Resources
A cytologist performs karyotyping and quantitative DNA fluorescence on individual dividing cells from an animal with a diploid genome (, with an unreplicated nuclear DNA content of ). An isolated meiotic cell is found to contain distinct, physically separated chromosomes clustered at each of two opposite spindle poles, where each chromosome still consists of two distinct chromatids connected at a centromere, and the total cellular DNA content is measured to be . Reverse-engineer this cellular state to determine: (a) the exact stage of meiosis that immediately preceded this observed configuration, and (b) the total number of chromatids and DNA mass in pg present during that preceding stage.
Answer and steps
Final answer
(a) Anaphase I; (b) chromatids and of DNA (representing the level before reductional division).
Steps
Identify the Observed Meiotic Stage
- Spindle Pole Clustering and Chromosome Structure: The cell exhibits distinct chromosomes gathered at each of the two opposite spindle poles, where each chromosome still consists of two sister chromatids joined at a centromere.
- Reduction of Chromosome Number: The organism has a diploid number of . Having double-chromatid chromosomes () at each pole indicates that homologous chromosome pairs have separated and reached the poles without sister chromatid separation.
- Deducing the Current Stage: The accumulation of separated sets of dyads at the poles marks Telophase I (or the telophase I / cytokinesis transition).
- Determining the Immediately Preceding Stage (Part a): The stage directly preceding Telophase I during which these homologous chromosomes traveled along the meiotic spindle toward opposite poles is Anaphase I.
Determine DNA Mass and Chromatid Configuration in the Preceding Stage (Part b)
-
DNA Mass Calculation:
- In the unreplicated diploid phase, the cell contains a DNA content of .
- Prior to meiosis, the cell undergoes DNA replication during meiotic S-phase, doubling the DNA mass from to :
- Throughout Prophase I, Metaphase I, and Anaphase I, this total DNA mass of remains within the single parent cell prior to the physical separation of the cytoplasm during cytokinesis I.
-
Chromatid and Chromosome Assessment:
- Before the reductional division completes, the total meiotic complement corresponding to the genetic level represents duplicated chromatid structures (dyad units) across the dividing complement, yielding of total cellular DNA.
- Therefore, during Anaphase I, the meiotic cell contains chromatids and of DNA.
Typical errors
01 The student misidentifies the observed stage as Anaphase II because there are 8 chromosomes at each pole, leading them to deduce Metaphase II with half the correct chromatid count and DNA mass.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
8 chromosomes at each pole Sister chromatids are separating to poles in meiosis II Preceding stage is Metaphase II
CorrectEach pole receives double-chromatid chromosomes (), meaning homologous chromosomes separated during Anaphase I. The observed stage is Telophase I, so the immediately preceding stage is Anaphase I.
You overlooked the detail that each chromosome at the poles still has two distinct chromatids attached at a centromere. Sister chromatids do not separate until Anaphase II. When double-chromatid chromosomes move to opposite poles, the cell is completing Meiosis I (Telophase I), so the preceding stage was Anaphase I.
- Step 2
In Metaphase II there are 8 replicated chromosomes
CorrectDuring Anaphase I, the cell maintains its replicated DNA complement of (with duplicated chromosome units / chromatid structures).
Your values were derived from your assumption of Metaphase II. Because the preceding stage was actually Anaphase I (prior to cytokinesis I), the cell still holds the full post-replication DNA complement of .
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly recognized that represents the haploid chromosome number for this organism.
You correctly related chromatid counts to replicated chromosomes by multiplying by .
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou assumed sister chromatids were separating because each pole had chromosomes, overlooking that each chromosome was still composed of two sister chromatids.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisConflating homologous chromosome disjunction (Meiosis I) with sister chromatid disjunction (Meiosis II). In Meiosis I, dyads (two-chromatid chromosomes) segregate, leaving each pole with replicated chromosomes; individual single-chromatid chromosomes do not move to opposite poles until Anaphase II.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Inspect Chromatid Structure at the Poles
If chromosomes arriving at the spindle poles consist of two sister chromatids joined at a centromere, reductional division (Meiosis I) has just occurred.
Check whether the migrating units are dyads (two chromatids per centromere Anaphase I / Telophase I) or monads (single chromatids Anaphase II / Telophase II).
- Track $C$-value Across Meiotic Stages
A diploid cell enters Meiosis I at after S-phase replication and remains until cytokinesis I divides it into two cells.
Multiply the baseline () by to find the total cellular DNA mass for any stage from Prophase I through late Anaphase I.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationIdentify the physical structure of chromosomes at each pole: chromosomes, each with chromatids attached at a centromere ( dyads).
Because dyads are segregated, homologous chromosomes separated during Anaphase I and have arrived at poles in Telophase I.
Conclude part (a): The stage immediately preceding Telophase I is Anaphase I.
For part (b), calculate the total cellular DNA content before cytokinesis I: unreplicated has , so the replicated cell in Anaphase I has and duplicated chromatid units.
(a) Anaphase I; (b) chromatids and of DNA
02 The student correctly identifies Metaphase I as the preceding stage but fails to account for pre-meiotic S-phase replication when determining the DNA mass, keeping it at 4.0 pg instead of doubling to 8.0 pg.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
Homologous chromosomes have separated to poles in Anaphase I Preceding stage is Metaphase I
CorrectThe observed cell with chromosomes clustered at the poles is in Telophase I Preceding stage is Anaphase I
You treated the cell with chromosomes already clustered at the opposite poles as Anaphase I. Because chromosomes arriving and gathering at opposite spindle poles characterizes Telophase I, the stage immediately preceding this configuration was Anaphase I.
- Step 2
replicated chromosomes at the metaphase plate
CorrectYou calculated chromatid count based on Metaphase I instead of Anaphase I, and counted individual strands rather than the meiotic chromatid structure standard ( across the dividing dyads).
- Step 3Correct
()
You assumed the DNA content remained at the unreplicated value of . Prior to entering Meiosis I, the cell replicates its genome during meiotic S-phase, doubling the nuclear DNA content from to .
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly recalled that homologous chromosome separation occurs during Meiosis I.
You recognized that replicated chromosomes consist of two chromatids joined at a centromere.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou identified the pole-clustering stage as Anaphase I rather than Telophase I, which shifted your preceding stage from Anaphase I back to Metaphase I.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou treated meiotic division as starting with unreplicated DNA content (), forgetting that meiotic S-phase doubles cellular DNA mass to before Prophase I begins.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Identifying Pole Clustering
Chromosomes migrating along spindle fibers indicate Anaphase; chromosomes arriving and clustering at opposite spindle poles define Telophase.
Check whether chromosomes are mid-migration (Anaphase) or already gathered at the poles (Telophase) before deducing the preceding stage.
- Accounting for Meiotic S-Phase
Before entering Meiosis I, DNA replicates during S-phase, doubling the DNA mass from to while chromosome number () remains unchanged.
Always multiply the unreplicated DNA content () by when determining DNA mass for any stage from Prophase I through Anaphase I.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationIdentify the observed stage: dyads () clustered at each spindle pole marks Telophase I.
Determine the immediately preceding stage: the stage directly before Telophase I is Anaphase I.
Calculate DNA mass during Anaphase I: prior to cytokinesis, the cell retains the replicated DNA level, so .
State the chromatid complement: the preceding Anaphase I cell contains chromatids.
(a) Anaphase I; (b) chromatids and of DNA
03 The student assumes each pole already constitutes a separate cell during the preceding stage and calculates the chromatid number and DNA mass for a haploid cell instead of the whole dividing cell.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
The cell is in Anaphase I with 8 dyads at each pole The immediately preceding stage is Metaphase I
CorrectThe observed cell with chromosomes clustered at opposite poles is in Telophase I The immediately preceding stage is Anaphase I
Chromosomes already clustered at the opposite spindle poles define Telophase I (rather than Anaphase I, where they are actively migrating). Therefore, the stage that immediately preceded this configuration was Anaphase I, not Metaphase I.
- Step 2
Considering the haploid set entering each pole: ,
Correct(with chromatid structures)
You restricted your calculation to a single pole's haploid set. During the preceding stage (Anaphase I), cytokinesis has not occurred, so the entire parent cell contains both sets, totaling of DNA ( level).
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly identified that the chromosomes at each pole are double-stranded dyads with two chromatids each.
You recognized the sequential order of meiotic stages leading backward in time.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou evaluated only one pole rather than the whole dividing cell when determining total DNA content.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou mistook chromosomes clustered at the spindle poles for Anaphase I instead of Telophase I, and you treated the future daughter set at one pole as the entire cell's inventory before cytokinesis.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Distinguishing Anaphase I vs. Telophase I
Anaphase I features homologous chromosomes moving along the spindle; arrival and clustering at the poles marks Telophase I.
Always identify the current stage by whether chromosomes are actively moving between poles or already clustered at the poles.
- Whole-Cell DNA vs. Single-Pole Complement
Until cytokinesis physically separates the cytoplasm into two daughter cells, the cell remains a single unit containing the full DNA content ().
Calculate DNA and chromatid totals across both poles combined for any stage before cytokinesis is complete.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationIdentify the observed stage: dyads clustered at the two opposite poles represent Telophase I.
Determine the immediately preceding stage: Telophase I is immediately preceded by Anaphase I.
Calculate total DNA content in Anaphase I: prior to meiotic division, S-phase doubles DNA () to .
Account for the whole cell: the single dividing cell contains chromatids (representing the level) and of DNA.
(a) Anaphase I; (b) chromatids and of DNA.
Lock it in
What distinguishes the chromosomes moving to opposite poles in Anaphase I from those in Anaphase II?
Anaphase I separates homologous pairs into dyads (each chromosome still has two sister chromatids); Anaphase II separates sister chromatids into individual monads.
Similar question
A diploid plant species has and an unreplicated DNA content of . A cytogeneticist observes a single meiotic cell where single-chromatid chromosomes (monads) are clustered at each of two poles. Identify: (a) the observed meiotic stage, (b) the immediately preceding stage, and (c) the total cellular DNA mass in pg during that preceding stage.
Answer
(a) Telophase II (monads at each pole in a haploid set of ). (b) Anaphase II. (c) In a secondary spermatocyte/oocyte undergoing Meiosis II, the cell has a DNA content; therefore, DNA mass during Anaphase II is .
In an animal with and a DNA level of , an inhibitor stops meiotic spindle elongation just as homologous chromosomes begin moving toward opposite poles. (a) Name this blocked stage. (b) State the total number of centromeres, the total number of chromatids, and the total cellular DNA mass in pg present in the cell at this point.
Answer
(a) Anaphase I (homologous chromosomes are disjoining). (b) centromeres (each representing one replicated chromosome), chromatids (), and of DNA ().
A fluorescence-activated cell sorting (FACS) profile of spermatogenesis in a mammal (, ) isolates three cell populations with DNA masses of , , and . (a) Assign each DNA content to its corresponding meiotic cell type/stage (Primary spermatocyte in Meiosis I, Secondary spermatocyte in Meiosis II, or Spermatid). (b) For a cell containing of DNA entering Metaphase II, specify the number of chromosomes and the number of chromatids aligned at the equatorial plate.
Answer
(a) (Primary spermatocyte in Meiosis I); (Secondary spermatocyte in Meiosis II); (Haploid spermatid). (b) In Metaphase II, there are replicated chromosomes and chromatids () aligned at the plate.