Resources

In a continuous culture experiment (Escherichia coli Long-Term Evolution Experiment), a population of bacteria is maintained under strict glucose-limiting conditions for 50,000 generations50{,}000\text{ generations}. A mutation in the regulatory promoter of the cit operon allows rare individuals to metabolize citrate aerobically (Cit+\text{Cit}^+), conferring a relative fitness of w=1.15w = 1.15 compared to ancestral citrate-nonutilizing strains (Cit−\text{Cit}^-, w=1.00w = 1.00). If the initial frequency of the novel Cit+\text{Cit}^+ allele at generation t=0t = 0 is p0=1.00×10−4p_0 = 1.00 \times 10^{-4}, use the discrete selection model pt+1=pt⋅wCit+wˉtp_{t+1} = \frac{p_t \cdot w_{\text{Cit}^+}}{\bar{w}_t} to determine: (1) the mean population fitness wˉ0\bar{w}_0 at generation 00, and (2) the allele frequency p1p_1 after exactly one generation of selection.

Answer and steps

Final answer

(1) wˉ0=1.000015\bar{w}_0 = 1.000015, (2) p1=1.15×10−4p_1 = 1.15 \times 10^{-4}

Steps

01

Identify the given values and frequencies at generation 00

In a population with two alternative traits (Cit+\text{Cit}^+ and Cit−\text{Cit}^-), the sum of their relative frequencies equals 11:

  • Relative fitness of the Cit+\text{Cit}^+ strain: wCit+=1.15w_{\text{Cit}^+} = 1.15
  • Relative fitness of the Cit−\text{Cit}^- strain: wCit−=1.00w_{\text{Cit}^-} = 1.00
  • Initial frequency of Cit+\text{Cit}^+: p0=1.00×10−4=0.0001p_0 = 1.00 \times 10^{-4} = 0.0001
  • Initial frequency of Cit−\text{Cit}^-: q0=1−p0=1−0.0001=0.9999q_0 = 1 - p_0 = 1 - 0.0001 = 0.9999

02

Calculate the mean population fitness (wˉ0\bar{w}_0) at generation 00

The mean population fitness (wˉ0\bar{w}_0) is the weighted average of the relative fitnesses of each genotype/phenotype in the population:

wˉ0=p0⋅wCit++q0⋅wCit−\bar{w}_0 = p_0 \cdot w_{\text{Cit}^+} + q_0 \cdot w_{\text{Cit}^-}

Substitute the values into the equation:

wˉ0=(1.00×10−4⋅1.15)+(0.9999⋅1.00)\bar{w}_0 = (1.00 \times 10^{-4} \cdot 1.15) + (0.9999 \cdot 1.00)

wˉ0=0.000115+0.9999=1.000015\bar{w}_0 = 0.000115 + 0.9999 = 1.000015

Common Pitfall: Do not round wˉ0\bar{w}_0 to 1.001.00 prematurely. Even though the mutant allele frequency is very small, keeping the exact digits reflects how the overall population fitness responds to rare advantageous mutations.


03

Calculate the allele frequency (p1p_1) after one generation of selection

Use the discrete selection equation:

p1=p0⋅wCit+wˉ0p_1 = \frac{p_0 \cdot w_{\text{Cit}^+}}{\bar{w}_0}

Substitute the numerator and denominator:

p1=1.00×10−4⋅1.151.000015=1.15×10−41.000015p_1 = \frac{1.00 \times 10^{-4} \cdot 1.15}{1.000015} = \frac{1.15 \times 10^{-4}}{1.000015}

Evaluating this quotient gives:

p1≈1.14998×10−4≈1.15×10−4p_1 \approx 1.14998 \times 10^{-4} \approx 1.15 \times 10^{-4}

Thus, after one generation, the frequency of the advantageous Cit+\text{Cit}^+ allele increases from 1.00×10−41.00 \times 10^{-4} to 1.15×10−41.15 \times 10^{-4}.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 A student might calculate the mean population fitness as the unweighted arithmetic mean of the two genotype fitnesses, leading to an overly inflated mean fitness and an underestimated allele frequency.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    wˉ0=wCit++wCit−2  ⟹  wˉ0=1.15+1.002=1.075\bar{w}_0 = \frac{w_{\text{Cit}^+} + w_{\text{Cit}^-}}{2} \implies \bar{w}_0 = \frac{1.15 + 1.00}{2} = 1.075

    Correct

    wˉ0=p0⋅wCit++q0⋅wCit−=(1.00×10−4⋅1.15)+(0.9999⋅1.00)=1.000015\bar{w}_0 = p_0 \cdot w_{\text{Cit}^+} + q_0 \cdot w_{\text{Cit}^-} = (1.00 \times 10^{-4} \cdot 1.15) + (0.9999 \cdot 1.00) = 1.000015

    You took the simple unweighted average of the two fitness values instead of weighting each strain's fitness by its frequency in the population (p0p_0 and q0=1−p0q_0 = 1 - p_0). Because the advantageous Cit+\text{Cit}^+ mutant is extremely rare (0.01%0.01\% of the population), almost all individuals have w=1.00w = 1.00, making the true population mean fitness very close to 1.001.00.

  2. Step 2

    p1=p0⋅wCit+wˉ0=1.00×10−4⋅1.151.075≈1.07×10−4p_1 = \frac{p_0 \cdot w_{\text{Cit}^+}}{\bar{w}_0} = \frac{1.00 \times 10^{-4} \cdot 1.15}{1.075} \approx 1.07 \times 10^{-4}

    Correct

    p1=p0⋅wCit+wˉ0=1.00×10−4⋅1.151.000015≈1.15×10−4p_1 = \frac{p_0 \cdot w_{\text{Cit}^+}}{\bar{w}_0} = \frac{1.00 \times 10^{-4} \cdot 1.15}{1.000015} \approx 1.15 \times 10^{-4}

    You correctly set up the discrete selection recurrence and substituted your values, but your result was downstream-affected by the inflated wˉ0\bar{w}_0 from Step 1.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified and applied the discrete selection recurrence relation pt+1=pt⋅wwˉtp_{t+1} = \frac{p_t \cdot w}{\bar{w}_t}.

You correctly extracted the individual strain fitness values and initial frequency from the problem text.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Unweighted Mean Population Fitness

You divided the sum of the two fitness values by 22 instead of weighting each fitness by its genotype frequency.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Conflating the simple arithmetic mean of two numbers with the frequency-weighted mean fitness of an entire population, where genotype frequencies determine each strain's actual contribution.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Mean Fitness Definition
  • Population mean fitness is always a weighted average: wˉ=∑piwi\bar{w} = \sum p_i w_i.

  • Multiply each genotype or phenotype fitness by its current population frequency before adding them together.

Sanity Check on Rare Alleles
  • When an advantageous allele is very rare (p≪1p \ll 1), wˉ≈wancestral\bar{w} \approx w_{\text{ancestral}}.

  • Check whether your calculated wˉ\bar{w} is close to the majority strain's fitness (1.001.00) rather than halfway to the mutant's fitness.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Calculate the frequency of the ancestral strain: q0=1−p0=1−0.0001=0.9999q_0 = 1 - p_0 = 1 - 0.0001 = 0.9999.

  2. Compute the weighted mean population fitness: wˉ0=p0wCit++q0wCit−=(0.0001)(1.15)+(0.9999)(1.00)=0.000115+0.9999=1.000015\bar{w}_0 = p_0 w_{\text{Cit}^+} + q_0 w_{\text{Cit}^-} = (0.0001)(1.15) + (0.9999)(1.00) = 0.000115 + 0.9999 = 1.000015.

  3. Substitute the correct wˉ0\bar{w}_0 into the discrete selection equation: p1=p0wCit+wˉ0=1.00×10−4⋅1.151.000015≈1.15×10−4p_1 = \frac{p_0 w_{\text{Cit}^+}}{\bar{w}_0} = \frac{1.00 \times 10^{-4} \cdot 1.15}{1.000015} \approx 1.15 \times 10^{-4}.

Final answer

(1) wˉ0=1.000015\bar{w}_0 = 1.000015, (2) p1≈1.15×10−4p_1 \approx 1.15 \times 10^{-4}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the definition of population mean fitness wˉ\bar{w} as an expected value weighted by genotype frequencies.

  • Practice calculating wˉ\bar{w} when one allele is at very low or very high initial frequency.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 A student might omit the ancestral Cit⁻ background frequency term when calculating mean population fitness by setting w̄₀ = p₀ · w_Cit⁺, causing an extremely underestimated mean fitness and an impossible p₁ value greater than 1.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    wˉ0=p0⋅wCit+  ⟹  wˉ0=1.00×10−4⋅1.15=1.15×10−4\bar{w}_0 = p_0 \cdot w_{\text{Cit}^+} \implies \bar{w}_0 = 1.00 \times 10^{-4} \cdot 1.15 = 1.15 \times 10^{-4}

    Correct

    wˉ0=p0⋅wCit++q0⋅wCit−=(1.00×10−4)(1.15)+(0.9999)(1.00)=1.000015\bar{w}_0 = p_0 \cdot w_{\text{Cit}^+} + q_0 \cdot w_{\text{Cit}^-} = (1.00 \times 10^{-4})(1.15) + (0.9999)(1.00) = 1.000015

    You calculated the contribution of the rare Cit+\text{Cit}^+ mutant alone rather than the weighted average fitness of the entire population. You need to include the ancestral Cit−\text{Cit}^- individuals, who make up the remaining frequency q0=1−p0=0.9999q_0 = 1 - p_0 = 0.9999 with fitness wCit−=1.00w_{\text{Cit}^-} = 1.00.

  2. Step 2

    p1=p0⋅wCit+wˉ0  ⟹  p1=1.15×10−41.15×10−4=1.0p_1 = \frac{p_0 \cdot w_{\text{Cit}^+}}{\bar{w}_0} \implies p_1 = \frac{1.15 \times 10^{-4}}{1.15 \times 10^{-4}} = 1.0

    Correct

    p1=p0⋅wCit+wˉ0=1.15×10−41.000015≈1.15×10−4p_1 = \frac{p_0 \cdot w_{\text{Cit}^+}}{\bar{w}_0} = \frac{1.15 \times 10^{-4}}{1.000015} \approx 1.15 \times 10^{-4}

    You applied the selection formula pt+1=pt⋅wwˉp_{t+1} = \frac{p_t \cdot w}{\bar{w}} correctly, but substituting your underestimated wˉ0\bar{w}_0 from Step 1 caused the numerator and denominator to cancel out completely to 1.01.0.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified the discrete selection model formula p1=p0⋅wCit+wˉ0p_1 = \frac{p_0 \cdot w_{\text{Cit}^+}}{\bar{w}_0}.

You accurately substituted your calculated values into the selection equation and evaluated the quotient without arithmetic slips.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Omission of Alternative Phenotype in Mean Population Fitness

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated mean population fitness wˉ\bar{w} as the absolute contribution of only the focal genotype rather than the weighted sum of all genotypes/phenotypes in the population (p⋅w1+q⋅w2p \cdot w_1 + q \cdot w_2).

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Mean Fitness as a Weighted Sum
  • In a population with multiple genotypes or phenotypes, mean fitness wˉ\bar{w} is the sum of each phenotype's frequency multiplied by its relative fitness: wˉ=∑piwi\bar{w} = \sum p_i w_i.

  • Always verify that the frequencies used in the mean fitness calculation sum to 11 (p+q=1p + q = 1) before computing wˉ\bar{w}.

Sanity Check for Next-Generation Allele Frequencies
  • A rare beneficial allele with a modest fitness advantage (e.g., w=1.15w = 1.15) cannot jump from frequency 10−410^{-4} to fixation (1.01.0) in a single generation.

  • If your calculated allele frequency changes by orders of magnitude after only one generation of selection, check whether wˉ\bar{w} was computed using the whole population.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Find the frequency of ancestral Cit−\text{Cit}^- cells: q0=1−p0=1−1.00×10−4=0.9999q_0 = 1 - p_0 = 1 - 1.00 \times 10^{-4} = 0.9999.

  2. Compute the mean population fitness as the weighted sum: wˉ0=p0⋅wCit++q0⋅wCit−=(1.00×10−4⋅1.15)+(0.9999⋅1.00)=1.000015\bar{w}_0 = p_0 \cdot w_{\text{Cit}^+} + q_0 \cdot w_{\text{Cit}^-} = (1.00 \times 10^{-4} \cdot 1.15) + (0.9999 \cdot 1.00) = 1.000015.

  3. Substitute wˉ0\bar{w}_0 into the discrete selection model: p1=p0⋅wCit+wˉ0=1.00×10−4⋅1.151.000015=1.15×10−41.000015≈1.15×10−4p_1 = \frac{p_0 \cdot w_{\text{Cit}^+}}{\bar{w}_0} = \frac{1.00 \times 10^{-4} \cdot 1.15}{1.000015} = \frac{1.15 \times 10^{-4}}{1.000015} \approx 1.15 \times 10^{-4}.

Final answer

(1) wˉ0=1.000015\bar{w}_0 = 1.000015, (2) p1=1.15×10−4p_1 = 1.15 \times 10^{-4}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the definition of average/mean population fitness wˉ\bar{w} as a weighted average over all alleles or morphs in the gene pool.

  • Practice setting up wˉ\bar{w} by first listing all phenotypes, their frequencies, and their relative fitness values in a table to ensure no background class is omitted.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A haploid yeast population contains a wild-type strain with fitness w1=1.00w_1 = 1.00 at frequency q0=0.99q_0 = 0.99 and a drug-resistant mutant with fitness w2=1.40w_2 = 1.40 at frequency p0=0.01p_0 = 0.01. Calculate the mean population fitness wˉ0\bar{w}_0 and the mutant frequency p1p_1 after one generation.

Answer

wˉ0=p0w2+q0w1=(0.01)(1.40)+(0.99)(1.00)=0.014+0.99=1.004\bar{w}_0 = p_0 w_2 + q_0 w_1 = (0.01)(1.40) + (0.99)(1.00) = 0.014 + 0.99 = 1.004. Then p1=p0w2wˉ0=0.01⋅1.401.004=0.0141.004≈1.39×10−2p_1 = \frac{p_0 w_2}{\bar{w}_0} = \frac{0.01 \cdot 1.40}{1.004} = \frac{0.014}{1.004} \approx 1.39 \times 10^{-2} (or 0.01390.0139).

02

In an asexual bacterial culture, two strains compete: Strain AA (wA=1.05w_A = 1.05) and Strain BB (wB=0.95w_B = 0.95). If the initial frequency of Strain AA is p0=0.40p_0 = 0.40, calculate wˉ0\bar{w}_0 and find the change in allele frequency Δp=p1−p0\Delta p = p_1 - p_0 after one generation.

Answer

q0=1−0.40=0.60q_0 = 1 - 0.40 = 0.60. wˉ0=(0.40)(1.05)+(0.60)(0.95)=0.420+0.570=0.990\bar{w}_0 = (0.40)(1.05) + (0.60)(0.95) = 0.420 + 0.570 = 0.990. p1=p0wAwˉ0=0.40⋅1.050.990=0.4200.990≈0.4242p_1 = \frac{p_0 w_A}{\bar{w}_0} = \frac{0.40 \cdot 1.05}{0.990} = \frac{0.420}{0.990} \approx 0.4242. Δp=p1−p0≈0.4242−0.4000=+0.0242\Delta p = p_1 - p_0 \approx 0.4242 - 0.4000 = +0.0242.

03

In a diploid population under selection with complete dominance, allele AA has frequency p=0.10p = 0.10. Genotypes AAAA and AaAa have relative fitness w=1.20w = 1.20, while recessive homozygotes aaaa have fitness w=1.00w = 1.00. Calculate the mean population fitness wˉ\bar{w} assuming Hardy-Weinberg genotype proportions before selection.

Answer

With p=0.10p = 0.10 and q=0.90q = 0.90, Hardy-Weinberg frequencies are: P(AA)=p2=0.01P(AA) = p^2 = 0.01, P(Aa)=2pq=0.18P(Aa) = 2pq = 0.18, P(aa)=q2=0.81P(aa) = q^2 = 0.81. Dominant phenotype frequency (AA+AaAA + Aa) is 0.01+0.18=0.190.01 + 0.18 = 0.19 with wdom=1.20w_{\text{dom}} = 1.20. Recessive phenotype frequency (aaaa) is 0.810.81 with wrec=1.00w_{\text{rec}} = 1.00. wˉ=(0.19)(1.20)+(0.81)(1.00)=0.228+0.810=1.038\bar{w} = (0.19)(1.20) + (0.81)(1.00) = 0.228 + 0.810 = 1.038.

Loading workspace…