Resources

In a long-term evolution experiment mimicking the Grant finch field studies, researchers tracked beak depths in an isolated population of Medium Ground Finches (Geospiza fortisGeospiza\ fortis). Prior to a severe drought, the population numbered N0=750N_0 = 750 birds, with an average beak depth of zˉ0=9.42 mm\bar{z}_0 = 9.42\text{ mm} and a standard deviation of σ0=0.90 mm\sigma_0 = 0.90\text{ mm}. During the drought, small soft seeds were rapidly depleted, leaving only large, hard woody fruits of Tribulus cistoides. Only 180180 finches survived the drought. The surviving cohort had an average beak depth of zˉ∗=10.14 mm\bar{z}^* = 10.14\text{ mm}. (a) Calculate the selection differential (SS) and the standardized selection gradient (β=Sσ02\beta = \frac{S}{\sigma_0^2}). (b) Midparent-offspring regression in this population established a narrow-sense heritability of h2=0.72h^2 = 0.72. Using the Breeder's Equation (R=h2SR = h^2 S), calculate the evolutionary response (RR) and the expected mean beak depth of the first post-drought offspring generation (zˉ1\bar{z}_1). Express all answers to three significant figures.

Answer and steps

Final answer

(a) S=0.720 mmS = 0.720\text{ mm}, β=0.889 mm−1\beta = 0.889\text{ mm}^{-1}; (b) R=0.518 mmR = 0.518\text{ mm}, zˉ1=9.94 mm\bar{z}_1 = 9.94\text{ mm}

Steps

Part (a): Selection Differential (SS) and Selection Gradient (β\beta)

  1. Calculate the selection differential (SS): The selection differential measures the within-generation change in the trait mean resulting from differential survival or reproductive success. It is defined as the difference between the mean trait value of the surviving breeders (zˉ∗\bar{z}^*) and the mean trait value of the initial parental population before selection (zˉ0\bar{z}_0): S=zˉ∗−zˉ0S = \bar{z}^* - \bar{z}_0 S=10.14 mm−9.42 mm=0.720 mmS = 10.14\text{ mm} - 9.42\text{ mm} = 0.720\text{ mm}
  2. Calculate the selection gradient (β\beta): The selection gradient quantifies the direct force of directional selection on a trait relative to the phenotypic variance (σ02\sigma_0^2): β=Sσ02\beta = \frac{S}{\sigma_0^2} Given σ0=0.90 mm\sigma_0 = 0.90\text{ mm}, the phenotypic variance is: σ02=(0.90 mm)2=0.810 mm2\sigma_0^2 = (0.90\text{ mm})^2 = 0.810\text{ mm}^2 Substituting into the formula: β=0.720 mm0.810 mm2≈0.889 mm−1\beta = \frac{0.720\text{ mm}}{0.810\text{ mm}^2} \approx 0.889\text{ mm}^{-1}

Part (b): Evolutionary Response (RR) and Offspring Mean Trait (zˉ1\bar{z}_1)

  1. Calculate the evolutionary response (RR): According to the Breeder's Equation, the intergenerational evolutionary response depends on both the strength of directional selection (SS) and the narrow-sense heritability (h2h^2), which represents the proportion of phenotypic variation attributable to additive genetic variance: R=h2SR = h^2 S Substituting the known values: R=0.72×0.720 mm=0.5184 mm≈0.518 mmR = 0.72 \times 0.720\text{ mm} = 0.5184\text{ mm} \approx 0.518\text{ mm}
  2. Calculate the expected mean beak depth of the offspring generation (zˉ1\bar{z}_1): The mean trait value of the next generation equals the original parental mean plus the evolutionary response: zˉ1=zˉ0+R\bar{z}_1 = \bar{z}_0 + R zˉ1=9.42 mm+0.5184 mm=9.9384 mm≈9.94 mm\bar{z}_1 = 9.42\text{ mm} + 0.5184\text{ mm} = 9.9384\text{ mm} \approx 9.94\text{ mm}

Common Pitfall: Do not add the evolutionary response RR to the surviving breeder mean zˉ∗\bar{z}^*. Selection acts on the original population (zˉ0\bar{z}_0), shifting the offspring generation from the original baseline (zˉ0+R\bar{z}_0 + R), not from the selected cohort. Because heritability is less than 11 (h2<1h^2 < 1), the offspring mean partially regresses toward the original pre-selection mean rather than completely matching the selected parents.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student divides by the standard deviation instead of the variance when calculating the selection gradient.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    S=10.14−9.42=0.720 mmS = 10.14 - 9.42 = 0.720\text{ mm}

  2. Step 2

    β=Sσ0=0.7200.90=0.800 mm−1\beta = \frac{S}{\sigma_0} = \frac{0.720}{0.90} = 0.800\text{ mm}^{-1}

    Correct

    β=Sσ02=0.720 mm(0.90 mm)2=0.720 mm0.810 mm2≈0.889 mm−1\beta = \frac{S}{\sigma_0^2} = \frac{0.720\text{ mm}}{(0.90\text{ mm})^2} = \frac{0.720\text{ mm}}{0.810\text{ mm}^2} \approx 0.889\text{ mm}^{-1}

    You divided by the standard deviation σ0\sigma_0 rather than the phenotypic variance σ02\sigma_0^2. The selection gradient measures the slope of relative fitness against trait value, which requires dividing the selection differential by variance.

  3. Step 3

    R=h2S=0.72×0.720=0.518 mmR = h^2 S = 0.72 \times 0.720 = 0.518\text{ mm}

  4. Step 4

    zˉ1=9.42+0.518=9.94 mm\bar{z}_1 = 9.42 + 0.518 = 9.94\text{ mm}

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You calculated the selection differential SS accurately from the parental and survivor means.

You correctly used the Breeder's Equation R=h2SR = h^2 S to find the evolutionary change across generations.

You correctly anchored the new generation's mean zˉ1\bar{z}_1 to the original pre-selection mean zˉ0\bar{z}_0.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Parameter Definition Error

You wrote β=Sσ0\beta = \frac{S}{\sigma_0} and divided by the standard deviation instead of squaring it to use the phenotypic variance P=σ02P = \sigma_0^2.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Confusing standard deviation (σ\sigma) with phenotypic variance (σ2\sigma^2) when setting up the selection gradient formula β=SP\beta = \frac{S}{P}.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Selection Gradient Formula
  • The directional selection gradient is β=Sσ2=Cov(w,z)Var(z)\beta = \frac{S}{\sigma^2} = \frac{\text{Cov}(w, z)}{\text{Var}(z)}. The denominator is always phenotypic variance, not standard deviation.

  • Whenever given σ\sigma, immediately compute σ2\sigma^2 before evaluating β\beta.

Dimensional Analysis Check
  • Selection differential SS has units of trait [mm][\text{mm}], while variance σ2\sigma^2 has units of [mm2][\text{mm}^2]. The quotient β\beta must have units of [trait−1][\text{trait}^{-1}] ([mm−1][\text{mm}^{-1}]), but mathematically derived from linear regression slope ΔwΔz=Cov(w,z)σ2\frac{\Delta w}{\Delta z} = \frac{\text{Cov}(w,z)}{\sigma^2}.

  • Remember that linear regression slopes always have variance σ2\sigma^2 in the denominator.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Identify the pre-selection standard deviation: σ0=0.90 mm\sigma_0 = 0.90\text{ mm}.

  2. Calculate the phenotypic variance: σ02=(0.90 mm)2=0.810 mm2\sigma_0^2 = (0.90\text{ mm})^2 = 0.810\text{ mm}^2.

  3. Divide the selection differential by the variance: β=0.720 mm0.810 mm2≈0.889 mm−1\beta = \frac{0.720\text{ mm}}{0.810\text{ mm}^2} \approx 0.889\text{ mm}^{-1}.

Final answer

(a) S=0.720 mmS = 0.720\text{ mm}, β=0.889 mm−1\beta = 0.889\text{ mm}^{-1}; (b) R=0.518 mmR = 0.518\text{ mm}, zˉ1=9.94 mm\bar{z}_1 = 9.94\text{ mm}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the distinction between standard deviation σ\sigma and phenotypic variance P=σ2P = \sigma^2 in quantitative genetics models.

  • Practice checking the denominator of regression-based evolutionary metrics like selection gradients and heritabilities.

  • Work through practice problems calculating both standardized and unstandardized selection gradients.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student calculates the expected mean of the offspring generation by adding the response to the survivor mean instead of the pre-drought parental mean.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    S=10.14−9.42=0.720 mmS = 10.14 - 9.42 = 0.720\text{ mm}

  2. Step 2

    β=0.720(0.90)2=0.7200.81=0.889 mm−1\beta = \frac{0.720}{(0.90)^2} = \frac{0.720}{0.81} = 0.889\text{ mm}^{-1}

  3. Step 3

    R=0.72×0.720=0.518 mmR = 0.72 \times 0.720 = 0.518\text{ mm}

  4. Step 4

    zˉ1=zˉ∗+R=10.14+0.518=10.7 mm\bar{z}_1 = \bar{z}^* + R = 10.14 + 0.518 = 10.7\text{ mm}

    Correct

    zˉ1=zˉ0+R=9.42 mm+0.518 mm=9.94 mm\bar{z}_1 = \bar{z}_0 + R = 9.42\text{ mm} + 0.518\text{ mm} = 9.94\text{ mm}

    The evolutionary response RR is defined as the change across generations relative to the base parental population (ar{z}_1 - \bar{z}_0). Adding RR to the survivor mean zˉ∗\bar{z}^* counts the selective shift twice.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified and calculated the selection differential SS as the difference between surviving breeders and the initial population.

You accurately computed the selection gradient β\beta using the trait variance.

You correctly used the Breeder's Equation R=h2SR = h^2 S to calculate the intergenerational response.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Misapplied Baseline for Evolutionary Response

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated the evolutionary response RR as an additional gain on top of the selected survivors (ar{z}^* + R) rather than as the intergenerational shift relative to the original pre-drought parental mean (ar{z}_0 + R). Because h2<1h^2 < 1, offspring partially regress toward the original population mean.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Definition of Evolutionary Response
  • R=zˉ1−zˉ0R = \bar{z}_1 - \bar{z}_0, which rearranges to zˉ1=zˉ0+R\bar{z}_1 = \bar{z}_0 + R

  • Always anchor the intergenerational change RR to the initial pre-selection parental mean zˉ0\bar{z}_0, never to the selected breeder mean zˉ∗\bar{z}^*.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. State the relationship between offspring mean, parental baseline, and response: zˉ1=zˉ0+R\bar{z}_1 = \bar{z}_0 + R.

  2. Substitute the initial mean zˉ0=9.42 mm\bar{z}_0 = 9.42\text{ mm} and calculated response R=0.5184 mmR = 0.5184\text{ mm}.

  3. Compute zˉ1=9.42 mm+0.5184 mm=9.9384 mm≈9.94 mm\bar{z}_1 = 9.42\text{ mm} + 0.5184\text{ mm} = 9.9384\text{ mm} \approx 9.94\text{ mm}.

Final answer

(a) S=0.720 mmS = 0.720\text{ mm}, β=0.889 mm−1\beta = 0.889\text{ mm}^{-1}; (b) R=0.518 mmR = 0.518\text{ mm}, zˉ1=9.94 mm\bar{z}_1 = 9.94\text{ mm}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the distinction between within-generation phenotypic selection (S=zˉ∗−zˉ0S = \bar{z}^* - \bar{z}_0) and intergenerational evolutionary response (R=zˉ1−zˉ0R = \bar{z}_1 - \bar{z}_0).

  • Practice problems that require calculating offspring trait means with heritability values strictly between 00 and 11 to observe regression toward the mean.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student reverses the direction of subtraction in the selection differential, yielding a negative selection differential and an erroneous decrease in mean beak depth.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    S=zˉ0−zˉ∗=9.42−10.14=−0.720 mmS = \bar{z}_0 - \bar{z}^* = 9.42 - 10.14 = -0.720\text{ mm}

    Correct

    S=zˉ∗−zˉ0=10.14−9.42=0.720 mmS = \bar{z}^* - \bar{z}_0 = 10.14 - 9.42 = 0.720\text{ mm}

    The selection differential measures how much the mean of the surviving breeders differs from the original population before selection: S=zˉ∗−zˉ0S = \bar{z}^* - \bar{z}_0. Subtracting in reverse produced a negative value, falsely implying selection against larger beaks.

  2. Step 2

    β=−0.720(0.90)2=−0.7200.81=−0.889 mm−1\beta = \frac{-0.720}{(0.90)^2} = \frac{-0.720}{0.81} = -0.889\text{ mm}^{-1}

    Correct

    β=Sσ02=0.7200.810≈0.889 mm−1\beta = \frac{S}{\sigma_0^2} = \frac{0.720}{0.810} \approx 0.889\text{ mm}^{-1}

    You correctly applied the selection gradient formula β=Sσ02\beta = \frac{S}{\sigma_0^2} and correctly squared the phenotypic standard deviation, but the result inherited the negative sign from Step 1.

  3. Step 3

    R=0.72×(−0.720)=−0.518 mmR = 0.72 \times (-0.720) = -0.518\text{ mm}

    Correct

    R=h2S=0.72×0.720 mm≈0.518 mmR = h^2 S = 0.72 \times 0.720\text{ mm} \approx 0.518\text{ mm}

    You applied the Breeder's Equation R=h2SR = h^2 S properly with the given heritability, but the calculation carried over the incorrect negative sign from SS.

  4. Step 4

    zˉ1=9.42+(−0.518)=8.90 mm\bar{z}_1 = 9.42 + (-0.518) = 8.90\text{ mm}

    Correct

    zˉ1=zˉ0+R=9.42+0.518=9.94 mm\bar{z}_1 = \bar{z}_0 + R = 9.42 + 0.518 = 9.94\text{ mm}

    You correctly added the evolutionary response to the pre-selection parental baseline zˉ0\bar{z}_0, but because RR was negative, your result showed the population evolving smaller beaks instead of larger ones.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly used the phenotypic standard deviation to find the variance σ02=0.81 mm2\sigma_0^2 = 0.81\text{ mm}^2 when computing the selection gradient.

You correctly applied the Breeder's Equation R=h2SR = h^2 S to connect heritability with evolutionary response.

You correctly added the response to the initial pre-selection parental mean zˉ0\bar{z}_0 rather than the survivor mean zˉ∗\bar{z}^*.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Reversed Selection Differential Definition

You set S=zˉ0−zˉ∗S = \bar{z}_0 - \bar{z}^* instead of S=zˉ∗−zˉ0S = \bar{z}^* - \bar{z}_0, creating an unintended negative sign across every subsequent answer.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You likely treated the subtraction as 'initial minus final' rather than the standard biological definition of a shift, which is 'selected breeders minus original population' (after selection minus before selection).

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Direction of Selection Differential
  • The selection differential is always defined as S=zˉ∗−zˉ0S = \bar{z}^* - \bar{z}_0 (selected survivors minus pre-selection parental mean).

  • Always check biological context: if survivors have larger traits than the starting cohort, SS must be positive.

Sanity Check on Directional Evolution
  • When directional selection favors a trait (S>0S > 0) and heritability is positive (h2>0h^2 > 0), the offspring mean must shift toward the selected phenotype: zˉ1>zˉ0\bar{z}_1 > \bar{z}_0.

  • Before finalizing, verify whether your predicted next-generation mean moved in the same direction favored by survival.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Set S=zˉ∗−zˉ0=10.14−9.42=0.720 mmS = \bar{z}^* - \bar{z}_0 = 10.14 - 9.42 = 0.720\text{ mm}.

  2. Calculate β=Sσ02=0.720 mm(0.90 mm)2=0.7200.810≈0.889 mm−1\beta = \frac{S}{\sigma_0^2} = \frac{0.720\text{ mm}}{(0.90\text{ mm})^2} = \frac{0.720}{0.810} \approx 0.889\text{ mm}^{-1}.

  3. Calculate R=h2S=0.72×0.720 mm≈0.518 mmR = h^2 S = 0.72 \times 0.720\text{ mm} \approx 0.518\text{ mm}.

  4. Calculate zˉ1=zˉ0+R=9.42 mm+0.5184 mm≈9.94 mm\bar{z}_1 = \bar{z}_0 + R = 9.42\text{ mm} + 0.5184\text{ mm} \approx 9.94\text{ mm}.

Final answer

(a) S=0.720 mmS = 0.720\text{ mm}, β=0.889 mm−1\beta = 0.889\text{ mm}^{-1}; (b) R=0.518 mmR = 0.518\text{ mm}, zˉ1=9.94 mm\bar{z}_1 = 9.94\text{ mm}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Memorize the definition of selection differential as 'after selection minus before selection' (S=zˉ∗−zˉ0S = \bar{z}^* - \bar{z}_0).

  • Do a quick biological sign check: if larger individuals survive better, SS, β\beta, and RR must all be positive.

  • Practice using the Breeder's Equation across different quantitative trait examples to reinforce consistent notation.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A population of alpine butterflies has an average wing length of zˉ0=32.0 mm\bar{z}_0 = 32.0\text{ mm} with standard deviation σ=2.0 mm\sigma = 2.0\text{ mm}. Following an early frost, surviving butterflies have a mean wing length of zˉ∗=33.6 mm\bar{z}^* = 33.6\text{ mm}. Calculate the selection differential SS and the selection gradient β\beta.

Answer

S=zˉ∗−zˉ0=33.6−32.0=1.6 mmS = \bar{z}^* - \bar{z}_0 = 33.6 - 32.0 = 1.6\text{ mm}. Phenotypic variance σ2=2.02=4.0 mm2\sigma^2 = 2.0^2 = 4.0\text{ mm}^2. Thus, β=Sσ2=1.6 mm4.0 mm2=0.40 mm−1\beta = \frac{S}{\sigma^2} = \frac{1.6\text{ mm}}{4.0\text{ mm}^2} = 0.40\text{ mm}^{-1}.

02

In a population of field mice, tail length has a standard deviation of σ=4.0 cm\sigma = 4.0\text{ cm} and narrow-sense heritability of h2=0.40h^2 = 0.40. Directional selection produces a selection gradient of β=0.125 cm−1\beta = 0.125\text{ cm}^{-1}. (a) Find the selection differential SS. (b) Find the evolutionary response RR.

Answer

(a) Phenotypic variance σ2=4.02=16.0 cm2\sigma^2 = 4.0^2 = 16.0\text{ cm}^2. Since β=Sσ2\beta = \frac{S}{\sigma^2}, S=βσ2=0.125 cm−1×16.0 cm2=2.0 cmS = \beta \sigma^2 = 0.125\text{ cm}^{-1} \times 16.0\text{ cm}^2 = 2.0\text{ cm}. (b) Using Breeder's Equation: R=h2S=0.40×2.0 cm=0.80 cmR = h^2 S = 0.40 \times 2.0\text{ cm} = 0.80\text{ cm}.

03

An agronomist studies stem height in a sunflower population with initial mean zˉ0=150 cm\bar{z}_0 = 150\text{ cm} and standard deviation σ0=12 cm\sigma_0 = 12\text{ cm}. Selected seed parents have mean zˉ∗=168 cm\bar{z}^* = 168\text{ cm}. If the next generation offspring mean is zˉ1=160.8 cm\bar{z}_1 = 160.8\text{ cm}, calculate (a) the selection gradient β\beta, and (b) the narrow-sense heritability h2h^2.

Answer

(a) S=168−150=18 cmS = 168 - 150 = 18\text{ cm}. Variance σ02=122=144 cm2\sigma_0^2 = 12^2 = 144\text{ cm}^2. Selection gradient β=18144=0.125 cm−1\beta = \frac{18}{144} = 0.125\text{ cm}^{-1}. (b) Response R=zˉ1−zˉ0=160.8−150=10.8 cmR = \bar{z}_1 - \bar{z}_0 = 160.8 - 150 = 10.8\text{ cm}. By Breeder's Equation R=h2S  ⟹  h2=RS=10.818=0.60R = h^2 S \implies h^2 = \frac{R}{S} = \frac{10.8}{18} = 0.60.

Loading workspace…