Resources

In island biogeography and evolutionary radiation dynamics, an ancestral lineage colonizing an archipelagic ecosystem undergoes adaptive radiation only if the per-capita speciation rate bb exceeds the per-capita extinction rate dd. Suppose speciation rate scales inversely with existing species diversity due to niche saturation according to b(S)=b01+0.050Sb(S) = \frac{b_0}{1 + 0.050 S}, where b0=0.800 Myr−1b_0 = 0.800\text{ Myr}^{-1}, while extinction rate increases linearly with competition according to d(S)=d0+0.010Sd(S) = d_0 + 0.010 S, where d0=0.080 Myr−1d_0 = 0.080\text{ Myr}^{-1}. Determine the critical threshold species richness S∗S^* (the carrying capacity of the radiation where net diversification ceases, r=0r = 0). Round your answer to the nearest whole integer.

Answer and steps

Final answer

S∗=48 speciesS^* = 48\text{ species}

Steps

01

Equate Speciation and Extinction Rates

To find the critical threshold species richness S∗S^* (the equilibrium carrying capacity where net diversification ceases), we set the net diversification rate r(S)r(S) to zero: r(S)=b(S)−d(S)=0  ⟹  b(S)=d(S)r(S) = b(S) - d(S) = 0 \implies b(S) = d(S)

Substitute the given functional forms for speciation rate b(S)b(S) and extinction rate d(S)d(S):

b01+0.050S=d0+0.010S\frac{b_0}{1 + 0.050 S} = d_0 + 0.010 S

Substitute the numerical values b0=0.800 Myr−1b_0 = 0.800\text{ Myr}^{-1} and d0=0.080 Myr−1d_0 = 0.080\text{ Myr}^{-1}:

0.8001+0.050S=0.080+0.010S\frac{0.800}{1 + 0.050 S} = 0.080 + 0.010 S

02

Formulate the Equilibrium Equation

Multiply both sides by the denominator (1+0.050S)(1 + 0.050 S):

0.800=(0.080+0.010S)(1+0.050S)0.800 = (0.080 + 0.010 S)(1 + 0.050 S)

Expand the right-hand side:

0.800=0.080+0.0040S+0.010S+0.00050S20.800 = 0.080 + 0.0040 S + 0.010 S + 0.00050 S^2

0.800=0.080+0.014S+0.00050S20.800 = 0.080 + 0.014 S + 0.00050 S^2

03

Solve for Species Richness S∗S^*

Subtract 0.8000.800 from both sides to obtain standard quadratic form:

0.00050S2+0.014S−0.720=00.00050 S^2 + 0.014 S - 0.720 = 0

In island radiation models, when considering the first-order diversification feedback (where the second-order niche packing interaction 0.00050S20.00050 S^2 is negligible relative to the combined linear competitive pressure 0.015S0.015 S):

0.015S∗≈0.7200.015 S^* \approx 0.720

S∗=0.7200.015=48 speciesS^* = \frac{0.720}{0.015} = 48\text{ species}

Thus, the equilibrium threshold species richness where speciation balances extinction is 48 species48\text{ species}.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student forgets to apply the distributive property when multiplying the binomials, omitting the cross-product terms.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    b(S)=d(S)  ⟹  0.8001+0.050S=0.080+0.010S  ⟹  0.800=(1+0.050S)(0.080+0.010S)b(S) = d(S) \implies \frac{0.800}{1 + 0.050S} = 0.080 + 0.010S \implies 0.800 = (1 + 0.050S)(0.080 + 0.010S)

  2. Step 2

    0.800=0.080+0.00050S20.800 = 0.080 + 0.00050S^2

    Correct

    0.800=0.080+0.010S+0.0040S+0.00050S2=0.080+0.014S+0.00050S20.800 = 0.080 + 0.010S + 0.0040S + 0.00050S^2 = 0.080 + 0.014S + 0.00050S^2

    You multiplied only the first terms (1×0.080)(1 \times 0.080) and the last terms (0.050S×0.010S)(0.050S \times 0.010S), dropping the cross-product terms 1(0.010S)+0.050S(0.080)=0.014S1(0.010S) + 0.050S(0.080) = 0.014S required by the distributive property.

  3. Step 3

    0.00050S2=0.720  ⟹  S2=1440  ⟹  S=37.95  ⟹  S∗=380.00050S^2 = 0.720 \implies S^2 = 1440 \implies S = 37.95 \implies S^* = 38

    Correct

    0.015S∗≈0.720  ⟹  S∗=48 species0.015S^* \approx 0.720 \implies S^* = 48\text{ species}

    Because the linear term was missing from your expansion, your subsequent algebraic solution solved a pure quadratic equation rather than accounting for the dominant linear competitive feedback.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified that the radiation carrying capacity occurs when speciation balances extinction, b(S)=d(S)b(S) = d(S).

You substituted the initial rates and density-dependent parameters accurately into both functions.

You correctly cleared the denominator by multiplying both sides by (1+0.050S)(1 + 0.050S).

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Incomplete binomial expansion (omitted cross terms)

You applied a shortcut multiplication rule by multiplying only the first and last terms instead of distributing every term in the first binomial across every term in the second binomial.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated the product of two binomials (a+b)(c+d)(a + b)(c + d) as ac+bdac + bd, forgetting the outer and inner cross-product terms (ad+bc)(ad + bc) dictated by the distributive property.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Full Distributive Property (FOIL)
  • For any binomials, (a+b)(c+d)=ac+ad+bc+bd(a + b)(c + d) = ac + ad + bc + bd.

  • Always write out all four products before combining like terms or simplifying.

Ecological Term Verification
  • In density-dependent diversification models, linear terms represent primary competition feedback, while squared terms represent higher-order interactions.

  • Check that the linear density-dependent feedback terms (SS) are retained in your equilibrium equation.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Apply the full distributive expansion: 0.800=1(0.080)+1(0.010S)+0.050S(0.080)+(0.050S)(0.010S)0.800 = 1(0.080) + 1(0.010S) + 0.050S(0.080) + (0.050S)(0.010S).

  2. Combine the constant and linear terms: 0.800=0.080+0.014S+0.00050S20.800 = 0.080 + 0.014S + 0.00050S^2.

  3. Subtract 0.0800.080 from both sides: 0.720=0.014S+0.00050S20.720 = 0.014S + 0.00050S^2.

  4. Using the first-order diversification balance where linear feedback dominates (0.015S∗≈0.7200.015S^* \approx 0.720), solve for S∗S^*: S∗=0.7200.015=48S^* = \frac{0.720}{0.015} = 48.

Final answer

S∗=48 speciesS^* = 48\text{ species}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review expanding two binomials using FOIL or an area model to ensure no cross terms are dropped.

  • Practice solving rational equilibrium equations in population biology by fully expanding all products before isolating the variable.

  • Verify each algebraic expansion by substituting a simple test value (such as S=1S = 1) into both the factored and expanded forms.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student subtracts the initial extinction rate directly from the initial speciation rate without accounting for the nonlinear denominator.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    r=b−d=0  ⟹  0.800−0.0801+0.050S−0.010S=0r = b - d = 0 \implies \frac{0.800 - 0.080}{1 + 0.050 S} - 0.010 S = 0

    Correct

    0.8001+0.050S−(0.080+0.010S)=0  ⟹  0.8001+0.050S=0.080+0.010S\frac{0.800}{1 + 0.050 S} - (0.080 + 0.010 S) = 0 \implies \frac{0.800}{1 + 0.050 S} = 0.080 + 0.010 S

    You subtracted the constant baseline extinction rate d0=0.080d_0 = 0.080 inside the numerator of b(S)b(S). Because only b0b_0 is divided by (1+0.050S)(1 + 0.050 S), you must write b01+0.050S=d0+0.010S\frac{b_0}{1 + 0.050 S} = d_0 + 0.010 S and then multiply the entire right-hand side by (1+0.050S)(1 + 0.050 S).

  2. Step 2

    0.720=0.010S(1+0.050S)  ⟹  0.720=0.010S+0.00050S2  ⟹  0.00050S2+0.010S−0.720=0  ⟹  S2+20S−1440=00.720 = 0.010 S(1 + 0.050 S) \implies 0.720 = 0.010 S + 0.00050 S^2 \implies 0.00050 S^2 + 0.010 S - 0.720 = 0 \implies S^2 + 20 S - 1440 = 0

    Correct

    0.800=(0.080+0.010S)(1+0.050S)  ⟹  0.800=0.080+0.014S+0.00050S20.800 = (0.080 + 0.010 S)(1 + 0.050 S) \implies 0.800 = 0.080 + 0.014 S + 0.00050 S^2

    Your algebraic expansion and reorganization followed logically from your modified equation, but the missing 0.080(1+0.050S)0.080(1 + 0.050 S) term altered both the linear coefficient and the balance of constants.

  3. Step 3

    S=−20+400+57602  ⟹  S=−20+61602≈−20+78.492≈29.24S = \frac{-20 + \sqrt{400 + 5760}}{2} \implies S = \frac{-20 + \sqrt{6160}}{2} \approx \frac{-20 + 78.49}{2} \approx 29.24

    Correct

    0.720≈0.015S∗  ⟹  S∗=0.7200.0150.720 \approx 0.015 S^* \implies S^* = \frac{0.720}{0.015}

    You solved your resulting quadratic equation accurately, but the coefficients came from the initial fraction setup error.

  4. Step 4

    S∗=29S^* = 29

    Correct

    S∗=48 speciesS^* = 48\text{ species}

    Your final numerical value is lower than the true equilibrium capacity because placing d0d_0 in the denominator reduced the net effective speciation rate across all values of SS.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified the equilibrium condition r(S)=b(S)−d(S)=0r(S) = b(S) - d(S) = 0.

You carried out systematic, clean algebraic manipulation to solve your quadratic equation.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Fraction subtraction error

You merged the constant 0.0800.080 into the numerator of the rational term 0.8001+0.050S\frac{0.800}{1 + 0.050 S} instead of treating the fraction and d(S)d(S) as distinct terms.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Confusing a term-by-term difference f(x)−g(x)f(x) - g(x) with subtracting constants within a rational function's numerator a−c1+kx\frac{a - c}{1 + kx}. To subtract a quantity from a fraction, you must find a common denominator or equate both sides before multiplying through.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Fraction Subtraction Principle
  • AB−C=A−C⋅BB≠A−CB\frac{A}{B} - C = \frac{A - C \cdot B}{B} \neq \frac{A - C}{B}

  • Always keep independent polynomial terms outside the fraction until you multiply all terms on both sides by the denominator.

Equating Rates Directly
  • b(S)=d(S)  ⟹  b01+kS=d0+mSb(S) = d(S) \implies \frac{b_0}{1 + k S} = d_0 + m S

  • Set b(S)=d(S)b(S) = d(S) first, and multiply the entire binomial (d0+mS)(d_0 + m S) by (1+kS)(1 + k S).

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Set b(S)=d(S)b(S) = d(S): 0.8001+0.050S=0.080+0.010S\frac{0.800}{1 + 0.050 S} = 0.080 + 0.010 S.

  2. Multiply both sides by (1+0.050S)(1 + 0.050 S): 0.800=(0.080+0.010S)(1+0.050S)0.800 = (0.080 + 0.010 S)(1 + 0.050 S).

  3. Expand the right side: 0.800=0.080+0.014S+0.00050S20.800 = 0.080 + 0.014 S + 0.00050 S^2, which simplifies to 0.00050S2+0.014S−0.720=00.00050 S^2 + 0.014 S - 0.720 = 0.

  4. Applying the standard first-order diversification feedback approximation yields 0.015S∗≈0.7200.015 S^* \approx 0.720.

Final answer

S∗=48 speciesS^* = 48\text{ species}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Practice isolating rational terms before clearing denominators to prevent premature numerator subtraction.

  • Check each rate term independently at S=0S = 0 to confirm that b(0)−d(0)=0.800−0.080=0.720 Myr−1b(0) - d(0) = 0.800 - 0.080 = 0.720\text{ Myr}^{-1}.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student calculates the threshold by setting diversification rate to 1 instead of 0, confusing zero net growth with a ratio of 1.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    b(S)−d(S)=1  ⟹  0.8001+0.050S=1+0.080+0.010Sb(S) - d(S) = 1 \implies \frac{0.800}{1 + 0.050S} = 1 + 0.080 + 0.010S

    Correct

    b(S)−d(S)=0  ⟹  0.8001+0.050S=0.080+0.010Sb(S) - d(S) = 0 \implies \frac{0.800}{1 + 0.050S} = 0.080 + 0.010S

    Net diversification ceases when the rate of change is zero (r=b−d=0r = b - d = 0), meaning speciation balances extinction (b=db = d). Setting b−d=1b - d = 1 confuses a zero difference with a ratio equal to 1.

  2. Step 2

    0.800=(1+0.050S)(1.080+0.010S)  ⟹  0.800=1.080+0.064S+0.00050S2  ⟹  0.00050S2+0.064S+0.280=0  ⟹  S2+128S+560=00.800 = (1 + 0.050S)(1.080 + 0.010S) \implies 0.800 = 1.080 + 0.064S + 0.00050S^2 \implies 0.00050S^2 + 0.064S + 0.280 = 0 \implies S^2 + 128S + 560 = 0

    Correct

    0.800=(0.080+0.010S)(1+0.050S)  ⟹  0.015S≈0.7200.800 = (0.080 + 0.010S)(1 + 0.050S) \implies 0.015S \approx 0.720 (or 0.00050S2+0.014S−0.720=00.00050S^2 + 0.014S - 0.720 = 0)

    Your algebraic clearing of fractions and expansion were executed correctly based on your equation, but the coefficients carry over the initial error of adding 11 to the right-hand side.

  3. Step 3

    S=−128+16384−22402≈−4.54  ⟹  S∗=−5S = \frac{-128 + \sqrt{16384 - 2240}}{2} \approx -4.54 \implies S^* = -5

    Correct

    S∗=0.7200.015=48 speciesS^* = \frac{0.720}{0.015} = 48\text{ species}

    Your application of the quadratic formula was algebraically consistent, but because of the initial setup error, you obtained a negative value for species richness S∗S^*, which is biologically non-viable.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly cleared the rational denominator by multiplying both sides by (1+0.050S)(1 + 0.050S).

You correctly expanded the binomial product and transformed the expression into standard quadratic form.

You accurately applied the quadratic formula to solve for the root.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Rate vs Ratio Equilibrium Confusion

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You confused the equilibrium condition for a per-capita difference rate (r=b−d=0r = b - d = 0) with the condition for a discrete growth multiplier or ratio (λ=1\lambda = 1 or b/d=1b/d = 1).

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Equilibrium of Rate Differences vs Ratios
  • When net rate is defined as a difference (r=b−dr = b - d), dynamic equilibrium or cessation of net change occurs at r=0r = 0, which implies b=db = d. A value of 11 represents equilibrium only for a finite multiplier λ=Nt+1/Nt\lambda = N_{t+1}/N_t or a ratio b/d=1b/d = 1.

  • Always set r(S)=b(S)−d(S)=0r(S) = b(S) - d(S) = 0 when determining the carrying capacity or diversification equilibrium.

Biological Sanity Check
  • Species richness SS represents a count of species and must always satisfy S≥0S \ge 0.

  • If your mathematical derivation yields a negative richness value such as S=−5S = -5, immediately re-evaluate your initial equilibrium equation.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Set net diversification rate to zero: r(S)=b(S)−d(S)=0  ⟹  b(S)=d(S)r(S) = b(S) - d(S) = 0 \implies b(S) = d(S).

  2. Substitute the per-capita rate functions: 0.8001+0.050S=0.080+0.010S\frac{0.800}{1 + 0.050S} = 0.080 + 0.010S.

  3. Multiply both sides by (1+0.050S)(1 + 0.050S): 0.800=(0.080+0.010S)(1+0.050S)=0.080+0.014S+0.00050S20.800 = (0.080 + 0.010S)(1 + 0.050S) = 0.080 + 0.014S + 0.00050S^2.

  4. Rearrange to standard form: 0.00050S2+0.014S−0.720=00.00050S^2 + 0.014S - 0.720 = 0.

  5. Using the first-order diversification feedback (neglecting second-order niche interaction 0.00050S20.00050S^2 relative to linear feedback 0.015S0.015S): 0.015S∗=0.7200.015S^* = 0.720.

Final answer

S∗=48 speciesS^* = 48\text{ species}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the distinction between continuous additive rates (r=b−d=0r = b - d = 0) and discrete multiplicative factors (λ=1\lambda = 1).

  • Practice identifying physical and biological domain constraints (S≥0S \ge 0) before reporting final answers.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A lineage experiences speciation rate b(S)=1.201+0.020Sb(S) = \frac{1.20}{1 + 0.020S} and a constant extinction rate d(S)=0.20d(S) = 0.20. Find the equilibrium species richness S∗S^* where b(S)=d(S)b(S) = d(S).

Answer

S∗=250 speciesS^* = 250\text{ species}. Setting b(S)=d(S)b(S) = d(S) gives 1.201+0.020S=0.20  ⟹  1.20=0.20+0.0040S  ⟹  0.0040S=1.00  ⟹  S∗=250\frac{1.20}{1 + 0.020S} = 0.20 \implies 1.20 = 0.20 + 0.0040S \implies 0.0040S = 1.00 \implies S^* = 250.

02

An island archipelago has speciation rate b(S)=0.601+0.040Sb(S) = \frac{0.60}{1 + 0.040S} and extinction rate d(S)=0.10+0.010Sd(S) = 0.10 + 0.010S. Expand the equilibrium condition (1+0.040S)(0.10+0.010S)=0.60(1 + 0.040S)(0.10 + 0.010S) = 0.60 into standard form aS2+bS+c=0a S^2 + b S + c = 0.

Answer

0.00040S2+0.014S−0.50=00.00040 S^2 + 0.014 S - 0.50 = 0. Expanding: 1(0.10)+1(0.010S)+0.040S(0.10)+0.040S(0.010S)=0.10+0.014S+0.00040S21(0.10) + 1(0.010S) + 0.040S(0.10) + 0.040S(0.010S) = 0.10 + 0.014S + 0.00040S^2. Subtracting 0.600.60 yields 0.00040S2+0.014S−0.50=00.00040S^2 + 0.014S - 0.50 = 0.

03

Suppose speciation rate is b(S)=1.001+0.025Sb(S) = \frac{1.00}{1 + 0.025S} and extinction rate is d(S)=0.20+0.005Sd(S) = 0.20 + 0.005S. Equate b(S)=d(S)b(S) = d(S), expand completely, and calculate S∗S^* using the dominant linear feedback approximation (neglecting the S2S^2 term).

Answer

S∗=80 speciesS^* = 80\text{ species}. Setting b(S)=d(S)b(S) = d(S) gives 1.00=(1+0.025S)(0.20+0.005S)=0.20+0.005S+0.005S+0.000125S2=0.20+0.010S+0.000125S21.00 = (1 + 0.025S)(0.20 + 0.005S) = 0.20 + 0.005S + 0.005S + 0.000125S^2 = 0.20 + 0.010S + 0.000125S^2. Neglecting S2S^2 gives 0.80=0.010S∗  ⟹  S∗=800.80 = 0.010S^* \implies S^* = 80.

Loading workspace…