Resources

In a field study assessing postzygotic reproductive isolation between two hybridizing toad species (Anaxyrus americanus and Anaxyrus fowleri), researchers set up controlled in vitro fertilization assays in microtiter plates. A total of 600600 eggs from A.americanusA. americanus females are fertilized with A.fowleriA. fowleri sperm (hybrid cross), and 600600 eggs are fertilized with A.americanusA. americanus sperm (conspecific control). At stage 25 (free-swimming tadpole metamorphosis), 486486 control embryos successfully hatch and metamorphose, whereas only 162162 hybrid embryos survive to metamorphosis. Surviving post-metamorphic hybrid adults are reared to maturity; out of 5050 hybrid males tested, 4242 produce completely non-motile sperm (azoospermia). Calculate: (a) the hybrid viability index Vhyb=Hybrid Survival RateControl Survival RateV_{\text{hyb}} = \frac{\text{Hybrid Survival Rate}}{\text{Control Survival Rate}}, (b) the postzygotic isolation index due to viability Iviability=1−VhybI_{\text{viability}} = 1 - V_{\text{hyb}}, and (c) state the biological rule that predicts why male hybrids (the XY heterogametic sex in these anurans) suffer much higher sterility rates than female hybrids.

Answer and steps

Final answer

(a) Vhyb=0.333V_{\text{hyb}} = 0.333; (b) Iviability=0.667I_{\text{viability}} = 0.667; (c) Haldane's Rule.

Steps

Part (a): Calculating the Hybrid Viability Index (VhybV_{\text{hyb}})

  1. Calculate the survival rate of the conspecific control: Control Survival Rate=Surviving Control EmbryosTotal Control Eggs=486600=0.81\text{Control Survival Rate} = \frac{\text{Surviving Control Embryos}}{\text{Total Control Eggs}} = \frac{486}{600} = 0.81
  2. Calculate the survival rate of the hybrid cross: Hybrid Survival Rate=Surviving Hybrid EmbryosTotal Hybrid Eggs=162600=0.27\text{Hybrid Survival Rate} = \frac{\text{Surviving Hybrid Embryos}}{\text{Total Hybrid Eggs}} = \frac{162}{600} = 0.27
  3. Compute the relative hybrid viability index (VhybV_{\text{hyb}}): Vhyb=Hybrid Survival RateControl Survival Rate=0.270.81=162486=13≈0.333V_{\text{hyb}} = \frac{\text{Hybrid Survival Rate}}{\text{Control Survival Rate}} = \frac{0.27}{0.81} = \frac{162}{486} = \frac{1}{3} \approx 0.333

Part (b): Calculating the Postzygotic Isolation Index (IviabilityI_{\text{viability}})

The postzygotic reproductive isolation index quantifies the reduction in gene flow attributable to reduced hybrid developmental viability relative to the parental species:

Iviability=1−Vhyb=1−13=23≈0.667I_{\text{viability}} = 1 - V_{\text{hyb}} = 1 - \frac{1}{3} = \frac{2}{3} \approx 0.667

Note on interpretation: An isolation index of 00 indicates no postzygotic barrier (hybrids survive equally as well as purebreds), whereas an index of 11 represents complete hybrid inviability. Here, Iviability≈0.667I_{\text{viability}} \approx 0.667 demonstrates substantial postzygotic isolation at the embryonic and metamorphic stages.


Part (c): Biological Rule

The biological principle is Haldane's Rule.

  • Formulation: When in the F1F_1 offspring of two different animal races or species one sex is absent, rare, or sterile, that sex is the heterogametic sex (the sex with two different sex chromosomes, such as XY\text{XY} males or ZW\text{ZW} females).
  • Application: In anuran amphibians where males are heterogametic (XY\text{XY}), recessive incompatibility alleles on the X\text{X} chromosome are fully exposed in hemizygous males (XAYB\text{X}_A \text{Y}_B), whereas homogametic females (XX\text{XX}) are masked by dominant functional alleles, resulting in asymmetric hybrid male sterility.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student calculates the hybrid viability index by taking the direct survival rate of hybrids relative to the total initial eggs (162/600 = 0.27) instead of normalizing it by the control survival rate.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Hybrid survival rate=162600=0.27  ⟹  Vhyb=0.27\text{Hybrid survival rate} = \frac{162}{600} = 0.27 \implies V_{\text{hyb}} = 0.27

    Correct

    Vhyb=Hybrid Survival RateControl Survival Rate=162/600486/600=162486≈0.333V_{\text{hyb}} = \frac{\text{Hybrid Survival Rate}}{\text{Control Survival Rate}} = \frac{162 / 600}{486 / 600} = \frac{162}{486} \approx 0.333

    You correctly calculated the absolute survival rate of the hybrids as 0.270.27, but you did not divide it by the control baseline survival rate (0.810.81) to obtain the relative viability index.

  2. Step 2

    Iviability=1−Vhyb=1−0.27=0.73I_{\text{viability}} = 1 - V_{\text{hyb}} = 1 - 0.27 = 0.73

    Correct

    Iviability=1−Vhyb=1−13=23≈0.667I_{\text{viability}} = 1 - V_{\text{hyb}} = 1 - \frac{1}{3} = \frac{2}{3} \approx 0.667

    Your formula and arithmetic were carried out correctly, but the final value was affected by using the unnormalized Vhyb=0.27V_{\text{hyb}} = 0.27 from part (a).

  3. Step 3

    Haldane’s rule\text{Haldane's rule}

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly calculated the hybrid survival rate from the raw counts.

You correctly set up the formula for postzygotic isolation as 1−Vhyb1 - V_{\text{hyb}}.

You correctly named Haldane's rule for heterogametic hybrid sterility.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Omission of Control Baseline in Relative Viability Index

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated the viability index as an absolute survival proportion rather than a relative fitness ratio normalized against the conspecific control group.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Relative vs. Absolute Viability
  • Vhyb=Hybrid Survival RateControl Survival RateV_{\text{hyb}} = \frac{\text{Hybrid Survival Rate}}{\text{Control Survival Rate}}

  • Always compute both the hybrid survival fraction and the control survival fraction, then divide the hybrid rate by the control rate to normalize baseline developmental mortality.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Calculate the control survival rate: Control Survival Rate=486600=0.81\text{Control Survival Rate} = \frac{486}{600} = 0.81.

  2. Calculate the relative viability index: Vhyb=0.270.81=162486=13≈0.333V_{\text{hyb}} = \frac{0.27}{0.81} = \frac{162}{486} = \frac{1}{3} \approx 0.333.

  3. Substitute the corrected VhybV_{\text{hyb}} into the isolation index formula: Iviability=1−13=23≈0.667I_{\text{viability}} = 1 - \frac{1}{3} = \frac{2}{3} \approx 0.667.

Final answer

(a) Vhyb=0.333V_{\text{hyb}} = 0.333; (b) Iviability=0.667I_{\text{viability}} = 0.667; (c) Haldane's Rule.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review how relative fitness indices account for non-hybrid background mortality in developmental biology and speciation assays.

  • Practice writing down the full ratio experimental ratecontrol rate\frac{\text{experimental rate}}{\text{control rate}} before plugging in values.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student inverts the ratio in the viability formula, dividing the control survival rate by the hybrid survival rate.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Hybrid survival rate=162600=0.27  ⟹  Control survival rate=486600=0.81\text{Hybrid survival rate} = \frac{162}{600} = 0.27 \implies \text{Control survival rate} = \frac{486}{600} = 0.81

  2. Step 2

    Vhyb=0.810.27=3V_{\text{hyb}} = \frac{0.81}{0.27} = 3

    Correct

    Vhyb=Hybrid Survival RateControl Survival Rate=0.270.81=13≈0.333V_{\text{hyb}} = \frac{\text{Hybrid Survival Rate}}{\text{Control Survival Rate}} = \frac{0.27}{0.81} = \frac{1}{3} \approx 0.333

    You inverted the formula by dividing the control survival rate by the hybrid survival rate instead of dividing the hybrid rate by the control rate.

  3. Step 3

    Iviability=1−Vhyb=1−3=−2I_{\text{viability}} = 1 - V_{\text{hyb}} = 1 - 3 = -2

    Correct

    Iviability=1−Vhyb=1−13=23≈0.667I_{\text{viability}} = 1 - V_{\text{hyb}} = 1 - \frac{1}{3} = \frac{2}{3} \approx 0.667

    You correctly applied the formula 1−Vhyb1 - V_{\text{hyb}}, but your numerical result was affected by the inverted viability value from the previous step. Note that an isolation index is bounded between 00 and 11 when hybrid fitness is lower than or equal to parental fitness.

  4. Step 4

    Haldane’s rule\text{Haldane's rule}

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You calculated both the hybrid and control survival proportions accurately from the raw counts.

You correctly recalled the definition formula for the postzygotic isolation index.

You correctly identified Haldane's Rule as the governing evolutionary principle.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Ratio Inversion

You set up the relative viability ratio upside down by placing the control group in the numerator.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated the larger rate as the numerator by default, overlooking that relative hybrid viability scales the hybrid's performance as a fraction of the wild-type/conspecific baseline (Vhyb=HybridControlV_{\text{hyb}} = \frac{\text{Hybrid}}{\text{Control}}).

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Relative Fitness Reference Frame
  • Relative fitness and relative viability are always defined with respect to a standard baseline: Relative Value=Observed TargetStandard Baseline\text{Relative Value} = \frac{\text{Observed Target}}{\text{Standard Baseline}}.

  • Always place the experimental group (hybrid) in the numerator and the reference standard (conspecific control) in the denominator.

Index Bounds Reality Check
  • Because hybrid survival was lower than control survival (162<486162 < 486), the relative viability must be less than 11 (Vhyb<1V_{\text{hyb}} < 1), and the reproductive isolation index must be positive (0<Iviability≤10 < I_{\text{viability}} \le 1).

  • If your isolation index turns out negative when hybrids survive worse than controls, stop and check whether your viability fraction was inverted.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Substitute the hybrid survival rate into the numerator and the control survival rate into the denominator: Vhyb=0.270.81=13≈0.333V_{\text{hyb}} = \frac{0.27}{0.81} = \frac{1}{3} \approx 0.333.

  2. Substitute this value into the isolation index formula: Iviability=1−Vhyb=1−13=23≈0.667I_{\text{viability}} = 1 - V_{\text{hyb}} = 1 - \frac{1}{3} = \frac{2}{3} \approx 0.667.

Final answer

(a) Vhyb=13≈0.333V_{\text{hyb}} = \frac{1}{3} \approx 0.333; (b) Iviability=23≈0.667I_{\text{viability}} = \frac{2}{3} \approx 0.667; (c) Haldane's Rule

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the convention for defining relative fitness indices against conspecific wild-type controls.

  • Practice checking boundary conditions (0≤I≤10 \le I \le 1) whenever calculating isolation metrics.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student confuses Haldane's rule with Bateman's principle regarding sex differences in reproductive variance.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Hybrid survival rate=162600=0.27  ⟹  Control survival rate=486600=0.81  ⟹  Vhyb=0.270.81=13\text{Hybrid survival rate} = \frac{162}{600} = 0.27 \implies \text{Control survival rate} = \frac{486}{600} = 0.81 \implies V_{\text{hyb}} = \frac{0.27}{0.81} = \frac{1}{3}

  2. Step 2

    Iviability=1−13=23I_{\text{viability}} = 1 - \frac{1}{3} = \frac{2}{3}

  3. Step 3

    Bateman’s principle\text{Bateman's principle}

    Correct

    Haldane’s rule\text{Haldane's rule}

    You named Bateman's principle, which describes sexual selection and variance in reproductive success between sexes, rather than the rule governing hybrid inviability or sterility in the heterogametic sex.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You accurately computed the survival rates for both the hybrid cross and conspecific control.

You correctly calculated the hybrid viability index as 13\frac{1}{3}.

You properly computed the postzygotic isolation index as 23\frac{2}{3}.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Concept Confusion

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You confused Haldane's rule with Bateman's principle because both concepts address differences between males and females in evolutionary biology. Haldane's rule specifically governs postzygotic isolation and the disproportionate sterility or inviability of the heterogametic sex (XYXY or ZWZW) in interspecific hybrids, whereas Bateman's principle concerns prezygotic sexual selection and mating variance.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Recall the definition of Haldane's Rule
  • When in the F1F_1 offspring of two different animal species one sex is absent, rare, or sterile, that sex is the heterogametic sex (XYXY males or ZWZW females).

  • Use Haldane's rule whenever evaluating asymmetric hybrid sterility or inviability between sexes.

Distinguish Haldane's Rule from Bateman's Principle
  • Bateman's principle states that reproductive success in males is limited primarily by access to mates, whereas in females it is limited by resource investment in gametes and offspring.

  • Reserve Bateman's principle for discussions of sexual dimorphism, parental investment, and mating competition.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Identify the biological context: an interspecific hybrid cross displaying sex-biased postzygotic sterility in the heterogametic (XYXY) sex.

  2. State the postzygotic rule formulated by J.B.S. Haldane: Haldane's rule.

Final answer

(a) Vhyb=13≈0.333V_{\text{hyb}} = \frac{1}{3} \approx 0.333; (b) Iviability=23≈0.667I_{\text{viability}} = \frac{2}{3} \approx 0.667; (c) Haldane's rule

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the genetic basis of Haldane's rule, specifically the dominance theory involving recessive X-linked incompatibility alleles.

  • Practice categorizing evolutionary principles into prezygotic/behavioral rules (such as Bateman's principle) versus postzygotic isolation rules (such as Haldane's rule).

Lock it in

Similar question

01

In a cross between two Drosophila species, 500500 conspecific control eggs yield 400400 adult flies, while 500500 interspecific hybrid eggs yield 100100 adult flies. Calculate the relative hybrid viability index (VhybV_{\text{hyb}}) and the postzygotic isolation index (IviabilityI_{\text{viability}}).

Answer

Control survival rate = 400500=0.80\frac{400}{500} = 0.80; Hybrid survival rate = 100500=0.20\frac{100}{500} = 0.20. Vhyb=0.200.80=0.25V_{\text{hyb}} = \frac{0.20}{0.80} = 0.25. Iviability=1−0.25=0.75I_{\text{viability}} = 1 - 0.25 = 0.75.

02

In a plant hybrid cross between two diploid iris species, 10001000 control seeds produce 750750 viable seedlings. Among 10001000 hybrid seeds, 450450 produce viable seedlings. Surviving F1F_1 hybrids are backcrossed: male hybrids show 90%90\% pollen sterility while female hybrids show only 10%10\% ovule sterility. Calculate (a) VhybV_{\text{hyb}}, (b) IviabilityI_{\text{viability}}, and (c) explain whether Haldane's rule typically applies to plants without differentiated heteromorphic sex chromosomes.

Answer

(a) Vhyb=450/1000750/1000=450750=0.60V_{\text{hyb}} = \frac{450/1000}{750/1000} = \frac{450}{750} = 0.60. (b) Iviability=1−0.60=0.40I_{\text{viability}} = 1 - 0.60 = 0.40. (c) Haldane's rule does not strictly apply because most hermaphroditic plants lack heterogametic sex chromosomes; asymmetry here is instead due to nucleo-cytoplasmic incompatibilities (cytoplasmic male sterility).

03

Two cricket species are crossed. In the control cross, egg-to-adult survival is 85%85\%. In reciprocal hybrid crosses, cross 11 yields 34%34\% survival and cross 22 yields 17%17\% survival. Calculate the postzygotic isolation index for both crosses and identify the genetic mechanism that typically causes such reciprocal asymmetry.

Answer

For Cross 1: Vhyb1=0.340.85=0.40  ⟹  Iviability1=1−0.40=0.60V_{\text{hyb1}} = \frac{0.34}{0.85} = 0.40 \implies I_{\text{viability1}} = 1 - 0.40 = 0.60. For Cross 2: Vhyb2=0.170.85=0.20  ⟹  Iviability2=1−0.20=0.80V_{\text{hyb2}} = \frac{0.17}{0.85} = 0.20 \implies I_{\text{viability2}} = 1 - 0.20 = 0.80. Reciprocal asymmetry is typically caused by maternal effects, sex-linked genes, or cytonuclear incompatibilities (mitochondrial-nuclear mismatches).

Loading workspace…