Resources
In a laboratory experiment on meiosis in male grasshoppers (), a temperature-sensitive spindle toxin is applied right at the boundary between Anaphase I and Telophase I, preventing cytokinesis from occurring after homologous chromosome segregation, but allowing the nuclear membranes to briefly reform and the cells to proceed directly into Meiosis II without a second interphase. If sister chromatids successfully separate during an uninhibited Anaphase II and are subsequently partitioned into two daughter nuclei by a single terminal cytokinesis, determine: (a) the chromosome number ( or state) and total chromatid count of each resulting daughter cell, and (b) whether these resulting gametes represent a viable haploid state or an aberrant ploidy state.
Answer and steps
Final answer
(a) Each resulting cell contains (), corresponding to a diploid () unreduced chromosome complement; (b) Aberrant diploid state (unreduced gametes), which upon fertilization with a normal haploid gamete () would produce triploid () offspring.
Steps
Normal Chromosome and Chromatid Baseline in the Primary Spermatocyte
The male grasshopper has a diploid chromosome number of .
- Before entering meiosis, during the S phase of interphase, each chromosome replicates to form two sister chromatids joined at a centromere.
- At Prophase I and Metaphase I, the primary spermatocyte contains , which equals .
Consequences of Inhibiting Cytokinesis I
In normal Meiosis I:
- Homologous chromosome pairs separate during Anaphase I: move toward each pole.
- Cytokinesis I normally cleaves the cell into two distinct secondary spermatocytes, each receiving (), achieving a haploid () state.
When cytokinesis I is blocked:
- Segregation of homologues occurs, but cytoplasmic division does not take place.
- All () remain within a single undivided cell.
Progression Through Meiosis II and Single Terminal Cytokinesis
- During Anaphase II, sister chromatids separate: each centromere divides, converting each chromatid into an individual, single-stranded chromosome.
- Across the entire undivided cell, all separate into individual chromosomes.
- When the single terminal cytokinesis divides the cell into two daughter cells, the separated chromatids are partitioned equally between the two resulting daughter cells:
Thus, each resulting cell receives (). This equals the full diploid complement (), rather than the normal haploid complement ().
Assessing Ploidy and Viability of the Resulting Gametes
- Ploidy State: Gametes normally contain a reduced, haploid set (). Because cytokinesis failed at Meiosis I, the reduction division was bypassed, resulting in unreduced, diploid () gametes.
- Fertilization Consequence: These gametes represent an aberrant ploidy state. If an unreduced diploid sperm () fertilizes a normal haploid egg (), the resulting zygote will have: This creates an aberrant triploid () individual, which typically suffers from developmental abnormalities and meiotic sterility.
Summary of Results
- (a) Each daughter cell contains (), corresponding to a diploid () unreduced chromosome complement.
- (b) These represent an aberrant diploid state (unreduced gametes) that would yield triploid () offspring upon fertilization with a normal haploid gamete ().
Typical errors
01 The student forgets that cytokinesis I failed and applies the standard meiotic division outcome, incorrectly concluding that the resulting cells are normal haploid gametes with 12 chromosomes.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
Homologs separate in meiosis I, reducing chromosome number to .
CorrectHomologues segregate, but because cytokinesis I is inhibited, the cell does not divide; all remain within a single undivided cell.
You treated Meiosis I as a normal reduction division into two separate cells. Because the spindle toxin blocks cytokinesis I, no division occurs, leaving all () together.
- Step 2
Sister chromatids separate in meiosis II, giving 12 single chromatids per cell. ⟹ Chromosome number: (haploid state), total chromatids = 12
CorrectSister chromatids separate in Anaphase II ( total), and a single terminal cytokinesis divides them into two cells: () per cell, representing a diploid () complement.
Because cytokinesis I failed, all sister chromatids separate within one cell during Anaphase II. The single terminal cytokinesis splits these single-stranded chromosomes equally into two daughter cells, yielding chromosomes per cell rather than .
- Step 3
The gametes represent a normal viable haploid state.
CorrectThe gametes represent an aberrant diploid state (, unreduced gametes), which upon fertilization with a normal haploid gamete () would form triploid () offspring.
Because the resulting cells retain the full diploid complement (), they are unreduced gametes rather than normal haploid gametes.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly identified that homologous chromosomes segregate in Meiosis I.
You correctly recognized that sister chromatids separate in Meiosis II.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou solved for a canonical, uninterrupted meiotic division instead of accounting for the experimental block of cytokinesis I.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou treated chromosome reduction as an automatic consequence of nuclear anaphase rather than tracking how physical cytoplasmic division partitions the total pool of chromatids into separate cells.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Track physical cell division
Nuclear segregation changes chromosome positions, but cellular reduction requires cytokinesis to physically enclose those genomes into separate cells.
Always draw or inventory total chromatids per cytoplasm before and after each cytokinesis event.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationAt the start of meiosis, the cell has replicated chromosomes ().
Homologues separate at Anaphase I, but cytokinesis I is blocked, leaving all inside a single cell.
Anaphase II separates all sister chromatids into individual, single-stranded chromosomes.
A single terminal cytokinesis partitions the cytoplasm into two cells: .
(a) (), representing a diploid () state; (b) Aberrant diploid state (unreduced gametes).
02 The student confuses chromatid count with chromosome count after sister chromatid separation in anaphase II, concluding that each daughter cell has 48 chromatids.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
Failure of cytokinesis I retains all replicated chromosomes ( chromatids) in one cell.
- Step 2
Sister chromatids separate in anaphase II to double the chromatid count to before division.
CorrectDuring anaphase II, centromeres split so the sister chromatids disjoin to become individual single-stranded chromosomes; the total number of chromatid strands remains .
Centromere cleavage separates existing sister chromatids into individual single-stranded chromosomes without replicating DNA; it does not double the number of chromatid strands to .
- Step 3
Terminal cytokinesis divides chromatids into two cells, yielding chromosomes () and chromatids per cell.
CorrectBecause you doubled the chromatid count in the previous step, your resulting chromatid count was doubled as well. Dividing the actual chromatids between the two daughter cells yields single-stranded chromosomes ( chromatids) per cell.
- Step 4
These gametes represent an aberrant diploid ploidy state.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly recognized that blocking cytokinesis I leaves all replicated chromosomes in one undivided cell.
You correctly identified that the resulting gametes possess an aberrant diploid ploidy state rather than a normal haploid state.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou treated centromere division and sister chromatid disjunction during anaphase as a DNA duplication event that doubles chromatids, confusing the doubling of individual single-stranded chromosome units with an increase in physical DNA/chromatid strands.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Anaphase Separation Rule
Separating sister chromatids splits existing two-chromatid chromosomes into single-stranded chromosomes; it doubles the chromosome count temporarily, but never changes the total number of chromatid/DNA strands.
Count centromeres for chromosome number and count individual DNA strands for chromatid number, remembering that only S phase replicates DNA.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationIn anaphase II, the centromeres of all replicated chromosomes divide, converting the sister chromatids into separate single-stranded chromosomes.
A single terminal cytokinesis cleaves the cytoplasm evenly into two cells, partitioning single-stranded chromosomes into each daughter cell.
Each resulting daughter cell therefore contains chromosomes, each consisting of chromatid, for a total of chromatids ().
(a) Each resulting cell contains (), corresponding to an unreduced diploid () complement; (b) Aberrant diploid state (unreduced gametes).
03 The student misinterprets the separation of sister chromatids as doubling the ploidy level to tetraploid (4n) in the daughter cells.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
Meiosis I fails to divide the cell, leaving replicated chromosomes.
- Step 2
Sister chromatids separate in anaphase II, which doubles the chromosome set to .
CorrectDuring Anaphase II, centromeres divide and sister chromatids separate toward opposite poles, producing individual single-stranded chromosomes ( moving to each pole) without altering the ploidy level.
You correctly realized that centromere separation produces individual single-stranded chromosomes. However, sister chromatids are identical replicates of DNA, not additional homologous chromosome sets, so their separation does not double the ploidy sets to .
- Step 3
Cytokinesis partitions these into two cells with chromosomes and chromatids each.
CorrectCytokinesis partitions the separated chromosomes equally between the two daughter cells: () per cell, yielding a diploid () complement.
When cytokinesis divides the undivided cell into two daughter cells, the separated chromosomes are shared equally between them. Each daughter cell receives chromosomes ( chromatids), not .
- Step 4
These gametes represent an aberrant tetraploid ploidy state.
CorrectThe resulting gametes represent an aberrant unreduced diploid state ().
Because each daughter cell receives single-stranded chromosomes (), the resulting gametes are unreduced diploids rather than tetraploids.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly identified that blocking cytokinesis after Meiosis I leaves the cell with replicated chromosomes ( chromatids).
You recognized that sister chromatids separate during Anaphase II to become individual single-stranded chromosomes.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou assigned all separated chromosomes to each daughter cell instead of dividing them equally (rac{48}{2} = 24) during cytokinesis.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou equated the separation of sister chromatids with an increase in ploidy sets (), conflating chromatid count () with homologous chromosome sets () and assuming that terminal cytokinesis preserves the undivided cell's total chromosome count in each daughter cell.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Distinguish Chromosome Sets (n) from Chromatid Count (c)
Sister chromatids are identical replicates produced during S phase. Splitting them separates existing copies; it does not add new homologous chromosome sets to increase ploidy.
Track ploidy by counting distinct homologous sets (), not by the temporary number of separated single chromatids.
- Divide Cell Contents During Cytokinesis
Cytokinesis divides the total pool of chromosomes gathered at opposite poles equally between the two resulting daughter cells.
When a single cell containing separated chromosomes divides into two daughter cells, calculate each daughter cell's complement as .
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationNote that the undivided cell enters Meiosis II with replicated chromosomes ( chromatids).
In Anaphase II, centromeres divide and sister chromatids separate: single-stranded chromosomes move toward one pole, and move toward the opposite pole.
Terminal cytokinesis cleaves between the two poles, allocating () to each daughter cell.
Compare this count () to the normal haploid complement (): each gamete possesses , which is an unreduced diploid state.
(a) Each resulting cell contains (), corresponding to an unreduced diploid () state; (b) Aberrant diploid state (unreduced gametes).
Lock it in
What happens to the chromatid count in a cell if homologous chromosomes separate in Anaphase I but cytokinesis I fails?
All chromatids remain in a single undivided cell (e.g., remain together). Karyokinesis moves chromatids to opposite poles, but cytokinesis is required to divide them into separate cells.
Similar question
A diploid plant cell () completes DNA replication, undergoes normal Meiosis I and cytokinesis I, but cytokinesis II is completely blocked in both daughter cells after sister chromatids separate in Anaphase II. How many nuclei and how many single chromosomes per cell are present in each resulting cell?
Answer
Each of the secondary spermatocytes/cells contains , with per nucleus ( total per binucleate cell). Alternatively, if the nuclei fuse, each cell has a single tetraploid/diploid complement of .
In a yeast strain (), a mutation blocks Anaphase II sister chromatid separation entirely, but cytokinesis II proceeds normally after a normal Meiosis I and cytokinesis I. One daughter cell receives both chromatids of every chromosome pair while the other receives none. What are the chromosome numbers and ploidy states of these two daughter cells?
Answer
One daughter cell receives (, diploid equivalent), while the other daughter cell receives (nullisomic/inviable).
An animal cell with undergoes meiosis where cytokinesis I fails completely, but anaphase II proceeds normally. However, during the single terminal cytokinesis, the cleavage furrow forms eccentrically, partitioning the 20 separated single chromatids in a ratio between the two daughter cells. State the chromosome number of each resulting cell and identify the resulting ploidy abnormalities.
Answer
The larger daughter cell receives (, triploid complement), and the smaller daughter cell receives (, haploid complement). Both arise from asymmetric partitioning of unreduced meiotic division.