Resources
A population of alpine beetles lives in a scree valley. Pigmentation is governed by an autosomal locus where allele confers dark coloration and allele confers light coloration. Initially, the population has allele frequency and is in Hardy-Weinberg equilibrium. A flash flood kills individuals at random before reproduction. Rather than tracking absolute mortality, calculate: (a) the expected percentage change in the frequency of the allele in the surviving adult gene pool, and (b) the expected change in the genotype ratio among the survivors. Explain why natural selection requires differential reproductive success of heritable variations across the population rather than individual organismal adaptation.
Answer and steps
Final answer
(a) ; (b) The expected genotype ratio remains unchanged (change ). While individuals survive or die, evolution is a statistical property of the population measured by shifts in genetic parameters; random mortality without phenotypic bias does not alter expected population allele frequencies.
Steps
Initial Allele and Genotype Frequencies
The initial population is in Hardy-Weinberg equilibrium with:
- Frequency of allele :
- Frequency of allele :
Under Hardy-Weinberg equilibrium, the initial genotype frequencies are:
The initial genotype ratio of homozygous dominant to homozygous recessive is:
Calculate the Expected Percentage Change
The flash flood kills of the individuals strictly at random.
- Because mortality is completely independent of genotype or phenotype, every individual has the identical probability of survival:
- The expected number of survivors carrying each allele is scaled down by the same factor (), meaning the expected allele frequency among the survivors is identical to the initial frequency:
Therefore, the expected percentage change in the allele frequency is:
Pitfall to Avoid: Do not confuse random mortality with natural selection. While genetic drift can cause small actual fluctuations due to finite sample size, the expected value (mean mathematical expectation) of allele frequencies remains unchanged when mortality is unbiased.
Calculate the Expected Change in the Genotype Ratio
Because random mortality affects all genotypes proportionally:
The expected ratio among the survivors remains:
The expected change in the genotype ratio is:
Evolution in Populations vs. Individuals
- Individuals do not evolve: An individual organism retains its inherited genetic makeup throughout its life. An individual beetle either survives or perishes in the flood; it cannot alter its alleles to adapt to the hazard.
- Evolution is a population-level process: Evolution is defined as a change in allele or genotype frequencies within a population's gene pool across generations.
- Requirements for Natural Selection: Natural selection requires differential reproductive success linked to heritable phenotypic variations. Because the flood causes catastrophic, random mortality without regard to coloration or genotype, all phenotypes have equal relative fitness. Without non-random survival favoring specific heritable traits, natural selection cannot occur.
Typical errors
01 The student misinterprets the 25% reduction in population size as an automatic 25% decrease in the allele frequency itself.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1Correct
You calculated the overall population mortality fraction as , but because the flood kills beetles entirely at random, both allele and allele are lost at the same expected rate. The expected allele frequency in the surviving gene pool remains , meaning .
- Step 2
- Step 3
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly calculated the initial genotype frequencies under Hardy-Weinberg equilibrium.
You recognized that random mortality causes an equal proportional loss across all genotypes.
You provided a clear, accurate explanation of why natural selection operates at the population level across generations rather than within an individual's lifespan.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou conflated the loss of total individuals in a population with a directional change in allele frequency, overlooking that unbiased random sampling scales the numerator (allele copies) and the denominator (total gene pool) by the same expected proportion.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Allele frequency definition
Allele frequency is an intensive ratio , not an extensive count.
When an event removes individuals uniformly without regard to genotype, both the numerator and denominator scale down by the same factor, so the expected frequency does not change.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationState the initial allele frequency: .
Because mortality is random, each allele copy has an equal probability of survival: .
Compute the expected surviving allele frequency: .
Calculate the expected percentage change: .
(a) ; (b) Expected change in ratio (ratio remains ); (c) Natural selection requires differential reproductive success of heritable traits, whereas individuals cannot change their genetic composition during their lifespan.
02 The student calculates the ratio as the allele frequency ratio p/q instead of the diploid genotype frequency ratio f(BB)/f(bb).
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
Mortality is completely random across genotypes Expected allele frequency does not change Expected
- Step 2
and Because mortality is random, expected surviving ratio Expected change
CorrectYou calculated the ratio of single alleles instead of the diploid genotype frequency ratio . Your conclusion that the expected change is was conceptually correct, but the baseline ratio was miscalculated.
- Step 3
Natural selection requires differential reproductive success of heritable traits across generations, because evolutionary change is a population-level shift in allele frequencies rather than individual genetic change.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly concluded that expected allele frequencies do not change under random mortality.
You correctly deduced that the expected change in the ratio between genotypes is zero.
You clearly articulated that evolution operates on population allele frequencies across generations rather than individual genetic change.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou substituted allele frequencies directly into a ratio specified for diploid genotypes.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou conflated haploid allele frequencies ( and ) with diploid homozygous genotype frequencies ( and ) under Hardy-Weinberg equilibrium.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Allele vs. Genotype Frequency
In a diploid population under Hardy-Weinberg equilibrium, individual allele frequencies are and , while homozygous genotype frequencies are and .
Always convert allele frequencies to genotype frequencies using the Hardy-Weinberg expansion before forming a genotype ratio.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationFind initial genotype frequencies under Hardy-Weinberg equilibrium: and .
Compute the initial genotype ratio: .
Because mortality is random across all phenotypes, all genotypes survive with equal probability (), leaving expected genotype frequencies and their ratio unchanged: .
(a) ; (b) Expected genotype ratio is with expected change .
03 The student conflates natural selection with physiological acclimation, claiming that individuals modify their traits and pass these acquired changes on.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
Deaths are random so allele frequencies do not systematically shift Expected
- Step 2
, Because death is random, expected surviving ratio Expected change
- Step 3
Natural selection occurs because individual beetles adapt to survive environmental changes and pass their acquired adaptations to offspring.
CorrectNatural selection acts on populations through differential reproductive success of individuals possessing preexisting heritable variations; individual organisms do not alter their genetic makeup or pass on acquired traits.
You described evolution as an active, individual-level adaptation where organisms acquire traits during their lifetime and pass them on. In modern evolutionary biology, individuals retain their inherited genotype; evolution is a population-level statistical shift in allele frequencies over generations.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly recognized that unbiased random mortality does not alter expected population allele frequencies.
You accurately calculated Hardy-Weinberg genotype frequencies and the resulting ratio .
You correctly concluded that the expected change in the genotype ratio is zero.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeNo slip was made in the calculations; this is a conceptual misconception regarding the mechanism of natural selection.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou relied on a Lamarckian concept of evolution, assuming that individual organisms adapt biochemically or anatomically to environmental pressures and pass those acquired adjustments to their offspring, rather than viewing natural selection as differential reproductive success acting on preexisting heritable genetic variation within a population.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Unit of Evolution
Individual organisms survive or reproduce, but only populations evolve across generations as allele frequencies change.
Check whether your explanation attributes genetic trait changes to an individual's lifetime response or to statistical shifts in the population gene pool.
- Origin of Adaptive Traits
Adaptive traits arise from preexisting heritable variation generated by mutation and recombination, not by purposeful organismal responses.
Ensure that natural selection is framed as the environmental filtering of preexisting genetic variants rather than the acquisition of new traits during an organism's lifetime.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationState that an individual organism's genotype remains fixed throughout its lifespan.
Define evolution as a generation-to-generation shift in allele frequencies within a population gene pool.
Explain that natural selection requires preexisting, heritable phenotypic differences that confer differential survival and reproductive success among members of the population.
(a) ; (b) Change in . Natural selection requires differential reproductive success of heritable variations across a population because individuals cannot alter their inherited genes in response to hazards; evolution is a statistical shift in allele frequencies of the population gene pool over generations.
Lock it in
Does a non-selective catastrophe that kills 50% of a population change the expected allele frequency ?
No; . When mortality is independent of genotype, both numerator (allele copies) and denominator (total gene pool) are reduced by the same expected factor.
Similar question
A pond contains 600 frogs where allele has frequency . A non-selective drainage event removes 150 frogs completely at random. What is the expected frequency of allele in the surviving pond population, and what is the expected percentage change ?
Answer
and . Because removal is independent of genotype, survival probability for all alleles is . The expected ratio of allele copies to total alleles remains .
In a diploid population of 1,000 wildflowers, flower color is controlled by locus , with and at Hardy-Weinberg equilibrium. A bulldozer clears a path destroying 30% of the plants at random. (a) What is the expected ratio of homozygous dominants to heterozygotes among survivors? (b) Did evolution by natural selection occur?
Answer
(a) . Because the loss is random, expected genotype frequencies are unchanged. (b) No; natural selection requires differential reproductive success based on heritable phenotype, whereas this was non-selective mortality.
A population of 500 mice has coat color alleles () and (). An owl predator hunts visually, killing 100 white mice () and 0 dark mice ( or ). Contrast this outcome with a random flash flood that also kills 100 mice at random, specifically stating the expected effect of each event on .
Answer
Under the owl predation (natural selection), selective mortality against reduces and increases the expected frequency (). Under the random flash flood (unbiased mortality/drift), every genotype suffers the same expected proportional loss, so the expected allele frequency remains unchanged at .