Resources
A population of marine iguanas displays standing genetic variation in adult body length (), ranging from to . During severe El Niño events, marine algae become scarce. Metabolic maintenance costs scale with body length according to , while grazing harvest rate on intertidal turf algae scales as . At the critical threshold where metabolic demand exactly balances maximal energy intake during starvation (), survival probability drops sharply. If physiological measurements establish : (a) determine the threshold body length , and (b) explain whether body length variation above functions as an adaptation or a maladaptive trait under severe El Niño selection pressure.
Answer and steps
Final answer
(a) . (b) Body length exceeding is maladaptive under the acute starvation selection pressure of El Niño because metabolic energy demand exceeds maximal intake rate (), leading to higher mortality; conversely, smaller body size () acts as a selective survival adaptation.
Steps
Part (a): Determining the Critical Body Length ()
- Set up the equilibrium condition: The critical threshold occurs when metabolic maintenance demand equals maximal energy harvest rate:
- Solve for : Since adult body length , divide both sides by :
- Substitute the given ratio: Given :
Part (b): Evaluating the Trait Under Selection Pressure
To evaluate whether body length above is adaptive or maladaptive, we differentiate the evolutionary components:
- Genetic Variation: The population exhibits standing phenotypic variation in adult body length spanning from to .
- Selection Pressure: Severe El Niño events cause widespread algal die-offs, drastically reducing food availability and imposing intense nutritional and energetic stress.
- Energetic Scaling and Fitness:
- Because metabolic costs scale with volume () while foraging intake scales with surface area or bite size (), metabolic demands grow faster than harvest capacity as body length increases.
- For individuals with , metabolic expenditure exceeds the maximal possible energy intake (). These larger iguanas experience a severe negative energy deficit, rapid depletion of fat stores, and elevated starvation mortality.
- Therefore, body lengths exceeding function as a maladaptive trait under El Niño starvation conditions.
- Conversely, a smaller body size () maintains a balanced or surplus energy budget (), functioning as a selective survival adaptation that confers higher fitness during resource-poor periods.
Typical errors
01 The student confuses adaptation with maladaptation by assuming larger body size is universally advantageous regardless of resource intake constraints.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
- Step 2
Body length above is an adaptation because larger body size allows iguanas to graze more algae and outcompete smaller individuals during food scarcity.
CorrectBody length above is a maladaptive trait under severe El Niño conditions because metabolic maintenance demand exceeds maximal harvest intake (), leading to starvation and higher mortality.
You assumed that grazing more food makes larger body size universally advantageous, but for , metabolic energy demand () outpaces food intake (), creating a fatal energy deficit under starvation conditions.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly equated metabolic demand and grazing harvest to find .
You recognized that body size affects foraging ability and resource competition.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou evaluated fitness by looking only at absolute foraging intake () rather than the net energy balance (). Because metabolic expenditure scales with volume () while intake scales only with surface area (), larger individuals experience a severe net energy deficit during resource collapse, making large size a maladaptive trait rather than an adaptation under El Niño selection pressure.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Trait Value vs. Environmental Context
An adaptation is a heritable trait that increases reproductive fitness under the specific prevailing selection pressure; if a trait decreases survival or fitness in that environment, it is maladaptive.
Check whether the net energy balance () is positive or negative under starvation conditions before deciding whether the trait is adaptive.
- Scaling Laws and Net Energy Balance
When maintenance costs scale as and intake scales as , exceeding guarantees .
Compare and for to show that larger body size creates an unsustainable metabolic deficit.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationEvaluate the net energy budget for an individual with : since , .
Recognize that when metabolic costs exceed maximal intake, the individual enters a severe energy deficit, depleting body reserves and facing elevated starvation mortality.
Conclude that body length above functions as a maladaptive trait under El Niño selection pressure, while smaller body size () is the adaptive trait.
(a) . (b) Body length above is maladaptive under severe El Niño selection pressure because metabolic maintenance costs exceed maximal energy intake (), resulting in starvation.
02 The student inverts the scaling ratio when solving for the threshold length, obtaining L_crit = k/c = 0.0139 cm instead of c/k.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1Correct
You correctly set up the metabolic and harvest balance equation, but when dividing both sides by , you inverted the quotient and wrote instead of .
- Step 2Correct
You accurately evaluated the numerical reciprocal of , but this value is affected by the algebraic inversion in Step 1. Notice also that falls far below the population's actual size range of to .
- Step 3
Body length above is a maladaptive trait because metabolic demands outpace energy intake, leading to starvation.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly equated metabolic maintenance cost and grazing harvest rate to find the threshold boundary.
You correctly identified that exceeding the critical threshold represents a maladaptive trait during food scarcity.
You clearly linked the scaling deficit to the physiological consequence of starvation.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisWhen isolating a linear variable from , you divided by instead of dividing both sides by the coefficient , inverting the resulting fraction.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Isolating Variables with Coefficients
For an equation , dividing both sides by yields , not .
Always write the intermediate step explicitly before dividing by the coefficient .
- Biological Sense Check
Calculated threshold values must fall within or near the biologically realistic trait distribution given in the problem.
Check whether your calculated threshold () fits within the population's natural variation range ( to ).
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationDivide both sides of by : .
Divide both sides by to isolate : .
Substitute the given ratio : .
(a) ; (b) Body length exceeding is maladaptive during severe El Niño starvation events because metabolic demands exceed maximal intake rate ().
03 The student misinterprets the scaling equations by assuming intake scales with the cube and cost with the square, resulting in the reversed conclusion that sizes above L_crit have excess energy.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1Correct
You assigned the cubic exponent to harvest rate and the quadratic exponent to metabolic cost instead of setting as defined in the problem.
- Step 2Correct
You correctly evaluated the reciprocal of based on your inverted formula, but this value is physically outside the population's actual size range of to .
- Step 3
Body length above is an adaptation because energy intake scales faster than metabolic cost at larger sizes, providing surplus energy.
CorrectBody length above is a maladaptive trait because metabolic demand scales with volume () and outpaces intake scaling (), resulting in an energetic deficit and starvation during El Niño.
Because metabolic expenditure scales as while intake scales as , metabolic costs increase more steeply with size than harvest intake. Consequently, iguanas larger than suffer an energy deficit, making large size maladaptive rather than adaptive under food-limited selection pressure.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou recognized that the critical threshold occurs when metabolic expenditure balances energy intake.
You correctly manipulated your chosen algebraic expression to isolate the length variable.
You related an energy surplus to evolutionary adaptation.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou accidentally exchanged the exponents of the metabolic cost () and grazing harvest rate () terms when writing down the equilibrium equation.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou conflated volumetric scaling (maintenance costs proportional to 3D tissue volume, ) with areal scaling (foraging intake proportional to 2D mouth or surface grazing area, ), leading to the conclusion that larger animals have higher relative energy intake.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Allometric Scaling of Volume vs. Surface Area
Biological mass and maintenance costs scale cubically with linear dimension (), whereas intake and exchange surfaces scale quadratically ().
Check that volume/mass-dependent traits receive the higher exponent () and surface/bite-dependent traits receive the lower exponent ().
- Biological Reality Check on Parameter Ranges
A derived threshold must fall within or near the biologically observed range of the population.
Compare your calculated value () against the given population size range ( to ) to catch inverted fractions early.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationWrite the balance condition: .
Divide both sides by to solve for : .
Substitute the given ratio directly: .
Analyze the net energy balance : for , metabolic cost exceeds intake, producing a negative energy balance that increases mortality.
(a) ; (b) Body length exceeding is a maladaptive trait under severe El Niño selection pressure because metabolic cost exceeds maximal food intake.
Lock it in
What determines whether a heritable trait variation functions as an adaptation or as maladaptive?
Its effect on net reproductive fitness under the specific, prevailing environmental selection pressure, not an absolute advantage across all conditions.
Similar question
During an El Niño event, two marine iguanas have body lengths of and . Given , determine which individual has a positive net energy budget and classify its body size as adaptive or maladaptive under starvation.
Answer
For , intake exceeds maintenance (), yielding a positive or sustainable energy balance; thus, smaller body size is adaptive. For , maintenance exceeds intake (), causing a negative energy budget and making large size maladaptive.
In normal non-El Niño years, algal abundance is high, increasing the harvest coefficient such that . Explain whether an iguana with has an adaptive or maladaptive body length in normal years compared to El Niño years.
Answer
In normal years, , meaning intake exceeds metabolic cost and large size confers mating and territory advantages, making it adaptive. In El Niño years (), the same body length exceeds threshold, making it maladaptive. This demonstrates that adaptation is environment-dependent.
Suppose a desert lizard's water loss rate scales as while water storage volume scales as . During a prolonged drought, survival time is proportional to . Identify whether larger body mass acts as an adaptation or maladaptation under drought selection pressure, and justify using scaling.
Answer
. Because drought endurance increases with , larger body mass extends survival time during dehydration, functioning as an adaptation under drought selection pressure.