Resources

According to the Equilibrium Theory of Island Biogeography, the rate of colonization (λ\lambda) of an isolated habitat patch by new bird species decreases linearly with increasing species richness (SS) present on the patch: λ(S)=I(1−SP)\lambda(S) = I \left(1 - \frac{S}{P}\right), where II is the maximum immigration rate and P=120P = 120 is the regional mainland species pool. Conversely, the local extinction rate (μ\mu) increases linearly with species richness: μ(S)=EA⋅S\mu(S) = \frac{E}{A} \cdot S, where AA represents patch area in square kilometers and EE is the baseline per-species extinction coefficient (E=0.050 yr−1E = 0.050\text{ yr}^{-1}). Anthropogenic highway expansion progressively fragments a continuous nature reserve into an extreme remnant micro-fragment. Evaluate the asymptotic theoretical limit of equilibrium species richness, S∗S^*, as the fragment area AA approaches zero (A→0+A \to 0^+), and determine the minimum fragment area Amin⁡A_{\min} (in km2\text{km}^2) required to sustain an equilibrium community of at least S∗=40S^* = 40 species if the patch isolation dictates a maximum immigration rate of I=2.0 species/yrI = 2.0\text{ species/yr}.

Answer and steps

Final answer

lim⁡A→0+S∗=0 species; Amin⁡=1.50 km2\lim_{A \to 0^+} S^* = 0\text{ species};\ A_{\min} = 1.50\text{ km}^2

Steps

01

Derive the Equilibrium Species Richness (S∗S^*)

According to MacArthur and Wilson's Equilibrium Theory of Island Biogeography, dynamic equilibrium occurs when the colonization rate (λ\lambda) equals the local extinction rate (μ\mu):

λ(S∗)=μ(S∗)\lambda(S^*) = \mu(S^*)

Substitute the provided rate functions into the equilibrium condition:

I(1−S∗P)=EAS∗I \left(1 - \frac{S^*}{P}\right) = \frac{E}{A} S^*

Expand the left-hand side and collect all terms containing S∗S^* on one side:

I−IPS∗=EAS∗I - \frac{I}{P} S^* = \frac{E}{A} S^*

I=S∗(EA+IP)I = S^* \left(\frac{E}{A} + \frac{I}{P}\right)

Solving for S∗S^* yields:

S∗=IEA+IP=I⋅A⋅PE⋅P+I⋅AS^* = \frac{I}{\frac{E}{A} + \frac{I}{P}} = \frac{I \cdot A \cdot P}{E \cdot P + I \cdot A}


02

Evaluate the Asymptotic Limit as Fragment Area Approaches Zero (A→0+A \to 0^+)

To assess the impact of extreme habitat fragmentation:

lim⁡A→0+S∗=lim⁡A→0+I⋅A⋅PE⋅P+I⋅A\lim_{A \to 0^+} S^* = \lim_{A \to 0^+} \frac{I \cdot A \cdot P}{E \cdot P + I \cdot A}

As A→0+A \to 0^+, the numerator approaches 00, while the denominator approaches the non-zero constant E⋅PE \cdot P (0.050×120=6.0 yr−10.050 \times 120 = 6.0\text{ yr}^{-1}):

lim⁡A→0+S∗=0E⋅P=0 species\lim_{A \to 0^+} S^* = \frac{0}{E \cdot P} = 0\text{ species}

Ecological interpretation: As a habitat fragment shrinks to a micro-scale remnant, extinction rates approach infinity (μ→∞\mu \to \infty), meaning no populations can persist long enough to maintain a resident community.


03

Calculate the Minimum Fragment Area (Amin⁡A_{\min}) for S∗=40S^* = 40

Given the parameter values:

  • Mainland species pool, P=120P = 120
  • Maximum immigration rate, I=2.0 species/yrI = 2.0\text{ species/yr}
  • Extinction coefficient, E=0.050 yr−1E = 0.050\text{ yr}^{-1}
  • Desired equilibrium richness, S∗=40 speciesS^* = 40\text{ species}

First, evaluate the immigration rate at S∗=40S^* = 40:

λ(40)=2.0(1−40120)=2.0(1−13)=2.0⋅23=43 species/yr\lambda(40) = 2.0 \left(1 - \frac{40}{120}\right) = 2.0 \left(1 - \frac{1}{3}\right) = 2.0 \cdot \frac{2}{3} = \frac{4}{3}\text{ species/yr}

At equilibrium, the extinction rate must equal this immigration rate:

μ(40)=λ(40)\mu(40) = \lambda(40)

EAmin⁡⋅S∗=43\frac{E}{A_{\min}} \cdot S^* = \frac{4}{3}

Substitute E=0.050E = 0.050 and S∗=40S^* = 40:

0.050⋅40Amin⁡=43\frac{0.050 \cdot 40}{A_{\min}} = \frac{4}{3}

2.0Amin⁡=43\frac{2.0}{A_{\min}} = \frac{4}{3}

Cross-multiply to solve for Amin⁡A_{\min}:

4⋅Amin⁡=6.0  ⟹  Amin⁡=6.04=1.50 km24 \cdot A_{\min} = 6.0 \implies A_{\min} = \frac{6.0}{4} = 1.50\text{ km}^2

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student misinterprets the limit as A approaches 0 by confusing area A with species pool P or assuming immigration alone sustains the regional baseline P.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    λ(S)=μ(S)  ⟹  I(1−SP)=(EA)S\lambda(S) = \mu(S) \implies I\left(1 - \frac{S}{P}\right) = \left(\frac{E}{A}\right)S

  2. Step 2

    When fragment area shrinks to zero, colonization rate is maximum so S∗S^* approaches PP. As A→0+A \to 0^+, S∗=120 speciesS^* = 120\text{ species}

    Correct

    S∗=I⋅A⋅PE⋅P+I⋅A  ⟹  lim⁡A→0+S∗=0 speciesS^* = \frac{I \cdot A \cdot P}{E \cdot P + I \cdot A} \implies \lim_{A \to 0^+} S^* = 0\text{ species}

    As fragment area A→0+A \to 0^+, the extinction coefficient term EA→∞\frac{E}{A} \to \infty, driving local extinction to infinity for any resident population. Therefore, the equilibrium species richness approaches 00, not the mainland pool PP.

  3. Step 3

    2.0(1−40120)=(0.050A)(40)  ⟹  2.0(23)=2.0A  ⟹  43=2.0A  ⟹  A=1.5 km22.0\left(1 - \frac{40}{120}\right) = \left(\frac{0.050}{A}\right)(40) \implies 2.0\left(\frac{2}{3}\right) = \frac{2.0}{A} \implies \frac{4}{3} = \frac{2.0}{A} \implies A = 1.5\text{ km}^2

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly balanced the colonization and extinction rate equations at equilibrium.

You accurately substituted the numerical values and solved for Amin⁡=1.5 km2A_{\min} = 1.5\text{ km}^2.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Extinction-rate divergence misconception

You reasoned qualitatively about immigration while neglecting that the extinction rate diverges to infinity as patch area shrinks to zero.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

In the MacArthur-Wilson framework, patch area directly governs extinction rate via μ(S)=EAS\mu(S) = \frac{E}{A}S. As A→0+A \to 0^+, extinction becomes instantaneous (μ→∞\mu \to \infty), overwhelming immigration regardless of how high colonization is. Solving algebraically for S∗=IEA+IPS^* = \frac{I}{\frac{E}{A} + \frac{I}{P}} shows that the denominator tends to infinity, driving S∗→0S^* \to 0.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Check Extinction Sensitivity to Area
  • In island biogeography models, extinction rate is inversely proportional to patch area: lim⁡A→0+μ(S)=∞\lim_{A \to 0^+} \mu(S) = \infty for any S>0S > 0.

  • Always express S∗S^* explicitly as a function of AA before taking the limit as area approaches zero.

Evaluate Rational Limits Explicitly
  • For S∗(A)=I⋅A⋅PE⋅P+I⋅AS^*(A) = \frac{I \cdot A \cdot P}{E \cdot P + I \cdot A}, evaluate both numerator and denominator at A=0A = 0.

  • Check whether the numerator approaches 00 while the denominator remains non-zero (E⋅P>0E \cdot P > 0).

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Expand and rearrange to isolate S∗S^*: I=S∗(EA+IP)I = S^*\left(\frac{E}{A} + \frac{I}{P}\right).

  2. Solve explicitly for S∗S^*: S∗=IEA+IP=I⋅A⋅PE⋅P+I⋅AS^* = \frac{I}{\frac{E}{A} + \frac{I}{P}} = \frac{I \cdot A \cdot P}{E \cdot P + I \cdot A}.

  3. Take the limit as A→0+A \to 0^+: lim⁡A→0+S∗=I⋅0⋅PE⋅P+0=0E⋅P=0 species\lim_{A \to 0^+} S^* = \frac{I \cdot 0 \cdot P}{E \cdot P + 0} = \frac{0}{E \cdot P} = 0\text{ species}.

Final answer

lim⁡A→0+S∗=0 species; Amin⁡=1.50 km2\lim_{A \to 0^+} S^* = 0\text{ species};\ A_{\min} = 1.50\text{ km}^2

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Practice deriving explicit algebraic formulas for equilibrium variables before taking asymptotic limits.

  • Review the ecological interpretation of island biogeography: smaller areas support smaller populations, which drastically elevates extinction risk.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student forgets to divide the species richness S by the mainland pool P in the colonization term, writing 1 - S instead of 1 - S/P.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    λ(S)=μ(S)  ⟹  I(1−SP)=(E/A)S  ⟹  S∗=IE/A+I/P\lambda(S) = \mu(S) \implies I\left(1 - \frac{S}{P}\right) = (E/A)S \implies S^* = \frac{I}{E/A + I/P}

  2. Step 2

    As A→0+, E/A→∞, so S∗→0 species\text{As } A \to 0^+,\ E/A \to \infty,\text{ so } S^* \to 0\text{ species}

  3. Step 3

    I(1−S)=(E/A)SI(1 - S) = (E/A)S

    Correct

    I(1−SP)=EASI\left(1 - \frac{S}{P}\right) = \frac{E}{A}S

    You omitted the mainland species pool P=120P = 120 in the denominator of the colonization term, writing 1−S1 - S instead of 1−SP1 - \frac{S}{P}.

  4. Step 4

    2.0(1−40)=(0.050/A)(40)  ⟹  2.0(−39)=2.0/A  ⟹  −78=2.0/A  ⟹  A=0.026 km22.0(1 - 40) = (0.050/A)(40) \implies 2.0(-39) = 2.0/A \implies -78 = 2.0/A \implies A = 0.026\text{ km}^2

    Correct

    2.0(1−40120)=0.050A(40)  ⟹  2.0(23)=2.0A  ⟹  Amin⁡=1.50 km22.0\left(1 - \frac{40}{120}\right) = \frac{0.050}{A}(40) \implies 2.0\left(\frac{2}{3}\right) = \frac{2.0}{A} \implies A_{\min} = 1.50\text{ km}^2

    Because of the missing PP, the left side evaluated to a negative immigration rate (2.0×(−39)=−782.0 \times (-39) = -78), which subsequently caused an incorrect and unphysical calculation for area.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly stated the dynamic equilibrium condition where colonization rate equals extinction rate.

You successfully solved for the algebraic formula for S∗S^* and analyzed its behavior as A→0+A \to 0^+.

You substituted the given numerical values for II, EE, and S∗S^* into your equation.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Missing normalization constant

You dropped the denominator PP in the linear colonization term when transitioning from the general algebraic form to the numerical calculation.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Treating the species saturation factor as an absolute difference (1−S)(1 - S) rather than a dimensionless fraction of the regional mainland pool (1−S/P)(1 - S/P), leading to a negative colonization rate when S>1S > 1.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Dimensionless Proportion Check
  • In the MacArthur-Wilson colonization formula λ(S)=I(1−SP)\lambda(S) = I\left(1 - \frac{S}{P}\right), the ratio SP\frac{S}{P} represents the fraction of mainland species already present on the island, so 1−SP1 - \frac{S}{P} must remain between 00 and 11.

  • Always verify that species richness SS is divided by the total mainland pool PP so the immigration factor remains non-negative whenever S≤PS \le P.

Physical Reality Check
  • Colonization rate λ(S)\lambda(S) and habitat area AA must always be positive physical quantities.

  • If your intermediate calculation produces a negative rate (such as −78 species/yr-78\text{ species/yr}), stop immediately and check the fractional terms in your rate equation.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Substitute P=120P = 120 into the immigration rate function: λ(40)=2.0(1−40120)=2.0(23)=43 species/yr\lambda(40) = 2.0\left(1 - \frac{40}{120}\right) = 2.0\left(\frac{2}{3}\right) = \frac{4}{3}\text{ species/yr}.

  2. Set the extinction rate equal to colonization rate: μ(40)=0.050×40Amin⁡=2.0Amin⁡\mu(40) = \frac{0.050 \times 40}{A_{\min}} = \frac{2.0}{A_{\min}}.

  3. Equate the two rates: 2.0Amin⁡=43\frac{2.0}{A_{\min}} = \frac{4}{3}.

  4. Solve for Amin⁡A_{\min}: Amin⁡=2.0×34=1.50 km2A_{\min} = \frac{2.0 \times 3}{4} = 1.50\text{ km}^2.

Final answer

Amin⁡=1.50 km2A_{\min} = 1.50\text{ km}^2

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the MacArthur-Wilson model to reinforce why colonization depends on the proportion of unrepresented species, 1−S/P1 - S/P.

  • Practice checking dimensions and physical plausibility (rates and areas must be positive) before completing numerical algebra.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student inverts the area relationship when solving for A, calculating A = (4/3) / 2.0 instead of 2.0 / (4/3).

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    I(1−S/P)=(E/A)S  ⟹  S∗(E/A+I/P)=I  ⟹  As A→0+, E/A→∞, so S∗→0 speciesI(1 - S/P) = (E/A)S \implies S^*(E/A + I/P) = I \implies \text{As } A \to 0^+,\ E/A \to \infty,\ \text{so } S^* \to 0\text{ species}

  2. Step 2

    2.0(1−40120)=(0.050A)(40)  ⟹  43=2A2.0\left(1 - \frac{40}{120}\right) = \left(\frac{0.050}{A}\right)(40) \implies \frac{4}{3} = \frac{2}{A}

  3. Step 3

    A=4/32  ⟹  A=0.67 km2A = \frac{4/3}{2} \implies A = 0.67\text{ km}^2

    Correct

    A=24/3=1.50 km2A = \frac{2}{4/3} = 1.50\text{ km}^2

    When solving an equation of the form c=kAc = \frac{k}{A} for the denominator variable AA, multiply both sides by AA and divide by cc to get A=kcA = \frac{k}{c}. Here, that gives A=24/3=2×34=1.50 km2A = \frac{2}{4/3} = 2 \times \frac{3}{4} = 1.50\text{ km}^2, rather than 4/32\frac{4/3}{2}.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly equated immigration and extinction rates to model equilibrium species richness.

You correctly determined that lim⁡A→0+S∗=0 species\lim_{A \to 0^+} S^* = 0\text{ species}.

You accurately computed the immigration rate λ(40)=43 species/yr\lambda(40) = \frac{4}{3}\text{ species/yr} and the numerator for extinction.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Algebraic inversion error

You inverted the divisor and dividend when isolating a variable located in the denominator.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

When solving for an unknown in the denominator of a fraction (c=kxc = \frac{k}{x}), you divided the left-hand constant by the numerator (x=ckx = \frac{c}{k}) instead of dividing the numerator by the constant (x=kcx = \frac{k}{c}).

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Isolating Denominator Variables
  • For any relation c=kxc = \frac{k}{x} with c,x≠0c, x \neq 0, cross-multiplication yields c⋅x=kc \cdot x = k, so x=kcx = \frac{k}{c}.

  • Always cross-multiply or take the reciprocal of both sides before dividing.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. 43=2A\frac{4}{3} = \frac{2}{A}

  2. 4A=2×3=6.04A = 2 \times 3 = 6.0

  3. A=6.04=1.50 km2A = \frac{6.0}{4} = 1.50\text{ km}^2

Final answer

lim⁡A→0+S∗=0 species; Amin⁡=1.50 km2\lim_{A \to 0^+} S^* = 0\text{ species};\ A_{\min} = 1.50\text{ km}^2

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • When an unknown sits in a denominator, use cross-multiplication to bring it to the numerator first.

  • Check your units and dimensions: smaller habitat area increases extinction rate, so a larger target species richness requires a larger area.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A nature preserve with an extinction coefficient E=0.040 yr−1E = 0.040\text{ yr}^{-1} and regional pool P=100P = 100 has a maximum immigration rate I=4.0 species/yrI = 4.0\text{ species/yr}. Calculate the equilibrium species richness S∗S^* when the fragment area is A=2.0 km2A = 2.0\text{ km}^2.

Answer

S∗=66.7 speciesS^* = 66.7\text{ species} (or 2003\frac{200}{3}). At equilibrium, 4.0(1−S∗/100)=(0.040/2.0)S∗  ⟹  4−0.04S∗=0.02S∗  ⟹  0.06S∗=4  ⟹  S∗=2003≈66.74.0(1 - S^*/100) = (0.040/2.0)S^* \implies 4 - 0.04S^* = 0.02S^* \implies 0.06S^* = 4 \implies S^* = \frac{200}{3} \approx 66.7.

02

Using the rate functions λ(S)=I(1−S/P)\lambda(S) = I(1 - S/P) and μ(S)=EAS\mu(S) = \frac{E}{A}S, evaluate the theoretical limit of equilibrium richness lim⁡I→∞S∗\lim_{I \to \infty} S^* as immigration becomes extremely high for a fixed non-zero area AA. Provide an ecological interpretation.

Answer

lim⁡I→∞S∗=P\lim_{I \to \infty} S^* = P. As immigration becomes overwhelming, S∗=IEA+IP=1EIA+1P→PS^* = \frac{I}{\frac{E}{A} + \frac{I}{P}} = \frac{1}{\frac{E}{I A} + \frac{1}{P}} \to P. Continuous rescue effect replenishes all extinct species from the mainland pool.

03

A highway reduces a habitat patch from A1=4.0 km2A_1 = 4.0\text{ km}^2 to A2=0.50 km2A_2 = 0.50\text{ km}^2. If P=150P = 150, I=3.0 species/yrI = 3.0\text{ species/yr}, and E=0.060 yr−1E = 0.060\text{ yr}^{-1}, determine the percentage loss in equilibrium species richness caused by this fragmentation.

Answer

Loss is approximately 42.9%42.9\%. For A1=4.0A_1 = 4.0, μ1=0.015S  ⟹  3(1−S/150)=0.015S  ⟹  3=0.035S  ⟹  S1∗=3003.5≈85.71\mu_1 = 0.015S \implies 3(1 - S/150) = 0.015S \implies 3 = 0.035S \implies S_1^* = \frac{300}{3.5} \approx 85.71. For A2=0.50A_2 = 0.50, μ2=0.12S  ⟹  3(1−S/150)=0.12S  ⟹  3=0.14S  ⟹  S2∗=30014≈21.43\mu_2 = 0.12S \implies 3(1 - S/150) = 0.12S \implies 3 = 0.14S \implies S_2^* = \frac{300}{14} \approx 21.43. Percentage loss =85.71−21.4385.71×100%=75.0%= \frac{85.71 - 21.43}{85.71} \times 100\% = 75.0\%.

Loading workspace…