Resources

Human skin fibroblasts are cultured in medium containing bromodeoxyuridine (BrdU), a thymidine analog that incorporates into newly synthesized DNA strands during SS phase. A diploid parental cell (2n=462n = 46) containing fully unlabeled, double-stranded DNA ([unlabeled/unlabeled][\text{unlabeled}/\text{unlabeled}]) completes exactly one round of DNA replication in the presence of BrdU and subsequently undergoes mitotic division into two daughter cells (Cell 1 and Cell 2). (a) Based on the semi-conservative model of DNA replication, what fraction of the double-stranded DNA molecules in Cell 1 contains BrdU? (b) Are the genetic nucleotide sequences of Cell 1 and Cell 2 identical, and what is the exact chromosome count in each daughter cell?

Answer and steps

Final answer

(a) 1.01.0 (or 100%100\%, where every double helix is hybrid [unlabeled/BrdU][\text{unlabeled}/\text{BrdU}]); (b) Yes, the nucleotide sequences are genetically identical, and each daughter cell contains exactly 4646 chromosomes.

Steps

01

Analyze DNA replication during S phase (Semi-Conservative Model)

According to the semi-conservative model of DNA replication:

  1. The two parent strands of each double-stranded DNA (dsDNA) molecule unwind and separate.
  2. Each original strand acts as a template for the synthesis of a new complementary strand.
  3. Because the culture medium contains bromodeoxyuridine (BrdU) instead of normal thymidine, every newly synthesized strand incorporates BrdU.

Before replication, each chromosome consists of one dsDNA molecule with two unlabeled strands: [unlabeled/unlabeled][\text{unlabeled}/\text{unlabeled}].

After one round of replication in the presence of BrdU:

  • Each chromosome consists of two identical sister chromatids joined at the centromere.
  • Each sister chromatid contains one dsDNA molecule composed of one parental template strand (unlabeled\text{unlabeled}) and one newly synthesized strand (BrdU\text{BrdU}).
  • Therefore, 100%100\% of the sister chromatid duplexes are hybrid [unlabeled/BrdU][\text{unlabeled}/\text{BrdU}].

02

Determine the fraction of BrdU-containing DNA in Cell 1

During mitosis:

  • The sister chromatids separate during anaphase, with one chromatid from each replicated chromosome moving to Cell 1 and the other to Cell 2.
  • Each daughter cell receives one complete set of chromatids (now individual chromosomes).
  • Since every single sister chromatid produced in S phase is a hybrid [unlabeled/BrdU][\text{unlabeled}/\text{BrdU}] double helix, every dsDNA molecule distributed to Cell 1 contains one BrdU-labeled strand.

Thus, the fraction of double-stranded DNA molecules in Cell 1 that contains BrdU is: Number of hybrid moleculesTotal dsDNA molecules=4646=1.0(or 100%)\frac{\text{Number of hybrid molecules}}{\text{Total dsDNA molecules}} = \frac{46}{46} = 1.0\quad (\text{or } 100\%)

Common Pitfall: Do not confuse the proportion of strands with the proportion of double-stranded molecules. While 50%50\% of individual single strands are BrdU-labeled and 50%50\% are unlabeled, 100%100\% of the intact double-stranded DNA molecules contain BrdU (as one of their two strands).


03

Evaluate genetic sequence identity and chromosome count

  • Genetic Identity: DNA replication produces two identical sister chromatids from each chromosome via complementary base pairing. Mitotic spindle fibers ensure that one sister chromatid from each chromosome is segregated to each daughter cell. Therefore, Cell 1 and Cell 2 receive identical sets of genetic information, making their nucleotide sequences genetically identical.
  • Chromosome Count: The parental cell is diploid (2n=462n = 46). Mitosis is an equational division: following the replication of 46 chromosomes into 92 sister chromatids, anaphase separates these into two poles of 46 single-chromatid chromosomes each. Thus, each daughter cell contains exactly 4646 chromosomes (2n=462n = 46).

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student misapplies the conservative replication model instead of the semi-conservative model, concluding that half of the DNA duplexes are fully unlabeled and the other half are fully labeled.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Conservative replication produces 1 original duplex and 1 entirely new duplex.

    Correct

    Semi-conservative replication separates the parental strands so that each new duplex consists of one original unlabeled strand and one newly synthesized BrdU strand.

    The prompt specified using the semi-conservative model of DNA replication. In semi-conservative replication, parental strands do not remain together as an entirely intact original duplex; instead, each daughter duplex is a hybrid containing one old strand and one new strand.

  2. Step 2

    Fraction of DNA duplexes with BrdU in Cell 1 = 1/2

    Correct

    Fraction of DNA duplexes with BrdU in Cell 1=1.0 (or 100%)\text{Fraction of DNA duplexes with BrdU in Cell 1} = 1.0\text{ (or }100\%\text{)}

    Because each replicated chromosome consists of two sister chromatids that are each hybrid [unlabeled/BrdU][\text{unlabeled}/\text{BrdU}] duplexes, every double-stranded DNA molecule received by Cell 1 contains BrdU.

  3. Step 3

    Yes, identical nucleotide sequences. ⟹ Chromosome count = 46

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly recognized that mitosis produces daughter cells with identical nucleotide sequences.

You correctly maintained the diploid chromosome count of 4646 after mitotic division.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Semi-conservative vs. conservative replication confusion

No slip occurred; you applied a completely different replication hypothesis (conservative) instead of the semi-conservative model explicitly stated in the prompt.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You recalled the definition of the hypothetical conservative model (where one duplex is completely conserved and one is entirely newly synthesized) rather than the biologically proven semi-conservative mechanism, in which each daughter duplex inherits one original template strand and one newly synthesized strand.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Model Selection
  • Eukaryotic DNA replication is always semi-conservative: each double-stranded helix unwinds, and each original strand serves as a template for a newly synthesized strand.

  • Always draw each parent strand separating into independent templates before adding newly synthesized, labeled strands.

Strand vs. Duplex Accounting
  • After one round of semi-conservative replication, 50%50\% of individual single strands contain the label, but 100%100\% of intact double helices contain at least one labeled strand.

  • Distinguish between the percentage of labeled single strands and the proportion of double-stranded DNA molecules containing label.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Start with one [unlabeled/unlabeled][\text{unlabeled}/\text{unlabeled}] double helix per chromosome.

  2. During S phase, the two strands separate in the presence of BrdU, producing two sister chromatid duplexes per chromosome, each of composition [unlabeled/BrdU][\text{unlabeled}/\text{BrdU}].

  3. During mitotic anaphase, sister chromatids separate equitably into Cell 1 and Cell 2, giving each daughter cell 46 double-stranded DNA molecules.

  4. Because every chromatid duplex is hybrid [unlabeled/BrdU][\text{unlabeled}/\text{BrdU}], all 46 duplexes in Cell 1 contain BrdU.

Final answer

(a) 1.01.0 (or 100%100\%); (b) Yes, identical nucleotide sequences, and chromosome count is 4646.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the Meselson-Stahl experiment to visualize the difference in band positions between conservative, semi-conservative, and dispersive replication.

  • Practice tracking labeled strands across multiple cell cycles (generation 1 vs. generation 2) to master strand distribution.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student confuses the fraction of total single strands containing BrdU with the fraction of double-stranded DNA molecules containing BrdU.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Each duplex has 1 old strand and 1 new strand with BrdU. 1 out of 2 strands contains BrdU, so fraction = 1/21/2

    Correct

    1.01.0 (or 100%100\%)

    You correctly determined that every double helix consists of one unlabeled template strand and one newly synthesized BrdU strand. However, the question asks for the fraction of double-stranded molecules that contain BrdU, not the fraction of individual strands. Because every double-stranded molecule contains a BrdU strand, the correct fraction is 4646=1.0\frac{46}{46} = 1.0 (or 100%100\%).

  2. Step 2

    Yes, identical nucleotide sequences.

  3. Step 3

    Chromosome count = 4646

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly applied the semi-conservative model to deduce that each newly replicated DNA duplex contains one parental strand and one BrdU-labeled strand.

You correctly recognized that mitotic division produces genetically identical daughter cells.

You accurately identified that the diploid chromosome count of 4646 is preserved in each daughter cell.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Units/Level of Analysis Confusion

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You calculated the proportion of individual single strands containing the label (11 out of 22 strands, or 50%50\%) instead of identifying what fraction of intact double-stranded DNA duplexes contain at least one labeled strand (100%100\%).

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Level of Analysis Check
  • Distinguish between counting individual polynucleotide strands versus counting intact double-stranded DNA (dsDNA) molecules.

  • Check whether the question asks about single strands or intact double-stranded duplexes before calculating the final ratio.

Containing vs. Exclusively Made Of
  • A duplex 'contains' a label if at least one of its two complementary strands incorporates the label.

  • If a duplex is hybrid [unlabeled/BrdU][\text{unlabeled}/\text{BrdU}], count that entire duplex as containing BrdU.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Because every replicated double-stranded molecule is a hybrid duplex [unlabeled/BrdU][\text{unlabeled}/\text{BrdU}], every single dsDNA molecule contains BrdU.

  2. Calculate the fraction of double-stranded DNA molecules: Number of duplexes with BrdUTotal duplexes=4646=1.0\frac{\text{Number of duplexes with BrdU}}{\text{Total duplexes}} = \frac{46}{46} = 1.0.

Final answer

(a) 1.01.0 (or 100%100\%); (b) Yes, genetically identical nucleotide sequences, and 4646 chromosomes per daughter cell.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Read carefully to distinguish between questions asking about 'single strands' versus 'double-stranded molecules (duplexes)'.

  • Practice sketching one or two rounds of semi-conservative replication using two distinct colors for template and newly synthesized strands.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student confuses mitotic division with meiotic division and incorrectly halves the chromosome count in the daughter cells.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Each replicated duplex has 1 parental strand and 1 BrdU strand.  ⟹  Fraction of DNA molecules with BrdU=1\text{Each replicated duplex has } 1 \text{ parental strand and } 1 \text{ BrdU strand.} \implies \text{Fraction of DNA molecules with BrdU} = 1

  2. Step 2

    Yes, identical nucleotide sequences.\text{Yes, identical nucleotide sequences.}

  3. Step 3

    Cell division halves the chromosome number.  ⟹  Chromosome count=23\text{Cell division halves the chromosome number.} \implies \text{Chromosome count} = 23

    Correct

    Chromosome count=46\text{Chromosome count} = 46

    You stated that cell division halves the chromosome number, which occurs only in meiosis. Mitosis is an equational division where sister chromatids separate into identical daughter cells, maintaining the diploid number of 2n=462n = 46 chromosomes.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly applied the semi-conservative model of DNA replication to conclude that all duplexes contain one BrdU strand.

You correctly recognized that mitotic division segregates identical sister chromatids into each daughter cell.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Mitosis vs. Meiosis Chromosome Number Confusion

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You confused mitotic division with meiotic reduction division, assuming that all cell divisions cut the chromosome count in half rather than recognizing that somatic mitosis maintains ploidy (2n=462n = 46).

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Identify the Division Type
  • Mitosis produces genetically identical diploid somatic cells (2n→2n2n \to 2n), whereas meiosis produces haploid gametes (2n→n2n \to n).

  • Check whether the problem specifies somatic cell division (mitosis) or gamete formation (meiosis) before writing down the daughter cell chromosome count.

Track Chromatids vs. Chromosomes
  • Before division, 46 replicated chromosomes contain 92 sister chromatids; during mitotic anaphase, these chromatids separate to become 46 individual chromosomes in each new cell.

  • Count individual centromeres per daughter nucleus after sister chromatid segregation to ensure the chromosome number equals 4646.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Recognize that skin fibroblasts are somatic cells undergoing mitosis, an equational division.

  2. Recall that during anaphase, the 92 sister chromatids separate equally into two poles.

  3. Conclude that each daughter cell receives a full diploid complement of 46 single-chromatid chromosomes.

Final answer

(a) 1.01.0 (or 100%100\%); (b) Yes, identical nucleotide sequences; chromosome count =46= 46.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the distinction between equational division (mitosis) and reductional division (meiosis I).

  • Practice tracking chromosome and chromatid numbers across G1G_1, SS, G2G_2, and anaphase of mitosis.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A cell with unlabeled DNA undergoes two consecutive rounds of DNA replication in medium containing BrdU. What fraction of the resulting double-stranded DNA molecules contains BrdU?

Answer

1.01.0 (or 100%100\%). After round 1, all duplexes are hybrid [unlabeled/BrdU][\text{unlabeled}/\text{BrdU}]. In round 2, the unlabeled strands form new hybrid [unlabeled/BrdU][\text{unlabeled}/\text{BrdU}] duplexes, while the BrdU strands form fully labeled [BrdU/BrdU][\text{BrdU}/\text{BrdU}] duplexes. Thus, every single duplex (100%100\%) contains at least one BrdU strand.

02

A diploid organism (2n=82n = 8) has all its DNA uniformly labeled with 15N^{15}\text{N}. The cell is transferred to medium containing standard 14N^{14}\text{N} and completes one full cell cycle, dividing into two daughter cells. For one daughter cell, state: (1) the chromosome count, and (2) how many double-stranded DNA molecules are hybrid [15N/14N][^{15}\text{N}/^{14}\text{N}].

Answer

(1) 88 chromosomes; (2) Exactly 88 double-stranded DNA molecules. Mitosis maintains diploid chromosome number (2n=82n = 8). Under semi-conservative replication, each of the 88 replicated chromosomes distributes one hybrid [15N/14N][^{15}\text{N}/^{14}\text{N}] chromatid to each daughter cell.

03

In a hypothetical organism using conservative replication, an unlabeled diploid cell (2n=42n = 4) divides once in medium containing BrdU. If sister chromatids segregate randomly to opposite poles during division, what are the possible counts of BrdU-containing double-stranded DNA molecules in a daughter cell?

Answer

Any integer from 00 to 44 (inclusive). Under conservative replication, each replicated chromosome produces one completely unlabeled duplex and one completely labeled duplex. Depending on how the labeled vs. unlabeled chromatids assort during anaphase, a daughter cell could receive anywhere between 00 and 44 labeled duplexes.

Loading workspace…