Resources
A student hypothesizes that because facilitated diffusion requires specialized transmembrane protein carriers, adding a chemical that uncouples or depletes cellular ATP will stop facilitated diffusion just as rapidly as it stops primary active transport. (a) Evaluate whether this hypothesis is conceptually correct, explicitly stating the fundamental difference in thermodynamic energy source between facilitated diffusion and primary active transport. (b) An erythrocyte has an intracellular D-glucose concentration of and is placed in blood plasma with at (). Calculate the free energy change (in ) for glucose influx mediated by the GLUT1 uniporter. (c) If oligomycin (an ATP-synthase inhibitor) is added to deplete ATP, does the initial rate of glucose uptake by GLUT1 drop to zero? Explain why or why not.
Answer and steps
Final answer
(a) The hypothesis is incorrect; facilitated diffusion is passive and driven exclusively by the entropic/electrochemical potential of the solute without consuming metabolic energy, whereas primary active transport directly couples endergonic transport to ATP hydrolysis; (b) ; (c) No, the initial uptake rate does not drop to zero because GLUT1 uniporters do not utilize ATP; transport continues spontaneously down the concentration gradient until .
Steps
(a) Evaluating the Student's Hypothesis
The hypothesis is incorrect.
- Facilitated Diffusion (Passive Transport): Although facilitated diffusion utilizes specialized membrane proteins (such as channels or uniporters), it does not couple transport to metabolic energy. The process is thermodynamically spontaneous () and driven solely by the solute's electrochemical or chemical concentration gradient, which dissipates free energy and increases entropy.
- Primary Active Transport: Primary active transport moves solutes against their electrochemical gradient (). To overcome this unfavorable thermodynamic barrier, the transport protein directly couples the translocation to an exergonic chemical reaction, most commonly the hydrolysis of to and inorganic phosphate ().
Therefore, depleting cellular halts primary active transport directly, but it does not immediately halt facilitated diffusion as long as a favorable concentration gradient exists.
(b) Calculating the Free Energy Change () for Glucose Influx
For an uncharged solute moving from the extracellular space () to the intracellular space (), the molar Gibbs free energy change is given by:
Given:
- Calculate the concentration ratio:
- Evaluate the natural logarithm:
- Compute :
The negative sign confirms that net inward flux via GLUT1 is exergonic and thermodynamically favorable.
(c) Effect of ATP Depletion on GLUT1 Glucose Uptake
No, the initial uptake rate does not drop to zero.
- Mechanism: GLUT1 is a passive carrier protein (uniporter) operating via an alternating-access mechanism. It alternates between outward-facing and inward-facing conformations driven by thermal motion and substrate binding, requiring no hydrolysis.
- Driving Force: Because (yielding ), the chemical gradient immediately drives inward transport.
- Outcome: In the absence of , glucose will continue to enter the cell until the intracellular and extracellular concentrations become equal (, at which point ).
Typical errors
01 The student confuses facilitated diffusion with active transport because both use protein transporters, incorrectly asserting that carrier-mediated transport inherently depends directly on ATP hydrolysis.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
The hypothesis is correct. Both processes require transmembrane carrier proteins, so both require ATP hydrolysis to operate the conformational cycle of the transporter.
CorrectThe hypothesis is incorrect. Facilitated diffusion is passive transport driven solely by the chemical/electrochemical potential gradient of the solute () without ATP hydrolysis, whereas primary active transport directly couples solute translocation against a gradient to an exergonic metabolic reaction, typically ATP hydrolysis.
You correctly noticed that both mechanisms involve transmembrane carrier proteins, but carrier protein conformational shifts do not necessarily require ATP. Facilitated diffusion carriers undergo thermal-driven alternating conformations down a concentration gradient without consuming metabolic energy.
- Step 2
- Step 3
Yes, the initial rate drops to zero. Without ATP, the GLUT1 protein cannot undergo the conformational change needed to transport glucose.
CorrectNo, the initial uptake rate does not drop to zero. GLUT1 is a passive uniporter that undergoes alternating-access conformational changes driven by thermal motion and substrate binding rather than ATP hydrolysis. Because , glucose influx proceeds spontaneously.
You concluded that GLUT1 requires ATP for its conformational cycle. Because GLUT1 mediates facilitated diffusion, its alternating conformations rely on thermal fluctuations and substrate binding affinity, so depleting ATP has no immediate effect on the initial influx rate.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly identified and applied the molar Gibbs free energy equation for uncharged solute transport.
You performed accurate algebraic evaluation and unit conversion to obtain .
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeThis is a fundamental conceptual confusion between passive carrier-mediated transport and primary active transport.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou assumed that any transmembrane protein undergoing conformational changes during transport requires direct ATP hydrolysis, overlooking that passive uniporters like GLUT1 utilize thermal kinetic energy and chemical potential gradients to cycle conformations.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Energy Source Classification
Transport driven down an electrochemical gradient () is passive and requires no metabolic energy, regardless of whether a carrier protein is involved.
Check the net thermodynamic driving force; if transport is downhill, it does not directly consume ATP.
- Conformational Cycling Mechanism
Passive uniporters undergo conformational transitions via thermal fluctuations (Brownian motion) and binding free energy, not ATP hydrolysis.
Distinguish between active pumps (which couple transport to chemical ATP cleavage) and passive carriers (which alternate shapes spontaneously).
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationEvaluate whether facilitated diffusion moves solutes down or against their gradient: it moves solutes down their gradient ().
Determine the thermodynamic energy source: solute chemical potential/entropy dissipates, so no ATP is hydrolyzed.
Conclude for (a): the hypothesis is incorrect because facilitated diffusion is energetically spontaneous and does not rely on ATP.
Apply this distinction to (c): because GLUT1 is a facilitated diffusion uniporter operating down the concentration gradient (), depleting ATP does not immediately alter the initial rate of glucose entry.
(a) Incorrect; facilitated diffusion is driven spontaneously by the solute's concentration gradient without ATP, whereas primary active transport couples transport to ATP hydrolysis. (b) . (c) No; GLUT1 does not hydrolyze ATP, so glucose uptake proceeds downhill until concentrations equilibrate.
02 The student inverts the ratio of concentrations in the thermodynamic equation for inward solute transport, obtaining a positive free energy change instead of a negative one.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
The hypothesis is incorrect. Facilitated diffusion is passive transport driven by the concentration gradient without metabolic energy, whereas primary active transport directly couples solute transport to ATP hydrolysis.
- Step 2Correct
For transport into the cell, the final destination is the intracellular space and the starting state is extracellular. Therefore, the ratio must be . Inverting this ratio produced instead of , incorrectly suggesting that inward transport down the concentration gradient is endergonic.
- Step 3
No, the rate does not drop to zero. GLUT1 operates by passive facilitated diffusion and does not consume ATP.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou clearly distinguished between passive transport driven by gradient dissipation and active transport coupled directly to ATP hydrolysis.
You carried out the arithmetic and unit conversions with accurate values for the gas constant and temperature.
You correctly deduced that inhibiting ATP synthase does not stop passive transport through GLUT1.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou accidentally placed the outside concentration in the numerator and inside in the denominator of the logarithmic ratio.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou set up the thermodynamic free energy of transport without aligning the numerator with the destination compartment (final state) and the denominator with the origin compartment (initial state).
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Thermodynamic State Direction
For any transport process, . For influx into a cell, and .
Always verify that downhill transport down a concentration gradient yields (exergonic and spontaneous).
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationIdentify the initial and final compartments for inward transport: and .
Set up the thermodynamic expression: .
Evaluate the concentration quotient: .
Calculate the natural logarithm: .
Multiply by : .
Lock it in
Does a transmembrane carrier protein undergoing a conformational change during transport always require ATP hydrolysis?
No. Facilitated diffusion uniporters alternate conformations via thermal fluctuations and ligand binding, requiring no ATP.
Similar question
A cell has an internal concentration of and an external concentration of . exits the cell through a voltage-gated potassium channel. Explain whether blocking ATP synthesis with cyanide will immediately stop this efflux.
Answer
No. Efflux through a channel is passive transport (facilitated diffusion) driven by the electrochemical gradient of . Ion channels do not hydrolyze ATP to open or conduct ions.
Intestinal epithelial cells transport D-glucose against its chemical gradient using the SGLT1 symporter powered by a gradient, whereas erythrocytes take up glucose down its gradient via GLUT1. If ATP is depleted, explain why SGLT1 eventually stops while GLUT1 continues until internal and external glucose concentrations equilibrate.
Answer
GLUT1 is a facilitated diffusion uniporter that requires no ATP and stops only when . SGLT1 is a secondary active transporter; although it does not directly hydrolyze ATP, it relies on the gradient maintained by the -ATPase. When ATP is depleted, the pump fails, dissipating the electrochemical gradient and halting SGLT1.
A researcher measures the transport of an uncharged solute across a synthetic bilayer containing a reconstituted uniporter. At , and . (a) Calculate for inward transport (). (b) If non-hydrolyzable ATP--S is added to the medium, what is the effect on and the transport rate?
Answer
(a) . (b) Because uniporters do not possess an ATP-binding catalytic domain and are driven exclusively by the concentration gradient, ATP--S has zero effect on either or the transport rate.