Resources
An artificial cell composed of a selectively permeable dialysis membrane is filled with an aqueous solution containing sucrose and glucose. The membrane is permeable to water and glucose, but completely impermeable to sucrose. The artificial cell is submerged in a large beaker containing sucrose and glucose. Assuming initial conditions before equilibrium is reached, determine: (a) whether the initial net diffusion of glucose is directed into or out of the cell, (b) whether the beaker solution is initially hypertonic, hypotonic, or isotonic relative to the cell with respect to non-penetrating solutes, and (c) the direction of the initial net osmotic flow of water.
Answer and steps
Final answer
(a) Net diffusion of glucose is directed into the cell; (b) The beaker solution is hypotonic relative to the cell with respect to non-penetrating solutes ( vs. sucrose); (c) The initial net osmotic flow of water is directed into the cell.
Steps
Determine the Direction of Glucose Diffusion
- Principle of Simple Diffusion: A substance capable of crossing a selectively permeable membrane moves down its own chemical concentration gradient—from an area of higher solute concentration to an area of lower solute concentration—independent of other solutes.
- Given Concentrations:
- Glucose inside the cell:
- Glucose outside in the beaker:
- Analysis: Because the membrane is permeable to glucose and the concentration in the beaker () is greater than inside the cell (), glucose will diffuse down its concentration gradient.
- Conclusion for (a): The initial net diffusion of glucose is directed into the cell.
Determine Tonicity with Respect to Non-Penetrating Solutes
- Concept of Tonicity: Tonicity refers to the ability of an extracellular solution to make water move into or out of a cell by osmosis. It is determined exclusively by the concentration of non-penetrating solutes (solutes that cannot cross the membrane), because penetrating solutes eventually equilibrate across the membrane and do not sustain a long-term osmotic gradient.
- Given Concentrations of Non-Penetrating Solute (Sucrose):
- Sucrose inside the cell:
- Sucrose outside in the beaker:
- Analysis: The extracellular solution has a lower concentration of non-penetrating solutes () than the intracellular environment ().
- Pitfall to Avoid: Do not confuse osmolarity (total solute concentration) with tonicity. Even when looking at total initial osmolarities, penetrating solutes like glucose can cross freely, so tonicity must be evaluated strictly based on non-penetrating solutes (sucrose).
- Conclusion for (b): Relative to the cell, the beaker solution is hypotonic ( vs. sucrose).
Determine the Direction of Net Osmotic Flow of Water
- Principle of Osmosis: Osmosis is the movement of water across a selectively permeable membrane toward the region with a higher effective solute concentration (lower free-water concentration / lower water potential).
- Initial Analysis:
- By Total Solute Concentration: The total initial solute concentration inside the cell is . The total initial solute concentration in the beaker is . Because the cell interior has a higher total solute concentration (), free water is at a higher concentration outside.
- By Tonicity: Placing a cell in a hypotonic solution causes water to move across the membrane into the cell to dilute the higher internal concentration of non-penetrating solutes.
- Conclusion for (c): The initial net osmotic flow of water is directed into the cell.
Typical errors
01 The student includes penetrating solutes when determining tonicity, erroneously comparing total osmolarity rather than non-penetrating solute concentrations.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
Outside glucose = , inside glucose = Net diffusion of glucose is into the cell
- Step 2
Total solute in beaker = Total solute in cell = Since is less than , the beaker solution is hypotonic
CorrectCompare only non-penetrating solutes (sucrose): Beaker sucrose () < Cell sucrose (), so the beaker solution is hypotonic.
Although your final label of 'hypotonic' is correct, your reasoning is flawed. Tonicity is defined exclusively by non-penetrating solutes (sucrose) because penetrating solutes (glucose) equilibrate across the membrane. Comparing total osmolarities determines osmolarity (hyposmotic), not tonicity.
- Step 3
Total osmolarity outside is and inside is Water moves toward higher total solute concentration Net osmotic flow of water is into the cell
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly evaluated the chemical gradient for glucose across the dialysis membrane.
You correctly identified the direction of net water movement across the membrane.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou summed both penetrating and non-penetrating solutes to judge tonicity.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisTonicity is determined strictly by the concentration of non-penetrating solutes, whereas total solute concentration defines osmolarity.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Evaluate Membrane Permeability
Identify which solutes can cross the membrane (penetrating) and which cannot (non-penetrating).
Classify glucose as penetrating and sucrose as non-penetrating before evaluating tonicity.
- Apply Non-Penetrating Solute Rule for Tonicity
Tonicity depends exclusively on the concentration gradient of non-penetrating solutes.
Compare only the extracellular and intracellular concentrations of sucrose ( vs. ) when stating whether the solution is hypotonic, isotonic, or hypertonic.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationIdentify non-penetrating solute: The membrane is impermeable only to sucrose.
Compare sucrose concentrations: Beaker has sucrose, while the cell has sucrose.
Determine tonicity: Because , the beaker solution has a lower non-penetrating solute concentration than the cell.
The beaker solution is hypotonic relative to the cell with respect to non-penetrating solutes ( vs. sucrose).
02 The student determines tonicity by considering total solute concentration and incorrectly calculates the beaker solution to have a higher total concentration, leading to an incorrect hypertonic classification and reversed water movement.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
Glucose is outside and inside Glucose diffuses into the cell
- Step 2
Total solute inside = Total solute outside = alone exceeds Beaker solution has higher total solute concentration and is hypertonic relative to the cell
CorrectCompare only non-penetrating solutes (sucrose): inside is sucrose and beaker is sucrose. Because , the beaker solution is hypotonic relative to the cell.
You evaluated tonicity using penetrating solutes (glucose) instead of restricting your comparison to non-penetrating solutes (sucrose). Because glucose crosses the membrane freely, tonicity depends solely on sucrose: the beaker () has a lower concentration of non-penetrating solutes than the cell (), making the beaker hypotonic.
- Step 3
Because the beaker is hypertonic, water is drawn out into the beaker Net osmotic flow of water is out of the cell
CorrectBecause the beaker is hypotonic (and the cell has a higher initial total osmolarity of vs. ), water moves by osmosis into the cell.
Because your conclusion in part (b) was inverted, your predicted direction of water movement was also reversed. A hypotonic solution causes net osmotic movement of water into the cell.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly identified the concentrations of glucose inside and outside the cell.
You applied the principle of diffusion down a solute's concentration gradient accurately.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou conflated tonicity with total solute osmolarity and included penetrating solutes (glucose) when assessing tonicity, while also improperly comparing extracellular glucose against intracellular sucrose.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Rule of Tonicity
Tonicity is determined exclusively by the relative concentration of non-penetrating solutes across a membrane.
First identify which solute cannot cross the membrane (sucrose). Ignore penetrating solutes when determining tonicity.
- Direction of Osmosis
Net water movement always flows from a hypotonic environment into a hypertonic compartment.
Since the beaker has less non-penetrating solute (), it is hypotonic, so water flows into the cell.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationIdentify non-penetrating solutes: Sucrose cannot cross the dialysis membrane, whereas glucose can.
Compare sucrose concentrations: The beaker has sucrose, while the cell has sucrose.
Determine tonicity: Because , the beaker solution is hypotonic relative to the cell.
Determine water movement: Water flows down its potential gradient toward the higher non-penetrating solute concentration, moving into the cell.
(a) Into the cell; (b) Hypotonic; (c) Into the cell
03 The student confuses the direction of net solute diffusion with water movement down its potential gradient, assuming solute moves from low to high concentration.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
Inside glucose is and outside glucose is Glucose diffuses out of the cell toward the higher concentration
CorrectBecause the concentration of glucose is higher outside () than inside (), glucose diffuses down its concentration gradient into the cell.
Passive diffusion moves solute particles down their chemical gradient from an area of higher concentration to an area of lower concentration, rather than toward higher concentration.
- Step 2
Non-penetrating solute sucrose is outside and inside Since non-penetrating solute concentration outside is lower, the beaker solution is hypotonic
- Step 3
Water potential is higher in the hypotonic beaker solution Net osmotic flow of water is into the cell
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly identified that tonicity depends strictly on the concentration of non-penetrating solutes.
You accurately determined that the surrounding beaker solution is hypotonic.
You correctly predicted that water moves down its potential gradient into the cell.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou accidentally treated solute diffusion as moving toward higher concentration instead of down the concentration gradient.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou likely mixed up the movement of water (which flows toward higher solute concentration) with the movement of a permeable solute (which diffuses down its own gradient from high solute concentration to low solute concentration).
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Rule of Passive Solute Diffusion
Permeable solutes spontaneously move down their chemical concentration gradient: .
Always compare the internal and external concentrations of that specific permeable solute and draw the arrow pointing from the higher number to the lower number.
- Separating Solute Movement from Water Movement
Solutes diffuse from high solute to low solute; water moves by osmosis from low solute (high water potential) to high solute (low water potential).
Check solute diffusion independently before analyzing osmotic water flow.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationCompare glucose concentrations: external glucose is and internal glucose is .
Apply diffusion: glucose moves down its gradient from toward , which is into the cell.
(a) Net diffusion of glucose is directed into the cell; (b) The beaker solution is hypotonic relative to the cell; (c) The initial net osmotic flow of water is directed into the cell.
Lock it in
What is the key biological distinction between osmolarity and tonicity?
Osmolarity measures total solute concentration (penetrating + non-penetrating), whereas tonicity is determined only by non-penetrating solutes that cannot cross the membrane.
Similar question
An artificial cell containing sucrose (non-penetrating) and glycerol (penetrating) is placed into a beaker containing sucrose and glycerol. (a) Is the beaker solution initially hypertonic, hypotonic, or isotonic? (b) What is the initial direction of net glycerol diffusion?
Answer
(a) Isotonic. Tonicity depends solely on non-penetrating solutes, and both the cell and the beaker have sucrose. (b) Out of the cell. Glycerol diffuses down its concentration gradient from (inside) to (outside).
A cell with an internal concentration of non-penetrating solutes and penetrating solute is placed in a beaker containing non-penetrating solutes and solute . Describe (a) the tonicity of the beaker solution and (b) the ultimate direction of water movement once solute fully equilibrates.
Answer
(a) Hypertonic. The beaker has a higher non-penetrating solute concentration (). (b) Out of the cell. Once penetrating solute reaches equal concentration on both sides, water moves toward the higher concentration of non-penetrating solute outside, causing cell shrinkage.
A dialysis bag containing urea (penetrating) and albumin (non-penetrating protein) is placed in a beaker with urea and albumin. Classify the beaker solution as: (a) hyperosmotic, hyposmotic, or isosmotic, and (b) hypertonic, hypotonic, or isotonic relative to the dialysis bag.
Answer
(a) Hyposmotic. Total initial osmolarity: inside is , beaker is ; since , the beaker is hyposmotic. (b) Hypertonic. Non-penetrating solute concentration is higher in the beaker (), which will cause water to leave the bag at long-term equilibrium.