Resources
Hemophilia A is an X-linked recessive bleeding disorder () with normal clotting governed by . A phenotypically normal woman whose father had hemophilia A marries a phenotypically normal man. A genetics student calculates the chance of hemophilia in their children and asserts: 'Because hemophilia is a recessive allele with a Punnett square frequency, the probability that a male child has hemophilia is .' Identify the conditioning error in this reasoning, and calculate the two distinct probabilities: (a) the probability that their first child is a boy with hemophilia, and (b) the conditional probability that the child has hemophilia given that prenatal screening reveals the child is male.
Answer and steps
Final answer
The student conflated overall unconditional probability with conditional probability given sex. (a) Probability that the child is a hemophiliac male = (); (b) Conditional probability that a male child has hemophilia = ().
Steps
Determine the Parental Genotypes
- Mother's genotype: Hemophilia A is an X-linked recessive trait. A female has two X chromosomes. Because the woman's father had hemophilia (), he passed his only X chromosome () to her. Since she is phenotypically normal, her second X chromosome must carry the dominant allele (). Thus, the mother is a carrier with the genotype:
- Father's genotype: The father is phenotypically normal and hemizygous for the X chromosome, so his genotype is:
Construct the Punnett Square
Crossing a carrier female () with an unaffected male ():
Across all four equally likely possible outcomes ( each):
- (unaffected female)
- (carrier female)
- (unaffected male)
- (hemophiliac male)
Identify the Conditioning Error
The student conflated an unconditional joint probability with a conditional probability:
- The fraction represents the joint probability of two simultaneous events: the child is male and has hemophilia: .
- When evaluating "the probability that a male child has hemophilia", the sample space is restricted exclusively to male offspring. Denominating by the entire offspring pool rather than the male subset is a classic conditioning error.
Calculate the Probabilities
- (a) Probability that their first child is a boy with hemophilia: This refers to the joint probability across all possible children:
- (b) Probability that the child has hemophilia given the child is male: Restricting the sample space to male children ( and , which make up of all outcomes):
Typical errors
01 The student calculates the conditional probability in part (b) by multiplying the conditional chance of being affected given male (1/2) by the overall prior probability of having a boy (1/2), erroneously reapplying the sex probability to an already-conditioned male outcome.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
The student evaluated the overall chance of an affected male out of all children rather than restricting the sample space to males. For a male child, the denominator is the number of male outcomes, not total offspring.
- Step 2
Mother is carrier: ⟹ Father is normal: ⟹ Offspring: , , ,
- Step 3
- Step 4Correct
You recognized that among male outcomes, the fraction is , but then you multiplied by . That re-computes the joint probability of having an affected son from all children () rather than keeping the conditional probability given that the child is already known to be male ().
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly identified the mother as a carrier () and the father as unaffected hemizygous ().
You listed all four equally likely offspring genotypes accurately.
You stated the correct joint probability for part (a) as .
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou understood the concept of restricting the sample space to males, but when formalizing the conditional calculation, you conflated the conditional probability with the joint probability .
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Conditional vs. Joint Probability
Conditional probability restricts the universe to condition . You do not multiply by again.
Once a condition is given (e.g., 'given male'), evaluate only the outcomes within that specific condition or use .
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationIdentify the condition: The child is known to be male, so the sample space consists solely of the male offspring: .
Count the favorable outcomes within this restricted sample space: only has hemophilia (1 out of 2 male outcomes).
Calculate .
The conditional probability that the child has hemophilia given that the child is male is (or ).
02 The student treats sex determination as an independent factor to multiply in part (a), taking the 1/4 Punnett square frequency of X^h Y and multiplying it again by 1/2 for being a boy.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
The student confused the proportion of affected males among all offspring with the proportion among sons only. The frequency represents all children, but given male, the reference group is only males.
- Step 2
Mother genotype: Father genotype: Chance of male = Chance of hemophilia from Punnett square =
CorrectIn an X-linked Punnett square, sex is already embedded in the chromosomal genotypes (). The single square representing hemophilia () is already male, so its frequency of already accounts for sex. Multiplying by an additional factor of double-counts the probability of having a son.
- Step 3
Males from cross: and
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly determined the parental genotypes as and .
You clearly explained why dividing by all offspring creates a conditioning error when evaluating risk for sons.
You accurately restricted the sample space to males to calculate the conditional probability in part (b).
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou treated sex as an independent factor to multiply after already pulling a sex-specific genotype () from the Punnett square.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisFailing to recognize that sex chromosomes ( and ) explicitly determine biological sex inside the Punnett square, unlike autosomal traits where sex and genotype are independent events requiring multiplication by .
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Autosomal vs. Sex-Linked Probability Rules
For autosomal genes, sex ( vs. ) is not shown in the square, so . For sex-linked genes, the Punnett square explicitly contains the sex chromosomes, so sex is already built into each box.
Read joint probabilities directly from the square count over total boxes without multiplying by an extra .
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationList the four equally likely outcomes from the cross : , , , and .
Identify the outcome that satisfies 'boy with hemophilia': exactly one outcome, .
Compute the joint probability directly from the Punnett square: ().
Part (a): (); Part (b): ()
Lock it in
What is the difference between and ?
is out of ALL children, while is restricted ONLY to male children.
Similar question
A woman who is a carrier for Duchenne muscular dystrophy () has children with an unaffected male (). An ultrasound determines that she is carrying a girl. What is the probability that this female child will have muscular dystrophy?
Answer
(or ). Female offspring genotypes are and ; both have normal phenotypes because the condition is X-linked recessive.
Red-green colorblindness is an X-linked recessive trait. A carrier woman () and a colorblind man () have a child. (a) What is the probability that their first child is a colorblind girl? (b) Given that their child is a girl, what is the probability she is colorblind?
Answer
(a) (or ), because the possible female offspring are and out of four total offspring. (b) (or ), because out of the two possible female genotypes, one () is colorblind.
In a cross between two individuals heterozygous for an autosomal recessive disorder (), an ultrasound confirms the fetus does not have the disorder. What is the probability that the child is a carrier ()?
Answer
. The unaffected sample space is (size 3), and 2 of these 3 are carriers.