Resources

In an alpine plant species, leaf trichome density is a heritable polygenic trait. Following the introduction of an invasive herbivorous beetle, an evolutionary biologist observes that the surviving adult population has an increased mean trichome density of 48.0 hairs/mm248.0\text{ hairs/mm}^2, up from an original pre-herbivory population mean of 32.0 hairs/mm232.0\text{ hairs/mm}^2. If the narrow-sense heritability (h2h^2) of trichome density in this population is known to be 0.4000.400, calculate: (a) the selection differential (SS) imposed by the herbivore selection pressure, and (b) the expected evolutionary response (RR) in trichome density in the next generation.

Answer and steps

Final answer

(a) Selection differential: S=xˉselected−xˉinitial=48.0 hairs/mm2−32.0 hairs/mm2=16.0 hairs/mm2S = \bar{x}_{\text{selected}} - \bar{x}_{\text{initial}} = 48.0\text{ hairs/mm}^2 - 32.0\text{ hairs/mm}^2 = 16.0\text{ hairs/mm}^2; (b) Expected evolutionary response: R=h2×S=0.400×16.0 hairs/mm2=6.40 hairs/mm2R = h^2 \times S = 0.400 \times 16.0\text{ hairs/mm}^2 = 6.40\text{ hairs/mm}^2 (predicting a mean trichome density of 38.4 hairs/mm238.4\text{ hairs/mm}^2 in the next generation).

Steps

01

Identify the given quantitative genetics parameters

  • Pre-selection parental population mean (xˉinitial\bar{x}_{\text{initial}}): 32.0 hairs/mm232.0\text{ hairs/mm}^2
  • Selected reproducing parental mean (xˉselected\bar{x}_{\text{selected}}): 48.0 hairs/mm248.0\text{ hairs/mm}^2
  • Narrow-sense heritability (h2h^2): 0.4000.400

02

Calculate the selection differential (SS)

The selection differential (SS) quantifies the strength of phenotypic selection within a single generation. It represents the difference between the mean trait value of the reproducing individuals surviving selection and the mean trait value of the entire parental population before selection:

S=xˉselected−xˉinitialS = \bar{x}_{\text{selected}} - \bar{x}_{\text{initial}}

Substitute the values:

S=48.0 hairs/mm2−32.0 hairs/mm2=16.0 hairs/mm2S = 48.0\text{ hairs/mm}^2 - 32.0\text{ hairs/mm}^2 = 16.0\text{ hairs/mm}^2


03

Calculate the expected evolutionary response (RR)

The evolutionary change across generations is predicted using the Breeder's Equation:

R=h2⋅SR = h^2 \cdot S

Where:

  • RR is the evolutionary response to selection (the expected difference in the mean trait value between the offspring generation and the original parental generation).
  • h2h^2 is the narrow-sense heritability, representing the proportion of total phenotypic variance attributable to additive genetic variance (VA/VPV_A / V_P).
  • SS is the selection differential.

Substitute the values:

R=0.400⋅16.0 hairs/mm2=6.40 hairs/mm2R = 0.400 \cdot 16.0\text{ hairs/mm}^2 = 6.40\text{ hairs/mm}^2


04

Interpret the result and determine the new generation's mean

The evolutionary response of 6.40 hairs/mm26.40\text{ hairs/mm}^2 means that the offspring generation is expected to have a higher mean trichome density than the original baseline population:

xˉoffspring=xˉinitial+R=32.0 hairs/mm2+6.40 hairs/mm2=38.4 hairs/mm2\bar{x}_{\text{offspring}} = \bar{x}_{\text{initial}} + R = 32.0\text{ hairs/mm}^2 + 6.40\text{ hairs/mm}^2 = 38.4\text{ hairs/mm}^2

Key Pitfall: Do not confuse the selection differential (SS) with the evolutionary response (RR). While selection shifted the surviving parent mean by 16.0 hairs/mm216.0\text{ hairs/mm}^2, only 40%40\% of this variation is due to additive genetic effects (h2=0.400h^2 = 0.400). Because environmental and non-additive effects are not passed faithfully to offspring, the trans-generational response (R=6.40 hairs/mm2R = 6.40\text{ hairs/mm}^2) is smaller than the within-generation selection differential (SS).

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student misinterprets the narrow-sense heritability symbol h² as needing to be squared, calculating (0.400)² instead of using 0.400 directly in the breeder's equation.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    S=48.0−32.0  ⟹  S=16.0 hairs/mm2S = 48.0 - 32.0 \implies S = 16.0\text{ hairs/mm}^2

  2. Step 2

    R=(h2)2×S  ⟹  R=(0.400)2×16.0  ⟹  R=0.160×16.0  ⟹  R=2.56 hairs/mm2R = (h^2)^2 \times S \implies R = (0.400)^2 \times 16.0 \implies R = 0.160 \times 16.0 \implies R = 2.56\text{ hairs/mm}^2

    Correct

    R=h2×S=0.400×16.0 hairs/mm2=6.40 hairs/mm2R = h^2 \times S = 0.400 \times 16.0\text{ hairs/mm}^2 = 6.40\text{ hairs/mm}^2

    In quantitative genetics, the symbol h2h^2 represents narrow-sense heritability as a single consolidated term (VA/VP=0.400V_A / V_P = 0.400). The superscript 22 is part of the standard notation, not an algebraic operation instructing you to square the given value.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified and applied the formula for the selection differential SS.

You carried out the arithmetic multiplication accurately based on your chosen formula.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Misinterpreting variable notation as an exponent

You squared the given heritability value (0.400)2(0.400)^2 because of the superscript 22 in the symbol h2h^2.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Confusing conventional parameter notation with mathematical exponentiation. In quantitative genetics, narrow-sense heritability is defined as h2=VA/VPh^2 = V_A / V_P, where h2h^2 is treated as an indivisible variable rather than a base hh raised to the second power.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Treat $h^2$ as an indivisible parameter
  • In the Breeder's equation R=h2SR = h^2 S, the quantity h2h^2 is the narrow-sense heritability itself.

  • Substitute the given heritability value directly into h2h^2 without squaring it again.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. State the Breeder's equation: R=h2×SR = h^2 \times S.

  2. Substitute h2=0.400h^2 = 0.400 and S=16.0 hairs/mm2S = 16.0\text{ hairs/mm}^2 directly into the formula: R=0.400×16.0 hairs/mm2R = 0.400 \times 16.0\text{ hairs/mm}^2.

  3. Calculate the final product: R=6.40 hairs/mm2R = 6.40\text{ hairs/mm}^2.

Final answer

(a) S=16.0 hairs/mm2S = 16.0\text{ hairs/mm}^2; (b) R=6.40 hairs/mm2R = 6.40\text{ hairs/mm}^2

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Remember that h2h^2 denotes narrow-sense heritability as an intact symbol, so you do not need to square or take the square root of the given heritability value.

  • Double-check that the calculated response RR is proportional to SS by the factor h2h^2, meaning R≤SR \le S whenever 0≤h2≤10 \le h^2 \le 1.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student calculates the mean phenotype of the next generation rather than the evolutionary response itself by adding the response R to the parental population mean.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Correct
  1. Step 1

    S=48.0−32.0=16.0 hairs/mm2S = 48.0 - 32.0 = 16.0\text{ hairs/mm}^2

  2. Step 2

    R=h2×S=0.400×16.0=6.4 hairs/mm2R = h^2 \times S = 0.400 \times 16.0 = 6.4\text{ hairs/mm}^2

  3. Step 3

    Next generation mean=32.0+6.4=38.4 hairs/mm2\text{Next generation mean} = 32.0 + 6.4 = 38.4\text{ hairs/mm}^2

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly calculated the selection differential as S=16.0 hairs/mm2S = 16.0\text{ hairs/mm}^2.

You accurately applied the Breeder's equation to compute the evolutionary response as R=6.4 hairs/mm2R = 6.4\text{ hairs/mm}^2.

You correctly interpreted the biological meaning of RR by calculating the new population mean.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Response vs. New Population Mean
  • The evolutionary response RR represents the change in trait mean (Δxˉ\Delta \bar{x}), while the next generation mean is xˉnew=xˉinitial+R\bar{x}_{\text{new}} = \bar{x}_{\text{initial}} + R.

  • When a question specifically asks for the evolutionary response RR, ensure RR is clearly highlighted as the final answer so it is not confused with the resulting new population mean.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. State the selection differential: S=16.0 hairs/mm2S = 16.0\text{ hairs/mm}^2.

  2. State the evolutionary response: R=6.40 hairs/mm2R = 6.40\text{ hairs/mm}^2.

  3. (Optional extension) Predict the next generation mean: xˉoffspring=38.4 hairs/mm2\bar{x}_{\text{offspring}} = 38.4\text{ hairs/mm}^2.

Final answer

(a) S=16.0 hairs/mm2S = 16.0\text{ hairs/mm}^2; (b) R=6.40 hairs/mm2R = 6.40\text{ hairs/mm}^2

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Practice problems where you solve for narrow-sense heritability (h2h^2) given SS and RR.

  • Explore how natural selection changes trait variance versus trait mean.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student confuses the selection differential with the response and divides the selection differential by the heritability instead of multiplying.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    S=48.0−32.0  ⟹  S=16.0 hairs/mm2S = 48.0 - 32.0 \implies S = 16.0\text{ hairs/mm}^2

  2. Step 2

    R=Sh2=16.00.400=40.0 hairs/mm2R = \frac{S}{h^2} = \frac{16.0}{0.400} = 40.0\text{ hairs/mm}^2

    Correct

    R=h2⋅S=0.400×16.0 hairs/mm2=6.40 hairs/mm2R = h^2 \cdot S = 0.400 \times 16.0\text{ hairs/mm}^2 = 6.40\text{ hairs/mm}^2

    The Breeder's Equation is R=h2⋅SR = h^2 \cdot S, which multiplies the selection differential by the narrow-sense heritability rather than dividing.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified the parental population means and subtracted them to find the selection differential S=16.0 hairs/mm2S = 16.0\text{ hairs/mm}^2.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Breeder's Equation formula inversion

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated heritability as a divisor rather than a scaling fraction, producing an evolutionary response larger than the selection differential itself.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Breeder's Equation scaling check
  • The evolutionary response across generations is given by R=h2⋅SR = h^2 \cdot S.

  • Multiply the selection differential SS by h2h^2, remembering that because 0≤h2≤10 \le h^2 \le 1, the evolutionary response RR cannot exceed SS under directional selection.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. State the Breeder's Equation: R=h2⋅SR = h^2 \cdot S.

  2. Substitute the given heritability h2=0.400h^2 = 0.400 and your calculated S=16.0 hairs/mm2S = 16.0\text{ hairs/mm}^2: R=0.400×16.0R = 0.400 \times 16.0.

  3. Compute the product: R=6.40 hairs/mm2R = 6.40\text{ hairs/mm}^2.

Final answer

(a) S=16.0 hairs/mm2S = 16.0\text{ hairs/mm}^2; (b) R=6.40 hairs/mm2R = 6.40\text{ hairs/mm}^2

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Memorize the standard Breeder's Equation as R=h2⋅SR = h^2 \cdot S.

  • Perform a sanity check on quantitative genetics calculations: since narrow-sense heritability h2h^2 represents the proportion of phenotypic variation due to additive genetic effects (0≤h2≤10 \le h^2 \le 1), the intergenerational response RR should normally be less than or equal to the within-generation selection differential SS.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A population of sunflowers has a mean stem height of 150 cm150\text{ cm}. Breeders select tall plants with a mean height of 180 cm180\text{ cm} as parents. If the narrow-sense heritability of stem height is h2=0.30h^2 = 0.30, calculate: (a) the selection differential (SS), and (b) the expected evolutionary response (RR) in the next generation.

Answer

(a) S=180 cm−150 cm=30 cmS = 180\text{ cm} - 150\text{ cm} = 30\text{ cm}.\n(b) R=h2×S=0.30×30 cm=9.0 cmR = h^2 \times S = 0.30 \times 30\text{ cm} = 9.0\text{ cm}.

02

In a population of field mice, the mean adult tail length is 70 mm70\text{ mm}. Following an environmental shift, individuals that successfully reproduce have a mean tail length of 62 mm62\text{ mm}. If narrow-sense heritability is h2=0.45h^2 = 0.45, find the expected mean tail length of the offspring generation.

Answer
  1. Selection differential: S=62 mm−70 mm=−8 mmS = 62\text{ mm} - 70\text{ mm} = -8\text{ mm}.\n2. Response: R=h2×S=0.45×(−8 mm)=−3.6 mmR = h^2 \times S = 0.45 \times (-8\text{ mm}) = -3.6\text{ mm}.\n3. Offspring mean: xˉoffspring=70 mm+(−3.6 mm)=66.4 mm\bar{x}_{\text{offspring}} = 70\text{ mm} + (-3.6\text{ mm}) = 66.4\text{ mm}.
03

An aquaculture facility selects larger trout for breeding. The initial population has a mean mass of 400 g400\text{ g}, and the selected breeding stock has a mean mass of 550 g550\text{ g}. The offspring generation shows an evolutionary response of R=45 gR = 45\text{ g}. Determine the narrow-sense heritability (h2h^2) of body mass in this population.

Answer
  1. Selection differential: S=550 g−400 g=150 gS = 550\text{ g} - 400\text{ g} = 150\text{ g}.\n2. Breeder's equation: R=h2×S  ⟹  h2=RS=45 g150 g=0.30R = h^2 \times S \implies h^2 = \frac{R}{S} = \frac{45\text{ g}}{150\text{ g}} = 0.30.
Loading workspace…