Resources

Suppose human height is a polygenic trait modeled by an additive polygenic threshold system involving 44 independently assorting gene loci (A,B,C,DA, B, C, D) with equal, cumulative additive effects. A baseline homozygous recessive genotype (aabbccddaabbccdd) yields a phenotype of 140 cm140\text{ cm}, and each active dominant capital allele contributes exactly +5 cm+5\text{ cm} to total adult height. If two individuals with identical heterozygous genotypes at all four loci (AaBbCcDdAaBbCcDd) have a child, determine: (a) the minimum adult height possible, (b) the maximum adult height possible, and (c) the exact theoretical probability that a child has a phenotypic height strictly greater than 170 cm170\text{ cm}.

Answer and steps

Final answer

(a) Minimum height = 140 cm140\text{ cm}; (b) Maximum height = 180 cm180\text{ cm}; (c) Probability of height >170 cm> 170\text{ cm} = 37256≈0.145\frac{37}{256} \approx 0.145 (14.5%14.5\%).

Steps

Understanding the Additive Model

In an additive polygenic system, multiple independent genes influence a single quantitative phenotype. Each locus contributes independently and equally to the baseline value:

  • Baseline phenotype (00 additive alleles): A child inheriting all recessive alleles (aabbccddaabbccdd) has the minimum height: Baseline=140 cm\text{Baseline} = 140\text{ cm}
  • Additive effect: Each dominant allele (A,B,C,or DA, B, C, \text{or } D) contributes +5 cm+5\text{ cm}.
  • Total number of alleles: Because height is governed by 44 diploid loci, an individual possesses a total of 2×4=82 \times 4 = 8 allele positions.

Part (a): Minimum Adult Height

The minimum height occurs when an offspring inherits zero dominant additive alleles (aabbccddaabbccdd):

Minimum height=140 cm+(0×5 cm)=140 cm\text{Minimum height} = 140\text{ cm} + (0 \times 5\text{ cm}) = 140\text{ cm}


Part (b): Maximum Adult Height

The maximum height occurs when an offspring inherits all 88 dominant additive alleles (AABBCCDDAABBCCDD):

Maximum height=140 cm+(8×5 cm)=140 cm+40 cm=180 cm\text{Maximum height} = 140\text{ cm} + (8 \times 5\text{ cm}) = 140\text{ cm} + 40\text{ cm} = 180\text{ cm}


Part (c): Theoretical Probability for the Upper Phenotypic Threshold

  1. Probability Distribution of Additive Alleles: Both parents are fully heterozygous (AaBbCcDdAaBbCcDd). For any given locus, a parent contributes a dominant allele with probability p=12p = \frac{1}{2} and a recessive allele with probability q=12q = \frac{1}{2}. Across all 88 independent allele transmissions from the two parents, the number of dominant alleles kk follows a binomial distribution: n=8,p=12n = 8, \quad p = \frac{1}{2} The total number of equally likely genetic combinations is: 28=2562^8 = 256
  2. Identifying the Relevant Genotypic Classes: Phenotypes corresponding to the upper phenotypic threshold classes representing heights at and above the 170 cm170\text{ cm} boundary involve individuals with k≥6k \ge 6 contributing alleles:

    • For k=6k = 6 alleles: Height=140+6(5)=170 cm\text{Height} = 140 + 6(5) = 170\text{ cm}
    • For k=7k = 7 alleles: Height=140+7(5)=175 cm\text{Height} = 140 + 7(5) = 175\text{ cm}
    • For k=8k = 8 alleles: Height=140+8(5)=180 cm\text{Height} = 140 + 8(5) = 180\text{ cm}
  3. Calculating Combinations Using the Binomial Coefficient (nk)\binom{n}{k}:

    • Ways to inherit k=6k = 6 dominant alleles: (86)=8⋅72⋅1=28\binom{8}{6} = \frac{8 \cdot 7}{2 \cdot 1} = 28
    • Ways to inherit k=7k = 7 dominant alleles: (87)=8\binom{8}{7} = 8
    • Ways to inherit k=8k = 8 dominant alleles: (88)=1\binom{8}{8} = 1
  4. Summing Favorable Outcomes: Total favorable outcomes=28+8+1=37\text{Total favorable outcomes} = 28 + 8 + 1 = 37
  5. Calculating Probability: P=37256≈0.145(14.5%)P = \frac{37}{256} \approx 0.145 \quad (14.5\%)

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student misinterprets 'strictly greater than 170 cm' as 'greater than or equal to 170 cm' and erroneously includes the 6-active-allele phenotype in the probability calculation.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Minimum alleles=0  ⟹  Height=140 cm+0×5 cm=140 cm\text{Minimum alleles} = 0 \implies \text{Height} = 140\text{ cm} + 0 \times 5\text{ cm} = 140\text{ cm}

  2. Step 2

    Maximum alleles=8  ⟹  Height=140 cm+8×5 cm=180 cm\text{Maximum alleles} = 8 \implies \text{Height} = 140\text{ cm} + 8 \times 5\text{ cm} = 180\text{ cm}

  3. Step 3

    140+5k≥170  ⟹  5k≥30, so k≥6  ⟹  Possible active alleles: k=6,7,8140 + 5k \ge 170 \implies 5k \ge 30, \text{ so } k \ge 6 \implies \text{Possible active alleles: } k = 6, 7, 8

    Correct

    140+5k>170  ⟹  5k>30  ⟹  k>6  ⟹  Possible active alleles: k=7,8140 + 5k > 170 \implies 5k > 30 \implies k > 6 \implies \text{Possible active alleles: } k = 7, 8

    You set up a non-strict inequality (≥170\ge 170) instead of a strict inequality (>170> 170). Because k=6k = 6 produces a height of exactly 140+5(6)=170 cm140 + 5(6) = 170\text{ cm}, it is not strictly greater than 170 cm170\text{ cm} and should not be included.

  4. Step 4

    Number of ways=C(8,6)+C(8,7)+C(8,8)  ⟹  Ways=28+8+1=37  ⟹  Probability=37256\text{Number of ways} = C(8,6) + C(8,7) + C(8,8) \implies \text{Ways} = 28 + 8 + 1 = 37 \implies \text{Probability} = \frac{37}{256}

    Correct

    Number of ways=C(8,7)+C(8,8)=8+1=9  ⟹  Probability=9256\text{Number of ways} = C(8,7) + C(8,8) = 8 + 1 = 9 \implies \text{Probability} = \frac{9}{256}

    Your binomial coefficients and arithmetic were correct, but including the C(8,6)=28C(8,6) = 28 term carried over the boundary error from Step 3.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified the baseline height (140 cm140\text{ cm}) and the maximum possible height (180 cm180\text{ cm}).

You correctly recognized that the four heterozygous loci yield 88 segregating allele positions and 28=2562^8 = 256 total outcomes.

You correctly calculated the binomial coefficients (86)\binom{8}{6}, (87)\binom{8}{7}, and (88)\binom{8}{8}.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Strict vs. Non-Strict Inequality Boundary

You wrote 140+5k≥170140 + 5k \ge 170 instead of 140+5k>170140 + 5k > 170, including the boundary height of 170 cm170\text{ cm}.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You conflated the phrase 'strictly greater than' (>>) with 'at least' or 'greater than or equal to' (≥\ge), causing an extra phenotypic class (k=6k = 6) to be counted among the favorable outcomes.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Strict vs. Inclusive Inequality Setup
  • 'Strictly greater than TT' means >T> T (the boundary TT is excluded); 'at least TT' or 'greater than or equal to TT' means ≥T\ge T (the boundary TT is included).

  • Always test the boundary value before summing classes: check if Height=170 cm\text{Height} = 170\text{ cm} satisfies the condition Height>170 cm\text{Height} > 170\text{ cm} (it does not, since 170≯170170 \ngtr 170).

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Set up the strict condition: 140+5k>170  ⟹  5k>30  ⟹  k>6140 + 5k > 170 \implies 5k > 30 \implies k > 6.

  2. Identify the integer allele counts strictly greater than 66: k∈{7,8}k \in \{7, 8\}.

  3. Calculate the favorable combinations: (87)+(88)=8+1=9\binom{8}{7} + \binom{8}{8} = 8 + 1 = 9.

  4. Divide by total outcomes: P(Height>170 cm)=9256P(\text{Height} > 170\text{ cm}) = \frac{9}{256}.

Final answer

9256\frac{9}{256}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Underline key phrases like 'strictly greater than', 'exceeds', or 'at least' before writing inequality symbols.

  • Verify integer boundary values by substituting them back into the original word condition.

  • Practice polygenic threshold problems with strict upper and lower bounds.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student confuses the number of gene loci with the total number of alleles inherited, treating the system as having 4 trials instead of 8 in the binomial distribution.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Minimum active alleles=0  ⟹  Height=140 cm\text{Minimum active alleles} = 0 \implies \text{Height} = 140\text{ cm}

  2. Step 2

    Maximum active alleles=8  ⟹  Height=140 cm+8×5 cm=180 cm\text{Maximum active alleles} = 8 \implies \text{Height} = 140\text{ cm} + 8 \times 5\text{ cm} = 180\text{ cm}

  3. Step 3

    Height>170 cm requires more than 30 cm  ⟹  Each locus contributes, total trials n=4\text{Height} > 170\text{ cm}\text{ requires more than }30\text{ cm} \implies \text{Each locus contributes, total trials } n = 4

    Correct

    Total independent allele transmissions n=2×4=8, each with p=12\text{Total independent allele transmissions } n = 2 \times 4 = 8, \text{ each with } p = \frac{1}{2}

    You correctly noted that exceeding the baseline requires an additional contribution, but you equated the number of trials to the number of gene loci (n=4n = 4). In a diploid organism, each parent donates one allele per locus, yielding 2×4=82 \times 4 = 8 independent allele inheritance events.

  4. Step 4

    Requires 7 or 8 active alleles  ⟹  Maximum possible alleles considered is 4, which is impossible  ⟹  Probability=0\text{Requires } 7 \text{ or } 8 \text{ active alleles} \implies \text{Maximum possible alleles considered is } 4, \text{ which is impossible} \implies \text{Probability} = 0

    Correct

    P(k≥6)=(86)+(87)+(88)28=28+8+1256=37256≈0.145P(k \ge 6) = \frac{\binom{8}{6} + \binom{8}{7} + \binom{8}{8}}{2^8} = \frac{28 + 8 + 1}{256} = \frac{37}{256} \approx 0.145

    Because you set n=4n = 4, inheriting 66 or more alleles appeared impossible, which caused your final probability of 00.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified the baseline height of 140 cm140\text{ cm} when zero active alleles are inherited.

You correctly determined that all 88 dominant alleles produce the maximum height of 180 cm180\text{ cm}.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Diploid Gene Loci vs. Total Allele Transmission Count

You knew in part (b) that there are 88 total active alleles possible, but switched to n=4n = 4 when setting up the probability model in part (c).

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Confusing the number of distinct gene loci (L=4L = 4) with the number of independent allele transmissions in a diploid cross (n=2L=8n = 2L = 8).

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Count Total Alleles in a Diploid Genotype
  • For LL independently assorting diallelic loci, an individual inherits 22 alleles per locus, meaning n=2Ln = 2L independent allele contributions.

  • Always multiply the number of loci by 22 when determining the number of binomial trials nn for parents who are both heterozygous.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Since both parents are heterozygous (AaBbCcDdAaBbCcDd) across 44 loci, each parent independently transmits a dominant allele with probability p=12p = \frac{1}{2} at each locus.

  2. Across all 44 loci, an offspring receives 44 maternal and 44 paternal alleles, giving n=8n = 8 independent trials with p=12p = \frac{1}{2}.

  3. To reach or exceed the upper threshold boundary of 170 cm170\text{ cm}, the child needs an increase of at least +30 cm+30\text{ cm}, which corresponds to k≥6k \ge 6 dominant alleles (140+6×5=170 cm140 + 6 \times 5 = 170\text{ cm}).

  4. Calculate the number of favorable combinations for k=6,7,8k = 6, 7, 8: (86)=28\binom{8}{6} = 28, (87)=8\binom{8}{7} = 8, and (88)=1\binom{8}{8} = 1.

  5. Sum the favorable combinations: 28+8+1=3728 + 8 + 1 = 37 out of 28=2562^8 = 256 total outcomes.

Final answer

37256≈0.145 (or 14.5%)\frac{37}{256} \approx 0.145\text{ (or }14.5\%\text{)}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the distinction between gene loci and total alleles in diploid genetics.

  • Practice calculating binomial probabilities for polygenic crosses with n=2Ln = 2L trials.

  • Double-check that the total number of trials matches your maximum allele count from earlier parts of the problem.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student counts only the 7-allele case and forgets to include the 8-allele maximum case when calculating the probability for height greater than 170 cm.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Minimum height=140 cm+0(5 cm)=140 cm  ⟹  Maximum height=140 cm+8(5 cm)=180 cm\text{Minimum height} = 140\text{ cm} + 0(5\text{ cm}) = 140\text{ cm} \implies \text{Maximum height} = 140\text{ cm} + 8(5\text{ cm}) = 180\text{ cm}

  2. Step 2

    170 cm corresponds to 140+6(5), so strictly greater requires 7 active alleles170\text{ cm}\text{ corresponds to } 140 + 6(5), \text{ so strictly greater requires } 7 \text{ active alleles}

    Correct

    170 cm=140+6(5) cm  ⟹  Height>170 cm requires k>6, meaning k∈{7,8}170\text{ cm} = 140 + 6(5)\text{ cm} \implies \text{Height} > 170\text{ cm} \text{ requires } k > 6, \text{ meaning } k \in \{7, 8\}

    You recognized that 66 active alleles yield exactly 170 cm170\text{ cm}, but you treated 'strictly greater' as requiring only exactly 77 active alleles. In an 88-allele polygenic system, any count greater than 66 (both k=7k = 7 and k=8k = 8) produces a height strictly greater than 170 cm170\text{ cm}.

  3. Step 3

    Number of ways to get 7 alleles=C(8,7)=8  ⟹  Total combinations=28=256  ⟹  Probability=8256=132\text{Number of ways to get } 7 \text{ alleles} = C(8,7) = 8 \implies \text{Total combinations} = 2^8 = 256 \implies \text{Probability} = \frac{8}{256} = \frac{1}{32}

    Correct

    Ways(k=7)=(87)=8,  Ways(k=8)=(88)=1  ⟹  Favorable=8+1=9  ⟹  P(>170 cm)=9256\text{Ways}(k = 7) = \binom{8}{7} = 8, \; \text{Ways}(k = 8) = \binom{8}{8} = 1 \implies \text{Favorable} = 8 + 1 = 9 \implies P(>170\text{ cm}) = \frac{9}{256}

    Your denominator 28=2562^8 = 256 and combination calculation for (87)=8\binom{8}{7} = 8 were correct, but because you omitted the k=8k = 8 genotype class, your favorable outcomes and final probability were incomplete.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly calculated the baseline minimum height and the fully dominant maximum height.

You correctly recognized that 44 heterozygous diploid loci produce 2×4=82 \times 4 = 8 total allele transmissions with 28=2562^8 = 256 total combinations.

You accurately identified that 66 additive alleles yield a height of 170 cm170\text{ cm} and correctly computed (87)=8\binom{8}{7} = 8.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Omitted Upper Extremes in Polygenic Range

You treated 'strictly greater than 170 cm170\text{ cm}' as pointing to just the single next integer value (k=7k = 7), forgetting that polygenic traits span a range that also includes the maximum class (k=8k = 8).

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Incomplete evaluation of threshold inequalities in quantitative genetics. When evaluating an inequality such as X>cX > c, all phenotypic classes satisfying k>kthresholdk > k_{\text{threshold}} up to nn must be summed together.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Define the Full Solution Set for Inequalities
  • For an additive trait with nn alleles, a condition X>cX > c corresponds to all integers kk such that kthreshold<k≤nk_{\text{threshold}} < k \le n.

  • List every possible integer value of kk from kthreshold+1k_{\text{threshold}} + 1 up to nn before applying binomial coefficients.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Identify all qualifying allele counts strictly above k=6k = 6: k=7k = 7 (height 175 cm175\text{ cm}) and k=8k = 8 (height 180 cm180\text{ cm}).

  2. Compute the number of combinations for each qualifying class: (87)=8\binom{8}{7} = 8 and (88)=1\binom{8}{8} = 1.

  3. Sum the favorable combinations: 8+1=98 + 1 = 9 (or 28+8+1=3728 + 8 + 1 = 37 if the problem context intended the inclusive threshold ≥170 cm\ge 170\text{ cm}).

  4. Divide by the total number of combinations: 9256\frac{9}{256}.

Final answer

9256\frac{9}{256} (or 37256\frac{37}{256} if inclusive of 170 cm170\text{ cm})

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Write down the inequality in terms of active allele count kk (e.g., k>6  ⟹  k∈{7,8}k > 6 \implies k \in \{7, 8\}) before computing combinations.

  • Check that you have not stopped at the first integer above the threshold and that your sum includes the upper boundary nn.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A plant trait is controlled by 33 additive loci (66 alleles total). The baseline phenotype is 10 cm10\text{ cm}, and each active allele contributes +2 cm+2\text{ cm}. In a cross between two fully heterozygous parents (AaBbCcAaBbCc), what is the probability that an offspring has a phenotype strictly greater than 20 cm20\text{ cm}?

Answer

164\frac{1}{64}. Phenotype >20  ⟹  10+2k>20  ⟹  2k>10  ⟹  k>5> 20 \implies 10 + 2k > 20 \implies 2k > 10 \implies k > 5. For n=6n = 6 alleles, the only integer satisfying k>5k > 5 is k=6k = 6. The favorable combinations are (66)=1\binom{6}{6} = 1, and total outcomes are 26=642^6 = 64.

02

Kernel color intensity in wheat is governed by 22 additive loci (44 alleles total). A baseline homozygous recessive genotype produces a score of 00, and each dominant allele adds 11 unit of intensity. If two dihybrids (AaBbAaBb) are crossed, find the exact probability of obtaining an offspring with an intensity score strictly greater than 22.

Answer

516\frac{5}{16}. Score >2  ⟹  k>2> 2 \implies k > 2, so k∈{3,4}k \in \{3, 4\}. Number of favorable combinations is (43)+(44)=4+1=5\binom{4}{3} + \binom{4}{4} = 4 + 1 = 5. Total combinations are 24=162^4 = 16.

03

Suppose skin pigmentation in a model organism is determined by 33 additive loci (66 alleles total). The baseline melanin index is 2020, and each active dominant allele contributes +10+10 units. If two fully heterozygous individuals are crossed, what is the probability that an offspring has a melanin index strictly greater than 5050 units?

Answer

1132\frac{11}{32}. Melanin index >50  ⟹  20+10k>50  ⟹  10k>30  ⟹  k>3> 50 \implies 20 + 10k > 50 \implies 10k > 30 \implies k > 3, so k∈{4,5,6}k \in \{4, 5, 6\}. Favorable combinations: (64)+(65)+(66)=15+6+1=22\binom{6}{4} + \binom{6}{5} + \binom{6}{6} = 15 + 6 + 1 = 22. Total outcomes: 26=642^6 = 64. Probability: 2264=1132\frac{22}{64} = \frac{11}{32}.

Loading workspace…