Resources
In an organism with chromosomes, a dihybrid germ cell has the genotype , where gene and gene reside on separate, non-homologous autosomes (chromosome 1 and chromosome 2, respectively). During male gametogenesis, crossing over occurs normally between sister chromatids, while chromosome segregation follows Mendel's principle of independent assortment during Anaphase I. (a) Calculate the total number of distinct tetrads formed in a primary spermatocyte during Prophase I. (b) Calculate the probability that a single developing primary spermatocyte yields four spermatids that carry only two distinct allele combinations ( and ) rather than all four combinations (), assuming no crossing over occurred between either gene locus and its respective centromere.
Answer and steps
Final answer
(a) ; (b) (or , because a single individual meiotic event with no crossing over between each locus and its centromere segregates one pair of alleles to one pole and the other to the opposite pole, producing only two recombinant-free parental genotype classes, and , among its 4 products).
Steps
Part (a): Number of Tetrads in Prophase I
- Relate chromosome count to homologous pairs: The organism has a diploid chromosome number of . This means the cell contains total chromosomes arranged into homologous pairs:
- Definition of a tetrad (bivalent): During Prophase I of meiosis, homologous chromosomes pair closely along their length in a process called synapsis. Each paired set of homologous chromosomes consists of chromosomes and sister chromatids, forming a structure called a tetrad (or bivalent).
- Calculate total tetrads: Because each homologous pair forms exactly one tetrad:
Part (b): Gamete Combinations from a Single Spermatocyte
-
Track chromatid composition without crossing over:
- After DNA replication in the phase, each chromosome consists of two identical sister chromatids.
- Because no crossing over occurs between either gene locus and its centromere, both sister chromatids of chromosome carry allele on one homologue, and allele on the other.
- Similarly, both sister chromatids of chromosome carry allele on one homologue, and allele on the other.
-
Segregation during Meiosis I and Meiosis II:
- During Anaphase I, homologous chromosomes separate to opposite poles. If chromosome with moves to the same pole as chromosome with , the opposite pole receives and .
- In Meiosis II, sister chromatids separate.
- As a result, the four resulting spermatids comprise two carrying allele combination and two carrying allele combination (a ratio).
-
Single cell vs. cell population (Pitfall):
- A single meiotic division without crossing over can never yield all four gametic combinations (). It physically produces only distinct allele combinations.
- The classic ratio of gametes is a population-level expectation that arises because half of the spermatocytes in the testis align one way (yielding and ) and the other half align the alternative way (yielding and ).
- Therefore, for any single meiotic event, the probability that it yields only two distinct types rather than all four is:
Typical errors
01 The student confuses the number of tetrads with the total number of chromatids or individual chromosomes, assuming each chromosome or sister chromatid pair is counted as a tetrad.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1Correct
You equated the number of tetrads to the total diploid chromosome number (). A tetrad (or bivalent) is formed by the synapsis of one homologous pair of replicated chromosomes, so an organism with has tetrads.
- Step 2
- Step 3Correct
You found the probability of one specific alignment ( and ), but the question asked for the probability that the cell yields only two distinct combinations rather than all four combinations. Without crossing over, any single meiotic event can only physically produce two distinct gamete genotypes ( of each type) and can never produce all four, so the probability is (or ).
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly identified that independent assortment at Metaphase I offers two alternative chromosome alignments for an dihybrid.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou calculated the probability of a specific alignment ( and ) instead of evaluating whether any single meiosis without crossing over could produce four distinct types.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou conflated the number of individual chromosomes with the number of paired homologous complexes (tetrads), and confused the population-level Mendelian gametic ratio () with the physical gametic output of a single individual spermatocyte.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Tetrad Count Definition
. Each tetrad contains homologous chromosomes and sister chromatids.
Divide the diploid chromosome number () by to find the number of tetrads formed in Prophase I.
- Single Meiotic Division vs. Population Gamete Pool
A single primary spermatocyte undergoes one round of DNA replication and two successive divisions, producing spermatids. Without crossing over, each homologue carries identical sister chromatids, yielding at most distinct gamete genotypes ( of each).
Remember that a single cell never yields all four gamete types () without crossing over; all four types only emerge across a large population of dividing cells.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationFor part (a), calculate the haploid number of homologous pairs: .
For part (b), recognize that each single spermatocyte without crossing over yields only two allele types (either or ).
Because a single meiotic division physically cannot produce all four combinations without crossing over, it yields two combinations with certainty: .
(a) ; (b)
02 The student applies the population-level independent assortment gamete ratio (1/4 AB, 1/4 Ab, 1/4 aB, 1/4 ab) to a single meiotic division, calculating the probability as (1/4)⁴ or 1/4 instead of considering whole-cell segregation.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
- Step 2Correct
You treated the four spermatids as independent draws from an overall population pool where each gamete genotype has probability . However, in a single meiotic division without crossing over between either locus and its centromere, Anaphase I separates homologues such that one pole receives one combination (e.g., and ) and the opposite pole receives the other (e.g., and ). Meiosis II simply separates sister chromatids, physically producing and (or and ). A single spermatocyte can never produce all four genotypes; it is guaranteed ( probability) to produce only two distinct combinations.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly calculated the number of homologous chromosome pairs from the diploid chromosome number.
You correctly recognized that each homologous pair forms exactly one tetrad in Prophase I.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou listed the four possible gamete types of the dihybrid () and assigned each a probability of , treating gamete formation as random independent draws.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisConfusing single-cell meiotic segregation with population-level independent assortment: Mendel's ratio arises across thousands of spermatocytes because different cells align chromosomes differently at Metaphase I, but any individual spermatocyte without crossing over can physically yield only two distinct allele combinations across its four spermatids.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Single Cell vs. Gamete Pool
A single primary spermatocyte produces exactly spermatids through one round of Meiosis I and Meiosis II.
Trace the physical movement of the two duplicated chromosome pairs through Anaphase I and II rather than using Punnett square or population probabilities.
- Chromosome Segregation without Crossing Over
Without crossing over, homologous chromosomes segregate to opposite poles at Anaphase I, so each secondary spermatocyte receives only one allele of each gene.
Conclude that Meiosis II yields identical duplicates of the Meiosis I poles, always producing exactly distinct types in a ratio.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationIn a single primary spermatocyte of genotype , duplicated chromosomes align at Metaphase I as pairs.
During Anaphase I, homologous chromosomes separate to opposite poles. If one pole receives chromatids carrying and , the opposite pole receives and .
During Meiosis II, sister chromatids separate, resulting in spermatids: and .
Because a single cell without crossing over always yields only distinct genotypes (and never all ), the probability of yielding only two distinct types rather than all four is .
(a) ; (b) (or )
Lock it in
What is a tetrad (bivalent) in meiosis, and how do you determine the number of tetrads in a cell?
A tetrad is a paired set of homologous chromosomes (comprising sister chromatids) formed during Prophase I. The number of tetrads equals the haploid number: .
Similar question
A diploid plant species has chromosomes. In a pollen mother cell at Metaphase I, determine: (a) the number of tetrads aligned at the metaphase plate, and (b) the total number of sister chromatids present in the cell.
Answer
(a) The number of tetrads equals the haploid number . (b) Each chromosome has replicated into sister chromatids, so there are .
Consider a dihybrid male mammal with genotype , where genes and are on different autosomes. In the absence of crossing over, what is the probability that a single primary spermatocyte produces four sperm cells that represent all four possible allele combinations ()?
Answer
(or ). In a single meiotic division without crossing over, only two distinct allele combinations are formed (either or ), never all four.
An organism with has genotype on separate chromosomes. If a single primary spermatocyte undergoes crossing over between gene and its centromere (involving non-sister chromatids), but gene has no crossing over, how many distinct gamete genotypes are produced by this single cell?
Answer
distinct gamete genotypes (). Crossing over between locus and its centromere creates recombinant chromatids on chromosome 1 ( and on the same dyad), which segregate in Meiosis II with the non-recombinant and chromatids, yielding all four genotypes in a ratio from that single cell.