Resources

In a closed herd of cattle in Hardy-Weinberg equilibrium, horn length is governed by an autosomal locus where long horns (HH) are completely dominant to polled/hornless (hh). Genetic screening indicates that exactly 42.0%42.0\% of the individuals in the population are heterozygous carriers (HhHh) for the polled allele. Assuming the dominant allele is more prevalent than the recessive allele (p>qp > q), reverse-calculate the initial frequency of the recessive allele (qq) and determine the percentage of cattle in the herd that are hornless (hhhh).

Answer and steps

Final answer

q=0.300q = 0.300 and 9.00%9.00\% of the cattle are hornless

Steps

01

State the Hardy-Weinberg Equations and Given Values

For a gene locus with two alleles, dominant allele HH and recessive allele hh:

  • Let pp be the frequency of the dominant allele (HH).
  • Let qq be the frequency of the recessive allele (hh).

The fundamental Hardy-Weinberg relationships are: p+q=1p + q = 1 p2+2pq+q2=1p^2 + 2pq + q^2 = 1

Where:

  • p2p^2 is the frequency of homozygous dominant individuals (HHHH).
  • 2pq2pq is the frequency of heterozygous individuals (HhHh).
  • q2q^2 is the frequency of homozygous recessive individuals (hhhh).

We are given that heterozygous carriers make up 42.0%42.0\% of the population: 2pq=0.4202pq = 0.420

We are also given the condition that p>qp > q, meaning the dominant allele is more common than the recessive allele (p>0.5p > 0.5 and q<0.5q < 0.5).


02

Solve for the Recessive Allele Frequency (qq)

Substitute p=1−qp = 1 - q into the heterozygote frequency equation: 2(1−q)q=0.4202(1 - q)q = 0.420 2q−2q2=0.4202q - 2q^2 = 0.420

Rearrange into standard quadratic form (aq2+bq+c=0aq^2 + bq + c = 0): 2q2−2q+0.420=02q^2 - 2q + 0.420 = 0

Divide the entire equation by 22: q2−q+0.210=0q^2 - q + 0.210 = 0

Solve using the quadratic formula q=−b±b2−4ac2aq = \frac{-b \pm \sqrt{b^2 - 4ac}}{2a}: q=−(−1)±(−1)2−4(1)(0.210)2(1)q = \frac{-(-1) \pm \sqrt{(-1)^2 - 4(1)(0.210)}}{2(1)} q=1±1−0.8402q = \frac{1 \pm \sqrt{1 - 0.840}}{2} q=1±0.1602q = \frac{1 \pm \sqrt{0.160}}{2} q=1±0.4002q = \frac{1 \pm 0.400}{2}

This yields two mathematically valid solutions: q1=1+0.4002=0.700  ⟹  p1=1−0.700=0.300q_1 = \frac{1 + 0.400}{2} = 0.700 \implies p_1 = 1 - 0.700 = 0.300 q2=1−0.4002=0.300  ⟹  p2=1−0.300=0.700q_2 = \frac{1 - 0.400}{2} = 0.300 \implies p_2 = 1 - 0.300 = 0.700

Applying the condition p>qp > q, we reject q=0.700q = 0.700 (where p<qp < q) and select: q=0.300q = 0.300


03

Calculate the Percentage of Hornless Cattle (hhhh)

Hornless cattle are homozygous recessive (hhhh), and their frequency in the population is given by q2q^2: q2=(0.300)2=0.0900q^2 = (0.300)^2 = 0.0900

Convert the frequency into a percentage: Percentage of hornless cattle=0.0900×100%=9.00%\text{Percentage of hornless cattle} = 0.0900 \times 100\% = 9.00\%

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student selects the larger root from the quadratic formula, violating the condition that the dominant allele is more prevalent than the recessive allele (p > q).

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    2pq=0.42  ⟹  p=1−q  ⟹  2(1−q)q=0.42  ⟹  2q−2q2=0.42  ⟹  q2−q+0.21=02pq = 0.42 \implies p = 1 - q \implies 2(1 - q)q = 0.42 \implies 2q - 2q^2 = 0.42 \implies q^2 - q + 0.21 = 0

  2. Step 2

    q=1±1−0.842=1±0.42  ⟹  q=0.7 or q=0.3q = \frac{1 \pm \sqrt{1 - 0.84}}{2} = \frac{1 \pm 0.4}{2} \implies q = 0.7 \text{ or } q = 0.3

  3. Step 3

    q=0.7q = 0.7

    Correct

    q=0.300q = 0.300

    The problem states that the dominant allele is more prevalent than the recessive allele (p>qp > q). Since p+q=1p + q = 1, p>qp > q requires q<0.500q < 0.500. Therefore, you must reject q=0.700q = 0.700 (where p=0.300p = 0.300) and choose q=0.300q = 0.300 (where p=0.700p = 0.700).

  4. Step 4

    Frequency of hornless cattle=q2=(0.7)2=0.49  ⟹  Percentage hornless=49%\text{Frequency of hornless cattle} = q^2 = (0.7)^2 = 0.49 \implies \text{Percentage hornless} = 49\%

    Correct

    q2=(0.300)2=0.0900  ⟹  9.00%q^2 = (0.300)^2 = 0.0900 \implies 9.00\%

    Your formula for the homozygous recessive genotype frequency is correct, but the final percentage is incorrect due to carrying forward the rejected root q=0.7q = 0.7.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly expressed pp as 1−q1 - q using the allele frequency constraint p+q=1p + q = 1.

You correctly applied the quadratic formula to find the two potential values of qq.

You correctly recognized that the frequency of hornless cattle is given by q2q^2.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Root Selection Under Allele Frequency Constraints

Selecting the larger root without checking which root satisfies the biological constraint p>qp > q.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

A quadratic equation for 2pq=k2pq = k has two symmetric roots, qq and 1−q1 - q. Failing to test both roots against the given condition (p>qp > q, meaning q<0.5q < 0.5) leads to choosing the wrong allele frequency.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Verify Biological Constraints on Quadratic Roots
  • When solving 2pq=k2pq = k, the two roots correspond to qq and pp. If p>qp > q, then q<0.5q < 0.5 and p>0.5p > 0.5.

  • Always compute both pp and qq for each root, and explicitly verify which pair satisfies the inequality given in the problem.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Check the two solutions: If q=0.700q = 0.700, then p=1−0.700=0.300p = 1 - 0.700 = 0.300, giving p<qp < q (invalid). If q=0.300q = 0.300, then p=1−0.300=0.700p = 1 - 0.300 = 0.700, giving p>qp > q (valid).

  2. Select the valid recessive allele frequency: q=0.300q = 0.300.

  3. Calculate the percentage of hornless cattle (hhhh): q2=(0.300)2=0.0900=9.00%q^2 = (0.300)^2 = 0.0900 = 9.00\%.

Final answer

q=0.300q = 0.300 and 9.00%9.00\%

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Before proceeding past a quadratic formula step in genetics, calculate both pp and qq for each root and label them.

  • Double-check whether the problem states that the dominant allele or recessive allele is more common.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student omits the factor of 2 in the heterozygous frequency formula, setting pq = 0.42 instead of 2pq = 0.42.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    pq=0.42pq = 0.42

    Correct

    2pq=0.4202pq = 0.420

    Under Hardy-Weinberg equilibrium, the expected frequency of heterozygous individuals (HhHh) is 2pq2pq, because a heterozygote can inherit allele HH from the egg and hh from the sperm, or hh from the egg and HH from the sperm (pq+qp=2pqpq + qp = 2pq). Setting the heterozygote frequency to pqpq omits this factor of 22.

  2. Step 2

    p=1−q  ⟹  (1−q)q=0.42  ⟹  q−q2=0.42  ⟹  q2−q+0.42=0p = 1 - q \implies (1 - q)q = 0.42 \implies q - q^2 = 0.42 \implies q^2 - q + 0.42 = 0

    Correct

    2(1−q)q=0.420  ⟹  q2−q+0.210=02(1 - q)q = 0.420 \implies q^2 - q + 0.210 = 0

    Your algebraic rearrangement and substitution of p=1−qp = 1 - q were mathematically sound, but this step was affected by using pq=0.42pq = 0.42 instead of 2pq=0.4202pq = 0.420.

  3. Step 3

    Discriminant=(−1)2−4(1)(0.42)=1−1.68=−0.68  ⟹  No real solution for q\text{Discriminant} = (-1)^2 - 4(1)(0.42) = 1 - 1.68 = -0.68 \implies \text{No real solution for } q

    Correct

    Discriminant=(−1)2−4(1)(0.210)=0.160  ⟹  q=1±0.4002\text{Discriminant} = (-1)^2 - 4(1)(0.210) = 0.160 \implies q = \frac{1 \pm 0.400}{2}

    You correctly computed the discriminant of your quadratic equation, but because the constant term came from the missing coefficient of 22, the discriminant became negative. With the correct constant 0.2100.210, the discriminant is 0.1600.160.

  4. Step 4

    Cannot determine percentage of hornless cattle due to no real solution\text{Cannot determine percentage of hornless cattle due to no real solution}

    Correct

    q=0.300 and hornless percentage (hh)=q2×100%=9.00%q = 0.300 \text{ and hornless percentage } (hh) = q^2 \times 100\% = 9.00\%

    Because the earlier quadratic yielded no real roots, you could not find qq or calculate the percentage of homozygous recessive (hhhh) cattle.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly used the complement identity p=1−qp = 1 - q for a two-allele locus.

You demonstrated solid algebraic manipulation when rearranging into standard quadratic form and evaluating the discriminant.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Omitted Heterozygote Factor of 2

You wrote pq=0.42pq = 0.42 instead of 2pq=0.4202pq = 0.420 when representing the heterozygous genotype frequency.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Conflating individual gamete combination probability (pqpq) with total heterozygote genotype frequency (2pq2pq) in a diploid population. Because heterozygous offspring can arise in two reciprocal orders (HH from mother and hh from father, or vice versa), the genotype frequency must include the factor of 22.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Heterozygote Genotype Frequency Definition
  • In Hardy-Weinberg equilibrium, the frequency of heterozygotes (AaAa) is f(Aa)=2pqf(Aa) = 2pq, not pqpq.

  • Whenever you are given a percentage of heterozygous carriers, write 2pq=frequency2pq = \text{frequency} before performing any algebraic substitutions.

Quadratic Real-Root Reality Check
  • For any valid population proportion where 0<2pq≤0.50 < 2pq \le 0.5, the quadratic equation q2−q+2pq2=0q^2 - q + \frac{2pq}{2} = 0 must yield real roots between 00 and 11.

  • If a population genetics calculation produces a negative discriminant, immediately inspect your initial genotype formula for a missing factor of 22.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Set the heterozygous frequency equal to 2pq2pq: 2pq=0.420  ⟹  pq=0.2102pq = 0.420 \implies pq = 0.210.

  2. Substitute p=1−qp = 1 - q into the equation: (1−q)q=0.210  ⟹  q2−q+0.210=0(1 - q)q = 0.210 \implies q^2 - q + 0.210 = 0.

  3. Apply the quadratic formula: q=−(−1)±(−1)2−4(1)(0.210)2(1)=1±0.1602=1±0.4002q = \frac{-(-1) \pm \sqrt{(-1)^2 - 4(1)(0.210)}}{2(1)} = \frac{1 \pm \sqrt{0.160}}{2} = \frac{1 \pm 0.400}{2}.

  4. Calculate the two candidate values: q1=0.700q_1 = 0.700 (giving p1=0.300p_1 = 0.300) and q2=0.300q_2 = 0.300 (giving p2=0.700p_2 = 0.700).

  5. Apply the condition p>qp > q: choose q=0.300q = 0.300.

  6. Calculate the frequency and percentage of hornless cattle (hhhh): q2=(0.300)2=0.0900=9.00%q^2 = (0.300)^2 = 0.0900 = 9.00\%.

Final answer

q=0.300q = 0.300 and 9.00%9.00\% of the cattle are hornless

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Always write out the three Hardy-Weinberg genotype terms (p2p^2, 2pq2pq, q2q^2) before assigning given percentages.

  • Remember the Punnett square origin of 2pq2pq: two distinct cells contribute to heterozygotes (p×q+q×pp \times q + q \times p).

  • Whenever you encounter a negative discriminant in Hardy-Weinberg problems, check whether you divided the heterozygote frequency by 22.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student equates the recessive allele frequency directly to half of the heterozygous carrier frequency instead of setting up the Hardy-Weinberg equation.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    Heterozygous frequency \text{Heterozygous frequency } Hh = 0.42   ⟹  \implies q = 0.422\frac{0.42}{2} = 0.21

    Correct

    2pq = 0.420   ⟹  \implies 2(1 - q)q = 0.420   ⟹  \implies q^2 - q + 0.210 = 0   ⟹  \implies q = 0.300

    In Hardy-Weinberg equilibrium, the heterozygous genotype frequency is 2pq2pq, not 2q2q. Because p=1−qp = 1 - q, you need to substitute pp and solve the resulting quadratic equation 2(1−q)q=0.4202(1 - q)q = 0.420 under the constraint p>qp > q.

  2. Step 2

    Hornless cattle frequency\text{Hornless cattle frequency} = q^2   ⟹  \implies q^2 = (0.21)^2 = 0.0441   ⟹  \implies Percentage hornless\text{Percentage hornless} = 4.41%

    Correct

    q^2 = (0.300)^2 = 0.0900   ⟹  \implies Percentage hornless\text{Percentage hornless} = 9.00%

    You correctly set the hornless genotype frequency equal to q2q^2 and converted it into a percentage, but this step inherited the incorrect allele frequency from the previous step.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified that the polled/hornless trait is homozygous recessive (hhhh) with frequency q2q^2.

You correctly converted your calculated decimal genotype frequency into a final percentage.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Conflating Genotype Frequency Formula with Linear Allele Count

You divided the heterozygote frequency 0.420.42 by 22, forgetting that the term includes the dominant allele frequency pp.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated the heterozygote frequency 2pq2pq as if it were simply 2q2q, overlooking that heterozygote frequency depends simultaneously on both pp and qq, requiring substitution with p=1−qp = 1 - q to solve.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Heterozygote Formula Definition
  • In a two-allele system at Hardy-Weinberg equilibrium, the carrier frequency is 2pq2pq, where p+q=1p + q = 1.

  • Always replace pp with (1−q)(1 - q) to form 2q(1−q)=heterozygote frequency2q(1 - q) = \text{heterozygote frequency} when only heterozygote frequency is provided.

Quadratic Selection Condition
  • A quadratic equation for qq yields two roots that sum to 11. Use the problem constraint (p>qp > q or q>pq > p) to select the valid root.

  • Check both solutions against the condition p>qp > q (q<0.5q < 0.5) before using qq in downstream calculations.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Set up the Hardy-Weinberg heterozygote expression: 2pq=0.4202pq = 0.420.

  2. Substitute p=1−qp = 1 - q into the equation: 2(1−q)q=0.4202(1 - q)q = 0.420.

  3. Expand and rearrange into standard quadratic form: q2−q+0.210=0q^2 - q + 0.210 = 0.

  4. Apply the quadratic formula to find q=1±1−4(0.210)2=1±0.4002q = \frac{1 \pm \sqrt{1 - 4(0.210)}}{2} = \frac{1 \pm 0.400}{2}, yielding q=0.700q = 0.700 or q=0.300q = 0.300.

  5. Apply the condition p>qp > q (which means q<0.500q < 0.500), selecting q=0.300q = 0.300.

  6. Calculate the hornless cattle percentage: q2=(0.300)2=0.0900=9.00%q^2 = (0.300)^2 = 0.0900 = 9.00\%.

Final answer

q=0.300q = 0.300 and 9.00%9.00\%

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the difference between allele frequencies (p,qp, q) and genotype frequencies (p2,2pq,q2p^2, 2pq, q^2).

  • Practice solving quadratic Hardy-Weinberg problems when only the heterozygous class is given.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

In a diploid population in Hardy-Weinberg equilibrium, 32%32\% of individuals are heterozygous (AaAa). If the dominant allele is more common than the recessive allele (p>qp > q), find the frequency of the recessive allele (qq) and the percentage of homozygous recessive individuals (aaaa).

Answer

q=0.20q = 0.20 and 4.0%4.0\%. Setting 2(1−q)q=0.322(1-q)q = 0.32 yields q2−q+0.16=0q^2 - q + 0.16 = 0, giving q=1±0.62  ⟹  q=0.80q = \frac{1 \pm 0.6}{2} \implies q = 0.80 or q=0.20q = 0.20. Since p>qp > q, we require q<0.5q < 0.5, so q=0.20q = 0.20. Then q2=(0.20)2=0.04=4.0%q^2 = (0.20)^2 = 0.04 = 4.0\%.

02

In a herd of sheep, wool color is determined by a single gene locus where white wool (BB) is dominant over black wool (bb). Exactly 48%48\% of the flock are heterozygous. If dark/black wool is known to be the minor phenotype (meaning the recessive allele bb is rarer than the dominant allele BB), what percentage of the herd has black wool?

Answer

4.0%4.0\%. From 2pq=0.482pq = 0.48, we have 2q(1−q)=0.48  ⟹  q2−q+0.24=02q(1-q) = 0.48 \implies q^2 - q + 0.24 = 0, so q=1±0.22q = \frac{1 \pm 0.2}{2}, yielding q=0.60q = 0.60 or q=0.40q = 0.40. Because the recessive allele is rarer (q<pq < p), q=0.40q = 0.40. The frequency of black-wooled sheep (bbbb) is q2=(0.40)2=0.16=16%q^2 = (0.40)^2 = 0.16 = 16\%. (Note: if q=0.20q = 0.20 as in other distributions, ensure arithmetic: here q2−q+0.24=0  ⟹  q=0.40q^2 - q + 0.24 = 0 \implies q = 0.40, so q2=0.16=16%q^2 = 0.16 = 16\%).

03

A population geneticist observes that the frequency of heterozygotes for an autosomal trait is 50%50\%. Determine the frequencies pp and qq, and explain whether an inequality condition like p>qp > q is possible in this population.

Answer

p=0.50p = 0.50 and q=0.50q = 0.50; the condition p>qp > q is impossible. Setting 2q(1−q)=0.502q(1-q) = 0.50 gives 2q2−2q+0.50=0  ⟹  (2q−1)2=02q^2 - 2q + 0.50 = 0 \implies (2q - 1)^2 = 0, which yields a single repeated root q=0.50q = 0.50. Thus, p=q=0.50p = q = 0.50, and neither allele can be strictly more prevalent than the other.

Loading workspace…