Resources
Students often assume that chromosome count is halved during cytokinesis after telophase II, or that chromosomes duplicate during the interkinesis phase between Meiosis I and Meiosis II. A sample of eukaryotic cells with is tracked from late Prophase II to late Telophase II. Address this counter-intuitive conceptual trap: (a) state the exact number of chromosomes in a single cell during Anaphase II before cytokinesis occurs, explaining why this transient count differs from both Telophase I and mature gametes, and (b) confirm whether DNA replication occurs during interkinesis.
Answer and steps
Final answer
(a) chromosomes; upon the cleavage of centromeric cohesin at Anaphase II, sister chromatids disjoin and are instantly classified as individual daughter chromosomes, temporarily doubling the chromosome count from to within that single cytoplasm until cytokinesis partitions them into two cells of ; (b) No DNA replication occurs during interkinesis.
Steps
Part (a): Chromosome Count During Anaphase II
-
How Chromosomes Are Counted: In cell biology, the number of chromosomes is defined by the number of independent centromeres (kinetochores), not the amount of DNA or the presence of duplicate arms:
- One replicated chromosome consists of two sister chromatids joined at a single shared centromere (counted as chromosome).
- One unreplicated chromosome consists of a single chromatid with its own centromere (also counted as chromosome).
-
The State Entering Meiosis II:
- The organism has a diploid number of .
- Meiosis I separates homologous chromosome pairs. Therefore, by the end of Meiosis I (Telophase I), each daughter cell is haploid (). Each of these chromosomes is still replicated, consisting of two sister chromatids.
- Consequently, a cell entering Prophase II and Metaphase II contains chromosomes (and chromatids).
-
The Event at Anaphase II:
- At the transition to Anaphase II, cohesin proteins holding the sister chromatids together at the centromere are cleaved.
- As the sister chromatids disjoin and are pulled toward opposite spindle poles, each chromatid acquires its own independent centromere and is immediately reclassified as an individual daughter chromosome.
- Because both sets of separating chromatids still reside within the boundaries of a single, undivided cytoplasm, the number of chromosomes temporarily doubles:
-
Comparison with Telophase I and Mature Gametes:
- Telophase I: Each daughter cell contains chromosomes (each composed of two sister chromatids).
- Anaphase II: Within the single cell, centromere cleavage creates individual chromosomes.
- Mature Gametes: Cytokinesis following Telophase II divides the cytoplasm, partitioning daughter chromosomes into each of the two resulting gametes, returning the count to unreplicated chromosomes.
Part (b): DNA Replication During Interkinesis
- No DNA replication occurs during interkinesis.
- Interkinesis is an abbreviated interphase-like pause between Meiosis I and Meiosis II that lacks an S (synthesis) phase.
- The sister chromatids formed during the pre-meiotic S phase are already present throughout Meiosis I and are simply awaiting separation in Meiosis II. If DNA were to replicate again during interkinesis, the chromosome/chromatid number would double, making it impossible to produce haploid gametes.
Typical errors
01 The student confuses sister chromatids with distinct chromosomes prior to separation, concluding that the cell still has 8 chromosomes during Anaphase II because cytokinesis has not yet partitioned them.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
Prophase II cell has chromosomes.
- Step 2
Chromatids pull apart but the cell is still haploid. ⟹ Number of chromosomes in Anaphase II = 8. ⟹ The count equals Telophase I cells because the cell has not divided yet, and mature gametes will receive 4 chromosomes after cytokinesis.
CorrectDuring Anaphase II, centromeres split and sister chromatids separate into individual daughter chromosomes. Within the single undivided cytoplasm, the chromosome count transiently doubles to chromosomes (), which are later partitioned by cytokinesis into two gametes of chromosomes each.
Chromosomes are defined by functional centromeres, not the quantity of DNA. Once cohesin cleaves and sister chromatids disjoin at Anaphase II, each chromatid is an autonomous chromosome. Thus, the single cell transiently contains chromosomes before cytokinesis resolves them into gametes with .
- Step 3
No, DNA replication does not occur during interkinesis.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly identified that cells entering Prophase II are haploid with chromosomes.
You accurately stated that DNA replication does not take place during interkinesis.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou treated chromosome count as an unchanging property across anaphase rather than applying the biological definition that each separated centromere defines an independent chromosome, leading to the incorrect deduction that gametes would have only chromosomes.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Centromere-Based Chromosome Definition
1 chromosome = 1 centromere. A replicated chromosome with 2 sister chromatids counts as chromosome; two separated sister chromatids count as individual chromosomes.
Always count functional centromeres rather than DNA strands when determining chromosome number.
- Transient Doubling in Anaphase
Whenever sister chromatids disjoin (Anaphase of mitosis or Anaphase II of meiosis) inside an undivided cell, the chromosome number doubles temporarily until cytokinesis.
Multiply the number of entering replicated chromosomes by to find the chromosome count during Anaphase II.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationStart with the replicated chromosomes present at Metaphase II, each having centromere and sister chromatids.
At Anaphase II, centromeric cohesin cleaves, allowing the sister chromatids to separate into opposite spindle poles.
Because each separated chromatid now possesses its own independent centromere, it is defined as an individual daughter chromosome.
Count all individual chromosomes within the undivided cytoplasm: chromosomes (a transient state).
Recognize that cytokinesis subsequently divides these chromosomes equally between two daughter cells, yielding mature gametes with unreplicated chromosomes each.
(a) chromosomes; (b) No DNA replication occurs during interkinesis.
02 The student believes that an interkinesis stage functions like a complete interphase containing an S phase, incorrectly concluding that DNA replication must duplicate chromosomes before Meiosis II.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
Sister chromatids split at the centromere in Anaphase II. Each chromatid becomes a full chromosome, temporarily doubling the count in the single cell. Number of chromosomes in Anaphase II = 16. This transient count of 16 is double the 8 chromosomes per daughter cell in Telophase I and mature gametes with 8 chromosomes.
- Step 2
Interkinesis is the interphase between meiosis I and meiosis II. DNA replication occurs during interkinesis to prepare chromatids for second division.
CorrectNo DNA replication occurs during interkinesis because interkinesis lacks an S phase and chromatids are already duplicated from pre-meiotic interphase.
Interkinesis is a brief resting stage between Meiosis I and Meiosis II that lacks an S (synthesis) phase. Because chromosomes are already composed of two sister chromatids from the pre-meiotic interphase, no further DNA replication takes place.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly identified that sister chromatid separation at Anaphase II doubles the number of individual chromosomes within a single undivided cell.
You accurately contrasted the transient count of chromosomes with the chromosomes present in Telophase I daughter cells and mature gametes.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou conflated interkinesis with standard pre-mitotic interphase, assuming any interphase-like stage must include an S phase for DNA replication.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Interkinesis vs. Pre-meiotic Interphase
DNA replication occurs only once during meiosis, specifically during the S phase of pre-meiotic interphase prior to Prophase I.
Remember that interkinesis is an abbreviated pause between divisions where no DNA replication occurs, ensuring the cell ends up with half the original genetic material.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationRecognize that chromosomes entering Meiosis II already consist of two sister chromatids formed prior to Meiosis I.
Note that interkinesis lacks an S phase, so no DNA synthesis or replication takes place.
Conclude that DNA replication does not occur during interkinesis.
No DNA replication occurs during interkinesis.
Lock it in
How do cytologists count the number of chromosomes in a cell at any stage?
Count the number of functional centromeres: one centromere equals one chromosome, regardless of whether it has one or two chromatids.
Similar question
A diploid plant species has . For a single cell undergoing meiosis, determine: (1) the chromosome count at Metaphase II, (2) the chromatid count at Metaphase II, and (3) the chromosome count at Anaphase II before cytokinesis.
Answer
(1) chromosomes; (2) chromatids; (3) chromosomes. At Metaphase II, the cell is haploid () with duplicated chromosomes ( chromatids). In Anaphase II, sister chromatids disjoin to become individual chromosomes in one cell.
An animal cell with is observed during cell division. A single undivided cell contains chromosomes, each composed of a single unreplicated chromatid moving toward spindle poles. Is this cell in mitotic anaphase, Anaphase I, or Anaphase II? Explain.
Answer
The cell is in Anaphase II. In mitotic anaphase, a cell would temporarily have single-chromatid chromosomes. In Anaphase I, homologous pairs separate, so the chromosomes would still have two chromatids each. In Anaphase II, the haploid set of replicated chromosomes splits into single-chromatid chromosomes.
Track the ratio of chromosome count to DNA molecule count (chromosomes : DNA molecules) in a single cell from Metaphase II to immediately after Telophase II cytokinesis for an organism with .
Answer
At Metaphase II, the ratio is ( replicated chromosomes, each containing DNA molecules). At Anaphase II, centromeres split, yielding chromosomes and DNA molecules, so the ratio is . Following cytokinesis, each gamete contains unreplicated chromosomes and DNA molecules, maintaining the ratio of .