Resources

A common misconception among biology students is that natural selection always reduces genetic variation whereas genetic drift always acts randomly to eliminate deleterious alleles. Consider an isolated population of butterflies where a single locus exhibits heterozygote advantage (overdominance) with relative fitness values wA1A1=0.75w_{A_1A_1} = 0.75, wA1A2=1.00w_{A_1A_2} = 1.00, and wA2A2=0.60w_{A_2A_2} = 0.60. (a) Calculate the stable equilibrium allele frequency p^\hat{p} of allele A1A_1 maintained by balancing natural selection in an infinitely large population. (b) Explain why, if this population is suddenly reduced to N=6N = 6 individuals, the population can become permanently fixed for the less fit homozygote genotype A2A2A_2A_2, despite natural selection favoring the maintenance of both alleles.

Answer and steps

Final answer

(a) p^=0.615\hat{p} = 0.615; (b) In very small populations (N=6N = 6), random sampling variance of alleles (genetic drift) overwhelms selection coefficients (s1=0.25,s2=0.40s_1 = 0.25, s_2 = 0.40), allowing the maladaptive A2A_2 allele to drift to fixation (p→0p \to 0) by chance alone.

Steps

Part (a): Equilibrium Allele Frequency under Heterozygote Advantage

Heterozygote advantage (overdominance) occurs when the heterozygous genotype has a higher relative fitness than either homozygous genotype. Under balancing natural selection, both alleles are stably maintained in the population.

  1. Determine the selection coefficients against each homozygote: The relative fitness values are: wA1A1=1−s1=0.75  ⟹  s1=1−0.75=0.25w_{A_1A_1} = 1 - s_1 = 0.75 \implies s_1 = 1 - 0.75 = 0.25 wA1A2=1.00w_{A_1A_2} = 1.00 wA2A2=1−s2=0.60  ⟹  s2=1−0.60=0.40w_{A_2A_2} = 1 - s_2 = 0.60 \implies s_2 = 1 - 0.60 = 0.40 Here, s1s_1 represents the selection coefficient against the A1A1A_1A_1 homozygote, and s2s_2 represents the selection coefficient against the A2A2A_2A_2 homozygote.
  2. Apply the equilibrium formula for overdominance: At equilibrium (Δp=0\Delta p = 0), the rates of allele loss due to selection against each homozygote balance each other: p^=s2s1+s2\hat{p} = \frac{s_2}{s_1 + s_2} where p^\hat{p} is the frequency of allele A1A_1.
  3. Calculate p^\hat{p}: p^=0.400.25+0.40=0.400.65=813≈0.615\hat{p} = \frac{0.40}{0.25 + 0.40} = \frac{0.40}{0.65} = \frac{8}{13} \approx 0.615

Common Pitfall: Be careful not to swap s1s_1 and s2s_2 in the numerator. The frequency of allele A1A_1 depends proportionally on the selection against the opposite homozygote (A2A2A_2A_2, quantified by s2s_2), because greater selective pressure against A2A2A_2A_2 drives up the relative proportion of A1A_1.


Part (b): Fixation in a Small Population (N=6N = 6)

  1. Relative strength of genetic drift vs. natural selection: In an infinite population, deterministic natural selection dictates allele trajectories. However, in finite populations, random sampling of gametes causes stochastic fluctuations in allele frequencies (genetic drift). The relative strength of selection versus drift depends on the magnitude of NesN_e s (where NeN_e is the effective population size and ss is the selection coefficient). Selection dominates when Nes≫1N_e s \gg 1, whereas drift dominates when Nes≪1N_e s \ll 1 or when population size is extremely small.
  2. Sampling variance in tiny populations: With N=6N = 6 individuals, the total gene pool consists of only 2N=122N = 12 allele copies. The sampling variance per generation is given by: σΔp2=p(1−p)2N=0.615⋅0.38512≈0.0197\sigma_{\Delta p}^2 = \frac{p(1-p)}{2N} = \frac{0.615 \cdot 0.385}{12} \approx 0.0197 This large variance means allele frequencies can shift drastically in a single generation by chance alone, completely overwhelming the modest deterministic selection pressures (s1=0.25s_1 = 0.25, s2=0.40s_2 = 0.40).
  3. Loss of beneficial alleles and fixation of maladaptive alleles: Due to random reproductive success or accidental mortality (e.g., a predator eating the few A1A_1-bearing individuals before mating), all copies of allele A1A_1 can be lost in a short number of generations (p→0p \to 0). Once allele A1A_1 is lost, allele A2A_2 becomes fixed (q=1q = 1). In the absence of recurrent mutation or immigration (gene flow), the population remains permanently fixed for the maladaptive A2A2A_2A_2 genotype despite its lower fitness.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student inverts the selection coefficients in the equilibrium frequency formula, using s₁/(s₁ + s₂) instead of s₂/(s₁ + s₂), calculating p̂ = 0.25 / 0.65 ≈ 0.385.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    s1=1−0.75=0.25s_1 = 1 - 0.75 = 0.25   ⟹  \implies s2=1−0.60=0.40s_2 = 1 - 0.60 = 0.40

  2. Step 2

    p^=s1s1+s2=0.250.25+0.40  ⟹  p^=0.250.65=513≈0.385\hat{p} = \frac{s_1}{s_1 + s_2} = \frac{0.25}{0.25 + 0.40} \implies \hat{p} = \frac{0.25}{0.65} = \frac{5}{13} \approx 0.385

    Correct

    p^=s2s1+s2=0.400.25+0.40=813≈0.615\hat{p} = \frac{s_2}{s_1 + s_2} = \frac{0.40}{0.25 + 0.40} = \frac{8}{13} \approx 0.615

    You placed s1s_1 in the numerator instead of s2s_2. The equilibrium frequency of allele A1A_1 is driven by the selective disadvantage against the alternative homozygote A2A2A_2A_2 (s2s_2).

  3. Step 3

    In a very small population with N=6N=6, genetic drift is strong and causes random changes in allele frequencies. Chance sampling can override natural selection and cause the loss of allele A1A_1, fixing allele A2A_2 and genotype A2A2A_2A_2 permanently.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly derived the selection coefficients from the given relative fitness values.

You clearly explained how genetic drift and random sampling overcome deterministic selection in small populations.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Inverted selection coefficients in overdominance equilibrium

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You matched the index of allele A1A_1 directly to s1s_1 in the numerator, forgetting that the equilibrium frequency of an allele under overdominance is directly proportional to the selection coefficient against the opposite homozygote (s2s_2).

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Intuition for overdominance numerator
  • Stronger selection against A2A2A_2A_2 (s2s_2) means fewer A2A_2 alleles survive, which increases the equilibrium frequency of A1A_1 (p^\hat{p}).

  • Always verify that p^=s2s1+s2\hat{p} = \frac{s_2}{s_1 + s_2} and q^=s1s1+s2\hat{q} = \frac{s_1}{s_1 + s_2}. Check your answer logically: since wA1A1=0.75>wA2A2=0.60w_{A_1A_1} = 0.75 > w_{A_2A_2} = 0.60, allele A1A_1 must be more frequent than allele A2A_2 at equilibrium (p^>0.5\hat{p} > 0.5).

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Substitute the correct selection coefficient s2=0.40s_2 = 0.40 into the numerator: p^=s2s1+s2=0.400.25+0.40\hat{p} = \frac{s_2}{s_1 + s_2} = \frac{0.40}{0.25 + 0.40}.

  2. Simplify the fraction: p^=0.400.65=813≈0.615\hat{p} = \frac{0.40}{0.65} = \frac{8}{13} \approx 0.615.

Final answer

(a) p^=813≈0.615\hat{p} = \frac{8}{13} \approx 0.615; (b) In very small populations (N=6N = 6), genetic drift overwhelms natural selection, allowing random chance to eliminate allele A1A_1 and fix genotype A2A2A_2A_2.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Memorize the reciprocal pairing rule for overdominance: p^\hat{p} pairs with s2s_2, and q^\hat{q} pairs with s1s_1.

  • Perform a sanity check on your equilibrium frequency: whichever homozygote has higher fitness should have its corresponding allele at a frequency greater than 0.50.5.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student uses the relative fitness values directly in the numerator and denominator instead of selection coefficients, resulting in p̂ = 0.75 / 1.35 ≈ 0.556.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    p^=w11w11+w22  ⟹  p^=0.750.75+0.60\hat{p} = \frac{w_{11}}{w_{11} + w_{22}} \implies \hat{p} = \frac{0.75}{0.75 + 0.60}

    Correct

    p^=s2s1+s2=1−w22(1−w11)+(1−w22)=0.400.25+0.40\hat{p} = \frac{s_2}{s_1 + s_2} = \frac{1 - w_{22}}{(1 - w_{11}) + (1 - w_{22})} = \frac{0.40}{0.25 + 0.40}

    Equilibrium under overdominance is determined by the selection coefficients against homozygotes (s=1−ws = 1 - w), not the fitness values themselves. Furthermore, the frequency of allele A1A_1 depends on the selection pressure against the opposite homozygote (A2A2A_2A_2, measured by s2s_2) in the numerator.

  2. Step 2

    p^=0.751.35=59≈0.556\hat{p} = \frac{0.75}{1.35} = \frac{5}{9} \approx 0.556

    Correct

    p^=0.400.65=813≈0.615\hat{p} = \frac{0.40}{0.65} = \frac{8}{13} \approx 0.615

    You calculated the arithmetic accurately from your formula, but the resulting value was incorrect due to the initial formula mistake.

  3. Step 3

    At N=6N=6, genetic drift dominates over natural selection due to high sampling error across generations. Random allele fluctuations can cause allele A1A_1 to drop to frequency 0, leaving allele A2A_2 fixed.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified that sampling error in a small population of size N=6N = 6 allows genetic drift to overwhelm deterministic natural selection.

You accurately explained how stochastic fluctuations can drive an allele to complete loss (p=0p = 0), leading to permanent fixation of the alternative allele.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Formula Substitution Error

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated equilibrium allele frequency as a direct ratio of relative fitnesses (w11/(w11+w22)w_{11} / (w_{11} + w_{22})) rather than balancing the selection coefficients against the two homozygous genotypes (s2/(s1+s2)s_2 / (s_1 + s_2)).

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Convert Fitness to Selection Coefficients
  • s1=1−w11s_1 = 1 - w_{11} and s2=1−w22s_2 = 1 - w_{22} relative to the heterozygote fitness w12=1.00w_{12} = 1.00.

  • Always subtract homozygote fitness from the heterozygote fitness before solving for equilibrium frequencies.

Use Opposite Selection Coefficient in Numerator
  • For allele A1A_1, p^=s2s1+s2\hat{p} = \frac{s_2}{s_1 + s_2}; for allele A2A_2, q^=s1s1+s2\hat{q} = \frac{s_1}{s_1 + s_2}.

  • Remember that allele A1A_1 increases in equilibrium frequency when selection against A2A2A_2A_2 (s2s_2) becomes stronger.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Determine the selection coefficients against each homozygote: s1=1−0.75=0.25s_1 = 1 - 0.75 = 0.25 and s2=1−0.60=0.40s_2 = 1 - 0.60 = 0.40.

  2. Substitute into the balancing selection equilibrium formula: p^=s2s1+s2=0.400.25+0.40\hat{p} = \frac{s_2}{s_1 + s_2} = \frac{0.40}{0.25 + 0.40}.

  3. Simplify the fraction: p^=0.400.65=813≈0.615\hat{p} = \frac{0.40}{0.65} = \frac{8}{13} \approx 0.615.

Final answer

(a) p^≈0.615\hat{p} \approx 0.615; (b) In a very small population (N=6N = 6), high sampling variance (genetic drift) dominates over natural selection, allowing allele A1A_1 to be randomly lost and fixing allele A2A_2.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Practice deriving the equilibrium condition Δp=0\Delta p = 0 for overdominance to solidify why the opposite selection coefficient belongs in the numerator.

  • Review the distinction between absolute fitness, relative fitness (ww), and the selection coefficient (s=1−ws = 1 - w).

  • Explore how effective population size (NeN_e) determines the threshold between drift-dominated (s<1/(2Ne)s < 1/(2N_e)) and selection-dominated dynamics.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student believes that natural selection operates teleologically to favor the survival of the species, concluding that fixation of a less fit genotype is impossible even in small populations.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    s1=1−0.75=0.25s_1 = 1 - 0.75 = 0.25, s2=1−0.60=0.40  ⟹  p^=s2s1+s2=0.400.65=813≈0.615s_2 = 1 - 0.60 = 0.40 \implies \hat{p} = \frac{s_2}{s_1 + s_2} = \frac{0.40}{0.65} = \frac{8}{13} \approx 0.615

  2. Step 2

    Natural selection acts to ensure the survival of the population by preventing detrimental traits from spreading. Because A2A2A_2A_2 has the lowest fitness of 0.600.60, natural selection will always eliminate A2A2A_2A_2 to keep the population from going extinct, so fixation cannot occur.

    Correct

    In a very small population (N=6N = 6, total gene pool 2N=122N = 12 alleles), genetic drift causes large random sampling variance in allele frequencies from generation to generation. Stochastic fluctuations overwhelm the selection coefficients (s1=0.25,s2=0.40s_1 = 0.25, s_2 = 0.40), so all copies of allele A1A_1 can be lost purely by chance, leading to the permanent fixation of allele A2A_2.

    Natural selection does not act with foresight or purpose to prevent population extinction, nor does it guarantee the elimination of deleterious alleles in finite populations. When population size drops to N=6N = 6, random genetic drift dominates over natural selection, allowing a less fit allele to drift to fixation by chance.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly derived the selection coefficients against both homozygotes.

You used the correct algebraic formula for overdominance equilibrium and accurately computed p^≈0.615\hat{p} \approx 0.615.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Teleological Misconception & Neglect of Genetic Drift

none

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated natural selection as a goal-oriented mechanism designed to ensure species survival, while neglecting the role of genetic drift and random sampling variance in small populations.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Natural Selection Has No Foresight
  • Natural selection is a non-teleological, passive filter based on differential reproductive success of individuals, not a forward-looking mechanism designed to protect population survival.

  • Avoid phrasing evolutionary mechanisms as acting 'to ensure survival' or 'to prevent extinction'.

Drift Overwhelms Selection in Small Populations
  • When Nes≪1N_e s \ll 1 (or when effective population size is tiny), random gamete sampling variance σΔp2=p(1−p)2N\sigma_{\Delta p}^2 = \frac{p(1-p)}{2N} causes allele frequencies to fluctuate stochastically, which can override selection and fix deleterious alleles.

  • Evaluate the population size NN to determine whether deterministic selection or stochastic drift drives allele frequency changes.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Identify the size of the total gene pool: with N=6N = 6 diploid individuals, there are only 2N=122N = 12 allele copies.

  2. Recognize that random sampling of gametes (genetic drift) introduces large sampling variance per generation, σΔp2=p(1−p)2N\sigma_{\Delta p}^2 = \frac{p(1-p)}{2N}.

  3. Compare the force of drift to selection: because NN is extremely small, stochastic fluctuations exceed the deterministic selective pressures (s1=0.25,s2=0.40s_1 = 0.25, s_2 = 0.40).

  4. Conclude that chance mortality or non-random mating can eliminate all copies of A1A_1, fixing the less fit A2A_2 allele permanently in the absence of mutation or gene flow.

Final answer

(a) p^≈0.615\hat{p} \approx 0.615; (b) In an extremely small population (N=6N = 6), random genetic drift causes substantial sampling variance that easily overpowers balancing selection, allowing the less fit allele A2A_2 to reach fixation by chance alone.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review how population size modulates the balance between deterministic selection (ss) and stochastic genetic drift (1/(2N)1/(2N)).

  • Practice explaining evolutionary outcomes in terms of individual reproductive variance and sampling error rather than population-level goals or needs.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A locus shows overdominance with relative fitness values wBB=0.80w_{BB} = 0.80, wBb=1.00w_{Bb} = 1.00, and wbb=0.20w_{bb} = 0.20. Calculate the stable equilibrium frequency p^\hat{p} of allele BB.

Answer

p^=0.80\hat{p} = 0.80. Step 1: Calculate selection coefficients: s1=1−0.80=0.20s_1 = 1 - 0.80 = 0.20, s2=1−0.20=0.80s_2 = 1 - 0.20 = 0.80. Step 2: Apply overdominance formula: p^=s2s1+s2=0.800.20+0.80=0.80\hat{p} = \frac{s_2}{s_1 + s_2} = \frac{0.80}{0.20 + 0.80} = 0.80.

02

In a sickle-cell anemia model, relative fitness in a malaria-endemic region is wAA=0.88w_{AA} = 0.88 (normal homozygote), wAS=1.00w_{AS} = 1.00 (heterozygote), and wSS=0.12w_{SS} = 0.12 (sickle-cell homozygote). Find the equilibrium frequency q^\hat{q} of the deleterious sickle allele SS.

Answer

q^=0.12\hat{q} = 0.12. Step 1: Find selection coefficients: sA=1−0.88=0.12s_A = 1 - 0.88 = 0.12 (against AAAA), sS=1−0.12=0.88s_S = 1 - 0.12 = 0.88 (against SSSS). Step 2: Formula for q^\hat{q} uses the opposite selection coefficient: q^=sAsA+sS=0.120.12+0.88=0.12\hat{q} = \frac{s_A}{s_A + s_S} = \frac{0.12}{0.12 + 0.88} = 0.12.

03

Under heterozygote advantage with s1=0.15s_1 = 0.15 and s2=0.45s_2 = 0.45, an isolated population maintains p^=0.75\hat{p} = 0.75. If a severe bottleneck reduces the population to N=4N = 4, explain the mathematical condition under which genetic drift dominates natural selection, and state the probability that allele A1A_1 is eventually fixed purely by drift starting from p^\hat{p}.

Answer

Condition: Nes≪1N_e s \ll 1 (or 4Nes<14N_e s < 1). With N=4N = 4, 2N=82N = 8 total gene copies, so random sampling variance dominates deterministic selection. Probability of fixation: In the absence of selection (drift dominated), the fixation probability of an allele equals its current frequency, so P(fixation of A1)≈p^=0.75P(\text{fixation of } A_1) \approx \hat{p} = 0.75 (and 0.250.25 for A2A_2).

Loading workspace…