Resources

In a population of wildflowers living in a subalpine meadow, plant height is a polygenic trait exhibiting continuous phenotypic variation, with a pre-selection mean height of zˉ=42.0 cm\bar{z} = 42.0\text{ cm} and a phenotypic variance of σP2=16.0 cm2\sigma_P^2 = 16.0\text{ cm}^2. An unusually early and heavy snowfall kills plants shorter than 38.0 cm38.0\text{ cm} before they can set seed. A student hypothesizes that because this selective event culls short individuals, the trait variance in the surviving breeding population must decrease, but the population will inherently exhibit higher developmental stability. The mean height of the surviving plants that successfully reproduce is zˉ∗=45.2 cm\bar{z}^* = 45.2\text{ cm}. Given that the narrow-sense heritability of height in this population is h2=0.45h^2 = 0.45: (a) Calculate the selection differential (SS) and the expected evolutionary response (RR) across one generation using the Breeder's Equation. (b) Predict the mean height of the progeny generation (zˉ′\bar{z}'). (c) Address the student's intuition: identify the mode of selection operating on this population and explain why directional truncation selection temporarily reduces phenotypic variance within the surviving cohort even while increasing mean phenotypic value. Round numerical values to two decimal places.

Answer and steps

Final answer

(a) S=3.20 cmS = 3.20\text{ cm}, R=1.44 cmR = 1.44\text{ cm}; (b) zˉ′=43.44 cm\bar{z}' = 43.44\text{ cm}; (c) The mode of selection is directional selection. Truncation culls one tail of the distribution, which mathematically reduces the within-generation variance of reproducing parents, demonstrating that directional selection removes phenotypic extremes rather than maintaining higher variability.

Steps

Part (a): Selection Differential and Evolutionary Response

  1. Calculate the selection differential (SS):
    The selection differential measures the difference between the mean phenotype of the reproducing parents (zˉ∗\bar{z}^*) and the mean phenotype of the entire parental population before selection (zˉ\bar{z}): S=zˉ∗−zˉS = \bar{z}^* - \bar{z} Substitute the given values: S=45.2 cm−42.0 cm=3.20 cmS = 45.2\text{ cm} - 42.0\text{ cm} = 3.20\text{ cm}
  2. Calculate the response to selection (RR):
    According to the Breeder's Equation, the evolutionary change from one generation to the next depends on the narrow-sense heritability (h2h^2) and the selection differential (SS): R=h2⋅SR = h^2 \cdot S Substitute h2=0.45h^2 = 0.45 and S=3.20 cmS = 3.20\text{ cm}: R=0.45⋅3.20 cm=1.44 cmR = 0.45 \cdot 3.20\text{ cm} = 1.44\text{ cm}

Part (b): Mean Height of the Progeny Generation

The predicted mean phenotype of the offspring generation (zˉ′\bar{z}') equals the original parental mean plus the evolutionary response: zˉ′=zˉ+R\bar{z}' = \bar{z} + R zˉ′=42.0 cm+1.44 cm=43.44 cm\bar{z}' = 42.0\text{ cm} + 1.44\text{ cm} = 43.44\text{ cm}

Pitfall Note: Be careful not to confuse the mean of the selected parents (zˉ∗=45.2 cm\bar{z}^* = 45.2\text{ cm}) with the mean of the next generation (zˉ′=43.44 cm\bar{z}' = 43.44\text{ cm}). Because heritability is less than 11 (h2=0.45h^2 = 0.45), environmental variation and non-additive genetic effects cause the offspring mean to regress partially back toward the original population mean.


Part (c): Mode of Selection and Variance Reduction

  1. Mode of Selection:
    The selective event targets and eliminates phenotypes at one extreme (individuals shorter than 38.0 cm38.0\text{ cm}), favoring taller individuals and shifting the population mean in a single direction. Therefore, this is directional selection (specifically, truncation selection).
  2. Why Within-Cohort Variance Decreases:

    • Phenotypic variance quantifies the dispersion of values around the mean.
    • When a strict threshold or truncation culls an entire tail of a normal distribution (the shortest individuals), the lower boundary of phenotypic values is removed.
    • Restricting the range of surviving phenotypes concentrates the remaining values closer to their new mean, mathematically reducing the sample variance among the surviving breeders (σ∗2<σP2\sigma^{*2} < \sigma_P^2).
    • Consequently, while directional selection increases the mean phenotypic value toward taller heights, it simultaneously removes phenotypic extremes, temporarily narrowing phenotypic variance within that cohort before recombination and environmental variation restore variation in the subsequent generations.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student confuses the selection differential S with the difference between the survivor mean and the truncation threshold rather than the pre-selection population mean.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    S=45.2−38.0=7.20 cmS = 45.2 - 38.0 = 7.20\text{ cm}

    Correct

    S=zˉ∗−zˉ=45.2−42.0=3.20 cmS = \bar{z}^* - \bar{z} = 45.2 - 42.0 = 3.20\text{ cm}

    You subtracted the minimum survival threshold (38.0 cm38.0\text{ cm}) instead of the pre-selection mean height of the population (zˉ=42.0 cm\bar{z} = 42.0\text{ cm}). The selection differential SS measures the difference between the mean of reproducing survivors and the mean of the entire parental population before selection.

  2. Step 2

    R=0.45×7.20=3.24 cmR = 0.45 \times 7.20 = 3.24\text{ cm}

    Correct

    R=h2S=0.45×3.20=1.44 cmR = h^2 S = 0.45 \times 3.20 = 1.44\text{ cm}

    You applied the Breeder's Equation R=h2SR = h^2 S correctly, but your numerical result was affected by the incorrect value of SS from Step 1.

  3. Step 3

    z′=42.0+3.24=45.24 cmz' = 42.0 + 3.24 = 45.24\text{ cm}

    Correct

    zˉ′=zˉ+R=42.0+1.44=43.44 cm\bar{z}' = \bar{z} + R = 42.0 + 1.44 = 43.44\text{ cm}

    You correctly added the response to the original mean zˉ\bar{z}, but this value was also affected by your earlier calculation of RR.

  4. Step 4

    Directional selection. Eliminating the shortest individuals below 38.0 cm38.0\text{ cm} truncates the lower tail of the distribution, which restricts phenotypic variation in the surviving group.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly used the Breeder's Equation R=h2SR = h^2 S to calculate the response to selection.

You correctly added the response RR to the baseline parental mean zˉ\bar{z} to determine the offspring mean zˉ′\bar{z}'.

You correctly identified directional selection and explained how truncation removes distribution tails and decreases within-cohort variance.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Confusing Selection Differential Baseline with Truncation Threshold

You used the survival cutoff threshold (38.0 cm38.0\text{ cm}) as the baseline value when computing the selection differential SS.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Confusing the selection threshold (the minimum phenotype required to survive) with the original population mean phenotype (ar{z}). The selection differential compares the average of selected parents to the average of the whole initial population, not to the survival cutoff boundary.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Define Selection Differential (S)
  • S=zˉ∗−zˉS = \bar{z}^* - \bar{z}, where zˉ∗\bar{z}^* is the mean of successful breeders and zˉ\bar{z} is the pre-selection population mean.

  • Always subtract the original population mean zˉ\bar{z}, never the truncation boundary or minimum survival threshold.

Breeder's Equation Components
  • R=h2SR = h^2 S and zˉ′=zˉ+R\bar{z}' = \bar{z} + R.

  • Ensure SS represents a shift between two population averages before multiplying by heritability.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Recalculate the selection differential using the pre-selection mean: S=zˉ∗−zˉ=45.2 cm−42.0 cm=3.20 cmS = \bar{z}^* - \bar{z} = 45.2\text{ cm} - 42.0\text{ cm} = 3.20\text{ cm}.

  2. Calculate the evolutionary response using the Breeder's Equation: R=h2S=0.45×3.20 cm=1.44 cmR = h^2 S = 0.45 \times 3.20\text{ cm} = 1.44\text{ cm}.

  3. Determine the offspring generation mean: zˉ′=zˉ+R=42.0 cm+1.44 cm=43.44 cm\bar{z}' = \bar{z} + R = 42.0\text{ cm} + 1.44\text{ cm} = 43.44\text{ cm}.

Final answer

(a) S=3.20 cmS = 3.20\text{ cm}, R=1.44 cmR = 1.44\text{ cm}; (b) zˉ′=43.44 cm\bar{z}' = 43.44\text{ cm}; (c) Directional selection

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the definition of selection differential SS as the difference between two sample means: zˉ∗−zˉ\bar{z}^* - \bar{z}.

  • Practice highlighting key given parameters in quantitative genetics problems to clearly separate thresholds from population averages.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student adds the response to the survivor mean instead of the original parental population mean to predict offspring mean height.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    S=45.2−42.0=3.20 cm  ⟹  R=0.45×3.20=1.44 cmS = 45.2 - 42.0 = 3.20\text{ cm} \implies R = 0.45 \times 3.20 = 1.44\text{ cm}

  2. Step 2

    zˉ′=45.2+1.44=46.64 cm\bar{z}' = 45.2 + 1.44 = 46.64\text{ cm}

    Correct

    zˉ′=zˉ+R=42.0+1.44=43.44 cm\bar{z}' = \bar{z} + R = 42.0 + 1.44 = 43.44\text{ cm}

    You added the evolutionary response RR to the selected parents' mean zˉ∗=45.2 cm\bar{z}^* = 45.2\text{ cm} instead of the original parental population mean zˉ=42.0 cm\bar{z} = 42.0\text{ cm}. The response R=zˉ′−zˉR = \bar{z}' - \bar{z} represents the change relative to the initial population.

  3. Step 3

    "Directional selection. Removing plants below 38.0 cm38.0\text{ cm} eliminates the left tail of the distribution, directly reducing phenotypic spread among the survivors."

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly computed the selection differential S=zˉ∗−zˉS = \bar{z}^* - \bar{z}.

You properly applied the Breeder's Equation R=h2SR = h^2 S to calculate the evolutionary response.

You clearly identified the mode of selection as directional selection and explained how truncation removes tail extremes.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Misapplied reference baseline for progeny mean

You used the selected breeder mean zˉ∗\bar{z}^* as the base value instead of the original population mean zˉ\bar{z} when calculating offspring mean height.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Confusing the definitions of the selection differential S=zˉ∗−zˉS = \bar{z}^* - \bar{z} and the evolutionary response R=zˉ′−zˉR = \bar{z}' - \bar{z}. The selection differential measures the shift from the original population to the selected parents, whereas the response measures the transgenerational shift from the original parental generation to the offspring generation.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Baseline for Evolutionary Change
  • By definition, the response to selection is the difference between generations: R=zˉ′−zˉR = \bar{z}' - \bar{z}.

  • Always add RR to the original pre-selection parental mean zˉ\bar{z}, giving zˉ′=zˉ+R\bar{z}' = \bar{z} + R.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Recall the definition of evolutionary response: R=zˉ′−zˉR = \bar{z}' - \bar{z}.

  2. Rearrange to solve for the progeny mean: zˉ′=zˉ+R\bar{z}' = \bar{z} + R.

  3. Substitute the pre-selection mean zˉ=42.0 cm\bar{z} = 42.0\text{ cm} and R=1.44 cmR = 1.44\text{ cm}: zˉ′=42.0+1.44=43.44 cm\bar{z}' = 42.0 + 1.44 = 43.44\text{ cm}.

Final answer

(a) S=3.20 cmS = 3.20\text{ cm}, R=1.44 cmR = 1.44\text{ cm}; (b) zˉ′=43.44 cm\bar{z}' = 43.44\text{ cm}; (c) Directional selection; truncation eliminates the lower tail of phenotypes, which mathematically narrows variance in the surviving cohort.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the distinction between within-generation parental shift (S=zˉ∗−zˉS = \bar{z}^* - \bar{z}) and across-generation evolutionary change (R=zˉ′−zˉR = \bar{z}' - \bar{z}).

  • Notice that because h2<1h^2 < 1, the progeny mean zˉ′\bar{z}' must lie between the original mean zˉ\bar{z} and the selected parent mean zˉ∗\bar{z}^* due to regression to the mean.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student misidentifies the mode of selection as stabilizing selection simply because phenotypic variance decreases.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    S=45.2−42.0=3.20 cm  ⟹  R=0.45×3.20=1.44 cmS = 45.2 - 42.0 = 3.20\text{ cm} \implies R = 0.45 \times 3.20 = 1.44\text{ cm}

  2. Step 2

    zˉ′=42.0+1.44=43.44 cm\bar{z}' = 42.0 + 1.44 = 43.44\text{ cm}

  3. Step 3

    Stabilizing selection.

    Correct

    Directional selection.

    Selection acts against only one extreme phenotypic tail (plants shorter than 38.0 cm38.0\text{ cm}) and shifts the population mean toward taller plants, which defines directional selection.

  4. Step 4

    Culling short plants eliminates one extreme, narrowing the distribution and lowering variance.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly used the formulas for selection differential and evolutionary response.

You calculated the offspring generation mean accurately.

You correctly recognized that truncating a phenotypic tail restricts the spread of values and lowers variance within the surviving group.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Misidentifying directional truncation selection as stabilizing selection

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You associated any reduction in phenotypic variance with stabilizing selection, overlooking the fact that stabilizing selection culls both extremes while keeping the mean constant, whereas directional selection eliminates one extreme and shifts the mean.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Shift in Mean vs. Change in Variance
  • Directional selection shifts the population mean by favoring one tail over the other (and truncation temporarily lowers cohort variance). Stabilizing selection favors intermediate phenotypes, culls both extremes, and leaves the mean unchanged while reducing variance.

  • Always check whether the population mean shifts (zˉ∗≠zˉ\bar{z}^* \ne \bar{z}) or whether selection acts asymmetrically on just one tail before classifying the mode of selection.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Check whether selection targets one extreme or both extremes: only short plants (<38.0 cm< 38.0\text{ cm}) are culled, which is a single tail.

  2. Check the shift in the mean: the breeding mean shifts upward from 42.0 cm42.0\text{ cm} to 45.2 cm45.2\text{ cm}, producing an evolutionary response (R>0R > 0).

  3. Conclude that selection favoring one extreme phenotype over another is directional selection (specifically truncation selection).

Final answer

(a) S=3.20 cmS = 3.20\text{ cm}, R=1.44 cmR = 1.44\text{ cm}; (b) zˉ′=43.44 cm\bar{z}' = 43.44\text{ cm}; (c) The mode of selection is directional selection. Truncation culls one tail of the distribution, which mathematically reduces the within-generation variance of reproducing parents while shifting the mean.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the defining differences between directional, stabilizing, and disruptive selection based on how both the mean and the extremes change.

  • Practice identifying modes of selection from graphical phenotypic distributions before and after selective events.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A population of alpine beetles has an initial average body length of zˉ=14.0 mm\bar{z} = 14.0\text{ mm}. A flood eliminates all beetles smaller than 11.0 mm11.0\text{ mm}, leaving a surviving reproductive group with mean length zˉ∗=16.5 mm\bar{z}^* = 16.5\text{ mm}. If narrow-sense heritability of body length is h2=0.40h^2 = 0.40, calculate the selection differential (SS) and the evolutionary response (RR).

Answer

S=zˉ∗−zˉ=16.5 mm−14.0 mm=2.50 mmS = \bar{z}^* - \bar{z} = 16.5\text{ mm} - 14.0\text{ mm} = 2.50\text{ mm}. Using Breeder's Equation: R=h2S=0.40×2.50 mm=1.00 mmR = h^2 S = 0.40 \times 2.50\text{ mm} = 1.00\text{ mm}.

02

In a dairy cattle breeding program, milk fat yield has a pre-selection mean of zˉ=320 kg/year\bar{z} = 320\text{ kg/year}. Cows producing less than 300 kg/year300\text{ kg/year} are culled. The selected cows produce an average of zˉ∗=356 kg/year\bar{z}^* = 356\text{ kg/year}. Given h2=0.25h^2 = 0.25, predict the mean milk fat yield of their daughters (zˉ′\bar{z}').

Answer

First find S=356−320=36 kg/yearS = 356 - 320 = 36\text{ kg/year}. Then R=0.25×36=9.0 kg/yearR = 0.25 \times 36 = 9.0\text{ kg/year}. The predicted offspring mean is zˉ′=zˉ+R=320+9.0=329.0 kg/year\bar{z}' = \bar{z} + R = 320 + 9.0 = 329.0\text{ kg/year}.

03

A plant breeder applies truncation selection to seed weight (initial mean zˉ=50 mg\bar{z} = 50\text{ mg}). Only seeds heavier than 55 mg55\text{ mg} are planted; their mean weight is zˉ∗=62 mg\bar{z}^* = 62\text{ mg}. The offspring generation exhibits a mean seed weight of zˉ′=54.2 mg\bar{z}' = 54.2\text{ mg}. (a) Calculate SS and RR. (b) Determine the narrow-sense heritability (h2h^2) of seed weight.

Answer

(a) S=zˉ∗−zˉ=62−50=12 mgS = \bar{z}^* - \bar{z} = 62 - 50 = 12\text{ mg}. R=zˉ′−zˉ=54.2−50=4.2 mgR = \bar{z}' - \bar{z} = 54.2 - 50 = 4.2\text{ mg}. (b) Since R=h2SR = h^2 S, heritability is h2=RS=4.212=0.35h^2 = \frac{R}{S} = \frac{4.2}{12} = 0.35.

Loading workspace…