Resources
A renal epithelial cell operates an antiporter (exchanger) that couples the movement of down its electrochemical gradient to the extrusion of into the urine (). A student evaluates whether the membrane potential provides electrical driving force for this transport cycle. Given , , cytosolic , and luminal at (, ): (a) write the net electrochemical free energy equation and explain why the membrane electrical term cancels out entirely to , and (b) calculate the net chemical (in ) to confirm whether inward transport can spontaneously power extrusion under these conditions.
Answer and steps
Final answer
(a) The electrical term cancels to because both and possess identical valence () and move in opposite directions across the membrane (), making the exchange electroneutral; (b) (or to 3 sig figs; practically at thermodynamic equilibrium, as the 10-fold sodium gradient perfectly balances the 10-fold proton gradient: ).
Steps
Part (a): Free Energy Equation and Electroneutrality
The total electrochemical free energy change () for moving an ion with valence across a membrane is the sum of its chemical (concentration) gradient and the electrical potential gradient:
For the exchanger:
- Inward movement of (from outside to inside):
- Outward movement of (from inside to outside):
Summing both components gives the net free energy equation:
Why the electrical term cancels: Both ions are monovalent cations ( and ). Because one positive charge moves inward for every one positive charge moving outward, the net transferred charge per cycle is:
Therefore, . The exchanger is electroneutral, meaning the membrane potential does not contribute any net driving force.
Part (b): Calculation of Net Chemical Free Energy ()
With the electrical component equal to zero, depends solely on the chemical gradients:
- Calculate the sodium concentration ratio:
- Calculate the proton concentration ratio from :
- Net free energy:
Conclusion: Under these physiological conditions, (specifically before rounding). The -fold inward chemical gradient of exactly balances the -fold outward gradient required to extrude . The transporter is at thermodynamic equilibrium, so there is no net driving force in either direction without an increase in the gradient or a decrease in extracellular proton concentration.
Typical errors
01 The student sums the membrane electrical potential terms instead of accounting for the opposite directions of Na+ entry and H+ exit.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1Correct
Because moves inward () while moves outward (), their electrical work terms have opposite signs and subtract rather than add.
- Step 2
- Step 3Correct
(system is at thermodynamic equilibrium; inward transport does not provide a net spontaneous driving force under these exact conditions).
Your final calculation and conclusion carried over the non-zero electrical term from Step 1.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly expressed the chemical potential equation for both ions moving across the membrane.
You accurately converted luminal and cytosolic values to relative concentrations.
You correctly calculated that the favorable 10-fold inward sodium gradient yields , exactly matching the needed to extrude protons against their 10-fold gradient.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou treated both ions as moving in the same direction across the membrane potential rather than accounting for the antiport exchange vector.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisOverlooking the directional sign convention of electrical work in antiporters: moving a positive charge into the cell experiences , whereas moving a positive charge out of the cell experiences , making an exchange of equal valences electroneutral ().
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Define the directional potential for each flux
For influx, electrical work is . For efflux, it is .
Always write the electrical work as with proper signs before combining terms.
- Check Net Charge Translocation (Electroneutral vs. Rheogenic)
Calculate net charge moved inside per cycle: .
If , the transporter is electroneutral and regardless of the magnitude of .
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationSet up the net electrochemical energy for : .
Substitute ion valences: , yielding .
Combine with your correct chemical term: .
(a) The electrical term cancels to because both and have valence and move in opposite directions, making the net translocated charge zero (electroneutral transport); (b) (specifically unrounded), meaning the system is at thermodynamic equilibrium and inward transport does not provide net driving force under these specific conditions.
02 The student inverts the proton ratio when calculating the free energy of moving H+ out of the cell, using [H+]_in / [H+]_out instead of [H+]_out / [H+]_in.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
⟹ enters the cell () while leaves the cell (), so and the electrical term cancels out to .
- Step 2
- Step 3Correct
You inverted the concentration ratio for the extruded proton. Because protons move outward from inside to outside, the destination over source ratio is , which equals , not .
- Step 4Correct
This step correctly evaluated the algebraic expression using your inverted ratio, but the result is incorrect due to the propagated error from Step 3.
- Step 5
Because is negative, inward transport can spontaneously drive extrusion.
CorrectBecause , the transporter is at thermodynamic equilibrium; inward transport cannot provide net spontaneous driving force to extrude further under these conditions.
Because your calculated was artificially negative from the inverted ratio, your conclusion about transport spontaneity was incorrect.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou stated the correct net electrochemical potential equation combining chemical and electrical components.
You clearly reasoned that equal and opposite monovalent ion movements make the exchange electroneutral ().
You accurately converted pH values into hydronium ion concentrations.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou wrote the algebraic term as in your formula, but accidentally evaluated on the next line.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisConfusing the direction of transport (source vs. destination) when setting up ion concentration gradients, leading to an inverted concentration ratio for species transported out of the cell.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Destination-over-Source Rule
For any passive or active movement of ion from compartment A to compartment B, the chemical driving force ratio inside the natural logarithm is always .
Always explicitly write labels with 'dest' and 'src' next to each ion before substituting numerical values.
- Sign Sense Check for Uphill Transport
Transporting a substance against its chemical gradient from lower to higher concentration must yield a positive chemical .
Check that extruding protons from () into a more acidic compartment at () costs energy (). Multiplying two values less than indicated two downhill movements, which violates the antiporter's secondary active transport mechanism.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationDetermine the correct proton ratio for outward transport: .
Multiply the coupled concentration ratios inside the logarithm: .
Calculate the net chemical free energy: .
; the system is at thermodynamic equilibrium, so inward movement does not spontaneously drive further outward extrusion under these exact conditions.
03 The student subtracts pH values directly as the proton concentration ratio instead of using 10^(-ΔpH).
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
Moving one in adds and moving one out adds , so the electrical work sums to .
- Step 2
- Step 3Correct
Because , a difference in represents an exponential factor of 10. Subtracting the values directly gives , which means the concentration ratio is , not .
- Step 4Correct
Your arithmetic was carried out accurately using your ratio of , but the numerical value was affected by the incorrect proton concentration ratio.
- Step 5
Because is , inward transport spontaneously drives extrusion.
CorrectBecause , the transporter is at thermodynamic equilibrium and there is no net driving force under these conditions.
Your conclusion was logical based on your calculated negative free energy, but with the correct ratio of , the inward sodium gradient () exactly balances the outward proton gradient ().
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly derived the net electrochemical free energy equation by balancing the inward and outward chemical and electrical components.
You clearly justified the electroneutrality of the antiporter by showing that .
You correctly computed the sodium concentration ratio as .
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou treated the arithmetic difference between two pH values as a direct concentration ratio rather than a power of 10.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisConfusing logarithmic scale differences with linear concentration ratios. Since , the ratio of two proton concentrations is , not .
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Converting pH to Proton Ratio
Always convert pH values back to molar concentrations using before substituting them into a concentration ratio or free energy equation.
- Thermodynamic Equilibrium in Exchangers
When , .
Check whether equal fold-gradients in opposing directions cancel out completely to zero net free energy.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationConvert each to : and .
Calculate the outward proton ratio: .
Substitute both chemical ratios into : .
(a) The electrical term cancels because ; (b) (the system is at thermodynamic equilibrium, so there is no net driving force).
Lock it in
How do you determine whether a coupled transporter (symporter or antiporter) is electroneutral or electrogenic?
Calculate the net charge translocated across the membrane per cycle: . If , it is electroneutral and contributes zero electrical driving force.
Similar question
A renal bicarbonate cotransporter moves and in the same direction out of the cell into the interstitial space. Write the net electrical term for this transport cycle where .
Answer
Net charge moved inward is (or moving outward means net outward charge of , equivalent to net inward charge of ). Across , moving and has electrical work .
The cardiac exchanger (NCX) exchanges . At and , calculate the electrical free energy component for one forward cycle in .
Answer
Net charge entering the cell is . Therefore, . (The negative membrane potential favors inward forward transport).
An intestinal cell absorbs glucose via the SGLT1 symporter () at with . If and , calculate the maximum theoretical concentration ratio that this sodium gradient can sustain at thermodynamic equilibrium.
Answer
For entry: . At equilibrium, . Since , , giving (an accumulation ratio of ~9000-fold).