Resources
A diploid somatic cell from an African clawed frog () contains chromosomes. At the start of phase, this cell contains of nuclear DNA. Assume the cell completes DNA replication during S phase and subsequently divides. Calculate: (a) the number of chromosomes and the mass of nuclear DNA (in ) per cell at metaphase of mitosis, (b) the number of chromosomes and the mass of nuclear DNA per cell at metaphase I of meiosis, and (c) the number of chromosomes and the mass of nuclear DNA per resulting daughter cell upon completion of meiosis II.
Answer and steps
Final answer
(a) chromosomes, DNA; (b) chromosomes, DNA; (c) chromosomes, DNA.
Steps
To track the chromosome number and DNA content throughout cell division, distinguish between the count of chromosomes (determined by the number of functional centromeres) and the mass of DNA (determined by the total amount of genetic material).
Baseline State ( Phase)
- Chromosome number (): chromosomes.
- DNA content (): .
During the S phase of interphase, each chromosome replicates to form two identical sister chromatids joined at a single centromere.
- Because sister chromatids remain joined at one centromere, the chromosome count remains unchanged ().
- Because the DNA has doubled, the total mass of DNA doubles to ().
(a) Metaphase of Mitosis
- Chromosome number: The replicated chromosomes align individually along the metaphase plate. Since sister chromatids have not yet separated, each replicated unit counts as one chromosome:
- DNA mass: DNA replication occurred in S phase, and no division has taken place yet:
(b) Metaphase I of Meiosis
- Chromosome number: In metaphase I, homologous chromosomes pair up to form bivalents (tetrads) along the metaphase plate. Although paired, there are still individual centromere-bearing chromosomes present in the cell:
- DNA mass: Meiosis I is preceded by a single round of DNA replication in premeiotic interphase. No cellular division has occurred yet:
(c) Completion of Meiosis II
Meiosis consists of two successive division events following one round of replication:
- Meiosis I: Homologous chromosomes separate into two daughter cells. Each intermediate daughter cell receives chromosomes and half of the DNA ().
- Meiosis II: Sister chromatids separate, distributing one chromatid of each chromosome into each of the resulting gametes.
- Chromosome number: The final gametes are haploid ():
- DNA mass: The DNA content is halved again from the intermediate state () or reduced to one-quarter of the mass ():
Summary Pitfall to Avoid
A common error is confusing chromatids with chromosomes. Replicated chromosomes with two sister chromatids are still counted as single chromosomes as long as they are attached at a shared centromere. Therefore, the chromosome count does not double during S phase; only the DNA mass doubles.
Typical errors
01 The student confuses replicated chromatids with separate chromosomes after S phase, incorrectly doubling the chromosome count at mitotic metaphase to 72.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
After S phase replication, each chromosome doubles to 2 chromosomes Number of chromosomes = ; DNA replicates:
CorrectNumber of chromosomes = ; Mass of nuclear DNA =
During S phase, DNA replicates so the DNA mass doubles to , which you calculated correctly. However, each chromosome replicates into two identical sister chromatids that remain attached at a single centromere. Because chromosome count is defined by the number of functional centromeres, the cell still contains chromosomes at metaphase of mitosis, not .
- Step 2
Number of chromosomes = ; Mass of nuclear DNA =
- Step 3
Number of chromosomes = ; Mass of nuclear DNA =
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly doubled the DNA mass from to after S phase.
You correctly identified the chromosome count of at metaphase I of meiosis.
You correctly calculated the final haploid chromosome count () and DNA mass () after meiosis II.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou assumed that DNA replication in S phase doubles the chromosome count rather than forming paired sister chromatids sharing one centromere.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou treated each newly replicated sister chromatid as an independent chromosome before anaphase separation, conflating total DNA strands or chromatids with centromere-defined chromosome units.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Counting Rule for Chromosomes
One functional centromere equals one chromosome, regardless of whether it consists of one chromatid (unreplicated) or two sister chromatids (replicated).
Count centromeres, not chromatids, when determining chromosome number before anaphase.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationA cell in has unreplicated chromosomes and of DNA.
In S phase, DNA replicates to form two sister chromatids joined at a single shared centromere per chromosome.
Because the sister chromatids have not separated, the chromosome count remains , while the DNA mass doubles to .
(a) chromosomes, DNA; (b) chromosomes, DNA; (c) chromosomes, DNA
02 The student treats homologous chromosome pairs at metaphase I as already reducing the chromosome count to n, concluding there are 18 chromosomes instead of 36.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
Number of chromosomes = 36 Mass of nuclear DNA = 8.0 pg
- Step 2
Homologous chromosomes pair up into 18 bivalents, so chromosome number is halved Number of chromosomes = 18, DNA is replicated: 4.0 pg 2 = 8.0 pg
Correctchromosomes, DNA
You correctly doubled the DNA mass to , but pairing into bivalents does not reduce the chromosome count of the cell. Chromosome count is defined by the number of functional centromeres; because the cell has not yet divided, all chromosomes are still present in this single cell.
- Step 3
Number of chromosomes = 18 Mass of nuclear DNA = 2.0 pg
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly calculated the chromosome number () and DNA mass () at mitotic metaphase.
You correctly identified that premeiotic replication doubles the nuclear DNA mass to .
You correctly calculated the final chromosome count () and DNA mass () in gametes at the end of meiosis II.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou assumed that because homologous chromosomes associate into bivalents (tetrads) at metaphase I, the chromosome number per cell is halved to . In reality, chromosome count is determined strictly by the number of centromeres in the cell. Pairing does not merge or eliminate centromeres, and physical reduction from to only happens after homologous chromosomes are segregated into separate daughter cells at the end of meiosis I.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Centromere Principle
The number of chromosomes in a cell always equals the total number of functional centromeres, regardless of whether chromosomes are replicated or paired.
Count the total centromeres present in the cell before looking at pairing configurations.
- Timing of Reduction Division
Reduction in chromosome number occurs only upon physical cytokinesis of meiosis I, never during metaphase I when homologs are merely aligned.
Keep the full diploid count () for all stages of meiosis I up to cytokinesis I.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationObserve that at metaphase I, the cell has completed DNA replication and chromosome pairing, but has not yet undergone division.
Recall that bivalents represent pairs of homologous chromosomes, meaning there are distinct chromosomes (and centromeres) inside this single cell.
Conclude that the chromosome number per cell at metaphase I is , and the nuclear DNA mass is .
(a) chromosomes, DNA; (b) chromosomes, DNA; (c) chromosomes, DNA.
03 The student assumes completion of meiosis II halves DNA content from the G1 level of 4.0 pg rather than accounting for the pre-meiotic S phase replication, calculating 1.0 pg instead of 2.0 pg.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
Number of chromosomes = ⟹ Mass of nuclear DNA =
- Step 2
Number of chromosomes = ⟹ Mass of nuclear DNA =
- Step 3
Completion of meiosis produces haploid cells with chromosomes ⟹ Meiosis divides starting G1 DNA content by 4 ⟹ Mass of nuclear DNA =
CorrectNumber of chromosomes = , Mass of nuclear DNA = (or )
You correctly found that gametes are haploid with chromosomes, but you divided the unreplicated DNA content (, ) by . Because S phase doubles the DNA to () before the two successive meiotic divisions, dividing among 4 gametes yields () per cell.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly tracked chromosome count by functional centromeres rather than chromatid number.
You correctly identified that premeiotic interphase replicates DNA to double its mass ().
You correctly deduced that meiosis produces haploid daughter cells with chromosomes.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou treated the starting DNA content () as the total pool divided among the four meiotic products, overlooking that S phase produces a pool prior to meiosis I and II, so each resulting haploid cell receives (half of , not one-quarter).
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Relate $C$-value to Ploidy ($n$)
A diploid cell has ploidy and DNA amount . After S phase it has chromosomes and DNA. A completed meiotic gamete has ploidy and DNA amount .
Always check whether your final cell is haploid (); its DNA mass should equal half of the diploid () value.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationEach daughter cell receives of DNA: (or ).
(a) chromosomes, DNA; (b) chromosomes, DNA; (c) chromosomes, DNA
Lock it in
How do you determine the total number of chromosomes present in a eukaryotic cell during prophase or metaphase?
Count the number of functional centromeres. Even though each chromosome has two sister chromatids after S phase, it is still counted as one chromosome until the centromere divides.
Similar question
A diploid somatic cell of a fruit fly () has chromosomes and of nuclear DNA in phase. State the number of chromosomes, the number of chromatids, and the mass of nuclear DNA (in ) per cell at mitotic metaphase.
Answer
chromosomes, chromatids, and DNA. During S phase, each of the chromosomes replicates into sister chromatids sharing one centromere ( centromeres total), doubling the DNA mass from to .
In a mammal with chromosomes and of DNA in a spermatogonium, what are the chromosome number and DNA mass per cell at: (a) anaphase of mitosis, and (b) anaphase I of meiosis?
Answer
(a) Mitotic anaphase: chromosomes and DNA (centromeres split, temporarily doubling the chromosome count). (b) Anaphase I of meiosis: chromosomes and DNA (homologous chromosomes separate, but sister centromeres remain intact).
A plant species has a somatic chromosome number of and a nuclear DNA content of . Complete the comparison table for a single cell at: (1) metaphase of mitosis, (2) anaphase II of meiosis, and (3) a mature pollen grain nucleus ( gametophyte cell). Give the chromosome number and DNA content in for each.
Answer
(1) Mitotic metaphase: chromosomes, DNA (). (2) Anaphase II of meiosis: chromosomes, DNA (sister chromatids split in a haploid cell, temporarily making single-chromatid chromosomes with DNA). (3) Mature pollen nucleus: chromosomes (), DNA ().