Resources

In a marine intertidal gastropod, shell thickness is controlled by two codominant alleles: T1T_1 (thin shell) and T2T_2 (thick shell). In a wave-exposed estuary without crab predators, T1T1T_1T_1 has a higher growth rate and produces 120120 viable offspring per adult on average, while T1T2T_1T_2 produces 9696 offspring and T2T2T_2T_2 produces 6060 offspring. A student attempts to calculate the relative fitnesses and selection coefficients, but mistakenly sets the least fit genotype (T2T2T_2T_2) as the reference (w22=1.0w_{22} = 1.0) and calculates selection coefficients using the formula s=w−1s = w - 1, resulting in positive coefficients. (a) State the correct standard evolutionary convention for defining relative fitness (ww) and selection coefficient (ss). (b) Calculate the correct normalized relative fitness values (w11w_{11}, w12w_{12}, w22w_{22}) and selection coefficients (s11s_{11}, s12s_{12}, s22s_{22}) relative to the fittest genotype. Express all values to three significant figures.

Answer and steps

Final answer

(a) The fittest genotype is assigned relative fitness w=1.00w = 1.00, and selection coefficients are defined as s=1−ws = 1 - w (where 0≤s≤10 \le s \le 1); (b) w11=1.00w_{11} = 1.00 (s11=0.00s_{11} = 0.00), w12=0.800w_{12} = 0.800 (s12=0.200s_{12} = 0.200), and w22=0.500w_{22} = 0.500 (s22=0.500s_{22} = 0.500).

Steps

01

Identify Absolute Fitness Values

Part (a): Standard Evolutionary Conventions for Fitness and Selection

In population genetics and evolutionary biology, fitness values are standardized relative to the most successful genotype:

  1. Relative Fitness (ww):
    • Absolute fitness (WW) is the raw reproductive output (average number of surviving offspring produced per individual of a given genotype).
    • By standard convention, the genotype with the highest absolute fitness (Wmax⁡W_{\max}) is assigned a relative fitness of w=1.00w = 1.00 (or 11).
    • For any genotype ii, relative fitness is computed by scaling against this maximum: wi=WiWmax⁡w_i = \frac{W_i}{W_{\max}}
  2. Selection Coefficient (ss):
    • The selection coefficient measures the proportional reduction in reproductive success (the intensity of natural selection acting against a genotype) compared to the optimal genotype.
    • It is defined as: si=1−wis_i = 1 - w_i
    • Under standard directional or stabilizing selection against less fit genotypes, 0≤s≤10 \le s \le 1. A value of s=0s = 0 indicates no selection against the genotype (maximum fitness), while s=1s = 1 denotes a lethal or sterile genotype.

Common Pitfall: Setting the least fit genotype to w=1.0w = 1.0 and writing s=w−1s = w - 1 produces positive values that represent relative advantages rather than selection against a genotype, violating standard population genetic models (such as the standard selection equations for allele frequency changes Δp\Delta p).


Part (b): Calculating Normalized Fitness and Selection Coefficients

From the data provided:

  • Genotype T1T1T_1T_1: W11=120 offspringW_{11} = 120\text{ offspring}
  • Genotype T1T2T_1T_2: W12=96 offspringW_{12} = 96\text{ offspring}
  • Genotype T2T2T_2T_2: W22=60 offspringW_{22} = 60\text{ offspring}

The fittest genotype is T1T1T_1T_1, so Wmax⁡=W11=120W_{\max} = W_{11} = 120.

02

Compute Relative Fitness (ww)

Divide each absolute fitness by Wmax⁡=120W_{\max} = 120:

  • For T1T1T_1T_1: w11=120120=1.00w_{11} = \frac{120}{120} = 1.00
  • For T1T2T_1T_2: w12=96120=0.800w_{12} = \frac{96}{120} = 0.800
  • For T2T2T_2T_2: w22=60120=0.500w_{22} = \frac{60}{120} = 0.500
03

Compute Selection Coefficients (ss)

Use s=1−ws = 1 - w:

  • For T1T1T_1T_1: s11=1−1.00=0.00s_{11} = 1 - 1.00 = 0.00
  • For T1T2T_1T_2: s12=1−0.800=0.200s_{12} = 1 - 0.800 = 0.200
  • For T2T2T_2T_2: s22=1−0.500=0.500s_{22} = 1 - 0.500 = 0.500

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student normalizes relative fitness by dividing by the mean or sum of absolute fitnesses instead of setting the fittest genotype to 1.0.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Relative fitness ww is defined by dividing absolute fitness by the fittest genotype so that the maximum w=1.0w = 1.0. The selection coefficient is defined as s=1−ws = 1 - w.

  2. Step 2

    Total offspring $= 120 + 96 + 60 = 276   ⟹  \implies w_{11} = 120 / 276 = 0.435   ⟹  \implies w_{12} = 96 / 276 = 0.348   ⟹  \implies w_{22} = 60 / 276 = 0.217_

    Correct

    w11=120120=1.00  ⟹  w12=96120=0.800  ⟹  w22=60120=0.500w_{11} = \frac{120}{120} = 1.00 \implies w_{12} = \frac{96}{120} = 0.800 \implies w_{22} = \frac{60}{120} = 0.500

    You normalized by dividing each absolute fitness by the total sum of offspring (276276), treating fitness like a frequency proportion. Relative fitness must be scaled by dividing by the fittest genotype's output (Wmax⁡=120W_{\max} = 120), setting the reference genotype to w=1.00w = 1.00.

  3. Step 3

    s_{11} = 1 - 0.435 = 0.565   ⟹  \implies s_{12} = 1 - 0.348 = 0.652   ⟹  \implies s_{22} = 1 - 0.217 = 0.783_

    Correct

    s11=1−1.00=0.00  ⟹  s12=1−0.800=0.200  ⟹  s22=1−0.500=0.500s_{11} = 1 - 1.00 = 0.00 \implies s_{12} = 1 - 0.800 = 0.200 \implies s_{22} = 1 - 0.500 = 0.500

    You correctly applied the formula s=1−ws = 1 - w, but your numerical values were affected by the incorrect relative fitness values from the previous step.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly defined relative fitness as being scaled to a maximum of 1.01.0 for the most fit genotype.

You stated and applied the correct relationship between the selection coefficient and relative fitness, s=1−ws = 1 - w.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Sum-normalization instead of maximum-normalization

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You confused normalizing relative fitness with calculating relative proportions or frequencies; relative fitness scales against the single maximum reproductive value (Wmax⁡W_{\max}), not the sum of all absolute fitness values.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Check the Reference Benchmark
  • Relative fitness wi=WiWmax⁡w_i = \frac{W_i}{W_{\max}}, where Wmax⁡W_{\max} is the absolute fitness of the most successful genotype.

  • Identify the genotype with the highest offspring count and use its value alone as the denominator.

Verify the Benchmark Fitness Value
  • The fittest genotype must always have a relative fitness of exactly w=1.00w = 1.00 and a selection coefficient of s=0.00s = 0.00.

  • Check that your calculated ww for the top performer equals 1.001.00 before calculating selection coefficients.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Identify the absolute fitness values: W11=120W_{11} = 120, W12=96W_{12} = 96, and W22=60W_{22} = 60. The maximum absolute fitness is Wmax⁡=120W_{\max} = 120.

  2. Divide each genotype's absolute fitness by Wmax⁡=120W_{\max} = 120: w11=120120=1.00w_{11} = \frac{120}{120} = 1.00, w12=96120=0.800w_{12} = \frac{96}{120} = 0.800, and w22=60120=0.500w_{22} = \frac{60}{120} = 0.500.

  3. Calculate each selection coefficient using si=1−wis_i = 1 - w_i: s11=1−1.00=0.00s_{11} = 1 - 1.00 = 0.00, s12=1−0.800=0.200s_{12} = 1 - 0.800 = 0.200, and s22=1−0.500=0.500s_{22} = 1 - 0.500 = 0.500.

Final answer

w11=1.00w_{11} = 1.00 (s11=0.00s_{11} = 0.00), w12=0.800w_{12} = 0.800 (s12=0.200s_{12} = 0.200), and w22=0.500w_{22} = 0.500 (s22=0.500s_{22} = 0.500)

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Double-check that your reference genotype always evaluates to w=1.00w = 1.00 and s=0.00s = 0.00.

  • Practice calculating relative fitness in problems with varying absolute survival rates and fecundities.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student calculates relative fitnesses correctly but confuses the definition of selection coefficient as s = w - 1 or forgets to subtract from 1, yielding negative values.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Relative fitness ww sets the fittest genotype to 1.01.0 by dividing each by the maximum absolute fitness. Selection coefficient is s=w−1s = w - 1.

    Correct

    Relative fitness sets the fittest genotype to w=1.00w = 1.00 (wi=Wi/Wmax⁡w_i = W_i / W_{\max}), and the selection coefficient is defined as s=1−ws = 1 - w (0≤s≤10 \le s \le 1).

    You defined relative fitness correctly, but the selection coefficient measures the proportional reduction in fitness or selection acting against a genotype, so it is defined as s=1−ws = 1 - w, not w−1w - 1.

  2. Step 2

    Fittest genotype is T1T1T_1T_1 with 120120 offspring.   ⟹  w11=120/120=1.00  ⟹  w12=96/120=0.800  ⟹  w22=60/120=0.500\implies w_{11} = 120/120 = 1.00 \implies w_{12} = 96/120 = 0.800 \implies w_{22} = 60/120 = 0.500

  3. Step 3

    s11=1.00−1=0.00  ⟹  s12=0.800−1=−0.200  ⟹  s22=0.500−1=−0.500s_{11} = 1.00 - 1 = 0.00 \implies s_{12} = 0.800 - 1 = -0.200 \implies s_{22} = 0.500 - 1 = -0.500

    Correct

    s11=1−1.00=0.00s_{11} = 1 - 1.00 = 0.00, s12=1−0.800=0.200s_{12} = 1 - 0.800 = 0.200, s22=1−0.500=0.500s_{22} = 1 - 0.500 = 0.500

    Your arithmetic followed your stated formula s=w−1s = w - 1, but because the standard definition is s=1−ws = 1 - w, the selection coefficients should be positive values measuring selection against each genotype.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified the most fit genotype (T1T1T_1T_1) with absolute fitness Wmax⁡=120W_{\max} = 120.

You accurately normalized all genotypes to find relative fitness values: w11=1.00w_{11} = 1.00, w12=0.800w_{12} = 0.800, and w22=0.500w_{22} = 0.500.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Formula inversion in selection coefficient definition

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You reversed the terms in the selection coefficient formula as s=w−1s = w - 1 instead of s=1−ws = 1 - w. In evolutionary genetics, selection coefficient (ss) quantifies selection against a phenotype relative to the optimal benchmark (w=1.0w = 1.0), so s=1−ws = 1 - w and must fall between 00 and 11.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Selection Coefficient Boundary Check
  • For standard selection against less fit genotypes, 0≤s≤10 \le s \le 1.

  • Always verify that ss is non-negative when computed from relative fitness w≤1.0w \le 1.0 by evaluating s=1−ws = 1 - w.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Apply s=1−ws = 1 - w to genotype T1T1T_1T_1: s11=1−1.00=0.00s_{11} = 1 - 1.00 = 0.00.

  2. Apply s=1−ws = 1 - w to genotype T1T2T_1T_2: s12=1−0.800=0.200s_{12} = 1 - 0.800 = 0.200.

  3. Apply s=1−ws = 1 - w to genotype T2T2T_2T_2: s22=1−0.500=0.500s_{22} = 1 - 0.500 = 0.500.

Final answer

(a) wmax⁡=1.00w_{\max} = 1.00 and s=1−ws = 1 - w; (b) w11=1.00w_{11} = 1.00 (s11=0.00s_{11} = 0.00), w12=0.800w_{12} = 0.800 (s12=0.200s_{12} = 0.200), and w22=0.500w_{22} = 0.500 (s22=0.500s_{22} = 0.500).

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Remember that selection coefficient ss represents reproductive disadvantage, so subtract relative fitness from 1 (s=1−ws = 1 - w).

  • Check that your calculated ss values are between 0.000.00 and 1.001.00, where s=0s = 0 means no selection against the genotype and s=1s = 1 means complete lethality or sterility.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student confuses the heterozygote or another genotype as the reference, dividing all values by the intermediate heterozygote fitness.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    Relative fitness ww divides each absolute fitness by a reference genotype so w=1.0w = 1.0. Selection coefficient is defined as s=1−ws = 1 - w.

    Correct

    The fittest genotype (Wmax⁡W_{\max}) is assigned relative fitness w=1.00w = 1.00 (wi=Wi/Wmax⁡w_i = W_i / W_{\max}), and the selection coefficient is defined as s=1−ws = 1 - w, measuring selection against a genotype (0≤s≤10 \le s \le 1).

    You correctly stated the relationship s=1−ws = 1 - w, but you did not specify that the reference genotype must be the one with the highest absolute fitness (Wmax⁡W_{\max}).

  2. Step 2

    Reference genotype T1T2T_1T_2 has 9696 offspring.   ⟹  w11=120/96=1.25  ⟹  w12=96/96=1.00  ⟹  w22=60/96=0.625\implies w_{11} = 120 / 96 = 1.25 \implies w_{12} = 96 / 96 = 1.00 \implies w_{22} = 60 / 96 = 0.625

    Correct

    Wmax⁡=W11=120  ⟹  w11=120120=1.00W_{\max} = W_{11} = 120 \implies w_{11} = \frac{120}{120} = 1.00, w12=96120=0.800w_{12} = \frac{96}{120} = 0.800, w22=60120=0.500w_{22} = \frac{60}{120} = 0.500

    You normalized by the heterozygote T1T2T_1T_2 (9696 offspring). Because T1T1T_1T_1 produces the most offspring (120120), the denominator must be 120120.

  3. Step 3

    s11=1−1.25=−0.250  ⟹  s12=1−1.00=0.00  ⟹  s22=1−0.625=0.375s_{11} = 1 - 1.25 = -0.250 \implies s_{12} = 1 - 1.00 = 0.00 \implies s_{22} = 1 - 0.625 = 0.375

    Correct

    s11=1−1.00=0.00  ⟹  s12=1−0.800=0.200  ⟹  s22=1−0.500=0.500s_{11} = 1 - 1.00 = 0.00 \implies s_{12} = 1 - 0.800 = 0.200 \implies s_{22} = 1 - 0.500 = 0.500

    You applied the formula s=1−ws = 1 - w consistently, but your resulting values were thrown off by the incorrect fitness values. Under the standard convention, ss cannot be negative.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly used the formula s=1−ws = 1 - w to relate relative fitness to the selection coefficient.

You performed the division and subtraction arithmetic accurately based on your chosen reference.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Incorrect reference genotype selected for relative fitness normalization

You selected the intermediate heterozygote (T1T2T_1T_2) as the baseline denominator rather than locating the maximum reproductive output (T1T1T_1T_1).

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated the reference genotype as an arbitrary choice rather than realizing that standard evolutionary models strictly require normalizing by Wmax⁡W_{\max} so that relative fitness never exceeds 1.001.00 and selection coefficients remain between 00 and 11.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Rule: Identify $W_{\max}$ first
  • Relative fitness is defined as wi=WiWmax⁡w_i = \frac{W_i}{W_{\max}}, where Wmax⁡=max⁡(W11,W12,W22)W_{\max} = \max(W_{11}, W_{12}, W_{22}).

  • Scan all absolute fitness values and set the highest value as the denominator for every genotype.

Sanity Check: Range of $w$ and $s$
  • For all genotypes under standard convention, 0≤wi≤1.000 \le w_i \le 1.00 and 0≤si≤1.000 \le s_i \le 1.00.

  • If you obtain any w>1.00w > 1.00 or s<0s < 0, pause immediately: you have chosen a sub-optimal genotype as your reference.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Find the genotype with the highest absolute fitness: W11=120W_{11} = 120, W12=96W_{12} = 96, and W22=60W_{22} = 60, so Wmax⁡=W11=120W_{\max} = W_{11} = 120.

  2. Compute relative fitnesses by dividing each absolute fitness by 120120: w11=120120=1.00w_{11} = \frac{120}{120} = 1.00, w12=96120=0.800w_{12} = \frac{96}{120} = 0.800, and w22=60120=0.500w_{22} = \frac{60}{120} = 0.500.

  3. Compute selection coefficients using s=1−ws = 1 - w: s11=1−1.00=0.00s_{11} = 1 - 1.00 = 0.00, s12=1−0.800=0.200s_{12} = 1 - 0.800 = 0.200, and s22=1−0.500=0.500s_{22} = 1 - 0.500 = 0.500.

Final answer

(a) Relative fitness w=1.00w = 1.00 is assigned to the fittest genotype (Wmax⁡W_{\max}), and the selection coefficient is s=1−ws = 1 - w (0≤s≤10 \le s \le 1). (b) w11=1.00w_{11} = 1.00 (s11=0.00s_{11} = 0.00), w12=0.800w_{12} = 0.800 (s12=0.200s_{12} = 0.200), and w22=0.500w_{22} = 0.500 (s22=0.500s_{22} = 0.500).

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the standard convention that relative fitness sets the most successful genotype to w=1.00w = 1.00.

  • Practice checking that all selection coefficients lie within the valid range 0≤s≤10 \le s \le 1 to catch reference errors early.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

In a population of pocket mice, the average number of surviving offspring per adult is 150150 for genotype DDDD, 150150 for DdDd, and 9090 for dddd. Calculate the relative fitness (ww) and selection coefficient (ss) for each genotype.

Answer

wDD=1.00w_{DD} = 1.00 (sDD=0.00s_{DD} = 0.00), wDd=1.00w_{Dd} = 1.00 (sDd=0.00s_{Dd} = 0.00), and wdd=90150=0.600w_{dd} = \frac{90}{150} = 0.600 (sdd=1−0.600=0.400s_{dd} = 1 - 0.600 = 0.400).

02

An annual plant species has three flower-color morphs with average seed productions of 400400 (white), 320320 (pink), and 240240 (red). (a) Determine ww and ss for each morph under standard evolutionary conventions. (b) Explain what an ss value of 0.4000.400 signifies biologically for the red morph.

Answer

(a) Wmax⁡=400W_{\max} = 400. White: w=1.00w = 1.00, s=0.00s = 0.00. Pink: w=320400=0.800w = \frac{320}{400} = 0.800, s=0.200s = 0.200. Red: w=240400=0.600w = \frac{240}{400} = 0.600, s=0.400s = 0.400. (b) An ss value of 0.4000.400 indicates a 40%40\% reduction in reproductive fitness compared to the most successful (white) morph due to natural selection acting against it.

03

In a drought environment, three genotypes at a water-retention locus have survival rates to maturity of 80%80\% (A1A1A_1A_1), 60%60\% (A1A2A_1A_2), and 20%20\% (A2A2A_2A_2). Surviving adults produce an average of 55, 44, and 22 viable seeds, respectively. Compute the absolute fitness (W=survival×fecundityW = \text{survival} \times \text{fecundity}), normalized relative fitness (ww), and selection coefficient (ss) for all three genotypes.

Answer

Absolute fitnesses: W11=0.80×5=4.0W_{11} = 0.80 \times 5 = 4.0; W12=0.60×4=2.4W_{12} = 0.60 \times 4 = 2.4; W22=0.20×2=0.4W_{22} = 0.20 \times 2 = 0.4. The maximum is W11=4.0W_{11} = 4.0. Normalized fitnesses: w11=4.04.0=1.00w_{11} = \frac{4.0}{4.0} = 1.00, w12=2.44.0=0.600w_{12} = \frac{2.4}{4.0} = 0.600, w22=0.44.0=0.100w_{22} = \frac{0.4}{4.0} = 0.100. Selection coefficients: s11=0.00s_{11} = 0.00, s12=1−0.600=0.400s_{12} = 1 - 0.600 = 0.400, and s22=1−0.100=0.900s_{22} = 1 - 0.100 = 0.900.

Loading workspace…