Resources
An evolutionary biologist examines five extant vertebrate species (, , , , and ) for five morphological character states: vertebral column, hinged jaws, four walking limbs, amniotic egg, and mammary glands. Species exhibits only the vertebral column. Species possesses a vertebral column, hinged jaws, four walking limbs, and an amniotic egg, but lacks mammary glands. Species possesses all five derived characters. Species possesses a vertebral column and hinged jaws, but lacks four walking limbs, amniotic egg, and mammary glands. Species serves as the outgroup possessing none of the five derived characters ( derived traits). Under the principle of maximum parsimony, determine: (1) which two species share the most recent common ancestor (MRCA), and (2) how many evolutionary transitions (character changes) define the lineage leading from the MRCA of all five species to Species .
Answer and steps
Final answer
(1) Species and Species share the most recent common ancestor; (2) Exactly evolutionary transitions define the lineage leading from the ancestral root to Species .
Steps
Construct the Character Matrix
In cladistics, shared derived traits (synapomorphies) are used to infer evolutionary relationships. Let us represent the presence () or absence () of each derived character for the five species:
Determine Relationships Using Parsimony
Under the principle of maximum parsimony, the simplest evolutionary path requiring the fewest character transitions is preferred.
Because each subsequent species contains all derived traits of the previous species plus new ones, the traits form a strictly nested hierarchy:
- Vertebral column evolved after species diverged, uniting the clade .
- Hinged jaws evolved next, separating species and uniting the clade .
- Four walking limbs and amniotic egg evolved next, separating species and uniting the clade .
- Mammary glands evolved exclusively along the terminal branch leading to species .
Therefore, the cladogram topology is:
Identify the Species Sharing the Most Recent Common Ancestor
Two taxa share the most recent common ancestor (MRCA) when they form a sister group (the most closely related pair on the tree, separated from each other by the fewest nodes).
- Species and Species are sister taxa, branching together from the node that defined the clade possessing four walking limbs and amniotic eggs.
- Thus, Species and Species share the most recent common ancestor among any pair in this group.
Count Transitions to Species
Starting at the root (the MRCA of all five species, which possessed the ancestral state of derived traits):
- Transition : Evolution of a vertebral column
- Transition : Evolution of hinged jaws
- Transition : Evolution of four walking limbs
- Transition : Evolution of an amniotic egg
- Transition : Evolution of mammary glands
Tracing the lineage directly from the root to Species requires evolutionary transitions.
Typical errors
01 The student misidentifies the most closely related pair by confusing the outgroup with an ingroup sister taxon or selecting species that share the fewest changes from the ancestral state.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
A has 1 derived trait and E has 0 derived traits ⟹ A and E differ by only 1 character ⟹ Species A and Species E share the most recent common ancestor
CorrectSpecies and Species share the most recent common ancestor because they share the greatest number of derived characters (synapomorphies) and form sister taxa on the cladogram.
You determined relatedness based on the smallest character difference from the outgroup rather than shared derived characters (synapomorphies). Because Species diverged at the very base of the tree before any derived traits evolved, the common ancestor of and is the basal root of all five species, making it the oldest (least recent) common ancestor, not the most recent.
- Step 2
Traits acquired to reach C: vertebral column, hinged jaws, four limbs, amniotic egg, mammary glands ⟹ Total transitions = 5
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly traced all five derived character states that evolved along the lineage leading to Species .
You accurately calculated the total number of character transitions from the ancestral state to Species as .
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou assumed that two species differing by the fewest derived characters must share the most recent common ancestor, overlooking that cladograms are constructed from shared derived traits (synapomorphies). The node linking Species and Species is the deepest root node of the tree, whereas Species and Species branch together at the most recent, most derived internal node.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Identifying the Most Recent Common Ancestor (MRCA)
In a rooted cladogram, the pair of species that share the most recent common ancestor are sister taxa connected by the node located furthest from the root (closest to the branch tips).
Look for taxa grouped by the largest set of shared derived characters (synapomorphies), rather than pairs sharing primitive ancestral states or having small absolute trait counts.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationIdentify the nested synapomorphies: all ingroup species share a vertebral column; share hinged jaws; share four walking limbs and an amniotic egg.
Because Species and Species share four derived traits not found in or , they branch from the most terminal shared node as sister taxa.
Conclude that Species and Species share the most recent common ancestor.
(1) Species and Species share the most recent common ancestor; (2) Exactly evolutionary transitions define the lineage leading from the MRCA of all five species to Species .
02 The student counts only the transitions that are unique (autapomorphic) to Species C rather than the total transitions from the MRCA of all five species.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
Shared derived characters between and : vertebral column, hinged jaws, four limbs, amniotic egg Species and share the most recent common ancestor
- Step 2
Only mammary glands are unique to Species after diverging from Transitions to
CorrectLineage from the MRCA of all five species (root) to Species accumulated transitions: vertebral column, hinged jaws, four walking limbs, amniotic egg, and mammary glands Transitions .
The question asked for the transitions along the lineage leading from the MRCA of all five species (the root of the tree) to Species , not from the MRCA of Species and . All derived traits accumulated along this full lineage from the root.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly identified the shared derived characters between Species and Species .
You correctly concluded that Species and Species share the most recent common ancestor.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou counted only the single autapomorphic transition on the terminal branch leading to Species instead of all transitions from the root MRCA.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisConfusing the starting reference point: counting transitions from the immediate sister-group node (the MRCA of and ) rather than from the ancestral root representing the common ancestor of all five taxa.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Identify the Starting Point
When a question specifies the 'MRCA of all species', trace from the basal root node containing derived traits.
Check whether the starting node is the tree's basal root or an internal branching node before counting transitions.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationLocate the ancestral root representing the MRCA of all five species, which exhibits derived traits.
Trace the complete path from this root node up to Species , counting each trait gain: vertebral column (), hinged jaws (), four walking limbs (), amniotic egg (), and mammary glands ().
Sum all transitions along this path: .
(1) Species and Species share the most recent common ancestor; (2) Exactly evolutionary transitions define the lineage leading from the MRCA of all five species to Species .
Lock it in
What determines whether two species share a 'more recent' common ancestor on a rooted cladogram?
The node connecting them is closer to the branch tips (representing a more recent divergence), identified by shared derived characters (synapomorphies).
Similar question
Four species (, , , and ) are analyzed using an outgroup ( derived traits). Species has traits 1 and 2. Species has traits 1, 2, and 3. Species has traits 1, 2, 3, and 4. Species has trait 1 only. Which two extant species share the most recent common ancestor?
Answer
Species and Species share the most recent common ancestor. Key steps: Trait 1 unites ; trait 2 unites ; trait 3 unites into the most derived sister clade before trait 4 arises in alone.
In a phylogenetic analysis of six bird species, Species 1 and Species 2 share unique derived traits, whereas Species 1 and the ancestral outgroup share derived traits but look almost identical in body size. Explain which pair (Species 1 & 2 vs. Species 1 & Outgroup) shared a common ancestor more recently.
Answer
Species 1 and Species 2 shared a common ancestor more recently. Key steps: Phenotypic resemblance due to ancestral traits (symplesiomorphy) does not indicate recent divergence. The synapomorphies shared exclusively by Species 1 and 2 place their common ancestral node much higher (more recent in time) on the phylogenetic tree than the basal root shared with the outgroup.
A researcher constructs a character matrix for taxa with an outgroup : , , , , and . (a) Identify the sister taxon to species . (b) How many total character state changes occur on the lineage leading from the MRCA of the entire clade to species ?
Answer
(a) Species is the sister taxon to Species , as they share the most derived internal node defined by traits 1, 2, and 3. (b) Exactly character state changes define the lineage from the root to species (acquisition of traits 1, 2, and 3).