Resources
Students often intuitively assume that when a population density is very small (), the absolute population growth rate must be at its highest because intraspecific competition is virtually absent and resources are abundant. For a population governed by with and individuals, calculate: (a) the per capita growth rate at versus , and (b) the absolute population growth rate at versus . Use these values to identify the carrying capacity and resolve this conceptual contradiction.
Answer and steps
Final answer
(a) At , ; at , . (b) At , ; at , . Carrying capacity is individuals, where per capita growth rate declines to .
Steps
Distinguishing Per Capita Growth Rate and Absolute Growth Rate
In the logistic growth model, population growth is described by:
- Per capita growth rate represents the net contribution of an individual to population growth per unit time:
- Absolute population growth rate represents the total number of individuals added to the population per unit time:
Here, the intrinsic rate of increase is and the carrying capacity is .
Calculating the Per Capita Growth Rate (Part a)
- At individuals:
- At individuals:
Calculating the Absolute Population Growth Rate (Part b)
- At individuals:
- At individuals:
Identifying Carrying Capacity and Resolving the Contradiction
- Identifying Carrying Capacity (): The carrying capacity is . At this density, the term becomes , reducing both the per capita growth rate and the absolute growth rate to zero (). This defines the maximum sustainable population size under the prevailing environmental limitations.
-
Resolving the Intuitive Contradiction: The misconception arises from conflating individual efficiency with collective output:
- When is small (), resources are abundant and intraspecific competition is almost negligible, so individual performance is at its peak (). However, because there are very few reproducing individuals, the absolute addition to the population is tiny ().
- At intermediate density (), intraspecific competition reduces per capita performance by half (down to ), but this rate is multiplied across a substantial base of individuals, maximizing the overall population increase at .
Typical errors
01 The student confuses per capita growth rate with absolute growth rate and calculates dN/dt instead of (1/N)(dN/dt) for part (a).
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1Correct
You included the population size in the per capita growth rate formula. To find the per capita rate , divide the absolute rate by , which leaves .
- Step 2
- Step 3Correct
. The contradiction is resolved by recognizing that individual efficiency (per capita rate) is highest near () due to minimal competition, but total population addition is small () because there are very few reproducing individuals. At , per capita growth drops to , but multiplying by individuals yields the maximum overall output ().
You correctly stated the carrying capacity, but because your part (a) values duplicated part (b), your explanation missed the essential contrast between per capita rate (individual contribution) and absolute rate (whole-population increase).
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly identified the carrying capacity as .
You correctly calculated the absolute population growth rate for both population sizes in part (b).
You included proper dimensional units for both calculations.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou wrote the label but kept the factor of on the right-hand side of the equation.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou conflated individual reproductive efficiency (the per capita rate, ) with collective population output (the absolute growth rate, ). Dividing both sides of by eliminates from the numerator, leaving only .
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Per Capita vs. Absolute Rate Formula Check
Absolute rate ; Per capita rate .
Whenever you see 'per capita' or 'per individual', verify that is not present as a multiplying factor outside the parentheses.
- Resolving the Low-Density Growth Paradox
Total addition = (Per capita contribution) (Number of individuals).
At low , per capita rate is maximal (near ), but total addition is minimal because the multiplier is tiny.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationWrite the per capita formula: .
At : .
At : .
(a) At , ; at , . (b) At , ; at , . Carrying capacity is , where individual contribution and total growth drop to zero.
02 The student misapplies the carrying capacity reduction factor in the absolute growth rate formula as (1 - N) instead of (1 - N/K).
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
⟹ At : ⟹ At :
- Step 2
⟹ At : ⟹ At :
Correct⟹ At : ⟹ At :
You omitted the carrying capacity in the density-dependent term, writing instead of . This led to an unphysical negative absolute growth rate for any .
- Step 3
. Absolute growth rate becomes negative when exceeds , so growth rate is highest when is very small.
Correct. Absolute growth rate at is much greater than at , resolving the paradox by showing that absolute growth depends on both per capita performance and the total number of reproducing individuals ().
You correctly identified , but your conclusion that growth rate is highest when is very small was influenced by the erroneous negative values from Step 2.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly used the per capita rate equation and obtained the correct values of and .
You correctly identified the carrying capacity as .
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou treated the density-dependent feedback term as rather than the dimensionless fraction , confusing population size with the fraction of carrying capacity utilized.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Dimensional Consistency of the Density-Dependent Term
The environmental resistance term must be dimensionless because and share the same units (individuals).
Always check that is divided by carrying capacity before subtracting from .
- Connecting Per Capita and Absolute Growth Rates
The absolute population growth rate is the product of population size and per capita growth rate: .
Multiply the per capita growth rate already calculated in part (a) directly by to find and avoid algebraic re-entry errors.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationApply the full logistic differential equation: .
Substitute : .
Substitute : .
Resolve the paradox: While per capita growth is highest near , absolute growth peaks at intermediate density () because a large number of individuals () are reproducing.
(a) At , ; at , . (b) At , ; at , . Carrying capacity is , where growth ceases.
03 The student calculates both rates correctly but incorrectly concludes that the contradiction means the logistic model is invalid near N = 0 rather than distinguishing per capita from total population growth.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
⟹ At : ⟹ At :
- Step 2
⟹ At : ⟹ At :
- Step 3
- Step 4
"The intuition is correct that competition is lowest near , so the mathematical formula fails to represent real biological populations at low densities."
CorrectThe model accurately reflects biology: at , per capita growth rate is indeed maximized because intraspecific competition is negligible, but absolute growth rate is small because very few individuals are present to reproduce.
You concluded that the model fails biologically, but the model actually works as intended. The contradiction is resolved by distinguishing per capita growth rate (individual reproductive output, which is highest near ) from absolute population growth rate (total new individuals added per unit time, which depends directly on the number of reproducing individuals ).
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly calculated the per capita growth rate at both densities.
You correctly calculated the absolute population growth rate at both densities.
You correctly stated the carrying capacity of the population.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakenone
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou conflated per capita reproductive rate with total population growth rate, leading you to believe that high individual growth potential must automatically produce a large total population increase.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Distinguish Individual Contribution from Collective Output
Absolute growth rate equals population size times per capita growth rate: .
Always multiply the individual rate by the number of individuals before evaluating the total growth of a population.
- Resolve Low-Density Growth Behavior
As , individual competition is minimal so per capita rate approaches , but total additions because the reproductive base is negligible.
Recognize that high individual fitness cannot yield large total numbers without a sufficient base of reproducing organisms.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationConnect the two computed rates using the identity .
Observe that at , individual performance is high (), but multiplying by only individuals yields a modest total addition of .
Observe that at , individual performance drops to , but multiplying by individuals yields the maximum addition of .
Conclude that the model is biologically valid: the intuition applies to individual (per capita) rate, not total rate.
(a) At , ; at , . (b) At , ; at , . Carrying capacity is . The contradiction is resolved because individual (per capita) efficiency is highest near , but absolute growth rate requires a sufficient number of reproducing individuals.
Lock it in
What is the algebraic and biological difference between and in logistic growth?
is the absolute growth rate (individuals added per unit time). is the per capita growth rate (contribution per single individual).
Similar question
A fish population follows logistic growth with and . Calculate both the per capita growth rate and the absolute population growth rate when .
Answer
Per capita rate: . Absolute rate: .
For a laboratory culture of yeast with and , find the population density where the absolute growth rate is maximized, and compute the value of at that density.
Answer
Absolute growth rate is maximized at . At this density: .
An endangered herbivore population has and . A conservationist claims: 'Because per capita birth rates are highest when the herd is tiny (), the herd will recover its total numbers faster now than when it reaches .' Evaluate this claim mathematically using .
Answer
The claim is incorrect. At , . At , . Although per capita efficiency is higher at ( vs ), the tiny breeding base means total population increase is over 25 times slower.