Resources

An isolated volcanic archipelago formed 4.50 Myr4.50\text{ Myr} ago was colonized by a single ancestral finch species (S0=1S_0 = 1). Ecological opportunity across diverse microhabitats triggered an adaptive radiation, yielding S(t)=18S(t) = 18 distinct endemic species today across four distinct feeding guilds. Paleontological and phylogenetic data indicate an average per-capita speciation rate of b=0.720 Myr−1b = 0.720\text{ Myr}^{-1} over this radiation. Under the constant-rate birth-death model dSdt=(b−d)S\frac{dS}{dt} = (b - d)S, calculate the average background per-capita extinction rate dd (in Myr−1\text{Myr}^{-1}) that operated within this clade across the 4.50 Myr4.50\text{ Myr} evolutionary timeframe. Express your answer to three significant figures.

Answer and steps

Final answer

d=0.0777 Myr−1d = 0.0777\text{ Myr}^{-1}

Steps

01

The Diversification Model

Under a continuous-time, constant-rate birth-death process of lineage diversification, the rate of change in species richness SS over time tt is governed by the differential equation:

dSdt=(b−d)S\frac{dS}{dt} = (b - d)S

where:

  • bb is the per-capita speciation rate (birth of lineages),
  • dd is the per-capita extinction rate (death of lineages),
  • r=b−dr = b - d represents the net diversification rate.

Integrating this differential equation from an initial time t=0t = 0 with an initial richness S0S_0 to time tt gives the exponential growth equation:

S(t)=S0e(b−d)t=S0ertS(t) = S_0 e^{(b - d)t} = S_0 e^{rt}


02

Identifying the Given Parameters

From the problem statement:

  • Initial ancestral species: S0=1S_0 = 1
  • Present species richness: S(t)=18S(t) = 18
  • Time elapsed: t=4.50 Myrt = 4.50\text{ Myr}
  • Speciation rate: b=0.720 Myr−1b = 0.720\text{ Myr}^{-1}

03

Calculating the Net Diversification Rate (rr)

Substitute the known values into the exponential formula:

18=1⋅er⋅4.5018 = 1 \cdot e^{r \cdot 4.50}

Take the natural logarithm of both sides:

ln⁡(18)=4.50⋅r\ln(18) = 4.50 \cdot r

Evaluate ln⁡(18)\ln(18):

ln⁡(18)≈2.89037\ln(18) \approx 2.89037

Solve for rr:

r=2.890374.50≈0.64230 Myr−1r = \frac{2.89037}{4.50} \approx 0.64230\text{ Myr}^{-1}


04

Determining the Per-Capita Extinction Rate (dd)

Using the relationship r=b−dr = b - d, isolate dd:

d=b−rd = b - r

Substitute the values for bb and rr:

d=0.720−0.64230=0.07770 Myr−1d = 0.720 - 0.64230 = 0.07770\text{ Myr}^{-1}

Rounding to three significant figures yields:

d=0.0777 Myr−1d = 0.0777\text{ Myr}^{-1}


Common Pitfall to Avoid

  • Confusing speciation rate (bb) with net diversification rate (rr): The observed rate of species accumulation ln⁡(S/S0)t\frac{\ln(S/S_0)}{t} reflects net lineage accumulation (b−db - d), not the speciation rate alone. Overlooking background extinction underestimates the total number of speciation events that actually took place across the evolutionary timeline.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 A student might confuse the net diversification rate formula r = b - d with r = b + d, mistakenly adding the extinction rate rather than subtracting it.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    S(t)=S0⋅e(b+d)t  ⟹  18=1⋅e(0.720+d)⋅4.50S(t) = S_0 \cdot e^{(b+d)t} \implies 18 = 1 \cdot e^{(0.720 + d) \cdot 4.50}

    Correct

    S(t)=S0e(b−d)t  ⟹  18=1⋅e(0.720−d)⋅4.50S(t) = S_0 e^{(b - d)t} \implies 18 = 1 \cdot e^{(0.720 - d) \cdot 4.50}

    You set up the exponential diversification formula with b+db + d instead of b−db - d. Because extinction decreases species richness over time, the net diversification rate is the speciation rate minus the extinction rate (r=b−dr = b - d), as defined by the problem's differential equation dSdt=(b−d)S\frac{dS}{dt} = (b - d)S.

  2. Step 2

    ln⁡(18)=(0.720+d)⋅4.50  ⟹  2.890=3.24+4.50d  ⟹  4.50d=2.890−3.24=−0.350\ln(18) = (0.720 + d) \cdot 4.50 \implies 2.890 = 3.24 + 4.50d \implies 4.50d = 2.890 - 3.24 = -0.350

    Correct

    ln⁡(18)=(0.720−d)⋅4.50  ⟹  2.890≈3.24−4.50d  ⟹  4.50d=3.24−2.890=0.350\ln(18) = (0.720 - d) \cdot 4.50 \implies 2.890 \approx 3.24 - 4.50d \implies 4.50d = 3.24 - 2.890 = 0.350

    You correctly took the natural logarithm of both sides and expanded the linear equation, but this step carries forward the incorrect sign from your formula setup.

  3. Step 3

    d=−0.0778 Myr−1d = -0.0778\text{ Myr}^{-1}

    Correct

    d=0.0777 Myr−1d = 0.0777\text{ Myr}^{-1}

    Your final value inherits the sign error and yields a negative rate. Extinction rates represent per-capita lineage deaths and must be positive.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly extracted all the given parameters (S0=1S_0 = 1, S(t)=18S(t) = 18, t=4.50 Myrt = 4.50\text{ Myr}, and b=0.720 Myr−1b = 0.720\text{ Myr}^{-1}) from the problem.

You correctly applied natural logarithms to isolate the rate inside the exponential function.

You carried out the algebraic linear rearrangement accurately.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Sign Error in Diversification Rate Formula

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You confused the net diversification rate r=b−dr = b - d with a total turnover sum b+db + d. In birth-death population and lineage models, 'birth' (speciation) adds lineages while 'death' (extinction) removes them, meaning net growth rate must always be birth minus death.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Net Diversification Definition
  • In a birth-death process dSdt=(b−d)S\frac{dS}{dt} = (b - d)S, the net growth rate is r=b−dr = b - d, never b+db + d.

  • Check that processes removing individuals or lineages enter the net rate with a negative sign.

Biological Sanity Check on Rates
  • Per-capita speciation rates (bb) and extinction rates (dd) are defined as non-negative quantities (b≥0b \ge 0, d≥0d \ge 0).

  • If an extinction rate computes to a negative number while diversity is increasing and b>rb > r, verify the sign convention in your initial formula.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. S(t)=S0e(b−d)t  ⟹  18=1⋅e(0.720−d)⋅4.50S(t) = S_0 e^{(b - d)t} \implies 18 = 1 \cdot e^{(0.720 - d) \cdot 4.50}

  2. ln⁡(18)=(0.720−d)⋅4.50\ln(18) = (0.720 - d) \cdot 4.50

  3. 2.89037=3.240−4.50d2.89037 = 3.240 - 4.50d

  4. 4.50d=3.240−2.89037=0.349634.50d = 3.240 - 2.89037 = 0.34963

  5. d=0.349634.50≈0.07770 Myr−1d = \frac{0.34963}{4.50} \approx 0.07770\text{ Myr}^{-1}

Final answer

d=0.0777 Myr−1d = 0.0777\text{ Myr}^{-1}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the derivation of the exponential growth model from the differential equation dSdt=(b−d)S\frac{dS}{dt} = (b - d)S.

  • Practice distinguishing between net diversification rate (r=b−dr = b - d) and lineage turnover rate (T=b+dT = b + d).

  • Always verify whether your final biological rates are non-negative as a sanity check.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 A student might solve for the net diversification rate r = b - d correctly but forget to subtract it from the speciation rate b, reporting r as the extinction rate d.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    S(t)=S0⋅e(r⋅t)  ⟹  18=1⋅e(r⋅4.50)S(t) = S_0 \cdot e^{(r \cdot t)} \implies 18 = 1 \cdot e^{(r \cdot 4.50)}

  2. Step 2

    r⋅4.50=ln⁡(18)=2.890  ⟹  r=2.8904.50=0.642 Myr−1r \cdot 4.50 = \ln(18) = 2.890 \implies r = \frac{2.890}{4.50} = 0.642\text{ Myr}^{-1}

  3. Step 3

    d=0.642 Myr−1d = 0.642\text{ Myr}^{-1}

    Correct

    d=b−r=0.720−0.6423=0.0777 Myr−1d = b - r = 0.720 - 0.6423 = 0.0777\text{ Myr}^{-1}

    You set dd equal to the net diversification rate rr. Because r=b−dr = b - d, the extinction rate is found by subtracting rr from the speciation rate bb.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly set up the continuous-time exponential model for species diversification.

You accurately took natural logarithms and solved for the net diversification rate r=0.642 Myr−1r = 0.642\text{ Myr}^{-1}.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Conflating net diversification rate with extinction rate

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated the net diversification rate rr as the extinction rate dd, overlooking the defining relationship r=b−dr = b - d where speciation (bb) and extinction (dd) jointly determine net accumulation.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Relate net diversification to speciation and extinction
  • The net diversification rate equals speciation rate minus extinction rate: r=b−dr = b - d.

  • After solving for rr, isolate the unknown parameter: d=b−rd = b - r.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Write the relationship between net diversification rate, speciation rate, and extinction rate: r=b−dr = b - d.

  2. Rearrange the formula to solve for the extinction rate: d=b−rd = b - r.

  3. Substitute the given speciation rate b=0.720 Myr−1b = 0.720\text{ Myr}^{-1} and the computed rate r=0.6423 Myr−1r = 0.6423\text{ Myr}^{-1}: d=0.720−0.6423=0.0777 Myr−1d = 0.720 - 0.6423 = 0.0777\text{ Myr}^{-1}.

Final answer

d=0.0777 Myr−1d = 0.0777\text{ Myr}^{-1}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Recall that observed lineage growth reflects net diversification (r=b−dr = b - d), not speciation or extinction alone.

  • Always check whether the problem asks for net diversification (rr), speciation (bb), or background extinction (dd) before stating your final answer.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 A student might incorrectly use common logarithm (base 10) instead of the natural logarithm to solve the exponential equation.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    S(t)=S0⋅e(b−d)t  ⟹  18=e(0.720−d)⋅4.50S(t) = S_0 \cdot e^{(b-d)t} \implies 18 = e^{(0.720 - d) \cdot 4.50}

  2. Step 2

    log⁡10(18)=(0.720−d)⋅4.50\log_{10}(18) = (0.720 - d) \cdot 4.50

    Correct

    ln⁡(18)=(0.720−d)⋅4.50\ln(18) = (0.720 - d) \cdot 4.50

    Because the base of the exponential term is Euler's number ee, you must take the natural logarithm (ln⁡\ln) of both sides so that ln⁡(eu)=u\ln(e^u) = u. Taking the common logarithm log⁡10\log_{10} leaves an uncancelled factor of log⁡10(e)≈0.4343\log_{10}(e) \approx 0.4343.

  3. Step 3

    1.255=3.24−4.50d  ⟹  4.50d=3.24−1.255=1.985  ⟹  d=0.441 Myr−11.255 = 3.24 - 4.50d \implies 4.50d = 3.24 - 1.255 = 1.985 \implies d = 0.441\text{ Myr}^{-1}

    Correct

    2.890=3.24−4.50d  ⟹  4.50d=3.24−2.890=0.350  ⟹  d=0.0777 Myr−12.890 = 3.24 - 4.50d \implies 4.50d = 3.24 - 2.890 = 0.350 \implies d = 0.0777\text{ Myr}^{-1}

    Your algebraic manipulation and rounding were executed correctly based on your intermediate values, but the result is downstream from using log⁡10(18)≈1.255\log_{10}(18) \approx 1.255 instead of ln⁡(18)≈2.890\ln(18) \approx 2.890.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly recalled and applied the continuous-time lineage diversification model S(t)=S0e(b−d)tS(t) = S_0 e^{(b-d)t}.

You correctly extracted and substituted all biological parameters from the problem statement.

You correctly carried out the subsequent linear algebra to isolate the extinction rate dd.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Logarithm Base Mismatch

You wrote log⁡10(18)\log_{10}(18) rather than ln⁡(18)\ln(18) when undoing the natural exponential e(b−d)te^{(b-d)t}.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Conflating the common logarithm (log⁡10\log_{10}) with the natural logarithm (ln⁡\ln) when solving exponential equations with base ee, assuming log⁡10(ex)=x\log_{10}(e^x) = x instead of using the inverse property ln⁡(ex)=x\ln(e^x) = x.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Inverse of Euler's Exponential
  • The inverse function of f(x)=exf(x) = e^x is the natural logarithm ln⁡(x)\ln(x), meaning ln⁡(ex)=x\ln(e^x) = x.

  • Whenever a variable is in the exponent of base ee, take ln⁡\ln of both sides, never log⁡10\log_{10}.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Take the natural logarithm of both sides: ln⁡(18)=(0.720−d)⋅4.50\ln(18) = (0.720 - d) \cdot 4.50

  2. Evaluate the natural logarithm: 2.89037=3.24−4.50d2.89037 = 3.24 - 4.50d

  3. Isolate 4.50d4.50d: 4.50d=3.24−2.89037=0.349634.50d = 3.24 - 2.89037 = 0.34963

  4. Divide by 4.504.50: d=0.349634.50≈0.077696 Myr−1d = \frac{0.34963}{4.50} \approx 0.077696\text{ Myr}^{-1}

Final answer

d=0.0777 Myr−1d = 0.0777\text{ Myr}^{-1}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the identity ln⁡(ex)=x\ln(e^x) = x versus log⁡10(10x)=x\log_{10}(10^x) = x.

  • Recalculate the extinction rate using ln⁡(18)≈2.890\ln(18) \approx 2.890 to confirm d=0.0777 Myr−1d = 0.0777\text{ Myr}^{-1}.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A monophyletic clade of cichlid fish radiated from a single ancestral species (S0=1S_0 = 1) to 2424 species over 3.00 Myr3.00\text{ Myr}. If the per-capita speciation rate is b=1.25 Myr−1b = 1.25\text{ Myr}^{-1}, calculate the background per-capita extinction rate dd to three significant figures.

Answer

d=0.191 Myr−1d = 0.191\text{ Myr}^{-1}. Key steps: r=ln⁡(24/1)3.00=3.178053.00≈1.05935 Myr−1r = \frac{\ln(24/1)}{3.00} = \frac{3.17805}{3.00} \approx 1.05935\text{ Myr}^{-1}; d=b−r=1.25−1.05935=0.19065≈0.191 Myr−1d = b - r = 1.25 - 1.05935 = 0.19065 \approx 0.191\text{ Myr}^{-1}.

02

An island beetle lineage diversified according to dSdt=(b−d)S\frac{dS}{dt} = (b - d)S. Over 6.00 Myr6.00\text{ Myr}, the clade grew from S0=2S_0 = 2 to S(t)=32S(t) = 32. If the extinction rate is estimated at d=0.110 Myr−1d = 0.110\text{ Myr}^{-1}, determine the average per-capita speciation rate bb to three significant figures.

Answer

b=0.572 Myr−1b = 0.572\text{ Myr}^{-1}. Key steps: r=ln⁡(32/2)6.00=ln⁡(16)6.00=2.772596.00≈0.46210 Myr−1r = \frac{\ln(32/2)}{6.00} = \frac{\ln(16)}{6.00} = \frac{2.77259}{6.00} \approx 0.46210\text{ Myr}^{-1}; b=r+d=0.46210+0.110=0.57210≈0.572 Myr−1b = r + d = 0.46210 + 0.110 = 0.57210 \approx 0.572\text{ Myr}^{-1}.

03

A clade exhibits an extinction-to-speciation fraction of ϵ=db=0.250\epsilon = \frac{d}{b} = 0.250. Starting from S0=1S_0 = 1, the clade reaches S(t)=50S(t) = 50 species in 8.00 Myr8.00\text{ Myr}. Calculate both the speciation rate bb and the extinction rate dd in Myr−1\text{Myr}^{-1} to three significant figures.

Answer

b=0.652 Myr−1b = 0.652\text{ Myr}^{-1} and d=0.163 Myr−1d = 0.163\text{ Myr}^{-1}. Key steps: Net diversification rate r=ln⁡(50)8.00=3.912028.00≈0.48900 Myr−1r = \frac{\ln(50)}{8.00} = \frac{3.91202}{8.00} \approx 0.48900\text{ Myr}^{-1}. Since d=0.250bd = 0.250b, r=b−0.250b=0.750br = b - 0.250b = 0.750b. Thus b=0.489000.750≈0.6520 Myr−1b = \frac{0.48900}{0.750} \approx 0.6520\text{ Myr}^{-1} and d=0.250×0.6520≈0.163 Myr−1d = 0.250 \times 0.6520 \approx 0.163\text{ Myr}^{-1}.

Loading workspace…