Resources
A diploid model organism has a somatic chromosome number of . A cytogeneticist prepares a stained squash of testicular tissue and observes a dividing meiocyte. Microscopic examination reveals homologous chromosome pairs aligned linearly along the equatorial plate of the spindle apparatus, with spindle fibers from opposite poles attached to the kinetochores of each homologue. Identify the specific sub-stage of meiosis observed, and state the exact number of physical chromosomes and chromatids present in this single cell at this stage.
Answer and steps
Final answer
Metaphase I; chromosomes ( bivalents/tetrads) and chromatids.
Steps
Identify the Specific Stage of Meiosis
To determine the exact stage, examine the key structural arrangement described:
- Alignment of homologous pairs: The chromosomes are arranged along the equatorial plane (metaphase plate) as homologous pairs (also called bivalents or tetrads).
- Spindle fiber attachment: Spindle microtubules from opposite poles attach to the kinetochores of each homologous chromosome (one homologue facing each pole), preparing them to separate into two daughter cells during anaphase I.
In mitotic metaphase and metaphase II, individual chromosomes line up single-file along the plate, with sister kinetochores attached to opposite poles. The alignment of paired homologues is unique to Metaphase I.
Determine the Number of Chromosomes
- The organism is diploid with , meaning somatic cells and meiocytes prior to the first meiotic division contain chromosomes.
- In metaphase I, the chromosomes are organized into pairs of homologous chromosomes ( bivalents or tetrads).
- Because a chromosome is defined by the presence of a centromere, the cell still contains physical chromosomes.
Determine the Number of Chromatids
- Chromosomes replicate during the preceding S phase of interphase.
- At metaphase I, each chromosome consists of identical sister chromatids joined at a common centromere.
- Multiplying the number of chromosomes by the number of chromatids per chromosome gives:
Common Pitfall
- Confusing Metaphase I and Metaphase II: In metaphase I, chromosomes align in pairs (double row of chromatids across the plate), whereas in metaphase II, the cell is haploid () and individual chromosomes align single-file.
- Counting Bivalents as Chromosomes: A bivalent contains complete chromosomes ( chromatids). Do not count a pair of homologues as a single chromosome.
Conclusion: The stage is Metaphase I, with chromosomes ( bivalents/tetrads) and chromatids.
Typical errors
01 The student confuses the alignment of homologous pairs in Metaphase I with the alignment of individual chromosomes in Metaphase II.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1Correct
Homologous chromosome pairs aligned together along the equatorial plate with kinetochores of each homologue facing opposite poles is the defining hallmark of Metaphase I. In Metaphase II, individual duplicated chromosomes line up single-file.
- Step 2Correct
Because the cell is in Meiosis I before reduction division takes place, the meiocyte is still diploid and contains all physical chromosomes.
- Step 3Correct
Your reasoning that each chromosome contains two sister chromatids was sound, but with duplicated chromosomes present at this stage, the total is chromatids.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou recognized that duplicated chromosomes at metaphase consist of two sister chromatids each.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakenone
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou confused the double-file alignment of homologous pairs (bivalents) in Metaphase I with the single-file alignment of individual chromosomes in Metaphase II, leading you to treat the cell as already reduced to haploid ().
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Alignment pattern at the metaphase plate
Alignment of paired homologues (tetrads/bivalents) indicates Metaphase I; alignment of individual chromosomes in a single line indicates Metaphase II or Mitosis.
Look for phrases like 'homologous chromosome pairs aligned' or 'attachment to each homologue' to immediately identify Meiosis I.
- Timing of ploidy reduction
Ploidy drops from to only after homologous pairs separate and daughter cells form at the end of Meiosis I (Telophase I / Cytokinesis).
Keep the chromosome count at the full diploid number () for all stages of Meiosis I.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationIdentify the stage from the paired arrangement: homologous chromosome pairs lining up at the spindle equator indicates Metaphase I.
Determine chromosome count: Meiosis I has not yet separated homologues into daughter cells, so the cell remains diploid with physical chromosomes organized into bivalents.
Calculate chromatid count: each of the duplicated chromosomes consists of sister chromatids, yielding chromatids.
Metaphase I; chromosomes and chromatids.
02 The student correctly identifies Metaphase I but counts each sister chromatid as a separate chromosome, doubling the chromosome count.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
- Step 2Correct
You multiplied the diploid number by , treating each sister chromatid as an independent chromosome. A chromosome is defined and counted by its functional centromere; after DNA replication in S phase, each chromosome consists of sister chromatids joined at one centromere, so the chromosome count remains .
- Step 3
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly identified the meiotic stage as Metaphase I by recognizing the alignment of paired homologues.
You correctly determined that the cell contains sister chromatids.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou treated each duplicated sister chromatid as an individual chromosome rather than counting physical chromosomes by their centromeres.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Count Centromeres to Count Chromosomes
One functional centromere equals one chromosome, regardless of whether it consists of one unduplicated chromatid or two replicated sister chromatids.
Count the number of centromeres in the cell. If a diploid cell starts with , it still has chromosomes in Metaphase I because sister chromatids remain attached at shared centromeres.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationIdentify the ploidy and chromosome count: for an organism with , the meiocyte begins meiosis with chromosomes organized into homologous pairs (bivalents/tetrads).
Recall that DNA replication in S phase doubles the DNA quantity and forms sister chromatids, but does not change the chromosome count because sister chromatids share a centromere.
State the chromosome count: there are physical chromosomes.
Metaphase I; chromosomes ( bivalents/tetrads) and chromatids.
03 The student misinterprets 2n = 8 as n = 8, believing the haploid number is 8 and incorrectly scaling the total counts.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
Metaphase I
- Step 2
chromosomes
Correctchromosomes ()
The problem states that the diploid somatic number is . You treated as the haploid number and doubled it to , but the cell at this stage contains the original diploid number of physical chromosomes arranged in bivalents.
- Step 3
chromatids
Correctchromatids
Your reasoning that each chromosome consists of sister chromatids is correct, but your calculation was affected by using chromosomes instead of .
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly recognized the cytological hallmark of Metaphase I from the alignment of homologous pairs.
You applied the correct relationship that each replicated chromosome contains two sister chromatids.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou interpreted the given value in as the haploid number , inadvertently calculating instead of recognizing that is already the total diploid chromosome number ().
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Interpret Ploidy Notation Directly
When a problem states , the value is already the total somatic (diploid) chromosome count; the haploid count is .
Read as 'the full diploid set is chromosomes,' meaning homologous pairs.
- Count Centromeres for Chromosome Number
One physical chromosome equals one centromere, regardless of whether it consists of one unduplicated chromatid or two sister chromatids.
In Metaphase I, count the distinct centromeres ( homologous pairs), giving chromosomes and chromatids.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationThe diploid number is given directly as , so a primary meiocyte entering Metaphase I has physical chromosomes.
These chromosomes pair up into homologous bivalents (tetrads).
Because DNA replication occurred during S phase, each of the chromosomes consists of sister chromatids: chromatids.
Metaphase I; chromosomes and chromatids.
Lock it in
How does the alignment of chromosomes along the equatorial plate differ between Metaphase I and Metaphase II?
In Metaphase I, homologous pairs (bivalents/tetrads) align in pairs; in Metaphase II, individual chromosomes align single-file.
Similar question
A diploid plant has . A pollen mother cell is observed during Metaphase I. How many bivalents, total chromosomes, and chromatids are present in this cell?
Answer
bivalents, chromosomes, and chromatids. In Metaphase I, homologous chromosomes pair up into bivalents (tetrads). The cell is still diploid ( centromeres), and each duplicated chromosome contains sister chromatids ().
During a cytogenetic assay of an insect with , an investigator notes a cell where individual, non-paired chromosomes are aligned linearly along the metaphase plate, with sister kinetochores connected to opposite spindle poles. Name the specific stage and give the number of chromatids in this cell.
Answer
Metaphase II, with chromatids. Individual chromosomes aligned single-file in a cell with half the somatic count () indicates Metaphase II. With replicated chromosomes, there are chromatids.
A mammalian meiocyte with undergoes meiosis. Specify the exact chromosome and chromatid counts in a single cell at: (a) Anaphase I, and (b) Anaphase II immediately after sister chromatids pull apart.
Answer
(a) Anaphase I: chromosomes and chromatids (homologues separate, but sister chromatids remain conjoined at centromeres). (b) Anaphase II: chromosomes and chromatids (centromeres split in the haploid cell, momentarily doubling the chromosome count from to individual single-chromatid chromosomes).