Resources
A student team sets up potato core osmolarity experiments to determine the internal solute concentration of Solanum tuberosum tissue. Cylinders of potato () are submerged in sucrose solutions of known concentrations () at for .
The measured percent change in mass () yields the following linear regression fit against molarity ():
A student calculates the internal solute potential using the van 't Hoff formula , where (sucrose does not ionize), , and . However, the student incorrectly writes , forgetting the mandatory negative sign convention of water and solute potential.
From the empirical regression evidence: (1) calculate the exact equilibrium sucrose molarity where (no net water movement); (2) calculate the correct internal solute potential in to three significant figures; and (3) explain the thermodynamic and biological meaning of the negative sign convention in chemical water potential, specifying why a positive solute potential violates physical principles in an open beaker.
Answer and steps
Final answer
- Setting : . 2. Using : . 3. Pure free water at atmospheric pressure has a reference chemical water potential of . Dissolving solute particles coordinates water molecules into hydration shells, decreasing the free energy and entropy of free water, which thermodynamically reduces water potential below zero (making it negative). A positive solute potential () would imply solutes increase the free energy of water above pure unconstrained water, which is physically impossible in an unpressurized open container.
Steps
Determine the Equilibrium Molarity (Isotonic Point)
When there is no net movement of water into or out of the potato tissue, the percent change in mass is zero (). At this point, the external sucrose solution is isotonic to the internal potato cells.
Set the empirical linear regression equation to zero and solve for the concentration :
The equilibrium sucrose molarity of the potato tissue is (or ).
Calculate the Internal Solute Potential ()
Use the van 't Hoff equation for solute potential:
Given values:
- Ionization constant for sucrose: (sucrose is non-ionizing)
- Molar concentration:
- Pressure constant:
- Absolute temperature:
Substitute these values into the formula:
Rounded to three significant figures, the internal solute potential is:
Thermodynamic and Biological Explanation of the Negative Sign
- Thermodynamic Reference State:
By international convention, pure water at standard atmospheric pressure and ambient temperature has a reference chemical water potential of . - Effect of Solutes:
When solute particles dissolve in water, water molecules form hydration shells around the solute particles via hydrogen bonding and dipole interactions. This restricts the random kinetic motion of water molecules, decreasing their free energy and chemical activity. Because pure, unconstrained water has , adding solute can only decrease water potential below zero, meaning solute potential must always be negative (). - Physical Impossibility of in an Open Beaker:
In an open container, the external pressure potential is zero (), giving . A positive solute potential () would imply that adding solute increases the free energy of water relative to pure water, causing spontaneous water flow out of pure water into a higher-energy state without an external energy or pressure source. This violates the second law of thermodynamics. Therefore, solute potential is always strictly non-positive.
Typical errors
01 The student misidentifies the equilibrium molarity as the y-intercept (21.6 M) instead of solving for the x-intercept where percent change in mass is zero.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
Equilibrium is at the intercept where
CorrectEquilibrium (isotonic state) occurs where there is no net water movement, meaning the percent mass change is zero (, the -intercept). In the regression equation , the value is the -intercept (the mass gain in pure water where ), not the concentration at equilibrium.
- Step 2Correct
Your application of the formula and the negative sign convention was mathematically sound, but your final numerical value was affected by substituting from Step 1 instead of .
- Step 3
Pure water is , and dissolved solutes decrease the free energy of water so solute potential must be negative, meaning positive values are impossible in an open system.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly included the mandatory negative sign in the van 't Hoff equation.
You accurately explained that pure water has a potential of and that adding solute decreases water's free energy, preventing positive solute potentials.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou confused the dependent variable's zero condition (solving for the x-intercept where ) with the regression equation's y-intercept constant (). In osmosis core experiments, no net mass change corresponds to the horizontal intercept where the regression line crosses the concentration axis.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Identify equilibrium from graph coordinates
Equilibrium occurs at no net water flow: set the dependent variable to zero () and solve for the independent variable ().
Substitute for in to find .
- Perform a reality check on molarity
Biological solutions generally have osmolarities below ; a value exceeding is physically impossible for dissolved sucrose.
Always verify whether your calculated molarity is biologically reasonable before computing water potential.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationSet :
Solve for equilibrium molarity:
Substitute into the van 't Hoff equation:
Calculate the solute potential:
(1) Equilibrium sucrose molarity is ; (2) Solute potential ; (3) Solute potential is negative because dissolved solutes lower the chemical free energy of water below the reference state of pure water ().
02 The student forgets the negative sign in the van 't Hoff equation and calculates a positive solute potential.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
- Step 2Correct
You used instead of . Solute potential always carries a negative sign because the addition of solutes lowers the chemical potential of water below that of pure water.
- Step 3
Pure water is assigned a reference potential of , and solutes reduce the chemical activity of water so solute potential is negative, meaning a positive value violates thermodynamics.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly solved the linear regression equation for the isotonic point where percent mass change is zero.
You selected the correct numerical parameters for the van 't Hoff equation and computed the absolute magnitude accurately to three significant figures.
You provided a sound conceptual explanation linking solute hydration to reduced chemical potential and thermodynamic reference states.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeNo, this is a conceptual formula error where the explicit negative sign of the van 't Hoff solute potential equation was omitted during calculation, despite being noted in your written explanation.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou treated osmotic pressure (, which is inherently positive) interchangeably with solute potential (, which is always negative or zero).
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Solute Potential Formula Definition
Solute potential is defined as , where the leading negative sign is mandatory.
Always write out the explicit negative sign before substituting values into .
- Sign Sanity Check for Water Potential
In an open container where , water potential equals solute potential (). Pure water has ; adding solutes can only make strictly negative.
Check your final value to ensure it is negative whenever solute concentration .
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationWrite the complete van 't Hoff formula including the negative sign: .
Substitute the values: , , , and .
Calculate: .
Round to three significant figures: .
03 The student confuses Celsius and Kelvin by subtracting 273 from 293 K instead of using 293 K directly in the calculation.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
- Step 2Correct
The problem statement already gave the absolute temperature as . Subtracting converts Kelvin to degrees Celsius (), but the van 't Hoff equation requires absolute temperature in Kelvin.
- Step 3Correct
You applied the van 't Hoff equation and negative sign convention correctly, but your numerical result was affected by substituting instead of .
- Step 4
Pure water at has a potential of , and solute particles decrease water's free energy, which makes solute potential strictly negative.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly identified that the equilibrium molarity occurs where percent mass change is zero.
You remembered and correctly included the negative sign in the van 't Hoff formula .
You accurately explained that dissolved solutes reduce the free energy of water relative to pure water.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeSubtracting from a temperature that was already supplied in Kelvin ().
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou habituated the temperature conversion step and mechanically applied an adjustment without checking the provided unit, confusing Kelvin with Celsius.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Verify Given Units
Always inspect the unit symbol attached to the given temperature before doing any arithmetic.
If the value already has the unit , substitute it directly into without adding or subtracting .
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationKeep the absolute temperature directly as .
Substitute the values into the formula: .
Calculate the product: .
Lock it in
In a tissue osmolarity graph of percent mass change vs. solution molarity, where is the isotonic equilibrium point located?
At the x-intercept (), where no net movement of water occurs into or out of the tissue.
Similar question
Sweet potato cores are incubated in various sucrose solutions. The resulting regression line is . Calculate the internal sucrose concentration of the sweet potato tissue at equilibrium.
Answer
Set : .
Using the equilibrium concentration found from (), calculate the solute potential at using and . Express your answer to three significant figures.
Answer
.
A student tests zucchini tissue in solutions () at (). The best-fit equation is . Determine: (a) the equilibrium molarity of the zucchini tissue, and (b) its internal solute potential in bars to three significant figures.
Answer
(a) Set . (b) Use with : .