Resources
In a cytogenetics study of an animal species with chromosomes, a non-disjunction event of a single autosome occurs during Meiosis I in an oocyte. The affected locus has two alleles, and , located on this chromosome, and the parent is heterozygous (). Consider the threshold boundary between normal segregation and primary non-disjunction: (a) State the chromosome number () and the exact allele content for the locus in each of the two secondary oocyte nuclei produced at the end of Telophase I resulting from this boundary error. (b) Assuming Meiosis II proceeds normally and all chromatids separate, what are the two possible abnormal chromosome numbers ( or ) found in the resulting mature ova? (c) If an ovum with the condition is fertilized by a normal sperm carrying chromosomes and the allele, determine the total chromosome number and the allelic genotype of the resulting zygote.
Answer and steps
Final answer
(a) One daughter cell has chromosomes ( chromatids) containing both and alleles ( copies of and copies of ); the other daughter cell has chromosomes ( chromatids) with copies of the locus; (b) chromosomes and chromosomes; (c) chromosomes with genotype .
Steps
Part (a): End of Telophase I Products
-
Normal Separation vs. Meiosis I Non-Disjunction:
- The diploid number is , so the standard haploid number is . Prior to Meiosis I, DNA replication duplicates each chromosome into two identical sister chromatids.
- A heterozygous cell () possesses one replicated homologous chromosome containing two chromatids () and one homologous chromosome containing two chromatids ().
- In a normal Meiosis I, the two homologous chromosomes separate to opposite poles, giving each secondary daughter cell replicated chromosomes (either or ).
-
Non-Disjunction Event:
- During primary non-disjunction at Anaphase I, a pair of homologous chromosomes fails to segregate and both homologs move together into the same daughter nucleus.
- Consequently, one secondary cell receives the extra replicated chromosome, yielding chromosomes ( chromatids total). This nucleus contains both homologous pairs, carrying copies of allele and copies of allele ( and ).
- The opposite secondary cell fails to receive this chromosome, leaving it with chromosomes ( chromatids total) and copies of the locus.
Part (b): Gamete Chromosome Numbers after Meiosis II
- Equational Division in Meiosis II:
- During normal Meiosis II, sister chromatids of each chromosome pull apart into separate daughter nuclei (mature ovum and polar bodies).
- Resulting Numbers:
- The cell starting with replicated chromosomes separates its chromatids to produce gametes with single-chromatid chromosomes.
- The cell starting with replicated chromosomes separates its chromatids to produce gametes with single-chromatid chromosomes.
Part (c): Total Chromosome Number and Genotype of the Zygote
- Alleles in the Ovum:
- In Meiosis II, the secondary oocyte splits its two replicated homologs ( and ). Each resulting gamete receives one chromatid with allele and one chromatid with allele . Therefore, the ovum has an allelic composition of .
- Fertilization by Normal Sperm:
- Chromosome Number: The ovum carries chromosomes, and the normal sperm carries chromosomes. Combining them produces a trisomic zygote with:
- Allelic Genotype: Combining the ovum's alleles () with the sperm's allele () gives a genotype of:
Typical errors
01 The student confuses Meiosis I non-disjunction with Meiosis II non-disjunction, incorrectly assuming sister chromatids separate instead of homologous chromosomes, yielding homozygous allele combinations in the gamete.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
, so normal Meiosis I non-disjunction gives nuclei with and chromosomes
- Step 2
Allele content in one nucleus is or , and the other has none
CorrectOne nucleus contains both homologous chromosomes, carrying both and alleles ( copies of and copies of ), while the other nucleus has no copies of the locus.
In Meiosis I, homologous chromosomes fail to separate. Because the parent cell is heterozygous (), both replicated homologs ( and ) travel together into the same daughter cell, meaning that cell possesses both and , not one or the other.
- Step 3
Mature ova chromosome numbers are and
- Step 4
Ovum has chromosomes and sperm has chromosomes Total chromosome number =
- Step 5
Zygote genotype = or
CorrectThe ovum receives one chromatid and one chromatid during Meiosis II, giving it genotype . Fertilization by a sperm yields genotype .
Because your Part (a) allele content assumed identical sister pairs rather than both homologs, your resulting zygote genotype inherited that error. With the correct ovum genotype (), the zygote is uniquely .
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou accurately calculated the aneuploid chromosome numbers across all meiotic stages.
You correctly combined the gamete chromosome counts to determine the zygote's total chromosome number.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeNo, this is a conceptual misunderstanding regarding which chromosome structures fail to separate during Meiosis I versus Meiosis II.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou confused Meiosis I non-disjunction with Meiosis II non-disjunction. In Meiosis I, homologous pairs fail to segregate, so both the maternal and paternal replicated homologs ( and ) end up in the same daughter cell. Identical sister chromatid failure occurs only during Meiosis II non-disjunction.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Meiosis I Segregation Rule
Meiosis I separates homologous chromosome pairs; Meiosis II separates sister chromatids.
When non-disjunction happens in Meiosis I for a heterozygote (), keep both different homologs ( and ) together in the daughter cell.
- Gamete Allele Composition
Normal Meiosis II following Meiosis I non-disjunction splits sister chromatids from each homolog into each gamete.
Distribute one chromatid from each homolog into the resulting gamete, giving an gamete with both heterozygous alleles ().
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationDuring Meiosis I non-disjunction, homologous chromosomes fail to separate, moving both replicated homologs into one cell: allele content is and .
In Meiosis II, sister chromatids separate normally, so each ovum receives one chromatid and one chromatid, making the ovum genotype .
Fertilizing this ovum () with a normal sperm carrying yields: .
Zygote genotype is .
02 The student forgets that chromosomes in Meiosis I are duplicated into sister chromatids, writing single-chromatid allele designations (Bb and none) instead of accounting for duplicated chromatids.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
Normal Meiosis I daughter nuclei have After non-disjunction, chromosome numbers are and One nucleus has and the other nucleus has no alleles
CorrectOne daughter nucleus has chromosomes with allele content ( copies of and copies of ), and the other daughter nucleus has chromosomes with copies of the locus.
You correctly determined the abnormal chromosome numbers ( and ), but chromosomes at the end of Telophase I are still duplicated into sister chromatids following S-phase replication. Because both replicated homologous chromosomes ( and ) segregated into the same daughter nucleus, that nucleus contains four total chromatid copies (), not just single-chromatid alleles .
- Step 2
Abnormal chromosome numbers in mature ova are and
- Step 3
Total chromosome number Ovum contributes and , sperm contributes Zygote genotype
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly calculated the aneuploid chromosome counts for both Meiosis I daughter nuclei and mature ova.
You correctly tracked that Meiosis I non-disjunction leads to heterozygous () gametes after Meiosis II.
You correctly combined the gametic chromosome numbers and alleles to determine the trisomic zygote genotype.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou treated chromosomes at the end of Meiosis I as unreplicated single chromatids, overlooking that DNA replication prior to Meiosis I means each homolog consists of two identical sister chromatids until Anaphase II.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Track Chromatid Status Across Meiotic Divisions
Prior to Anaphase II, each chromosome consists of two sister chromatids. A heterozygous locus entering Meiosis I consists of one homolog carrying and one homolog carrying .
When recording allele copy numbers in Telophase I daughter cells, count two allele copies per replicated chromosome ( if both homologs nondisjoin into one pole).
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationIdentify that DNA replicates in S phase prior to Meiosis I, converting allele into two sister chromatids () and allele into two sister chromatids ().
During Anaphase I non-disjunction, both replicated homologs move to the same pole, delivering copies of and copies of () to one nucleus and copies to the opposite nucleus.
(a) One daughter cell has chromosomes with allele content ( copies of and copies of ); the other daughter cell has chromosomes with copies of the locus. (b) and . (c) Total chromosomes , genotype .
03 The student confuses the haploid chromosome number n with the diploid number 2n when calculating the abnormal chromosome counts, adding and subtracting 1 from 2n instead of n.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
Homologous chromosomes fail to separate in Meiosis I One nucleus gets and the other nucleus gets no copies Chromosome numbers are and
CorrectOne daughter nucleus has chromosomes (), and the other daughter nucleus has chromosomes ( copies of the locus).
You correctly determined that one daughter nucleus receives both replicated homologs () while the other receives neither. However, normal Meiosis I produces haploid nuclei with replicated chromosomes, so a single non-disjunction event produces and chromosomes, not .
- Step 2
Possible chromosome numbers in mature ova are and
CorrectPossible chromosome numbers in mature ova are and .
Because of your earlier calculation using , you carried forward and . Since Meiosis II separates sister chromatids without changing the chromosome count per cell, the resulting ova carry and chromosomes.
- Step 3
Ovum has chromosomes and sperm has chromosomes Total chromosome number Zygote genotype
CorrectTotal chromosome number (); Zygote genotype .
You correctly paired the alleles from the ovum () and the normal sperm () to get the genotype . The total chromosome count of was carried over from your ovum count of ; adding a normal sperm () to the correct ovum () gives chromosomes.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly deduced that Meiosis I non-disjunction sends both replicated homologous chromosomes () to one pole and none to the other.
You correctly determined that an ovum carries both alleles (), yielding a zygote when fertilized by a sperm.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou confused the haploid number () with the diploid number () when computing gamete chromosome counts, applying aneuploidy formulas as instead of .
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Baseline Ploidy in Meiosis
Meiosis is a reduction division that halves the ploidy from diploid () to haploid (); gamete aneuploidies are always relative to .
Always write down and explicitly before tracking non-disjunction. Normal gametes are , so single-chromosome non-disjunction yields gametes with or chromosomes.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationIdentify the normal haploid number from , which gives .
At Telophase I, normal segregation gives chromosomes per nucleus. A single non-disjunction event adds one replicated chromosome to one daughter cell () and subtracts one from the other ().
Meiosis II equational division yields mature ova with and chromosomes.
Combine the ovum ( chromosomes, alleles ) with the normal sperm ( chromosomes, allele ) to get chromosomes () and genotype .
(a) One daughter nucleus has chromosomes (), the other has chromosomes ( copies); (b) and ; (c) chromosomes, genotype .
Lock it in
What chromosomal structures fail to separate during non-disjunction in Meiosis I versus Meiosis II?
Meiosis I non-disjunction is the failure of homologous chromosomes to separate; Meiosis II non-disjunction is the failure of sister chromatids to separate.
Similar question
An organism with experiences non-disjunction of a single chromosome during Meiosis II in a spermatocyte heterozygous for allele pair . Assuming Meiosis I was normal, list all possible chromosome numbers and allelic genotypes for the four resulting sperm cells.
Answer
Two normal sperm have chromosomes (one with genotype , one with genotype ). The two abnormal sperm from the affected secondary spermatocyte have (genotype or ) and (no allele).
A human female carrier for red-green color blindness () has a child with Klinefelter syndrome () who has normal vision. The father has normal vision (). If genetic testing shows the child's genotype is , during which meiotic division and in which parent did non-disjunction occur?
Answer
Non-disjunction occurred during maternal Meiosis I. The child received both maternal alleles ( and ), which indicates failure of homologous chromosomes to separate during Meiosis I in the mother, combined with a paternal chromosome.
In a plant with , locus is linked to locus on chromosome 1 (, no crossing over). A Meiosis I non-disjunction event occurs for chromosome 1. If an gamete is fertilized by a normal gamete with genotype , what is the exact chromosomal genotype of the resulting seedling?
Answer
The gamete receives both homologous chromosomes, carrying alleles and . Fertilization with an gamete yields a trisomic zygote () with genotype .