Resources

Consider the transport of an uncharged polar metabolite SS into a eukaryotic cell at T=298 KT = 298\text{ K} (R=8.314 J/(mol⋅K)R = 8.314\text{ J}/(\text{mol}\cdot\text{K})). The intracellular concentration is fixed at [S]in=2.0 mM[S]_{\text{in}} = 2.0\text{ mM}. (a) Formulate the expression for the molar free energy of transport ΔGtransport\Delta G_{\text{transport}} (in kJ/mol\text{kJ/mol}) for moving SS from the outside into the cell as a function of external concentration [S]out[S]_{\text{out}}. (b) Evaluate the asymptotic limit lim⁡[S]out→0+ΔGtransport\lim_{[S]_{\text{out}} \to 0^+} \Delta G_{\text{transport}} and interpret its biological significance regarding the feasibility of passive transport versus active transport. (c) If a primary active pump hydrolyzes ATP with ΔGATP=−50.0 kJ/mol\Delta G_{\text{ATP}} = -50.0\text{ kJ/mol}, calculate the absolute theoretical minimum extracellular concentration [S]out,min⁡[S]_{\text{out},\min} (in M\text{M}) from which 1 mole of ATP per mole of SS can still drive uptake.

Answer and steps

Final answer

(a) ΔGtransport=RTln⁡([S]in[S]out)=2.478ln⁡(2.0×10−3[S]out) kJ/mol\Delta G_{\text{transport}} = RT \ln\left(\frac{[S]_{\text{in}}}{[S]_{\text{out}}}\right) = 2.478 \ln\left(\frac{2.0 \times 10^{-3}}{[S]_{\text{out}}}\right)\text{ kJ/mol}; (b) lim⁡[S]out→0+ΔGtransport=+∞\lim_{[S]_{\text{out}} \to 0^+} \Delta G_{\text{transport}} = +\infty, meaning passive entry is impossible and infinite energy per mole would be required at absolute zero external concentration; (c) [S]out,min⁡=3.48×10−12 M[S]_{\text{out},\min} = 3.48 \times 10^{-12}\text{ M} (or 3.48 pM3.48\text{ pM}).

Steps

Part (a): Free Energy Expression for Solute Transport

Because the metabolite SS is uncharged, there is no electrical contribution to the electrochemical potential (ΔΨ=0\Delta \Psi = 0). The molar free energy change (ΔGtransport\Delta G_{\text{transport}}) for moving an uncharged substance from the extracellular space (out\text{out}) to the intracellular space (in\text{in}) depends solely on the chemical concentration gradient:

ΔGtransport=RTln⁡([S]in[S]out)\Delta G_{\text{transport}} = RT \ln\left(\frac{[S]_{\text{in}}}{[S]_{\text{out}}}\right)

Given:

  • R=8.314 J/(mol⋅K)=8.314×10−3 kJ/(mol⋅K)R = 8.314\text{ J}/(\text{mol}\cdot\text{K}) = 8.314 \times 10^{-3}\text{ kJ}/(\text{mol}\cdot\text{K})
  • T=298 KT = 298\text{ K}
  • RT=(8.314×10−3 kJ/(mol⋅K))(298 K)≈2.478 kJ/molRT = (8.314 \times 10^{-3}\text{ kJ}/(\text{mol}\cdot\text{K}))(298\text{ K}) \approx 2.478\text{ kJ/mol}
  • [S]in=2.0 mM=2.0×10−3 M[S]_{\text{in}} = 2.0\text{ mM} = 2.0 \times 10^{-3}\text{ M}

Substituting these values into the thermodynamic equation:

ΔGtransport=2.478ln⁡(2.0×10−3[S]out) kJ/mol\Delta G_{\text{transport}} = 2.478 \ln\left(\frac{2.0 \times 10^{-3}}{[S]_{\text{out}}}\right)\text{ kJ/mol}


Part (b): Asymptotic Limit and Biological Implications

Evaluating the limit as [S]out→0+[S]_{\text{out}} \to 0^+:

lim⁡[S]out→0+ΔGtransport=lim⁡[S]out→0+[RTln⁡([S]in[S]out)]=RTln⁡(+∞)=+∞\lim_{[S]_{\text{out}} \to 0^+} \Delta G_{\text{transport}} = \lim_{[S]_{\text{out}} \to 0^+} \left[RT \ln\left(\frac{[S]_{\text{in}}}{[S]_{\text{out}}}\right)\right] = RT \ln(+\infty) = +\infty

Biological Interpretation:

  1. Passive Transport: Passive transport (such as facilitated diffusion) is strictly spontaneous and driven only down a concentration gradient (ΔG<0\Delta G < 0). Spontaneous passive entry requires [S]out>[S]in[S]_{\text{out}} > [S]_{\text{in}}. When [S]out<[S]in[S]_{\text{out}} < [S]_{\text{in}}, passive uptake cannot occur, and net efflux would occur instead.
  2. Active Transport: Active transport couples an exergonic reaction (such as ATP hydrolysis) to overcome an unfavorable gradient (ΔGtransport>0\Delta G_{\text{transport}} > 0). However, because lim⁡[S]out→0+ΔGtransport=+∞\lim_{[S]_{\text{out}} \to 0^+} \Delta G_{\text{transport}} = +\infty, an infinite amount of free energy would be required per mole to import solute from a compartment where its concentration is absolute zero. Thus, no finite chemical energy source can drive uptake from a truly empty environment; active uptake is only possible above a finite threshold concentration.

Part (c): Minimum Extracellular Concentration Supported by ATP Hydrolysis

Primary active transport couples the transport of 1 mole of SS to the hydrolysis of 1 mole of ATP:

ΔGnet=ΔGtransport+ΔGATP\Delta G_{\text{net}} = \Delta G_{\text{transport}} + \Delta G_{\text{ATP}}

For transport to be thermodynamically feasible, the overall process must be exergonic (ΔGnet≤0\Delta G_{\text{net}} \le 0). The theoretical lower limit [S]out,min⁡[S]_{\text{out},\min} occurs at thermodynamic equilibrium (ΔGnet=0\Delta G_{\text{net}} = 0):

ΔGtransport=−ΔGATP=−(−50.0 kJ/mol)=+50.0 kJ/mol\Delta G_{\text{transport}} = -\Delta G_{\text{ATP}} = -(-50.0\text{ kJ/mol}) = +50.0\text{ kJ/mol}

Set up the equation:

RTln⁡([S]in[S]out,min⁡)=50.0 kJ/molRT \ln\left(\frac{[S]_{\text{in}}}{[S]_{\text{out},\min}}\right) = 50.0\text{ kJ/mol}

Using RT≈2.478 kJ/molRT \approx 2.478\text{ kJ/mol} (or 2.479 kJ/mol2.479\text{ kJ/mol} at standard biological reference temperature):

ln⁡(2.0×10−3 M[S]out,min⁡)=50.02.478≈20.178\ln\left(\frac{2.0 \times 10^{-3}\text{ M}}{[S]_{\text{out},\min}}\right) = \frac{50.0}{2.478} \approx 20.178

Exponentiate both sides to solve for the concentration ratio:

2.0×10−3 M[S]out,min⁡=e20.178≈5.75×108\frac{2.0 \times 10^{-3}\text{ M}}{[S]_{\text{out},\min}} = e^{20.178} \approx 5.75 \times 10^8

Now, solve for [S]out,min⁡[S]_{\text{out},\min}:

[S]out,min⁡=2.0×10−3 M5.75×108≈3.48×10−12 M=3.48 pM[S]_{\text{out},\min} = \frac{2.0 \times 10^{-3}\text{ M}}{5.75 \times 10^8} \approx 3.48 \times 10^{-12}\text{ M} = 3.48\text{ pM}

Therefore, the cell can theoretically concentrate the metabolite by a factor of nearly 6×1086 \times 10^8, accumulating SS up to 2.0 mM2.0\text{ mM} from an external concentration as dilute as 3.48 pM3.48\text{ pM}.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student inverts the ratio of concentrations in the free energy expression as [S]_out / [S]_in, leading to an incorrect negative limit and inverted threshold concentration.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    ΔGtransport=R⋅T⋅ln⁡([S]out[S]in)  ⟹  R⋅T=8.314⋅2981000=2.478 kJ/mol  ⟹  ΔGtransport=2.478⋅ln⁡([S]out0.002) kJ/mol\Delta G_{\text{transport}} = R \cdot T \cdot \ln\left(\frac{[S]_{\text{out}}}{[S]_{\text{in}}}\right) \implies R \cdot T = 8.314 \cdot \frac{298}{1000} = 2.478\text{ kJ/mol} \implies \Delta G_{\text{transport}} = 2.478 \cdot \ln\left(\frac{[S]_{\text{out}}}{0.002}\right)\text{ kJ/mol}

    Correct

    ΔGtransport=RTln⁡([S]in[S]out)=2.478ln⁡(2.0×10−3[S]out) kJ/mol\Delta G_{\text{transport}} = RT \ln\left(\frac{[S]_{\text{in}}}{[S]_{\text{out}}}\right) = 2.478 \ln\left(\frac{2.0 \times 10^{-3}}{[S]_{\text{out}}}\right)\text{ kJ/mol}

    When transporting solute from the outside to the inside, the final state is inside and the initial state is outside. The chemical potential difference is ΔG=μin−μout=RTln⁡([S]in[S]out)\Delta G = \mu_{\text{in}} - \mu_{\text{out}} = RT \ln\left(\frac{[S]_{\text{in}}}{[S]_{\text{out}}}\right). You placed [S]out[S]_{\text{out}} in the numerator, which inverts the sign of ΔG\Delta G.

  2. Step 2

    As \text{As } [S]{out\text{out}} →\to 0^+, [S]out[S]in\frac{[S]_{\text{out}}}{[S]_{\text{in}}} →\to 0,  so \text{ so } \ln([S]out[S]in)\left(\frac{[S]_{\text{out}}}{[S]_{\text{in}}}\right) →\to -∞\infty   ⟹  \implies \lim{[S]{out\text{out}} →\to 0^+} Δ\Delta G{transport\text{transport}} = -∞\infty   ⟹  \implies Since \text{Since } Δ\Delta G  is negative, transport into the cell is spontaneous, so passive transport is favorable and active transport is not needed.\text{ is negative, transport into the cell is spontaneous, so passive transport is favorable and active transport is not needed.}

    Correct

    lim⁡[S]out→0+ΔGtransport=lim⁡[S]out→0+RTln⁡([S]in[S]out)=+∞\lim_{[S]_{\text{out}} \to 0^+} \Delta G_{\text{transport}} = \lim_{[S]_{\text{out}} \to 0^+} RT \ln\left(\frac{[S]_{\text{in}}}{[S]_{\text{out}}}\right) = +\infty. Because ΔG>0\Delta G > 0 when [S]out<[S]in[S]_{\text{out}} < [S]_{\text{in}}, passive entry is impossible. Furthermore, at absolute zero external concentration, ΔG→+∞\Delta G \to +\infty, meaning an infinite amount of energy per mole is required, so no finite energy source can drive uptake from an entirely empty medium.

    Because your transport equation was inverted, your limit evaluated to −∞-\infty instead of +∞+\infty. Moving a solute from an extremely dilute extracellular space into a concentrated cell requires moving against the concentration gradient, which is non-spontaneous and requires active transport.

  3. Step 3

    ΔGtransport+ΔGATP=0  ⟹  2.478⋅ln⁡([S]out,min⁡0.002)−50.0=0  ⟹  ln⁡([S]out,min⁡0.002)=20.18  ⟹  [S]out,min⁡=0.002⋅e20.18=1.16×106 M\Delta G_{\text{transport}} + \Delta G_{\text{ATP}} = 0 \implies 2.478 \cdot \ln\left(\frac{[S]_{\text{out},\min}}{0.002}\right) - 50.0 = 0 \implies \ln\left(\frac{[S]_{\text{out},\min}}{0.002}\right) = 20.18 \implies [S]_{\text{out},\min} = 0.002 \cdot e^{20.18} = 1.16 \times 10^6\text{ M}

    Correct

    ΔGnet=RTln⁡([S]in[S]out,min⁡)+ΔGATP=0  ⟹  2.478ln⁡(2.0×10−3[S]out,min⁡)=50.0  ⟹  [S]out,min⁡=2.0×10−3e20.178≈3.48×10−12 M\Delta G_{\text{net}} = RT \ln\left(\frac{[S]_{\text{in}}}{[S]_{\text{out},\min}}\right) + \Delta G_{\text{ATP}} = 0 \implies 2.478 \ln\left(\frac{2.0 \times 10^{-3}}{[S]_{\text{out},\min}}\right) = 50.0 \implies [S]_{\text{out},\min} = \frac{2.0 \times 10^{-3}}{e^{20.178}} \approx 3.48 \times 10^{-12}\text{ M}

    Your coupling condition ΔGtransport+ΔGATP=0\Delta G_{\text{transport}} + \Delta G_{\text{ATP}} = 0 was correct in concept, but substituting the inverted ratio yielded an unphysical concentration of over one million molar instead of the correct picomolar concentration.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly calculated the thermal energy factor RT≈2.478 kJ/molRT \approx 2.478\text{ kJ/mol} at 298 K298\text{ K}.

You correctly recognized that the threshold concentration occurs at thermodynamic equilibrium where ΔGtransport+ΔGATP=0\Delta G_{\text{transport}} + \Delta G_{\text{ATP}} = 0.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Inverted concentration ratio in transport free energy

none

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You defined the reaction quotient for transport as initialfinal\frac{\text{initial}}{\text{final}} ([S]out/[S]in[S]_{\text{out}} / [S]_{\text{in}}) instead of finaldestination\frac{\text{final}}{\text{destination}} ([S]in/[S]out[S]_{\text{in}} / [S]_{\text{out}}), which inverted the sign of ΔGtransport\Delta G_{\text{transport}} and produced an unphysical concentration limit.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Define Destination Over Source
  • For movement from compartment AA to compartment BB, the molar free energy change is ΔG=RTln⁡([S]B[S]A)=RTln⁡([S]destination[S]source)\Delta G = RT \ln\left(\frac{[S]_B}{[S]_A}\right) = RT \ln\left(\frac{[S]_{\text{destination}}}{[S]_{\text{source}}}\right).

  • Always check that the concentration in the compartment being entered goes in the numerator.

Perform a Biological Reality Check
  • Moving a substance from low concentration to high concentration is thermodynamically unfavorable (requires free energy input, ΔG>0\Delta G > 0).

  • If [S]out<[S]in[S]_{\text{out}} < [S]_{\text{in}}, verify that your ΔGtransport\Delta G_{\text{transport}} is positive before continuing.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Set up the chemical potential difference for influx: ΔGtransport=RTln⁡([S]in[S]out)=2.478ln⁡(2.0×10−3[S]out) kJ/mol\Delta G_{\text{transport}} = RT \ln\left(\frac{[S]_{\text{in}}}{[S]_{\text{out}}}\right) = 2.478 \ln\left(\frac{2.0 \times 10^{-3}}{[S]_{\text{out}}}\right)\text{ kJ/mol}.

  2. Evaluate the limit: as [S]out→0+[S]_{\text{out}} \to 0^+, the ratio [S]in[S]out→+∞\frac{[S]_{\text{in}}}{[S]_{\text{out}}} \to +\infty, so lim⁡[S]out→0+ΔGtransport=+∞\lim_{[S]_{\text{out}} \to 0^+} \Delta G_{\text{transport}} = +\infty. This proves that moving a solute into the cell against an infinitely steep gradient requires infinite free energy; passive uptake cannot occur.

  3. Equate the energy required for transport to the energy provided by ATP hydrolysis at the threshold: 2.478ln⁡(2.0×10−3[S]out,min⁡)=50.0 kJ/mol2.478 \ln\left(\frac{2.0 \times 10^{-3}}{[S]_{\text{out},\min}}\right) = 50.0\text{ kJ/mol}.

  4. Solve for the ratio: 2.0×10−3[S]out,min⁡=e50.0/2.478=e20.178≈5.75×108\frac{2.0 \times 10^{-3}}{[S]_{\text{out},\min}} = e^{50.0 / 2.478} = e^{20.178} \approx 5.75 \times 10^8.

  5. Calculate [S]out,min⁡=2.0×10−35.75×108≈3.48×10−12 M[S]_{\text{out},\min} = \frac{2.0 \times 10^{-3}}{5.75 \times 10^8} \approx 3.48 \times 10^{-12}\text{ M} (3.48 pM3.48\text{ pM}).

Final answer

(a) ΔGtransport=2.478ln⁡(2.0×10−3[S]out) kJ/mol\Delta G_{\text{transport}} = 2.478 \ln\left(\frac{2.0 \times 10^{-3}}{[S]_{\text{out}}}\right)\text{ kJ/mol}; (b) lim⁡[S]out→0+ΔGtransport=+∞\lim_{[S]_{\text{out}} \to 0^+} \Delta G_{\text{transport}} = +\infty, showing passive entry cannot occur and uptake requires active transport, which is impossible at absolute zero external concentration; (c) [S]out,min⁡=3.48×10−12 M[S]_{\text{out},\min} = 3.48 \times 10^{-12}\text{ M} (3.48 pM3.48\text{ pM}).

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the thermodynamic convention for chemical reactions and transport: ΔG=Gfinal−Ginitial=RTln⁡([final][initial])\Delta G = G_{\text{final}} - G_{\text{initial}} = RT \ln\left(\frac{[\text{final}]}{[\text{initial}]}\right).

  • Before finishing a calculation, sanity-check whether an extracellular concentration of 106 M10^6\text{ M} is physically achievable in an aqueous biological system.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student forgets to convert the gas constant R from J/(mol·K) to kJ/(mol·K) or ATP energy to J/mol, causing a three-orders-of-magnitude unit mismatch in part (c).

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    ΔGtransport=R⋅T⋅ln⁡([S]in[S]out)  ⟹  RT=8.314⋅2981000=2.478 kJ/mol  ⟹  ΔGtransport=2.478⋅ln⁡(0.002[S]out) kJ/mol\Delta G_{\text{transport}} = R \cdot T \cdot \ln\left(\frac{[S]_{\text{in}}}{[S]_{\text{out}}}\right) \implies RT = 8.314 \cdot \frac{298}{1000} = 2.478\text{ kJ/mol} \implies \Delta G_{\text{transport}} = 2.478 \cdot \ln\left(\frac{0.002}{[S]_{\text{out}}}\right)\text{ kJ/mol}

  2. Step 2

    As \text{As } [S]{out\text{out}} →\to 0^+, 0.002[S]out\frac{0.002}{[S]_{\text{out}}} →\to ∞\infty,  so \text{ so } \ln(0.002[S]out)\left(\frac{0.002}{[S]_{\text{out}}}\right) →\to +∞\infty   ⟹  \implies \lim{[S]{out\text{out}} →\to 0^+} Δ\Delta G{transport\text{transport}} = +∞\infty   ⟹  \implies Passive transport is unfavorable because \text{Passive transport is unfavorable because } Δ\Delta G > 0,  so active transport is required to move S into the cell.\text{ so active transport is required to move S into the cell.}

  3. Step 3

    Δ\Delta G_{transport\text{transport}} = -Δ\Delta G_{ATP\text{ATP}} = 50.0   ⟹  \implies RT \ln([S]in[S]out,min⁡)\left(\frac{[S]_{\text{in}}}{[S]_{\text{out},\min}}\right) = 50.0   ⟹  \implies 2477.6 ⋅\cdot \ln(0.002[S]out,min⁡)\left(\frac{0.002}{[S]_{\text{out},\min}}\right) = 50.0   ⟹  \implies \ln(0.002[S]out,min⁡)\left(\frac{0.002}{[S]_{\text{out},\min}}\right) = 0.02018   ⟹  \implies [S]{out\text{out},\min} = 0.002e0.02018\frac{0.002}{e^{0.02018}} = 0.00196 M\text{ M}

    Correct

    2.478 \ln(2.0×10−3[S]out,min⁡)\left(\frac{2.0 \times 10^{-3}}{[S]_{\text{out},\min}}\right) = 50.0   ⟹  \implies \ln(2.0×10−3[S]out,min⁡)\left(\frac{2.0 \times 10^{-3}}{[S]_{\text{out},\min}}\right) = 50.02.478\frac{50.0}{2.478} ≈\approx 20.178   ⟹  \implies [S]{out\text{out},\min} = 2.0×10−3e20.178\frac{2.0 \times 10^{-3}}{e^{20.178}} ≈\approx 3.48 ×\times 10^{-12} M\text{ M}

    You substituted RT=2477.6 J/molRT = 2477.6\text{ J/mol} instead of 2.478 kJ/mol2.478\text{ kJ/mol} while keeping ΔGATP=50.0 kJ/mol\Delta G_{\text{ATP}} = 50.0\text{ kJ/mol}. This 1000×1000\times unit mismatch caused the concentration ratio to be severely underestimated.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly formulated the free energy equation for the transport of an uncharged solute.

You correctly converted RTRT to kJ/mol\text{kJ/mol} in part (a).

You accurately evaluated the asymptotic limit as [S]out→0+[S]_{\text{out}} \to 0^+.

You set up the thermodynamic coupling equilibrium ΔGtransport=−ΔGATP\Delta G_{\text{transport}} = -\Delta G_{\text{ATP}} correctly in part (c).

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Unit Mismatch (kJ vs J)

In part (c), you wrote RT=2477.6RT = 2477.6 (which has units of J/mol\text{J/mol}) while setting the other side equal to 50.050.0 (which is in kJ/mol\text{kJ/mol}).

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Failing to track explicit energy units on both sides of a thermodynamic equation when equating free energy terms.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Unit Consistency Check
  • When equating free energy terms (e.g., RTln⁡(Q)=−ΔGRT \ln(Q) = -\Delta G), both sides must share identical energy units (either both in kJ/mol\text{kJ/mol} or both in J/mol\text{J/mol}).

  • Write down explicit unit labels alongside each number before dividing.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Equate the transport free energy to the energy supplied by ATP hydrolysis: RTln⁡([S]in[S]out,min⁡)=50.0 kJ/molRT \ln\left(\frac{[S]_{\text{in}}}{[S]_{\text{out},\min}}\right) = 50.0\text{ kJ/mol}

  2. Use consistent units of kJ/mol\text{kJ/mol} for RTRT: 2.478 kJ/mol⋅ln⁡(2.0×10−3 M[S]out,min⁡)=50.0 kJ/mol2.478\text{ kJ/mol} \cdot \ln\left(\frac{2.0 \times 10^{-3}\text{ M}}{[S]_{\text{out},\min}}\right) = 50.0\text{ kJ/mol}

  3. Divide both sides by 2.478 kJ/mol2.478\text{ kJ/mol}: ln⁡(2.0×10−3 M[S]out,min⁡)=50.02.478≈20.178\ln\left(\frac{2.0 \times 10^{-3}\text{ M}}{[S]_{\text{out},\min}}\right) = \frac{50.0}{2.478} \approx 20.178

  4. Exponentiate to solve for the concentration: [S]out,min⁡=2.0×10−3 Me20.178≈3.48×10−12 M[S]_{\text{out},\min} = \frac{2.0 \times 10^{-3}\text{ M}}{e^{20.178}} \approx 3.48 \times 10^{-12}\text{ M}

Final answer

[S]out,min⁡≈3.48×10−12 M[S]_{\text{out},\min} \approx 3.48 \times 10^{-12}\text{ M} (or 3.48 pM3.48\text{ pM})

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Always write out complete units next to RR, TT, and ΔG\Delta G before performing algebraic divisions.

  • Sanity-check active transport accumulation ratios: ATP hydrolysis is highly exergonic (−50 kJ/mol-50\text{ kJ/mol}), which typically drives concentration gradients of several orders of magnitude, not just a few percent.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student sets the concentration in millimolar directly into the final molar calculation without converting 2.0 mM to 0.002 M, yielding an extracellular concentration in mM while reporting it as M.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    ΔGtransport=R⋅T⋅ln⁡([S]in[S]out)  ⟹  R⋅T=8.314⋅2981000=2.478 kJ/mol  ⟹  ΔGtransport=2.478⋅ln⁡(2.0[S]out) kJ/mol\Delta G_{\text{transport}} = R \cdot T \cdot \ln\left(\frac{[S]_{\text{in}}}{[S]_{\text{out}}}\right) \implies R \cdot T = 8.314 \cdot \frac{298}{1000} = 2.478\text{ kJ/mol} \implies \Delta G_{\text{transport}} = 2.478 \cdot \ln\left(\frac{2.0}{[S]_{\text{out}}}\right)\text{ kJ/mol}

  2. Step 2

    As [S]out→0+,2.0[S]out→∞, so ln⁡(2.0[S]out)→+∞  ⟹  lim⁡[S]out→0+ΔGtransport=+∞  ⟹  Passive transport cannot occur because ΔG is infinitely positive, necessitating active transport.\text{As }[S]_{\text{out}} \to 0^+, \frac{2.0}{[S]_{\text{out}}} \to \infty, \text{ so } \ln\left(\frac{2.0}{[S]_{\text{out}}}\right) \to +\infty \implies \lim_{[S]_{\text{out}} \to 0^+} \Delta G_{\text{transport}} = +\infty \implies \text{Passive transport cannot occur because } \Delta G \text{ is infinitely positive, necessitating active transport.}

  3. Step 3

    2.478⋅ln⁡(2.0[S]out,min⁡)=50.0  ⟹  ln⁡(2.0[S]out,min⁡)=20.18  ⟹  2.0[S]out,min⁡=e20.18=5.81×1082.478 \cdot \ln\left(\frac{2.0}{[S]_{\text{out},\min}}\right) = 50.0 \implies \ln\left(\frac{2.0}{[S]_{\text{out},\min}}\right) = 20.18 \implies \frac{2.0}{[S]_{\text{out},\min}} = e^{20.18} = 5.81 \times 10^8

  4. Step 4

    [S]out,min⁡=2.0(5.81×108)=3.44×10−9 M[S]_{\text{out},\min} = \frac{2.0}{(5.81 \times 10^8)} = 3.44 \times 10^{-9}\text{ M}

    Correct

    [S]out,min⁡=2.0×10−3 M5.81×108≈3.44×10−12 M[S]_{\text{out},\min} = \frac{2.0 \times 10^{-3}\text{ M}}{5.81 \times 10^8} \approx 3.44 \times 10^{-12}\text{ M}

    Because you entered the numerator as 2.02.0 instead of 2.0×10−3 M2.0 \times 10^{-3}\text{ M}, your calculated concentration came out in millimolar (3.44×10−9 mM3.44 \times 10^{-9}\text{ mM}) rather than molar units (3.44×10−12 M3.44 \times 10^{-12}\text{ M}).

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly stated and applied the thermodynamic equation for transport of an uncharged solute.

You correctly converted the gas constant RR into kJ/(mol⋅K)\text{kJ}/(\text{mol}\cdot\text{K}) to match the energy units.

You accurately evaluated the asymptotic behavior of the logarithm as external concentration approaches zero.

You correctly balanced the thermodynamic threshold against ATP hydrolysis free energy.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Unit Conversion Omission

You calculated [S]out,min⁡[S]_{\text{out},\min} using millimolar concentration values but attached the label M\text{M} to your final answer without converting by 10−310^{-3}.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Overlooking the initial unit conversion from mM\text{mM} to M\text{M} before substituting into logarithmic thermodynamic equations causes the resulting concentration to inherit the unscaled unit (extmM ext{mM}), leading to an off-by-10310^3 error in molarity.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Standard Concentration Units in Free Energy Equations
  • Thermodynamic equations using standard chemical potentials require concentrations to be expressed in standard units (extM ext{M} or extmol/L ext{mol/L}) unless ratios are explicitly dimensionless.

  • Whenever solving for an absolute concentration [S][S] in M\text{M}, convert all given concentrations to molarity (1 mM=10−3 M1\text{ mM} = 10^{-3}\text{ M}) before solving.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Express the intracellular concentration in molar units: [S]in=2.0 mM=2.0×10−3 M[S]_{\text{in}} = 2.0\text{ mM} = 2.0 \times 10^{-3}\text{ M}.

  2. Substitute this value into the ratio equation: 2.0×10−3 M[S]out,min⁡=5.81×108\frac{2.0 \times 10^{-3}\text{ M}}{[S]_{\text{out},\min}} = 5.81 \times 10^8.

  3. Solve for [S]out,min⁡[S]_{\text{out},\min}: [S]out,min⁡=2.0×10−3 M5.81×108≈3.44×10−12 M[S]_{\text{out},\min} = \frac{2.0 \times 10^{-3}\text{ M}}{5.81 \times 10^8} \approx 3.44 \times 10^{-12}\text{ M}.

Final answer

[S]out,min⁡=3.44×10−12 M[S]_{\text{out},\min} = 3.44 \times 10^{-12}\text{ M} (or 3.48×10−12 M3.48 \times 10^{-12}\text{ M} using unrounded intermediate values)

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Write down explicit units beside every quantity during the setup phase (e.g., 2.0 mM=2.0×10−3 M2.0\text{ mM} = 2.0 \times 10^{-3}\text{ M}).

  • Double-check that the unit of the solved variable matches the exact unit requested in the prompt before writing the final boxed answer.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A cell maintains an internal glucose concentration of [Glc]in=5.0 mM[\text{Glc}]_{\text{in}} = 5.0\text{ mM}. Calculate ΔGtransport\Delta G_{\text{transport}} (in kJ/mol\text{kJ/mol}) for glucose entering the cell when the extracellular concentration is [Glc]out=20.0 mM[\text{Glc}]_{\text{out}} = 20.0\text{ mM} at T=298 KT = 298\text{ K} (RT=2.478 kJ/molRT = 2.478\text{ kJ/mol}). State whether transport can occur passively.

Answer

ΔGtransport=RTln⁡([Glc]in[Glc]out)=2.478ln⁡(5.020.0)=2.478ln⁡(0.25)≈−3.44 kJ/mol\Delta G_{\text{transport}} = RT \ln\left(\frac{[\text{Glc}]_{\text{in}}}{[\text{Glc}]_{\text{out}}}\right) = 2.478 \ln\left(\frac{5.0}{20.0}\right) = 2.478 \ln(0.25) \approx -3.44\text{ kJ/mol}. Because ΔG<0\Delta G < 0, transport into the cell is thermodynamically spontaneous and can occur passively via facilitated diffusion.

02

An active transporter uses the hydrolysis of 1 mole of ATP (providing ΔGATP=−45.0 kJ/mol\Delta G_{\text{ATP}} = -45.0\text{ kJ/mol}) to accumulate an uncharged nutrient inside the cell at T=310 KT = 310\text{ K} (RT=2.577 kJ/molRT = 2.577\text{ kJ/mol}). If [nutrient]in=10.0 mM[\text{nutrient}]_{\text{in}} = 10.0\text{ mM}, calculate the minimum extracellular concentration [nutrient]out,min⁡[\text{nutrient}]_{\text{out},\min} (in M\text{M}) that allows continued uptake.

Answer

At thermodynamic equilibrium, ΔGtransport+ΔGATP=0  ⟹  RTln⁡([nutrient]in[nutrient]out,min⁡)=45.0 kJ/mol\Delta G_{\text{transport}} + \Delta G_{\text{ATP}} = 0 \implies RT \ln\left(\frac{[\text{nutrient}]_{\text{in}}}{[\text{nutrient}]_{\text{out},\min}}\right) = 45.0\text{ kJ/mol}. Thus, ln⁡(10.0×10−3[nutrient]out,min⁡)=45.02.577≈17.46\ln\left(\frac{10.0 \times 10^{-3}}{[\text{nutrient}]_{\text{out},\min}}\right) = \frac{45.0}{2.577} \approx 17.46. Exponentiating gives 10.0×10−3[nutrient]out,min⁡=e17.46≈3.83×107\frac{10.0 \times 10^{-3}}{[\text{nutrient}]_{\text{out},\min}} = e^{17.46} \approx 3.83 \times 10^7, yielding [nutrient]out,min⁡=10.0×10−33.83×107≈2.61×10−10 M[\text{nutrient}]_{\text{out},\min} = \frac{10.0 \times 10^{-3}}{3.83 \times 10^7} \approx 2.61 \times 10^{-10}\text{ M} (261 pM261\text{ pM}).

03

A symporter couples the inward transport of 1 mole of an uncharged solute SS to the inward transport of 2 moles of Na+\text{Na}^+. The free energy released by Na+\text{Na}^+ entry under physiological conditions is ΔGNa+=−14.0 kJ/mol of Na+\Delta G_{\text{Na}^+} = -14.0\text{ kJ/mol of }\text{Na}^+. At T=298 KT = 298\text{ K} (RT=2.478 kJ/molRT = 2.478\text{ kJ/mol}), what is the maximum concentration gradient ratio [S]in[S]out\frac{[S]_{\text{in}}}{[S]_{\text{out}}} the cell can generate?

Answer

Total energy provided by the co-transport of 2 moles of Na+\text{Na}^+ is 2×(−14.0 kJ/mol)=−28.0 kJ/mol2 \times (-14.0\text{ kJ/mol}) = -28.0\text{ kJ/mol}. For coupled transport to occur, ΔGtransport≤−ΔGcoupled=+28.0 kJ/mol\Delta G_{\text{transport}} \le -\Delta G_{\text{coupled}} = +28.0\text{ kJ/mol}. Setting RTln⁡([S]in[S]out)=28.0 kJ/molRT \ln\left(\frac{[S]_{\text{in}}}{[S]_{\text{out}}}\right) = 28.0\text{ kJ/mol}, we have ln⁡([S]in[S]out)=28.02.478≈11.30\ln\left(\frac{[S]_{\text{in}}}{[S]_{\text{out}}}\right) = \frac{28.0}{2.478} \approx 11.30. Exponentiating both sides yields [S]in[S]out=e11.30≈8.08×104\frac{[S]_{\text{in}}}{[S]_{\text{out}}} = e^{11.30} \approx 8.08 \times 10^4. The cell can concentrate the solute up to approximately 8.1×1048.1 \times 10^4-fold.

Loading workspace…