Resources

An isolated population of desert mice is monitored for coat color determined by alleles DD (agouti) and dd (black). After a five-year period of raptor predation, the generation-to-generation frequency of the recessive allele dd shifted from q0q_0 to q1=0.250q_1 = 0.250. Extensive mark-recapture data revealed that no individual mouse changed its coat color during its lifespan, but dark owls preyed disproportionately on light individuals. If the mean relative fitness of genotype dddd was wdd=0.400w_{dd} = 0.400 while wDD=wDd=1.000w_{DD} = w_{Dd} = 1.000, and the initial population was in Hardy-Weinberg equilibrium with q0=0.500q_0 = 0.500, reconstruct the backward calculation: determine (a) the initial gene pool genotype frequencies before selection, and (b) the precise post-selection allele frequency q1q_1 to confirm whether the observed endpoint matches theoretical generational selection on the population.

Answer and steps

Final answer

(a) Initial baseline genotype frequencies were f(DD)=p02=0.250f(DD) = p_0^2 = 0.250, f(Dd)=2p0q0=0.500f(Dd) = 2p_0q_0 = 0.500, and f(dd)=q02=0.250f(dd) = q_0^2 = 0.250; (b) Post-selection population allele frequency is q1=wDd(p0q0)+wdd(q02)wˉ=1.000(0.250)+0.400(0.250)0.250(1.000)+0.500(1.000)+0.250(0.400)=0.3500.850≈0.412q_1 = \frac{w_{Dd}(p_0q_0) + w_{dd}(q_0^2)}{\bar{w}} = \frac{1.000(0.250) + 0.400(0.250)}{0.250(1.000) + 0.500(1.000) + 0.250(0.400)} = \frac{0.350}{0.850} \approx 0.412. Because q1=0.412≠0.250q_1 = 0.412 \neq 0.250, a single generation of selection with wdd=0.400w_{dd}=0.400 accounts for only part of the multi-generational shift in the population's gene pool.

Steps

Part (a): Initial Genotype Frequencies Before Selection

Under the Hardy-Weinberg equilibrium model, the genotype frequencies in a two-allele system (DD and dd) are predicted directly from the initial allele frequencies p0p_0 and q0q_0:

  1. Calculate the dominant allele frequency (p0p_0): p0=1−q0=1−0.500=0.500p_0 = 1 - q_0 = 1 - 0.500 = 0.500
  2. Compute initial baseline genotype frequencies:

    • Homozygous dominant (DDDD): f(DD)=p02=(0.500)2=0.250f(DD) = p_0^2 = (0.500)^2 = 0.250
    • Heterozygous (DdDd): f(Dd)=2p0q0=2(0.500)(0.500)=0.500f(Dd) = 2p_0q_0 = 2(0.500)(0.500) = 0.500
    • Homozygous recessive (dddd): f(dd)=q02=(0.500)2=0.250f(dd) = q_0^2 = (0.500)^2 = 0.250

Part (b): Theoretical Post-Selection Allele Frequency (q1q_1)

Natural selection acts on individual phenotypes, altering their survival and reproductive success, which changes allele frequencies within the gene pool across generations.

  1. Determine the proportional survival of each genotype: Multiply each initial genotype frequency by its respective relative fitness (ww):

    • For DDDD: f(DD)⋅wDD=0.250⋅1.000=0.250f(DD) \cdot w_{DD} = 0.250 \cdot 1.000 = 0.250
    • For DdDd: f(Dd)⋅wDd=0.500⋅1.000=0.500f(Dd) \cdot w_{Dd} = 0.500 \cdot 1.000 = 0.500
    • For dddd: f(dd)⋅wdd=0.250⋅0.400=0.100f(dd) \cdot w_{dd} = 0.250 \cdot 0.400 = 0.100
  2. Calculate mean population fitness (wˉ\bar{w}): Sum the surviving contributions of all genotypes: wˉ=(0.250⋅1.000)+(0.500⋅1.000)+(0.250⋅0.400)=0.250+0.500+0.100=0.850\bar{w} = (0.250 \cdot 1.000) + (0.500 \cdot 1.000) + (0.250 \cdot 0.400) = 0.250 + 0.500 + 0.100 = 0.850
  3. Calculate the allele frequency of dd after one generation of selection (q1q_1): The new frequency q1q_1 is the proportion of dd alleles contributed by surviving heterozygotes (carrying one dd allele, weight 0.50.5) and surviving recessive homozygotes (carrying two dd alleles, weight 1.01.0), divided by the average fitness: q1=wDd(p0q0)+wdd(q02)wˉ=1.000(0.250)+0.400(0.250)0.850=0.250+0.1000.850=0.3500.850≈0.412q_1 = \frac{w_{Dd}(p_0q_0) + w_{dd}(q_0^2)}{\bar{w}} = \frac{1.000(0.250) + 0.400(0.250)}{0.850} = \frac{0.250 + 0.100}{0.850} = \frac{0.350}{0.850} \approx 0.412
  4. Comparison with the observed multi-year shift:

    • The theoretical frequency after a single generation of selection is q1≈0.412q_1 \approx 0.412.
    • Because 0.412≠0.2500.412 \neq 0.250, one generation of selection accounts for only part of the observed decline. Reaching q=0.250q = 0.250 requires successive rounds of selection across multiple generations within the population.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student forgets to normalize surviving genotype contributions by the mean population fitness w_bar when calculating the post-selection allele frequency.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    p0=1−0.500=0.500  ⟹  f(DD)=p02=0.250  ⟹  f(Dd)=2p0q0=0.500  ⟹  f(dd)=q02=0.250p_0 = 1 - 0.500 = 0.500 \implies f(DD) = p_0^2 = 0.250 \implies f(Dd) = 2p_0q_0 = 0.500 \implies f(dd) = q_0^2 = 0.250

  2. Step 2

    Surviving contribution of d allele=f(dd)wdd+(12)f(Dd)wDd=0.250(0.400)+0.5(0.500)(1.000)=0.100+0.250=0.350\text{Surviving contribution of } d \text{ allele} = f(dd)w_{dd} + \left(\frac{1}{2}\right)f(Dd)w_{Dd} = 0.250(0.400) + 0.5(0.500)(1.000) = 0.100 + 0.250 = 0.350

  3. Step 3

    q1=0.350q_1 = 0.350, so the theoretical value of 0.3500.350 does not match the observed 0.2500.250.

    Correct

    q1=wDd(p0q0)+wdd(q02)wˉ=0.3500.850≈0.412q_1 = \frac{w_{Dd}(p_0q_0) + w_{dd}(q_0^2)}{\bar{w}} = \frac{0.350}{0.850} \approx 0.412

    You set q1q_1 equal to the raw surviving contribution of 0.3500.350 without normalizing by the mean population fitness wˉ=0.250(1.000)+0.500(1.000)+0.250(0.400)=0.850\bar{w} = 0.250(1.000) + 0.500(1.000) + 0.250(0.400) = 0.850, which yields q1≈0.412q_1 \approx 0.412.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly used Hardy-Weinberg formulas to compute the initial baseline genotype frequencies.

You correctly assigned the relative fitness weights to homozygous recessive and heterozygous genotypes.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Missing mean fitness normalization in post-selection allele frequency

You found the numerator representing the weighted surviving gene contribution but forgot to divide by the average population fitness wˉ\bar{w}.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Treating relative gene pool survival as an absolute frequency instead of normalizing by the total surviving fraction of the population (mean fitness wˉ\bar{w}).

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Normalizing Post-Selection Frequencies
  • Allele frequencies in a gene pool must sum to 1.01.0. Because differential survival reduces the total reproducing pool, any surviving genotype contribution must be normalized by the mean population fitness: wˉ=∑fiwi\bar{w} = \sum f_i w_i.

  • Always compute wˉ=f(DD)wDD+f(Dd)wDd+f(dd)wdd\bar{w} = f(DD)w_{DD} + f(Dd)w_{Dd} + f(dd)w_{dd} first, and place it in the denominator when calculating post-selection allele frequencies.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Calculate the mean fitness of the population: wˉ=(0.250)(1.000)+(0.500)(1.000)+(0.250)(0.400)=0.250+0.500+0.100=0.850\bar{w} = (0.250)(1.000) + (0.500)(1.000) + (0.250)(0.400) = 0.250 + 0.500 + 0.100 = 0.850.

  2. Divide the surviving contribution of allele dd by wˉ\bar{w} to normalize: q1=0.3500.850≈0.412q_1 = \frac{0.350}{0.850} \approx 0.412.

  3. Compare with the observed endpoint: since q1≈0.412≠0.250q_1 \approx 0.412 \neq 0.250, one generation of selection explains only part of the multi-generational shift to 0.2500.250.

Final answer

(a) f(DD)=0.250f(DD) = 0.250, f(Dd)=0.500f(Dd) = 0.500, f(dd)=0.250f(dd) = 0.250; (b) Theoretical q1≈0.412q_1 \approx 0.412, which confirms that the observed shift to 0.2500.250 spans multiple generations rather than a single generation.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Write out the full post-selection equation q1=wDdpq+wddq2wˉq_1 = \frac{w_{Dd}pq + w_{dd}q^2}{\bar{w}} before substituting numerical values.

  • Check that post-selection allele frequencies p1p_1 and q1q_1 sum to 1.01.0 as a quick self-verification step.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student misidentifies the heterozygous genotype Dd as sharing the reduced fitness of the recessive homozygote dd rather than being fully fit.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    p0=0.500,q0=0.500  ⟹  f(DD)=(0.500)2=0.250,f(Dd)=2(0.500)(0.500)=0.500,f(dd)=(0.500)2=0.250p_0 = 0.500, q_0 = 0.500 \implies f(DD) = (0.500)^2 = 0.250, f(Dd) = 2(0.500)(0.500) = 0.500, f(dd) = (0.500)^2 = 0.250

  2. Step 2

    wˉ=0.250(1.000)+0.500(0.400)+0.250(0.400)=0.250+0.200+0.100=0.550\bar{w} = 0.250(1.000) + 0.500(0.400) + 0.250(0.400) = 0.250 + 0.200 + 0.100 = 0.550

    Correct

    wˉ=f(DD)wDD+f(Dd)wDd+f(dd)wdd=0.250(1.000)+0.500(1.000)+0.250(0.400)=0.850\bar{w} = f(DD)w_{DD} + f(Dd)w_{Dd} + f(dd)w_{dd} = 0.250(1.000) + 0.500(1.000) + 0.250(0.400) = 0.850

    You substituted wDd=0.400w_{Dd} = 0.400 instead of wDd=1.000w_{Dd} = 1.000. Because agouti is dominant, heterozygotes have the fully fit agouti phenotype (wDd=1.000w_{Dd} = 1.000).

  3. Step 3

    q1=0.100+0.5(0.200)0.550=0.2000.550=411≈0.364q_1 = \frac{0.100 + 0.5(0.200)}{0.550} = \frac{0.200}{0.550} = \frac{4}{11} \approx 0.364

    Correct

    q1=0.5⋅f(Dd)wDd+f(dd)wddwˉ=0.5(0.500)(1.000)+0.250(0.400)0.850=0.3500.850≈0.412q_1 = \frac{0.5 \cdot f(Dd)w_{Dd} + f(dd)w_{dd}}{\bar{w}} = \frac{0.5(0.500)(1.000) + 0.250(0.400)}{0.850} = \frac{0.350}{0.850} \approx 0.412

    Your formula structure for calculating post-selection allele frequency was logical, but your result was altered by using the incorrect genotype fitness for heterozygotes and incorrect mean population fitness.

  4. Step 4

    Theoretical q1≈0.364, which does not match the observed 0.250.\text{Theoretical } q_1 \approx 0.364 \text{, which does not match the observed } 0.250.

    Correct

    Theoretical q1≈0.412≠0.250, confirming that a single generation accounts for only part of the multi-year shift.\text{Theoretical } q_1 \approx 0.412 \neq 0.250\text{, confirming that a single generation accounts for only part of the multi-year shift.}

    Your qualitative conclusion that one generation does not match the observed 0.2500.250 is consistent with your work, but it relies on your altered value of q1q_1.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly calculated the baseline genotype frequencies before selection using the Hardy-Weinberg formula.

You correctly structured the calculation of post-selection allele frequency by weighting heterozygous and homozygous recessive contributions.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Genotype-Phenotype Fitness Misassignment

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated the heterozygous genotype DdDd as experiencing selection against the recessive phenotype, overlooking the problem statement that wDD=wDd=1.000w_{DD} = w_{Dd} = 1.000 due to complete dominance.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Match Fitness to Genotype Dominance
  • Under complete dominance, heterozygotes display the dominant phenotype and share the dominant relative fitness (wDd=wDD=1.000w_{Dd} = w_{DD} = 1.000).

  • Always list the given relative fitness for each genotype (DDDD, DdDd, and dddd) separately before computing the mean fitness.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Compute mean fitness: wˉ=0.250(1.000)+0.500(1.000)+0.250(0.400)=0.250+0.500+0.100=0.850\bar{w} = 0.250(1.000) + 0.500(1.000) + 0.250(0.400) = 0.250 + 0.500 + 0.100 = 0.850.

  2. Compute post-selection frequency of dd: q1=0.5(0.500)+0.1000.850=0.250+0.1000.850=0.3500.850≈0.412q_1 = \frac{0.5(0.500) + 0.100}{0.850} = \frac{0.250 + 0.100}{0.850} = \frac{0.350}{0.850} \approx 0.412.

  3. Compare: q1≈0.412>0.250q_1 \approx 0.412 > 0.250, so the observed shift to 0.2500.250 required multiple generations of selection across the population.

Final answer

(a) f(DD)=0.250f(DD) = 0.250, f(Dd)=0.500f(Dd) = 0.500, f(dd)=0.250f(dd) = 0.250; (b) theoretical post-selection q1≈0.412q_1 \approx 0.412, which does not match the observed multi-generational frequency of 0.2500.250.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review how dominance shelters recessive alleles in heterozygotes during natural selection.

  • Practice computing mean fitness wˉ\bar{w} by explicitly tabulating genotype, frequency, fitness, and survival contribution.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A population in Hardy-Weinberg equilibrium has initial allele frequencies p0=0.60p_0 = 0.60 and q0=0.40q_0 = 0.40. If the relative fitness values are wAA=1.0w_{AA} = 1.0, wAa=1.0w_{Aa} = 1.0, and waa=0.50w_{aa} = 0.50, calculate the mean population fitness wˉ\bar{w} and the new frequency q1q_1 after one generation of selection.

Answer

First, calculate initial genotype frequencies: f(AA)=0.36f(AA) = 0.36, f(Aa)=0.48f(Aa) = 0.48, f(aa)=0.16f(aa) = 0.16. Mean fitness is wˉ=0.36(1.0)+0.48(1.0)+0.16(0.50)=0.36+0.48+0.08=0.92\bar{w} = 0.36(1.0) + 0.48(1.0) + 0.16(0.50) = 0.36 + 0.48 + 0.08 = 0.92. Surviving contribution of aa is 0.5(0.48)(1.0)+0.16(0.50)=0.24+0.08=0.320.5(0.48)(1.0) + 0.16(0.50) = 0.24 + 0.08 = 0.32. Thus, q1=0.320.92≈0.348q_1 = \frac{0.32}{0.92} \approx 0.348.

02

In a plant population, alleles CRC^R and CWC^W show incomplete dominance. Baseline frequencies are f(CRCR)=0.49f(C^R C^R) = 0.49, f(CRCW)=0.42f(C^R C^W) = 0.42, and f(CWCW)=0.09f(C^W C^W) = 0.09. Herbivores avoid white flowers, leading to fitnesses wRR=0.60w_{RR} = 0.60, wRW=0.80w_{RW} = 0.80, and wWW=1.00w_{WW} = 1.00. Compute the mean population fitness wˉ\bar{w} and the allele frequency of CWC^W after selection.

Answer

Calculate surviving genotype proportions: 0.49(0.60)=0.2940.49(0.60) = 0.294, 0.42(0.80)=0.3360.42(0.80) = 0.336, 0.09(1.00)=0.0900.09(1.00) = 0.090. Mean fitness is wˉ=0.294+0.336+0.090=0.720\bar{w} = 0.294 + 0.336 + 0.090 = 0.720. Surviving contribution of CWC^W is 12(0.336)+0.090=0.168+0.090=0.258\frac{1}{2}(0.336) + 0.090 = 0.168 + 0.090 = 0.258. The new allele frequency is q1=0.2580.720=0.358q_1 = \frac{0.258}{0.720} = 0.358.

03

A lethal recessive allele bb causes complete mortality before reproduction (wbb=0w_{bb} = 0), while wBB=wBb=1.0w_{BB} = w_{Bb} = 1.0. Starting with an initial recessive allele frequency q0q_0, derive the expression for q1q_1 in terms of q0q_0 and calculate q1q_1 if q0=0.20q_0 = 0.20.

Answer

Initial genotype frequencies are p02,2p0q0,q02p_0^2, 2p_0q_0, q_0^2. Mean fitness is wˉ=p02(1)+2p0q0(1)+q02(0)=p0(p0+2q0)=(1−q0)(1+q0)=1−q02\bar{w} = p_0^2(1) + 2p_0q_0(1) + q_0^2(0) = p_0(p_0 + 2q_0) = (1 - q_0)(1 + q_0) = 1 - q_0^2. Surviving bb alleles come only from heterozygotes: p0q0=(1−q0)q0p_0q_0 = (1 - q_0)q_0. Therefore, q1=q0(1−q0)(1−q0)(1+q0)=q01+q0q_1 = \frac{q_0(1 - q_0)}{(1 - q_0)(1 + q_0)} = \frac{q_0}{1 + q_0}. For q0=0.20q_0 = 0.20, q1=0.201.20=16≈0.167q_1 = \frac{0.20}{1.20} = \frac{1}{6} \approx 0.167.

Loading workspace…