Resources
A researcher tracks chromosome coordinates in a dividing mammalian somatic cell () defining the spindle pole-to-pole axis as the -axis, with the equatorial metaphase plate located at and the two centrosomes fixed at and . At time , separase cleaves cohesin. At , the mean position of one set of separated sister chromatid centromeres is (moving with velocity vector ) while the opposing set is at (moving with velocity vector ). Identify: (a) the active mitotic stage, and (b) avoid the common sign and terminology trap by explaining whether the distance between homologous chromosomes or between sister chromatids is increasing along the -axis, explicitly noting the ploidy state of each pole's chromosome cluster.
Answer and steps
Final answer
(a) Mitotic stage: Anaphase (specifically Anaphase A); (b) The distance between separated sister chromatids (now individual daughter chromosomes) is increasing along the -axis (); homologous chromosomes do not pair during mitosis, and each pole receives a complete diploid () set of individual daughter chromosomes, not a haploid set.
Steps
Identify the Mitotic Stage
- Trigger Event: At time , the protease separase cleaves the cohesin rings that hold sister chromatids together. This cleavage is the biochemical hallmark marking the transition from metaphase to anaphase.
- Kinematic Evidence: At , the two separated sets of centromeres are positioned at and , moving with velocities directed toward their respective spindle poles ( toward the centrosome at , and toward the centrosome at ).
- Sub-stage Designation: Shortening of kinetochore microtubules to pull chromatids toward opposite poles constitutes Anaphase A (while spindle pole separation is Anaphase B). Thus, the active stage is anaphase (specifically Anaphase A).
Determine What is Separating (Sister Chromatids vs. Homologous Chromosomes)
- Separation Entity: In somatic cell mitosis, homologous chromosomes do not pair or form bivalents/tetrads. Each individual replicated chromosome lines up independently at the metaphase plate ().
- When cohesin is cleaved, the linkage between sister chromatids is dissolved. As they move poleward, each former sister chromatid is properly termed a daughter chromosome.
- The distance separating the two sets along the -axis is: This increasing distance is strictly between separated sister chromatids (daughter chromosomes), not between homologous chromosomes.
Determine the Ploidy State of Each Pole
- Common Pitfall: A frequent misconception is confusing mitotic anaphase with meiotic Anaphase I. In Anaphase I of meiosis, homologous pairs separate, leading to a reduction in ploidy ().
- Mitotic Segregation: In this somatic mammalian cell (), all replicated chromosomes (each containing sister chromatids) align at the equator. When the chromatids separate:
- individual daughter chromosomes move toward the negative pole ().
- individual daughter chromosomes move toward the positive pole ().
- Because each pole receives one full set of maternal and paternal chromosomes, each pole's cluster remains fully diploid ().
Typical errors
01 The student confuses mitotic sister chromatid separation with meiotic homologous chromosome separation, concluding that homologous chromosomes are moving apart and each pole becomes haploid.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
Separase cleaving cohesin and movement toward poles indicates anaphase.
- Step 2
The distance between homologous chromosomes is increasing.
CorrectThe distance between separated sister chromatids (daughter chromosomes) is increasing along the -axis.
In mitosis, homologous chromosomes do not pair or segregate. Separase cleaves cohesin between sister chromatids, so it is the sister chromatids (now individual daughter chromosomes) that are moving apart.
- Step 3
Mitosis separates homologous pairs, leaving each pole haploid with .
CorrectEach spindle pole receives a complete diploid () set of daughter chromosomes.
Separation of homologous pairs occurs exclusively during Anaphase I of meiosis, not mitosis. Because all replicated chromosomes split their sister chromatids evenly, each pole receives individual daughter chromosomes, maintaining the diploid state ().
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly identified the active stage of cell division as anaphase from the cleavage of cohesin and poleward movement.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou conflated mitotic anaphase with meiotic Anaphase I. Mitosis maintains ploidy by segregating identical sister chromatids of individual chromosomes, whereas homologous chromosome separation and reduction to haploidy occur only during meiosis I.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Mitosis vs. Meiosis I Segregation Rule
Mitosis separates sister chromatids (), while Meiosis I separates homologous pairs ().
Always verify whether the cell is undergoing somatic mitosis or meiotic reduction before stating the separating entity and resulting ploidy.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationIdentify the cell type and division process: this is a somatic cell undergoing mitosis, so homologous chromosomes do not pair.
Identify the separating structures: cleavage of cohesin releases sister chromatids, which move in opposite directions along the -axis as daughter chromosomes.
Count the chromosomes migrating to each pole: each of the original chromosomes sends one chromatid to pole and one to pole .
Deduce the pole ploidy: each pole receives a complete complement of chromosomes, remaining fully diploid ().
(a) Anaphase (specifically Anaphase A); (b) The distance between sister chromatids (now daughter chromosomes) is increasing along the -axis; each pole's cluster remains diploid ().
02 The student confuses the number of chromatids at each pole with the reduction of ploidy, incorrectly claiming that each pole is haploid because each chromatid is now single-stranded.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
Cohesin is cleaved and chromatids move toward opposite poles at and , so the stage is anaphase.
- Step 2
The distance between sister chromatids is increasing along the -axis as they move apart.
- Step 3
Because each pole receives only one chromatid from each replicated chromosome, each cluster is haploid ().
CorrectEach pole receives one chromatid from each of the replicated chromosomes, forming a complete diploid cluster ().
In mitotic anaphase, each separated sister chromatid becomes an independent chromosome. Because all chromosomes send one chromatid to each pole, both poles receive a complete set of maternal and paternal homologs (), not a haploid set ().
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly diagnosed the mitotic stage as anaphase based on cohesin cleavage and poleward velocity.
You correctly recognized that the separating entities are sister chromatids rather than homologous pairs.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou conflated chromosome replication status (replicated vs. unreplicated) with ploidy level ( vs. ). Ploidy is determined by whether homologous chromosome pairs are present, not by whether chromosomes consist of one or two chromatids.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Count Centromeres, Not Chromatids, for Chromosome Number
Every independent centromere defines one functional chromosome. When cohesin cleaves, sister chromatids become independent daughter chromosomes.
Count the total number of centromeres moving toward one pole to determine the chromosome count of that pole.
- Distinguish Mitotic Segregation from Meiotic Reduction
Mitosis preserves ploidy: a parent cell produces two clusters. Reduction to occurs only in Meiosis I when homologous pairs separate.
Verify whether homologous pairs paired and separated (Meiosis I) or individual duplicated chromosomes split their sister chromatids (Mitosis).
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationThe parent somatic cell is diploid with (containing pairs of homologous chromosomes).
During metaphase, all duplicated chromosomes align independently along the equatorial plate.
In anaphase, each of the chromosomes splits its two sister chromatids apart.
Each pole receives exactly chromatid from each of the chromosomes, giving daughter chromosomes per pole.
Because both members of each homologous pair are still represented at each pole, both poles remain diploid ().
(a) Anaphase (specifically Anaphase A); (b) The distance between sister chromatids is increasing; each pole's cluster remains diploid ().
Lock it in
What specific chromosome structures separate during mitotic anaphase versus meiotic Anaphase I?
Mitotic anaphase separates sister chromatids; meiotic Anaphase I separates homologous chromosome pairs.
Similar question
A mammalian dermal fibroblast () enters anaphase. State: (1) what structures are being pulled toward opposite centrosomes, (2) the total count of individual centromeres moving to each pole, and (3) the ploidy of each developing daughter nucleus.
Answer
(1) Sister chromatids (daughter chromosomes) separate; (2) Exactly 46 individual centromeres move to each pole; (3) Each pole is diploid ().
During live-cell fluorescence imaging of a plant cell (), sister kinetochores split and move apart along the spindle axis. A student claims: 'Because the chromosomes split in half, the poles are now haploid ().' Explain why this claim is incorrect and state the actual chromosome count per pole.
Answer
The claim confuses chromatid separation with chromosome reduction. Each of the 16 replicated chromosomes consists of two identical sister chromatids; when they split, each pole receives one full copy of all 16 chromosomes. Therefore, each pole remains diploid with 16 chromosomes, not haploid ().
Compare two dividing cells from the same organism (): Cell A is in mitotic anaphase, while Cell B is in meiotic Anaphase I. For each cell, describe the configuration of moving chromosomes along the spindle axis, state whether cohesin along the chromosome arms or at the centromeres is cleaved, and give the ploidy at each pole.
Answer
Cell A (Mitosis): Separates 6 individual pairs of sister chromatids; centromeric cohesin is cleaved; each pole receives 6 daughter chromosomes and remains diploid (). Cell B (Meiosis I): Separates 3 homologous bivalents (homolog pairs) while sister chromatids remain joined at their centromeres; arm cohesin is cleaved but centromeric cohesin is protected by shugoshin; each pole receives 3 replicated chromosomes and becomes haploid ().