts to minimize energetic expense rather than maximizing net fitness gain. Find the true optimal shift in call frequency (Δf)∗(\Delta f)^* that maximizes net fitness benefit WsignalW_{\text{signal}}, and calculate the true maximum net benefit.

Answer and steps

Final answer

(Δf)∗=24.0 Hz(\Delta f)^* = 24.0\text{ Hz}, yielding a maximum net benefit of Wsignal=28.8W_{\text{signal}} = 28.8 arbitrary fitness units.

Steps

01

Model the Net Fitness Function

In evolutionary biology and behavioral ecology, an optimal behavioral strategy balances the fitness benefits gained against the energetic or survival costs incurred. Natural selection favors the behavioral effort that maximizes net selective advantage:

Wsignal(Δf)=B(Δf)−C(Δf)W_{\text{signal}}(\Delta f) = B(\Delta f) - C(\Delta f)

Substitute the given equations for benefit B(Δf)B(\Delta f) and energetic cost C(Δf)C(\Delta f):

Wsignal(Δf)=2.4(Δf)−0.05(Δf)2W_{\text{signal}}(\Delta f) = 2.4(\Delta f) - 0.05(\Delta f)^2

This is a downward-opening quadratic function of the form f(x)=ax2+bx+cf(x) = ax^2 + bx + c, where a=−0.05a = -0.05, b=2.4b = 2.4, and c=0c = 0.


02

Determine the Optimal Frequency Shift (Δf)∗(\Delta f)^*

Because the coefficient of the squared term is negative (a=−0.05<0a = -0.05 < 0), the vertex represents the global maximum of the net fitness benefit.

Method 1: Using the Vertex Formula

For any quadratic equation y=ax2+bx+cy = ax^2 + bx + c, the axis of symmetry (location of the vertex) is given by:

(Δf)∗=−b2a=−2.42(−0.05)=2.40.10=24.0 Hz(\Delta f)^* = -\frac{b}{2a} = -\frac{2.4}{2(-0.05)} = \frac{2.4}{0.10} = 24.0\text{ Hz}

Method 2: Using Marginal Analysis (Calculus)

At the optimum, the marginal fitness benefit equals the marginal energetic cost:

dWsignald(Δf)=dBd(Δf)−dCd(Δf)=0\frac{d W_{\text{signal}}}{d(\Delta f)} = \frac{d B}{d(\Delta f)} - \frac{d C}{d(\Delta f)} = 0

Taking the derivatives:

2.4−2(0.05)(Δf)=02.4 - 2(0.05)(\Delta f) = 0 2.4−0.10(Δf)=0  ⟹  (Δf)∗=2.40.10=24.0 Hz2.4 - 0.10(\Delta f) = 0 \implies (\Delta f)^* = \frac{2.4}{0.10} = 24.0\text{ Hz}

The second derivative is d2Wsignald(Δf)2=−0.10<0\frac{d^2 W_{\text{signal}}}{d(\Delta f)^2} = -0.10 < 0, verifying that this point is indeed a maximum.


03

Calculate the Maximum Net Benefit

Evaluate WsignalW_{\text{signal}} at the optimal shift (Δf)∗=24.0 Hz(\Delta f)^* = 24.0\text{ Hz}:

Wsignal(24.0)=2.4(24.0)−0.05(24.0)2W_{\text{signal}}(24.0) = 2.4(24.0) - 0.05(24.0)^2 Wsignal(24.0)=57.6−0.05(576)=57.6−28.8=28.8 arbitrary fitness unitsW_{\text{signal}}(24.0) = 57.6 - 0.05(576) = 57.6 - 28.8 = 28.8\text{ arbitrary fitness units}


Biological Pitfall to Avoid

Minimizing energetic expenditure alone would favor Δf=0 Hz\Delta f = 0\text{ Hz} (producing no signal modification at all), which avoids cost but yields zero territorial deterrence benefit. Similarly, optimizing the error expression Werr=C−BW_{\text{err}} = C - B treats costs as advantages and benefits as penalties. Natural selection maximizes the difference B−CB - C, yielding an intermediate optimum where the marginal benefit of lowering the pitch matches the marginal physiological cost.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student uses the distractor objective function W_err = C(Δf) - B(Δf) mentioned in the problem statement and finds the minimum of cost minus benefit instead of maximizing net fitness.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Werr=C(Δf)−B(Δf)=0.05(Δf)2−2.4ΔfW_{\text{err}} = C(\Delta f) - B(\Delta f) = 0.05(\Delta f)^2 - 2.4\Delta f

    Correct

    Wsignal(Δf)=B(Δf)−C(Δf)=2.4Δf−0.05(Δf)2W_{\text{signal}}(\Delta f) = B(\Delta f) - C(\Delta f) = 2.4\Delta f - 0.05(\Delta f)^2

    You defined the objective function as cost minus benefit instead of net fitness benefit, which is defined as benefit minus cost.

  2. Step 2

    dWerrd(Δf)=0.10Δf−2.4=0  ⟹  0.10Δf=2.4  ⟹  (Δf)∗=24 Hz\frac{d W_{\text{err}}}{d(\Delta f)} = 0.10\Delta f - 2.4 = 0 \implies 0.10\Delta f = 2.4 \implies (\Delta f)^* = 24\text{ Hz}

  3. Step 3

    Werr(24)=0.05(24)2−2.4(24)=28.8−57.6=−28.8W_{\text{err}}(24) = 0.05(24)^2 - 2.4(24) = 28.8 - 57.6 = -28.8

    Correct

    Wsignal(24)=2.4(24)−0.05(24)2=57.6−28.8=28.8W_{\text{signal}}(24) = 2.4(24) - 0.05(24)^2 = 57.6 - 28.8 = 28.8

    Because you substituted the optimal shift into WerrW_{\text{err}} instead of WsignalW_{\text{signal}}, your net fitness benefit had the wrong sign.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly differentiated the quadratic function.

You accurately solved the linear first-order condition to find (Δf)∗=24 Hz(\Delta f)^* = 24\text{ Hz}.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Objective function misformulation

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated the distractor error scenario described in the prompt (Werr=C−BW_{\text{err}} = C - B) as the target objective function rather than maximizing the true net selective advantage Wsignal=B−CW_{\text{signal}} = B - C.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Net Fitness Definition
  • Net fitness benefit in behavioral ecology is always quantified as total benefit minus total cost: W=B−CW = B - C.

  • Always verify that positive contributions to fitness are added and energetic/survival costs are subtracted.

Sign of Net Fitness at the Optimum
  • An adaptive evolutionary behavior selected by natural selection should yield a positive net fitness payoff (W>0W > 0) relative to baseline.

  • If your evaluated net fitness at the calculated optimum turns out negative when costs are supposed to be outweighed by benefits, check if you reversed the signs of BB and CC.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Write the true net fitness equation: Wsignal(Δf)=B(Δf)−C(Δf)=2.4(Δf)−0.05(Δf)2W_{\text{signal}}(\Delta f) = B(\Delta f) - C(\Delta f) = 2.4(\Delta f) - 0.05(\Delta f)^2.

  2. Substitute the optimal frequency shift (Δf)∗=24 Hz(\Delta f)^* = 24\text{ Hz} into WsignalW_{\text{signal}}: Wsignal(24)=2.4(24)−0.05(24)2W_{\text{signal}}(24) = 2.4(24) - 0.05(24)^2.

  3. Evaluate the arithmetic: 57.6−0.05(576)=57.6−28.8=28.857.6 - 0.05(576) = 57.6 - 28.8 = 28.8.

Final answer

(Δf)∗=24.0 Hz(\Delta f)^* = 24.0\text{ Hz}, yielding a maximum net benefit of Wsignal=28.8 arbitrary fitness unitsW_{\text{signal}} = 28.8\text{ arbitrary fitness units}.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Carefully read problem prompts that describe a hypothetical error to distinguish between the flawed model and the actual question asked.

  • Practice checking whether your final objective value represents a maximum or a minimum using the second derivative test.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student forgets to apply the power rule properly to the quadratic cost term by omitting the factor of 2 during differentiation, solving 2.4 - 0.05Δf = 0 instead.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    Wsignal=2.4Δf−0.05(Δf)2W_{\text{signal}} = 2.4\Delta f - 0.05(\Delta f)^2

  2. Step 2

    dWd(Δf)=2.4−0.05Δf=0  ⟹  0.05Δf=2.4  ⟹  (Δf)∗=48 Hz\frac{dW}{d(\Delta f)} = 2.4 - 0.05\Delta f = 0 \implies 0.05\Delta f = 2.4 \implies (\Delta f)^* = 48\text{ Hz}

    Correct

    dWd(Δf)=2.4−2(0.05)Δf=2.4−0.10Δf=0  ⟹  (Δf)∗=24.0 Hz\frac{dW}{d(\Delta f)} = 2.4 - 2(0.05)\Delta f = 2.4 - 0.10\Delta f = 0 \implies (\Delta f)^* = 24.0\text{ Hz}

    When differentiating cx2c x^2 with respect to xx, the power rule requires multiplying by the exponent: ddx(cx2)=2cx\frac{d}{dx}(c x^2) = 2cx. Differentiating −0.05(Δf)2-0.05(\Delta f)^2 yields −0.10Δf-0.10\Delta f, not −0.05Δf-0.05\Delta f.

  3. Step 3

    Wsignal(48)=2.4(48)−0.05(48)2  ⟹  Wsignal(48)=115.2−0.05(2304)  ⟹  Wsignal(48)=115.2−115.2=0W_{\text{signal}}(48) = 2.4(48) - 0.05(48)^2 \implies W_{\text{signal}}(48) = 115.2 - 0.05(2304) \implies W_{\text{signal}}(48) = 115.2 - 115.2 = 0

    Correct

    Wsignal(24.0)=2.4(24.0)−0.05(24.0)2=57.6−28.8=28.8 arbitrary fitness unitsW_{\text{signal}}(24.0) = 2.4(24.0) - 0.05(24.0)^2 = 57.6 - 28.8 = 28.8\text{ arbitrary fitness units}

    You correctly substituted your calculated value of Δf\Delta f into the fitness equation, but because your (Δf)∗(\Delta f)^* was derived from the incorrect derivative, you evaluated the net benefit at a root where cost exactly equals benefit (W=0W = 0) rather than at the peak.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly recognized that net fitness is the difference between social benefit and energetic cost: Wsignal=B(Δf)−C(Δf)W_{\text{signal}} = B(\Delta f) - C(\Delta f).

You correctly identified that finding the optimum requires setting the first derivative dWd(Δf)\frac{dW}{d(\Delta f)} equal to zero.

You carried out the subsequent arithmetic and substitution steps accurately according to your differentiated equation.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Omission of power-rule exponent factor during differentiation

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated the derivative of ax2a x^2 as simply axa x, omitting the coefficient multiplication by the exponent 22. In behavioral optimization models with linear benefits and quadratic costs, setting the un-multiplied rate b−ax=0b - a x = 0 inadvertently locates the break-even root bx−ax2=0b x - a x^2 = 0 where costs consume all benefits, exactly twice the true optimal effort.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Power Rule for Quadratic Terms
  • ddx(ax2)=2ax\frac{d}{dx}(a x^2) = 2a x

  • Always bring the exponent down as a multiplier before reducing the power by one.

Vertex vs. Root Check in Optimization
  • For a downward-opening parabola y=bx−ax2y = bx - ax^2, the maximum occurs at the vertex x∗=b2ax^* = \frac{b}{2a}, whereas the non-zero root occurs at x=ba=2x∗x = \frac{b}{a} = 2x^*.

  • If evaluating your proposed optimum gives W=0W = 0, verify whether you solved for the axis of symmetry or accidentally solved for the horizontal intercept.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Differentiate Wsignal(Δf)=2.4Δf−0.05(Δf)2W_{\text{signal}}(\Delta f) = 2.4\Delta f - 0.05(\Delta f)^2 using the power rule: dWd(Δf)=2.4−2(0.05)Δf=2.4−0.10Δf\frac{dW}{d(\Delta f)} = 2.4 - 2(0.05)\Delta f = 2.4 - 0.10\Delta f.

  2. Set the marginal fitness to zero and solve for (Δf)∗(\Delta f)^*: 2.4−0.10Δf=0  ⟹  (Δf)∗=2.40.10=24.0 Hz2.4 - 0.10\Delta f = 0 \implies (\Delta f)^* = \frac{2.4}{0.10} = 24.0\text{ Hz}.

  3. Substitute (Δf)∗=24.0 Hz(\Delta f)^* = 24.0\text{ Hz} into the original fitness function: Wsignal(24.0)=2.4(24.0)−0.05(24.0)2=57.6−28.8=28.8 arbitrary fitness unitsW_{\text{signal}}(24.0) = 2.4(24.0) - 0.05(24.0)^2 = 57.6 - 28.8 = 28.8\text{ arbitrary fitness units}.

Final answer

(Δf)∗=24.0 Hz(\Delta f)^* = 24.0\text{ Hz}, yielding a maximum net benefit of Wsignal=28.8 arbitrary fitness unitsW_{\text{signal}} = 28.8\text{ arbitrary fitness units}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the calculus power rule for polynomial functions, paying close attention to multiplying constant coefficients by the exponent.

  • Practice sketching the marginal benefit curve dBdx\frac{dB}{dx} and marginal cost curve dCdx\frac{dC}{dx} to visually inspect where they intersect.

  • Perform sanity checks on your maximum: evaluate WW at your critical point to ensure it yields a positive value greater than nearby points.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student sets the benefit equal to the cost to find where net fitness equals zero rather than finding the marginal optimum where the derivative equals zero.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    B(Δf)=C(Δf)B(\Delta f) = C(\Delta f)

    Correct

    dWsignald(Δf)=0  ⟹  dBd(Δf)=dCd(Δf)\frac{d W_{\text{signal}}}{d(\Delta f)} = 0 \implies \frac{d B}{d(\Delta f)} = \frac{d C}{d(\Delta f)} (or finding the vertex of Wsignal=2.4Δf−0.05(Δf)2W_{\text{signal}} = 2.4\Delta f - 0.05(\Delta f)^2)

    You set total deterrence benefit equal to total energetic cost. Setting B(Δf)=C(Δf)B(\Delta f) = C(\Delta f) finds the point where net fitness gain is zero (Wsignal=0W_{\text{signal}} = 0). To maximize net fitness, you need to find where the rate of change of net fitness is zero, meaning marginal benefit equals marginal cost.

  2. Step 2

    2.4Δf=0.05(Δf)2  ⟹  2.4=0.05Δf  ⟹  (Δf)∗=48 Hz2.4\Delta f = 0.05(\Delta f)^2 \implies 2.4 = 0.05\Delta f \implies (\Delta f)^* = 48\text{ Hz}

    Correct

    2.4−0.10Δf=0  ⟹  (Δf)∗=2.40.10=24.0 Hz2.4 - 0.10\Delta f = 0 \implies (\Delta f)^* = \frac{2.4}{0.10} = 24.0\text{ Hz}

    Your algebraic solving of 2.4Δf=0.05(Δf)22.4\Delta f = 0.05(\Delta f)^2 was mathematically correct for the equation you wrote, but it produced the break-even frequency shift rather than the optimal shift.

  3. Step 3

    Wsignal=B(48)−C(48)=2.4(48)−0.05(48)2=115.2−115.2=0W_{\text{signal}} = B(48) - C(48) = 2.4(48) - 0.05(48)^2 = 115.2 - 115.2 = 0

    Correct

    Wsignal(24.0)=2.4(24.0)−0.05(24.0)2=57.6−28.8=28.8W_{\text{signal}}(24.0) = 2.4(24.0) - 0.05(24.0)^2 = 57.6 - 28.8 = 28.8

    You substituted your calculated value accurately into the net fitness formula, which confirmed that at Δf=48 Hz\Delta f = 48\text{ Hz}, net fitness is zero instead of being maximized.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified the functions for benefit B(Δf)B(\Delta f) and cost C(Δf)C(\Delta f).

You solved the quadratic-linear equation accurately through valid algebraic steps.

You substituted your result back into the net fitness definition Wsignal=B−CW_{\text{signal}} = B - C without arithmetic error.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Break-even vs. Marginal Optimization Confusion

You equated total benefit and total cost (B=CB = C) instead of finding where their slopes are equal (dBd(Δf)=dCd(Δf)\frac{dB}{d(\Delta f)} = \frac{dC}{d(\Delta f)}).

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Confusing the break-even condition (B=CB = C, where net profit/fitness is zero) with the optimal condition (where the gap B−CB - C reaches its maximum). In behavioral models, natural selection maximizes net fitness, which occurs at the vertex of the net curve or where marginal benefit equals marginal cost, not where costs entirely consume benefits.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Optimization vs. Break-even
  • Net value W=B−CW = B - C is maximized when dWdx=0  ⟹  dBdx=dCdx\frac{dW}{dx} = 0 \implies \frac{dB}{dx} = \frac{dC}{dx}, whereas B=CB = C yields W=0W = 0.

  • Always write down the objective function W(x)=B(x)−C(x)W(x) = B(x) - C(x) first, then take its derivative (or use the vertex formula −b2a-\frac{b}{2a}) to locate the peak.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Express the net fitness function: Wsignal(Δf)=2.4Δf−0.05(Δf)2W_{\text{signal}}(\Delta f) = 2.4\Delta f - 0.05(\Delta f)^2.

  2. Take the first derivative with respect to Δf\Delta f and set it to zero: dWsignald(Δf)=2.4−0.10Δf=0\frac{d W_{\text{signal}}}{d(\Delta f)} = 2.4 - 0.10\Delta f = 0.

  3. Solve for the optimal frequency shift: (Δf)∗=2.40.10=24.0 Hz(\Delta f)^* = \frac{2.4}{0.10} = 24.0\text{ Hz}.

  4. Evaluate the maximum net benefit at (Δf)∗=24.0 Hz(\Delta f)^* = 24.0\text{ Hz}: Wsignal(24.0)=2.4(24.0)−0.05(24.0)2=57.6−28.8=28.8W_{\text{signal}}(24.0) = 2.4(24.0) - 0.05(24.0)^2 = 57.6 - 28.8 = 28.8.

Final answer

(Δf)∗=24.0 Hz(\Delta f)^* = 24.0\text{ Hz}, yielding a maximum net benefit of Wsignal=28.8W_{\text{signal}} = 28.8 arbitrary fitness units.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review how to distinguish between finding zeros of a function (f(x)=0f(x) = 0) and finding extrema (f′(x)=0f'(x) = 0).

  • Practice graphing benefit and cost curves together to visually identify the point of maximum vertical separation.

  • Complete the follow-up practice exercises to solidify marginal cost-benefit analysis.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A bird species produces an alarm call whose social warning benefit is modeled as B(t)=8tB(t) = 8t and predation risk cost is C(t)=0.4t2C(t) = 0.4t^2, where tt is call duration in seconds. Find the optimal duration t∗t^* that maximizes net fitness W(t)=B(t)−C(t)W(t) = B(t) - C(t) and compute the maximum net fitness.

Answer

t∗=10 st^* = 10\text{ s}, with maximum net fitness W(10)=40W(10) = 40. Key step: dWdt=8−0.8t=0  ⟹  t=10\frac{dW}{dt} = 8 - 0.8t = 0 \implies t = 10, then W(10)=8(10)−0.4(100)=80−40=40W(10) = 8(10) - 0.4(100) = 80 - 40 = 40.

02

A male cricket increases its calling rate rr (chirps per minute) to attract mates. The mating benefit function is B(r)=15rB(r) = 15r, but metabolic expenditure accelerates as C(r)=0.15r2+5C(r) = 0.15r^2 + 5. Determine the optimal calling rate r∗r^* and the net fitness benefit at that rate.

Answer

r∗=50 chirps/minr^* = 50\text{ chirps/min}, with maximum net benefit W(50)=370W(50) = 370. Key step: W(r)=15r−0.15r2−5W(r) = 15r - 0.15r^2 - 5. Setting dWdr=15−0.30r=0  ⟹  r∗=50\frac{dW}{dr} = 15 - 0.30r = 0 \implies r^* = 50. Evaluating gives W(50)=750−375−5=370W(50) = 750 - 375 - 5 = 370.

03

An aggressive territorial display incurs an energetic cost C(s)=2s2C(s) = 2s^2 and produces deterrence benefit B(s)=36s−s2B(s) = 36s - s^2, where ss is display intensity (s≥0s \ge 0). Compare the net fitness maximizing intensity s∗s^* against the intensity that minimizes cost alone, and state the net fitness payoff in each case.

Answer

s∗=6s^* = 6 yields maximum net fitness W(6)=108W(6) = 108; minimizing cost alone yields s=0s = 0 with net fitness W(0)=0W(0) = 0. Key steps: W(s)=B(s)−C(s)=36s−3s2W(s) = B(s) - C(s) = 36s - 3s^2. Setting dWds=36−6s=0  ⟹  s∗=6\frac{dW}{ds} = 36 - 6s = 0 \implies s^* = 6, where W(6)=216−108=108W(6) = 216 - 108 = 108. Minimizing cost C(s)=2s2C(s) = 2s^2 gives s=0s = 0, where B(0)−C(0)=0B(0) - C(0) = 0.

Loading workspace…