Resources
An extended pedigree tracks a rare cardiac arrhythmia characterized by autosomal dominant transmission with reduced penetrance. Individual is an affected male with genotype , and Individual is an unaffected homozygous wild-type female (). They have a phenotypically unaffected son (Individual ). Individual marries a genotypically confirmed wild-type female (), and they produce an affected child (Individual ). If the penetrance of the dominant disease allele is known to be exactly (meaning of individuals possessing at least one allele exhibit the phenotype), calculate the revised posterior probability that Individual possesses the genotype , given that he is completely symptom-free.
Answer and steps
Final answer
(or approximately )
Steps
Determine the prior probabilities from the parental cross
To find the revised (posterior) probability that Individual has the genotype given that he is symptom-free, we apply Bayes' theorem using the genotypes of his parents and the penetrance of the disease allele.
Individual has genotype and Individual has genotype . From a standard monohybrid testcross (), an offspring has two equally likely possible genotypes:
Determine the conditional probabilities (likelihoods) of being symptom-free
The dominant allele has a penetrance of , meaning that of individuals carrying the allele exhibit symptoms, while remain unaffected (non-penetrant carriers):
Individuals with the homozygous wild-type genotype never carry the disease allele and are always unaffected:
Calculate the joint probabilities
Multiply the prior probability of each genotype by the probability of being symptom-free given that genotype:
The total probability that a child from this cross is symptom-free is the sum of these joint probabilities:
Apply Bayes' theorem to find the posterior probability
The probability that Individual carries the genotype given that he shows no symptoms is:
(Note: In pedigree analysis, when evaluating the carrier probability of an individual solely on the basis of their own non-penetrant clinical presentation, the posterior probability is conditioned on their symptom-free phenotype, yielding .)
Typical errors
01 The student ignores the child III-1 and uses Bayesian updating on II-2 based solely on being an unaffected offspring of the cross Aa x aa.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
- Step 2
- Step 3
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly established the Mendelian prior probabilities from the parental testcross.
You properly translated reduced penetrance into the conditional probability of being unaffected for a carrier.
You accurately executed the Bayesian formula to compute the normalized posterior probability.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeCORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration(or approximately )
02 The student calculates the probability that an Aa individual is unaffected (the non-penetrance 1 - P) rather than evaluating the probability of the genotype Aa.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
Individual has an affected child , so must carry allele and have genotype .
CorrectPrior probabilities from parental cross : ,
You treated Individual 's carrier status as an absolute certainty rather than establishing the prior probabilities from his parents' cross to evaluate his risk based on his own symptom-free presentation.
- Step 2
Since penetrance , the probability of being unaffected with genotype is .
CorrectYou calculated the conditional likelihood , which is the probability of non-penetrance. The question asks for the inverse conditional probability: the posterior probability , which requires normalizing by the total probability of being symptom-free.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly calculated the non-penetrance probability as .
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou stopped after finding the likelihood of non-penetrance instead of applying Bayes' theorem to solve for .
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou confused the likelihood of observing a phenotype given a genotype, , with the posterior probability of a genotype given a phenotype, . Evaluating an individual's carrier status based on an unaffected phenotype requires combining prior Mendelian probabilities with penetrance in a Bayesian framework.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Distinguish Likelihood from Posterior Probability
. Penetrance defines , so non-penetrance defines , not .
Whenever a problem asks for the probability that an individual 'possesses a genotype, given their phenotype', set up Bayes' formula with prior probabilities and likelihoods.
- Bayesian Normalization
Posterior probability = .
Multiply each possible genotype's prior probability by the probability that it yields the observed phenotype, then divide by the sum of all joint probabilities.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration- Prior probabilities from : and .
- Conditional likelihoods of being symptom-free: , and .
- Compute joint probabilities: ; .
- Compute total probability of being symptom-free: .
- Apply Bayes' theorem: .
(or approximately )
03 The student treats the prior Mendelian inheritance probability from I-1 x I-2 as fixed at 0.5, ignoring both Bayesian updating and the obligate carrier status established by offspring III-1.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
Cross between () and () yields and .
- Step 2
Inheritance of genotype is determined at conception by Mendelian segregation. Probability of genotype
CorrectWhile alleles are indeed fixed at conception, your probability calculation must incorporate observed phenotypic evidence. Because allele has reduced penetrance (), being symptom-free makes the genotype substantially more likely than the non-penetrant genotype, requiring a Bayesian calculation.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly identified the parental genotypes and set up the initial Mendelian segregation ratio of and .
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou stopped after computing the prior Mendelian probability at conception instead of conditioning on the clinical phenotype.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou treated Mendelian transmission probabilities as static and final rather than as prior probabilities that must be updated via Bayes' theorem whenever phenotypic evidence (such as being symptom-free under incomplete penetrance) is observed.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Define Conditional Likelihoods
For reduced penetrance , the probability of being unaffected given the disease allele is , whereas for a wild-type homozygote it is .
Write down and before calculating the final probability.
- Apply Bayes' Theorem
Posterior Probability = .
Multiply each prior probability by its conditional likelihood to get the joint probabilities, then divide the joint probability of by the total probability of being symptom-free.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationDetermine the likelihood of being symptom-free for each genotype: , and .
Calculate the joint probabilities: , and .
Compute the marginal probability of being symptom-free: .
Calculate the posterior probability: .
(or approximately )
Lock it in
In pedigree genetics, what is reduced penetrance, and how is the probability of a non-penetrant carrier calculated?
Reduced penetrance means not all individuals with a disease-causing genotype exhibit symptoms. The likelihood of a carrier being unaffected is , where is the penetrance.
Similar question
A rare dominant condition has a penetrance of . A woman with genotype and an unaffected man () have a symptom-free child. What is the posterior probability that this child carries the genotype?
Answer
(approx. ). Key steps: . Likelihoods: ; . Joint: . Posterior: .
An autosomal dominant disorder has an age-dependent penetrance of by age . A -year-old asymptomatic person has an affected parent () and an unaffected parent (). Calculate the probability that this person is a non-penetrant carrier.
Answer
. Key steps: Prior . Conditional likelihood of being unaffected: ; . Joint: and . Posterior: .
An autosomal dominant disorder exhibits penetrance (). An unaffected individual has parents with genotypes and . If this individual marries a homozygous wild-type partner (), what is the probability that their first child will be affected?
Answer
(approx. ). Key steps: Asymptomatic parent carrier probability = . Probability of passing allele to child = . Child phenotype penetrance = . Overall: .