Resources

An agricultural weed population infesting wheat fields develops resistance to a synthetic herbicide. Resistance is conferred by an allele RR, which is completely dominant over the wild-type susceptible allele rr. After four generations of continuous herbicide application, the frequency of the susceptible allele dropped from an initial value of q0=0.80q_0 = 0.80 to a final value of q4=0.20q_4 = 0.20. Assuming generations are non-overlapping, the population is very large, and homozygous resistant (RRRR) and heterozygous resistant (RrRr) individuals suffer no fitness disadvantage (wRR=wRr=1.0w_{RR} = w_{Rr} = 1.0), calculate the effective selection coefficient (ss) acting against susceptible homozygotes (rrrr, where wrr=1−sw_{rr} = 1 - s) per generation under the standard discrete haploid/diploid selection approximation 1qt−1q0≈s⋅t\frac{1}{q_t} - \frac{1}{q_0} \approx s \cdot t. Round your final answer to three significant figures.

Answer and steps

Final answer

s=0.938s = 0.938

Steps

01

Identify the given population genetics parameters

From the problem statement, we have:

  • Initial frequency of the recessive susceptible allele (rr): q0=0.80q_0 = 0.80
  • Final frequency of the susceptible allele after tt generations: q4=0.20q_4 = 0.20
  • Number of generations of herbicide selection: t=4t = 4
  • Selection model: Complete dominance of resistance (RR), where susceptible homozygotes (rrrr) have a relative fitness of wrr=1−sw_{rr} = 1 - s.
02

Set up the selection approximation formula

For natural selection acting against a recessive allele in a diploid population, the rate of change in the recessive allele frequency qq over generation time tt can be approximated by:

1qt−1q0≈s⋅t\frac{1}{q_t} - \frac{1}{q_0} \approx s \cdot t

where:

  • q0q_0 is the starting allele frequency,
  • qtq_t is the allele frequency at generation tt,
  • ss is the selection coefficient against the susceptible phenotype (rrrr),
  • tt is the elapsed number of generations.
03

Substitute the known values and solve for ss

  1. Compute the reciprocal terms: 1q4=10.20=5.0\frac{1}{q_4} = \frac{1}{0.20} = 5.0 1q0=10.80=1.25\frac{1}{q_0} = \frac{1}{0.80} = 1.25
  2. Calculate the total change in the reciprocal frequency: 1q4−1q0=5.0−1.25=3.75\frac{1}{q_4} - \frac{1}{q_0} = 5.0 - 1.25 = 3.75
  3. Solve for the selection coefficient ss: s⋅t=3.75s \cdot t = 3.75 s⋅4=3.75s \cdot 4 = 3.75 s=3.754=0.9375s = \frac{3.75}{4} = 0.9375
04

Round to the requested precision

Rounding 0.93750.9375 to three significant figures gives:

s=0.938s = 0.938

(Note: A selection coefficient of s=0.938s = 0.938 indicates extremely strong directional selection, meaning susceptible plants have a relative fitness of only wrr=1−0.938=0.062w_{rr} = 1 - 0.938 = 0.062, or about 6.2%6.2\% reproductive success compared to resistant plants).

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 A student inverts the subtraction order in the formula, leading to a negative selection coefficient of -0.938.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    1q0−1qt=s⋅t  ⟹  10.80−10.20=4s\frac{1}{q_0} - \frac{1}{q_t} = s \cdot t \implies \frac{1}{0.80} - \frac{1}{0.20} = 4s

    Correct

    1qt−1q0=s⋅t  ⟹  10.20−10.80=4s\frac{1}{q_t} - \frac{1}{q_0} = s \cdot t \implies \frac{1}{0.20} - \frac{1}{0.80} = 4s

    You reversed the order of terms in the formula. The formula computes the change over time as final minus initial, 1qt−1q0\frac{1}{q_t} - \frac{1}{q_0}, rather than initial minus final.

  2. Step 2

    1.25−5=4s  ⟹  −3.75=4s1.25 - 5 = 4s \implies -3.75 = 4s

    Correct

    5.0−1.25=4s  ⟹  3.75=4s5.0 - 1.25 = 4s \implies 3.75 = 4s

    Your arithmetic evaluation of the reciprocals and difference was carried out correctly according to your formula setup.

  3. Step 3

    s=−0.938s = -0.938

    Correct

    s=0.938s = 0.938

    You accurately divided by 44 and rounded to three significant figures, but the sign was negative due to the inverted subtraction in Step 1.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified the given values for q0q_0, qtq_t, and tt.

You calculated the reciprocals 10.80=1.25\frac{1}{0.80} = 1.25 and 10.20=5.0\frac{1}{0.20} = 5.0 accurately.

You isolated the variable ss and rounded to three significant figures correctly.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Formula term order inversion

You set up the formula with initial frequency reciprocal minus final frequency reciprocal instead of final minus initial.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Confusing the direction of change in reciprocal allele frequency formulations: when selection acts against a recessive allele, qq decreases over time, so 1q\frac{1}{q} increases. To find a positive selection coefficient ss, the difference must be 1qt−1q0\frac{1}{q_t} - \frac{1}{q_0}.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Check the sign of the selection coefficient
  • The selection coefficient ss against a disadvantageous phenotype (w=1−sw = 1 - s) is defined as a non-negative value between 00 and 11.

  • Always verify that s≥0s \ge 0. If you get a negative value, check whether you subtracted the initial state from the final state or vice versa.

Standard change convention (Final - Initial)
  • In population genetics and calculus, changes over an interval tt are set up as Δ(1q)=1qt−1q0≈s⋅t\Delta\left(\frac{1}{q}\right) = \frac{1}{q_t} - \frac{1}{q_0} \approx s \cdot t.

  • Place the final reciprocal value 1qt\frac{1}{q_t} first and subtract the starting reciprocal value 1q0\frac{1}{q_0}.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Substitute into the standard formula 1qt−1q0=s⋅t\frac{1}{q_t} - \frac{1}{q_0} = s \cdot t: 10.20−10.80=s⋅4\frac{1}{0.20} - \frac{1}{0.80} = s \cdot 4.

  2. Evaluate the reciprocals: 5.0−1.25=4s  ⟹  3.75=4s5.0 - 1.25 = 4s \implies 3.75 = 4s.

  3. Solve for ss: s=3.754=0.9375s = \frac{3.75}{4} = 0.9375.

Final answer

s=0.938s = 0.938

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the definition of the selection coefficient ss and ensure its value falls within the standard expected biological range [0,1][0, 1].

  • Practice rewriting change equations by explicitly writing Final−Initial\text{Final} - \text{Initial} before plugging in numerical values.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 A student calculates the linear change in allele frequency directly without taking reciprocals, resulting in s = 0.150.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    q0−qt=s⋅tq_0 - q_t = s \cdot t

    Correct

    1qt−1q0≈s⋅t\frac{1}{q_t} - \frac{1}{q_0} \approx s \cdot t

    You set up a linear difference equation for the change in allele frequency. Because selection against a recessive allele slows down drastically as the allele becomes hidden in heterozygotes, the change is non-linear and follows the reciprocal approximation 1qt−1q0≈s⋅t\frac{1}{q_t} - \frac{1}{q_0} \approx s \cdot t.

  2. Step 2

    0.80−0.20=4s  ⟹  0.60=4s0.80 - 0.20 = 4s \implies 0.60 = 4s

    Correct

    10.20−10.80=4s  ⟹  5.0−1.25=4s  ⟹  3.75=4s\frac{1}{0.20} - \frac{1}{0.80} = 4s \implies 5.0 - 1.25 = 4s \implies 3.75 = 4s

    You substituted the correct numerical values (q0=0.80q_0 = 0.80, q4=0.20q_4 = 0.20, and t=4t = 4), but they were placed into the incorrect linear relationship from Step 1.

  3. Step 3

    s=0.150s = 0.150

    Correct

    s=3.754=0.938s = \frac{3.75}{4} = 0.938

    Your arithmetic division 0.604=0.150\frac{0.60}{4} = 0.150 was executed correctly, but it inherits the formula error from earlier steps.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly extracted the numerical values for initial frequency, final frequency, and number of generations from the problem.

You accurately carried out the linear algebra steps to solve for the variable.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Incorrect selection approximation formula

No; this was not a simple arithmetic miscalculation, but the use of an incorrect linear model instead of the reciprocal approximation formula stated in the prompt.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You assumed that natural selection decreases allele frequency at a constant linear rate per generation (q0−qt=s⋅tq_0 - q_t = s \cdot t). In diploid selection with complete dominance, rare recessive alleles are mostly masked in heterozygotes (RrRr) and shielded from selection, producing a non-linear decay represented by the reciprocal difference 1qt−1q0≈s⋅t\frac{1}{q_t} - \frac{1}{q_0} \approx s \cdot t.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Identify the Genetic Model
  • Selection against a recessive allele in diploids is non-linear due to heterozygote masking.

  • Check whether the phenotype under negative selection is dominant or recessive, and use the reciprocal approximation formula 1qt−1q0≈s⋅t\frac{1}{q_t} - \frac{1}{q_0} \approx s \cdot t when given.

Calculate Reciprocals First
  • In the reciprocal selection model, take reciprocals of frequencies before computing the difference: Δ(1q)=1qt−1q0\Delta\left(\frac{1}{q}\right) = \frac{1}{q_t} - \frac{1}{q_0}.

  • Compute 1qt\frac{1}{q_t} and 1q0\frac{1}{q_0} independently before subtracting and dividing by the generation time tt.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Set up the given approximation formula: 1qt−1q0≈s⋅t\frac{1}{q_t} - \frac{1}{q_0} \approx s \cdot t.

  2. Substitute q0=0.80q_0 = 0.80, q4=0.20q_4 = 0.20, and t=4t = 4: 10.20−10.80=4s\frac{1}{0.20} - \frac{1}{0.80} = 4s.

  3. Simplify the reciprocals: 5.0−1.25=3.755.0 - 1.25 = 3.75.

  4. Solve for ss: s=3.754=0.9375s = \frac{3.75}{4} = 0.9375.

  5. Round to three significant figures: s=0.938s = 0.938.

Final answer

s=0.938s = 0.938

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review why recessive alleles are shielded from selection at low frequencies due to diploid heterozygosity.

  • Practice calculating the selection coefficient using reciprocal differences rather than raw frequency differences.

  • Solve the follow-up practice exercises to solidify applying 1qt−1q0≈s⋅t\frac{1}{q_t} - \frac{1}{q_0} \approx s \cdot t under varying generation counts.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 A student computes the total change across all four generations without dividing by t = 4, obtaining s = 3.75.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    s=1qt−1q0  ⟹  s=10.20−10.80s = \frac{1}{q_t} - \frac{1}{q_0} \implies s = \frac{1}{0.20} - \frac{1}{0.80}

    Correct

    s⋅t=1qt−1q0  ⟹  s⋅4=10.20−10.80s \cdot t = \frac{1}{q_t} - \frac{1}{q_0} \implies s \cdot 4 = \frac{1}{0.20} - \frac{1}{0.80}

    You set up the selection equation without dividing by the generation time t=4t = 4. The formula given is 1qt−1q0≈s⋅t\frac{1}{q_t} - \frac{1}{q_0} \approx s \cdot t, which means s=1t(1qt−1q0)s = \frac{1}{t}\left(\frac{1}{q_t} - \frac{1}{q_0}\right).

  2. Step 2

    s=5−1.25  ⟹  s=3.75s = 5 - 1.25 \implies s = 3.75

    Correct

    s=5−1.254=3.754=0.9375≈0.938s = \frac{5 - 1.25}{4} = \frac{3.75}{4} = 0.9375 \approx 0.938

    Your arithmetic 5−1.25=3.755 - 1.25 = 3.75 is completely correct, but because t=4t = 4 was omitted in the previous step, this value represents the cumulative reciprocal change across 4 generations rather than the per-generation rate ss.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified and substituted the initial allele frequency q0=0.80q_0 = 0.80 and final frequency qt=0.20q_t = 0.20.

You evaluated the reciprocals 10.20=5\frac{1}{0.20} = 5 and 10.80=1.25\frac{1}{0.80} = 1.25 and computed their difference accurately.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Omission of generation time variable

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You equated the selection coefficient ss directly to the total change in reciprocal allele frequency Δ(1/q)\Delta(1/q), neglecting that ss is a rate per generation and must be solved by dividing by the elapsed time tt.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Selection Rate Formula
  • When selection acts against a recessive allele, 1qt−1q0≈s⋅t\frac{1}{q_t} - \frac{1}{q_0} \approx s \cdot t, where ss is the per-generation selection coefficient.

  • Always isolate the target variable algebraically (s=1t(1qt−1q0)s = \frac{1}{t}\left(\frac{1}{q_t} - \frac{1}{q_0}\right)) before substituting numeric values.

Biological Sanity Check
  • In standard viability selection models with non-negative fitness (w=1−s≥0w = 1 - s \ge 0), the selection coefficient ss satisfies 0≤s≤10 \le s \le 1.

  • If you obtain s>1s > 1 for a standard viability selection problem, verify whether you forgot to divide by elapsed generations tt.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Write the selection approximation formula: s⋅t=1qt−1q0s \cdot t = \frac{1}{q_t} - \frac{1}{q_0}

  2. Rearrange to isolate the per-generation selection coefficient: s=1t(1qt−1q0)s = \frac{1}{t}\left(\frac{1}{q_t} - \frac{1}{q_0}\right)

  3. Substitute q0=0.80q_0 = 0.80, q4=0.20q_4 = 0.20, and t=4t = 4: s=14(10.20−10.80)s = \frac{1}{4}\left(\frac{1}{0.20} - \frac{1}{0.80}\right)

  4. Evaluate the arithmetic: s=5−1.254=3.754=0.9375s = \frac{5 - 1.25}{4} = \frac{3.75}{4} = 0.9375

  5. Round to three significant figures: s=0.938s = 0.938

Final answer

s=0.938s = 0.938

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the relationship between rates per generation and cumulative changes across multiple generations in population genetics.

  • Perform a range check on your result: since relative fitness cannot be negative (w=1−sw = 1 - s), an ss value greater than 11 signals a missing time divisor.

  • Practice solving similar selection problems by isolating ss algebraically before performing numeric substitutions.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A pest population is subjected to an insecticide for t=5t = 5 generations. The frequency of the susceptible recessive allele drops from q0=0.50q_0 = 0.50 to q5=0.10q_5 = 0.10. Using the approximation 1qt−1q0≈s⋅t\frac{1}{q_t} - \frac{1}{q_0} \approx s \cdot t, determine the selection coefficient ss against the susceptible homozygote.

Answer

s=1.60s = 1.60. Key steps: 10.10−10.50=10−2=8\frac{1}{0.10} - \frac{1}{0.50} = 10 - 2 = 8. Then s⋅5=8  ⟹  s=85=1.60s \cdot 5 = 8 \implies s = \frac{8}{5} = 1.60.

02

In a bacterial culture, a non-resistant recessive allele declines in frequency from q0=0.40q_0 = 0.40 to qt=0.05q_t = 0.05 under antibiotic pressure with a selection coefficient of s=0.875s = 0.875. Calculate the number of generations tt elapsed under the model 1qt−1q0≈s⋅t\frac{1}{q_t} - \frac{1}{q_0} \approx s \cdot t.

Answer

t=20t = 20. Key steps: 10.05−10.40=20−2.5=17.5\frac{1}{0.05} - \frac{1}{0.40} = 20 - 2.5 = 17.5. Then 0.875⋅t=17.5  ⟹  t=17.50.875=200.875 \cdot t = 17.5 \implies t = \frac{17.5}{0.875} = 20 generations.

03

A diploid weed species has an initial susceptible recessive allele frequency of q0=0.25q_0 = 0.25. If an intense herbicide regime imposes a selection coefficient of s=0.75s = 0.75 against susceptible homozygotes, predict the susceptible allele frequency q2q_2 after t=2t = 2 generations using 1qt−1q0≈s⋅t\frac{1}{q_t} - \frac{1}{q_0} \approx s \cdot t.

Answer

q2=0.182q_2 = 0.182 (or 211\frac{2}{11}). Key steps: 1q2−10.25=0.75×2  ⟹  1q2−4=1.5  ⟹  1q2=5.5  ⟹  q2=15.5=211≈0.182\frac{1}{q_2} - \frac{1}{0.25} = 0.75 \times 2 \implies \frac{1}{q_2} - 4 = 1.5 \implies \frac{1}{q_2} = 5.5 \implies q_2 = \frac{1}{5.5} = \frac{2}{11} \approx 0.182.

Loading workspace…