Resources

An institutional biosafety panel evaluates an engineered gene drive designed to suppress populations of Anopheles gambiae to combat malaria transmission. The drive couples a homing endonuclease construct with a recessive female sterility mutation (dd). In an isolated test enclosure of initial size N0=10,000N_0 = 10{,}000 mosquitoes, the starting wild-type allele frequency is p0=0.900p_0 = 0.900 and the drive allele frequency is q0=0.100q_0 = 0.100. The drive exhibits a cleavage and homing transmission efficiency of e=0.950e = 0.950, such that the drive allele frequency in gametes produced by heterozygotes is q′=1+e2q' = \frac{1 + e}{2}. Simultaneously, the demographic cost reduces the net population growth factor to λ=0.850\lambda = 0.850 per generation. Calculate: (a) the effective frequency of the gene drive allele q1q_1 in the next generation under panmictic mating, given q1=q02+2p0q0(1+e2)q_1 = q_0^2 + 2p_0q_0\left(\frac{1 + e}{2}\right), and (b) the absolute population size N1=N0×λN_1 = N_0 \times \lambda following the first reproductive cycle.

Answer and steps

Final answer

(a) q1=(0.100)2+2(0.900)(0.100)(1+0.9502)=0.0100+0.1755=0.1855=18.6%q_1 = (0.100)^2 + 2(0.900)(0.100)\left(\frac{1 + 0.950}{2}\right) = 0.0100 + 0.1755 = 0.1855 = 18.6\%; (b) N1=8,500 mosquitoesN_1 = 8{,}500\text{ mosquitoes}

Steps

Part (a): Calculating the Allele Frequency in the Next Generation (q1q_1)

  1. Understand Gene Drive Super-Mendelian Inheritance In standard Mendelian genetics, a heterozygote passes each allele to gametes with equal probability (50%50\%). A homing endonuclease gene drive cuts the homologous wild-type chromosome, using the drive construct as a repair template. This converts heterozygous germline cells into drive homozygotes with an efficiency ee.

    The effective proportion of gametes carrying the drive allele from a heterozygote is: q′=1+e2=1+0.9502=1.9502=0.975q' = \frac{1 + e}{2} = \frac{1 + 0.950}{2} = \frac{1.950}{2} = 0.975

  2. Combine Contributions from Genotypic Classes Under panmictic (random) mating, genotype frequencies in the zygote stage follow Hardy-Weinberg proportions:

    • Homozygotes for the drive allele (d/dd/d): frequency q02=(0.100)2=0.0100q_0^2 = (0.100)^2 = 0.0100. All gametes produced by these individuals carry the drive allele.
    • Heterozygotes (+/d+/d): frequency 2p0q0=2(0.900)(0.100)=0.1802p_0q_0 = 2(0.900)(0.100) = 0.180. A fraction q′q' of their gametes carries the drive allele.
    • Wild-type homozygotes (+/++/+): produce zero drive gametes.
  3. Substitute Values into the Given Expression q1=q02+2p0q0(1+e2)q_1 = q_0^2 + 2p_0q_0\left(\frac{1 + e}{2}\right) q1=(0.100)2+2(0.900)(0.100)(0.975)q_1 = (0.100)^2 + 2(0.900)(0.100)(0.975) q1=0.0100+0.180⋅0.975q_1 = 0.0100 + 0.180 \cdot 0.975 q1=0.0100+0.1755=0.1855q_1 = 0.0100 + 0.1755 = 0.1855

    Expressed as a percentage, q1=18.55%≈18.6%q_1 = 18.55\% \approx 18.6\%.


Part (b): Calculating the Absolute Population Size (N1N_1)

  1. Apply the Net Reproductive Growth Factor The recessive female sterility mutation induces a reproductive fitness cost on the overall population, characterized by the growth factor λ=0.850\lambda = 0.850.
  2. Compute N1N_1 N1=N0×λ=10,000×0.850=8,500 mosquitoesN_1 = N_0 \times \lambda = 10{,}000 \times 0.850 = 8{,}500\text{ mosquitoes}

Common Pitfall: Do not confuse an increasing allele frequency with an increasing population size. The gene drive allele spreads through the population (qq increases from 10.0%10.0\% to 18.55%18.55\%) even while causing the total population size to decline (NN decreases from 10,00010{,}000 to 8,5008{,}500) due to the sterility load it introduces.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student forgets to square the initial homozygote frequency q_0, writing q_0 instead of q_0², which inflates the next-generation drive frequency to 0.2755.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    1+e2=0.975\frac{1+e}{2} = 0.975

  2. Step 2

    q1=q0+2p0q0(0.975)  ⟹  q1=0.100+2(0.900)(0.100)(0.975)  ⟹  q1=0.100+0.1755=0.2755q_1 = q_0 + 2p_0q_0(0.975) \implies q_1 = 0.100 + 2(0.900)(0.100)(0.975) \implies q_1 = 0.100 + 0.1755 = 0.2755

    Correct

    q1=q02+2p0q0(0.975)=(0.100)2+2(0.900)(0.100)(0.975)=0.0100+0.1755=0.1855q_1 = q_0^2 + 2p_0q_0(0.975) = (0.100)^2 + 2(0.900)(0.100)(0.975) = 0.0100 + 0.1755 = 0.1855

    You substituted the initial allele frequency q0q_0 directly as a linear term instead of squaring it as the genotype frequency of homozygotes (q02q_0^2). Under Hardy-Weinberg equilibrium before transmission, the drive homozygotes contribute q02=(0.100)2=0.0100q_0^2 = (0.100)^2 = 0.0100 to the gene pool.

  3. Step 3

    N1=N0×λ  ⟹  N1=10,000×0.850=8,500N_1 = N_0 \times \lambda \implies N_1 = 10{,}000 \times 0.850 = 8{,}500

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly calculated the biased inheritance fraction from heterozygotes as 0.9750.975.

You accurately computed the absolute population size N1=8,500N_1 = 8{,}500 using the demographic multiplier λ\lambda.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Omission of Exponent in Genotype Frequency

You wrote q0q_0 instead of q02q_0^2 when setting up the recurrence equation for q1q_1.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Confusing individual allele frequency (q0q_0) with the diploid homozygous genotype frequency (q02q_0^2) in the population zygote pool.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Allele vs. Genotype Frequency
  • In a diploid population under random mating, the zygote frequency of drive homozygotes is q02q_0^2, not q0q_0.

  • Ensure that the homozygous parental class carries the square exponent (q2q^2) before adding it to heterozygous contributions.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Write the recurrence equation preserving the square: q1=q02+2p0q0(1+e2)q_1 = q_0^2 + 2p_0q_0\left(\frac{1+e}{2}\right).

  2. Substitute the initial frequency: q02=(0.100)2=0.0100q_0^2 = (0.100)^2 = 0.0100.

  3. Add the heterozygous contribution: q1=0.0100+2(0.900)(0.100)(0.975)=0.0100+0.1755=0.1855q_1 = 0.0100 + 2(0.900)(0.100)(0.975) = 0.0100 + 0.1755 = 0.1855.

Final answer

(a) q1=0.1855q_1 = 0.1855 (18.55%18.55\% or approx. 18.6%18.6\%); (b) N1=8,500 mosquitoesN_1 = 8{,}500\text{ mosquitoes}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Double-check that all zygotic genotype terms follow the binomial expansion (p2+2pq+q2=1p^2 + 2pq + q^2 = 1).

  • Remember that allele frequencies represent gamete probabilities, while genotype frequencies represent diploid pairs.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student directly substitutes the homing efficiency e rather than using the heterozygote gametic output (1 + e)/2, resulting in an overestimated drive frequency of 0.181.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    q1=q02+2p0q0(e)  ⟹  q1=(0.100)2+2(0.900)(0.100)(0.950)  ⟹  q1=0.010+0.171=0.181q_1 = q_0^2 + 2p_0q_0(e) \implies q_1 = (0.100)^2 + 2(0.900)(0.100)(0.950) \implies q_1 = 0.010 + 0.171 = 0.181

    Correct

    q1=q02+2p0q0(1+e2)=(0.100)2+2(0.900)(0.100)(1+0.9502)=0.0100+0.1755=0.1855q_1 = q_0^2 + 2p_0q_0\left(\frac{1 + e}{2}\right) = (0.100)^2 + 2(0.900)(0.100)\left(\frac{1 + 0.950}{2}\right) = 0.0100 + 0.1755 = 0.1855

    You substituted ee directly into the formula for heterozygote contribution rather than the gametic frequency 1+e2=0.975\frac{1 + e}{2} = 0.975. Even without homing (e=0e = 0), Mendelian transmission contributes 12\frac{1}{2} of gametes from heterozygotes, so the homing conversion adds to that baseline rather than replacing it.

  2. Step 2

    N1=N0×λ  ⟹  N1=10,000×0.850=8,500N_1 = N_0 \times \lambda \implies N_1 = 10{,}000 \times 0.850 = 8{,}500

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified and applied the demographic formula N1=N0×λN_1 = N_0 \times \lambda to compute the suppressed population size.

You accurately calculated the homozygous drive contribution q02=0.010q_0^2 = 0.010.

You performed all intermediate arithmetic and products cleanly.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Direct substitution of homing rate for gametic transmission fraction

You used ee directly in place of the heterozygote transmission term 1+e2\frac{1 + e}{2}.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Confusing the homing conversion efficiency (ee) with the total fraction of gametes carrying the drive allele from a heterozygote (q′=1+e2q' = \frac{1 + e}{2}). Mendelian segregation already provides a baseline transmission rate of 0.500.50; homing converts an additional fraction ee of the remaining 0.500.50 wild-type alleles into drive alleles.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Check Baseline Mendelian Transmission
  • A heterozygote naturally transmits each allele to 50%50\% of gametes (e=0  ⟹  q′=0.50e = 0 \implies q' = 0.50).

  • Ensure your transmission factor approaches 0.500.50 when efficiency is zero, and approaches 1.001.00 when homing is complete (e=1.00e = 1.00).

Verify Given Expression Form
  • The drive allele frequency follows q1=q02+2p0q0(1+e2)q_1 = q_0^2 + 2p_0q_0\left(\frac{1 + e}{2}\right).

  • Substitute the evaluated quantity 1+e2\frac{1 + e}{2} into the parentheses rather than the raw parameter ee.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Calculate the heterozygote gametic output: q′=1+e2=1+0.9502=0.975q' = \frac{1 + e}{2} = \frac{1 + 0.950}{2} = 0.975.

  2. Evaluate the homozygous drive zygote contribution: q02=(0.100)2=0.0100q_0^2 = (0.100)^2 = 0.0100.

  3. Evaluate the heterozygous zygote contribution: 2p0q0q′=2(0.900)(0.100)(0.975)=0.17552p_0q_0 q' = 2(0.900)(0.100)(0.975) = 0.1755.

  4. Sum both contributions: q1=0.0100+0.1755=0.1855q_1 = 0.0100 + 0.1755 = 0.1855 (or 18.6%18.6\%).

Final answer

(a) q1=0.1855q_1 = 0.1855 (or 18.6%18.6\%); (b) N1=8,500 mosquitoesN_1 = 8{,}500\text{ mosquitoes}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review how homing endonucleases convert heterozygous +/d+/d germline cells into homozygous d/dd/d cells to derive why the gametic frequency is 1+e2\frac{1+e}{2}.

  • Practice checking boundary cases: verify what happens to gamete transmission when e=0e = 0 (standard Mendelian inheritance) versus e=1e = 1 (complete gene drive conversion).

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student misinterprets the net population growth factor λ as a fractional decrease rather than the multiplicative growth factor, calculating N_1 = N_0(1 - λ) = 1,500.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    1+e2=1+0.9502=0.975  ⟹  q1=(0.100)2+2(0.900)(0.100)(0.975)  ⟹  q1=0.010+0.1755=0.1855\frac{1 + e}{2} = \frac{1 + 0.950}{2} = 0.975 \implies q_1 = (0.100)^2 + 2(0.900)(0.100)(0.975) \implies q_1 = 0.010 + 0.1755 = 0.1855

  2. Step 2

    N1=N0×(1−λ)  ⟹  N1=10,000×(1−0.850)  ⟹  N1=10,000×0.150=1,500N_1 = N_0 \times (1 - \lambda) \implies N_1 = 10{,}000 \times (1 - 0.850) \implies N_1 = 10{,}000 \times 0.150 = 1{,}500

    Correct

    N1=N0×λ=10,000×0.850=8,500N_1 = N_0 \times \lambda = 10{,}000 \times 0.850 = 8{,}500

    You treated the net growth factor λ\lambda as a fractional decrease rather than the multiplicative growth factor. In demographic modeling, the finite rate of population growth is defined directly by λ=Nt+1Nt\lambda = \frac{N_{t+1}}{N_t}, so N1=N0×λN_1 = N_0 \times \lambda.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly evaluated the transmission rate of the drive allele from heterozygotes as q′=0.975q' = 0.975.

You accurately applied the panmictic mating formula to find the next generation allele frequency q1=0.1855q_1 = 0.1855.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Growth factor confused with fractional reduction rate

You subtracted λ\lambda from 11 as if it were a mortality or reduction rate (rr), calculating N1=N0(1−λ)N_1 = N_0(1 - \lambda) instead of multiplying directly by λ\lambda.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Conflating the finite rate of population increase (the geometric growth factor λ\lambda, where λ<1\lambda < 1 represents population decline) with a fractional loss rate dd or percent decrease. In discrete demographic models, Nt+1=λNtN_{t+1} = \lambda N_t, not Nt(1−λ)N_t(1 - \lambda).

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Finite Growth Factor vs. Relative Change
  • The net growth factor λ=Nt+1Nt\lambda = \frac{N_{t+1}}{N_t} is the ratio of successive population sizes. A value of λ=0.850\lambda = 0.850 means the population retains 85.0%85.0\% of its size each generation, corresponding to a 15.0%15.0\% decline (1−λ=0.1501 - \lambda = 0.150).

  • When given a net growth factor λ\lambda, multiply the current population directly by λ\lambda: Nt+1=Nt×λN_{t+1} = N_t \times \lambda.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Identify the demographic relationship from the problem statement: N1=N0×λN_1 = N_0 \times \lambda.

  2. Substitute the given values N0=10,000N_0 = 10{,}000 and λ=0.850\lambda = 0.850: N1=10,000×0.850N_1 = 10{,}000 \times 0.850.

  3. Multiply directly to obtain the population size: N1=8,500N_1 = 8{,}500.

Final answer

(a) q1=0.1855q_1 = 0.1855 (18.6%18.6\%); (b) N1=8,500 mosquitoesN_1 = 8{,}500\text{ mosquitoes}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the distinction between discrete growth factors (λ\lambda) and continuous or fractional rates of change (r=λ−1r = \lambda - 1).

  • Practice applying population growth equations directly without re-interpreting multiplicative factors as percentage subtractions.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A gene drive has an initial frequency of q0=0.200q_0 = 0.200 (wild-type p0=0.800p_0 = 0.800) with a homing transmission efficiency of e=0.900e = 0.900. Using q′=1+e2q' = \frac{1+e}{2}, calculate the drive frequency q1q_1 in the next generation under panmictic mating.

Answer

q1=0.3440q_1 = 0.3440 (34.4%34.4\%). First, q′=1+0.9002=0.950q' = \frac{1 + 0.900}{2} = 0.950. Then, q1=q02+2p0q0(q′)=(0.200)2+2(0.800)(0.200)(0.950)=0.0400+0.3040=0.3440q_1 = q_0^2 + 2p_0q_0(q') = (0.200)^2 + 2(0.800)(0.200)(0.950) = 0.0400 + 0.3040 = 0.3440.

02

An engineered population suppression construct has initial parameters q0=0.050q_0 = 0.050, p0=0.950p_0 = 0.950, and e=1.000e = 1.000. If the net growth factor is λ=0.920\lambda = 0.920 and the initial population is N0=50,000N_0 = 50{,}000, find both q1q_1 and N1N_1.

Answer

q1=0.0975q_1 = 0.0975 (9.75%9.75\%) and N1=46,000N_1 = 46{,}000. Transmission efficiency e=1.000e = 1.000 gives q′=1.000q' = 1.000. Thus, q1=(0.050)2+2(0.950)(0.050)(1.000)=0.0025+0.0950=0.0975q_1 = (0.050)^2 + 2(0.950)(0.050)(1.000) = 0.0025 + 0.0950 = 0.0975. Population size is N1=50,000×0.920=46,000N_1 = 50{,}000 \times 0.920 = 46{,}000.

03

A drive construct is introduced at q0=0.150q_0 = 0.150 (p0=0.850p_0 = 0.850) with e=0.800e = 0.800. However, female drive homozygotes are completely sterile, so only heterozygous females (+/d+/d) and all males contribute to the gamete pool. If the overall formula reduces to q1=2p0q0q′1−q02q_1 = \frac{2p_0q_0 q'}{1 - q_0^2}, calculate q1q_1 to three decimal places.

Answer

q1≈0.235q_1 \approx 0.235. With e=0.800e = 0.800, q′=1.8002=0.900q' = \frac{1.800}{2} = 0.900. The denominator is 1−(0.150)2=1−0.0225=0.97751 - (0.150)^2 = 1 - 0.0225 = 0.9775. The numerator is 2(0.850)(0.150)(0.900)=0.22952(0.850)(0.150)(0.900) = 0.2295. Dividing gives q1=0.22950.9775≈0.2348≈0.235q_1 = \frac{0.2295}{0.9775} \approx 0.2348 \approx 0.235.

Loading workspace…