Resources
In population genetics, the relative efficacy of natural selection versus random genetic drift depends on the magnitude of the selection coefficient relative to the effective population size . A deleterious recessive allele is subject to negative selection with selection coefficient . (a) Determine the threshold effective population size below which genetic drift dominates over selection according to the standard boundary criterion . (b) If a bottleneck contracts the population to individuals, evaluate whether drift or selection predominates, and state whether the frequency of this deleterious allele can increase by chance.
Answer and steps
Final answer
(a) individuals (drift dominates if ); (b) Because , genetic drift predominates over selection, and the deleterious allele can increase in frequency purely by chance.
Steps
Part (a): Determining the Threshold Effective Population Size ()
Natural selection and genetic drift act simultaneously on allele frequencies in biological populations:
- Natural selection tends to systematically change allele frequencies based on reproductive fitness differences measured by the selection coefficient ().
- Genetic drift causes random fluctuations in allele frequencies from generation to generation due to sampling error, with an intensity inversely proportional to the effective population size ().
According to diffusion theory in population genetics, random genetic drift overpowers directional selection when the magnitude of the selection coefficient is smaller than the reciprocal of twice the effective population size:
To find the critical threshold effective population size at which selection and drift have roughly equal influence, set the two sides equal:
Rearranging the expression to solve for :
Substitute the given selection coefficient :
Thus, whenever the effective population size falls below this threshold (, or as an integer count, ), genetic drift dominates over natural selection.
Part (b): Evaluating the Population Bottleneck ()
-
Comparison with the threshold: Following the population contraction, the effective population size is .
Alternatively, evaluating the drift boundary condition directly: Because , the condition is satisfied.
-
Dominant evolutionary force and allele dynamics:
- Because , genetic drift predominates over natural selection.
- Under strong drift, random sampling error overrides the weak selective disadvantage of the deleterious allele. Consequently, the deleterious allele behaves effectively neutrally, meaning its frequency can increase purely by chance and potentially even become fixed in the population.
Common Pitfall: Assuming that negative selection always decreases the frequency of a deleterious allele. In small or bottlenecked populations, drift can cause harmful alleles to rise in frequency despite negative selection coefficients.
Typical errors
01 The student omits the factor of 2 in the boundary criterion denominator, miscalculating the threshold as Ne* = 66.67.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1Correct
You omitted the factor of in the denominator of the boundary condition given in the problem statement (). Setting yields individuals rather than .
- Step 2Correct
Your numerical comparison used instead of , which inherited the missing factor of from Step 1. However, your qualitative conclusion is correct because is indeed below the true threshold of .
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly recognized that when genetic drift predominates over selection, a deleterious allele can increase in frequency purely by chance.
You correctly set up the reciprocal relationship to solve for the critical population threshold from your inequality.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou dropped the factor of from the denominator specified in the problem statement.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou recalled or applied the haploid or unscaled drift approximation () instead of the standard diploid threshold criterion () provided in the prompt.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Diploid allele copies and drift strength
In a diploid population of size , there are gene copies, making the variance in allele frequency per generation and the drift threshold .
Always check whether the population model is diploid () before omitting coefficients in population genetic thresholds.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationStart with the given diploid criterion: .
Substitute : individuals.
Compare the bottleneck size to : because , genetic drift dominates over selection, and the deleterious allele can increase in frequency by chance.
(a) individuals; (b) Genetic drift predominates over selection, and the deleterious allele can increase in frequency by chance.
02 The student inverts the condition by concluding that selection always eliminates deleterious alleles, incorrectly asserting that deleterious alleles cannot increase in frequency.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
- Step 2
, so drift predominates
- Step 3
Since the allele is deleterious, natural selection prevents it from increasing, so its frequency cannot increase.
CorrectBecause genetic drift predominates over natural selection, the allele behaves nearly neutrally, so its frequency can increase (and even become fixed) purely by chance.
When genetic drift dominates over selection (), random sampling error overpowers the directional force of selection. Consequently, a deleterious allele is not strictly purged and can increase in frequency by chance.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou set up and rearranged the boundary formula accurately to find the threshold population size.
You calculated the drift threshold value for and correctly recognized that drift predominates.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou treated natural selection as an absolute barrier to allele increase, overlooking that when drift predominates, stochastic sampling error overrides weak negative selection and allows deleterious alleles to fluctuate upward or even fix purely by chance.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Drift-Dominance Regime
When , genetic drift overrides natural selection, making alleles behave nearly neutrally.
Whenever you conclude that drift dominates, recognize that allele frequency trajectories are driven primarily by random chance rather than fitness differences.
- Deleterious Allele Dynamics Under Drift
In small populations where drift predominates, deleterious alleles can increase in frequency or reach fixation by chance despite carrying a selective disadvantage.
Do not assume negative selection automatically prevents an allele from increasing; check whether is small enough for drift to override selection.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationBecause drift predominates over selection (), random sampling variance between generations is larger than the deterministic change caused by selection.
Under these conditions, the deleterious allele behaves nearly neutrally, meaning its frequency fluctuates stochastically.
Therefore, the deleterious allele can increase in frequency, and may even reach fixation, purely by chance.
(a) individuals (drift dominates when ); (b) Because , genetic drift predominates over selection, and the frequency of this deleterious allele can increase purely by chance.
03 The student misinterprets the inequality direction, concluding that selection dominates because 25 is less than the threshold.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
- Step 2
is smaller than , so selection dominates over drift
CorrectSince (or ), random genetic drift dominates over natural selection.
Genetic drift is strongest in small populations because random sampling error increases when population size decreases. Below the threshold , drift overpowers selection, not the other way around.
- Step 3
Because selection dominates, the deleterious allele cannot increase.
CorrectBecause genetic drift dominates, random fluctuations can cause the deleterious allele to increase in frequency by chance.
This conclusion follows directly from your inverted assessment of the dominant force in Step 2. When drift dominates, deleterious alleles behave almost neutrally and can rise in frequency or even fix by chance.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly set up the critical boundary equation .
You accurately computed the threshold value .
You correctly calculated the drift threshold value for .
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou associated smaller effective population size with stronger natural selection rather than stronger genetic drift, reversing the diffusion-theory criterion .
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Population Size vs. Drift Strength
Sampling variance in allele frequency per generation is proportional to , meaning genetic drift is stronger in smaller populations and weaker in larger populations.
Remember that as shrinks, drift becomes more powerful; whenever , genetic drift dominates over selection.
- Deleterious Allele Dynamics Under Drift
When , selection is too weak to systematically purge harmful mutations against stochastic fluctuations.
Recognize that under drift dominance, deleterious alleles can increase in frequency or even fix purely through random sampling error.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationCompare the population size to the threshold: .
Apply the governing rule: because smaller populations experience greater sampling error, genetic drift dominates when .
Evaluate allele dynamics: because drift overpowers selection, the deleterious allele behaves nearly neutrally and its frequency can increase purely by chance.
(a) individuals; (b) Because , genetic drift predominates over natural selection, and the deleterious allele can increase in frequency purely by chance.
Lock it in
What is the standard boundary criterion determining whether genetic drift overpowers directional selection in a diploid population?
. Drift dominates when selection is weaker than the sampling variation across the total gene copies.
Similar question
A slightly beneficial mutation has a selective advantage of . Calculate the critical effective population size below which drift effectively neutralizes selection according to .
Answer
. Setting gives individuals. If , drift dominates.
An endangered feline population undergoes a bottleneck reducing its size to . A mildly deleterious mutation with selection coefficient arises. Determine whether drift or selection predominates.
Answer
Selection predominates. Calculate the threshold boundary: . Since , the selective disadvantage is strong enough to overcome drift.
In a diploid population where , find the range of selection coefficients for which alleles behave as effectively neutral (governed predominantly by drift rather than selection).
Answer
. An allele behaves as effectively neutral when drift dominates selection, satisfying . Substituting yields .