Resources

In a field population of N=500N = 500 diploid perennial plants, coat hairiness is controlled by a single diallelic locus with incomplete dominance: genotype A1A1A_1A_1 produces dense hairs (120120 individuals), A1A2A_1A_2 produces intermediate hairs (260260 individuals), and A2A2A_2A_2 produces glabrous (smooth) stems (120120 individuals). During a severe drought season, several individual plants increase their cuticle thickness via phenotypic plasticity during their lifetime, but their genomic sequences remain unchanged. (a) Calculate the baseline allele frequencies p=f(A1)p = f(A_1) and q=f(A2)q = f(A_2) in the population before selective mortality occurs. (b) Explain why an individual plant that develops a thicker cuticle during its lifetime does not represent biological evolution.

Answer and steps

Final answer

(a) p=f(A1)=0.500p = f(A_1) = 0.500 and q=f(A2)=0.500q = f(A_2) = 0.500; (b) Biological evolution is defined strictly as a change in allele or genotype frequencies in the gene pool of a population across generations. Individual acclimation (phenotypic plasticity) alters non-heritable somatic expression during an organism's lifetime without altering its inherited DNA sequence or the population's allele frequencies.

Steps

Part (a): Calculating Baseline Allele Frequencies

In a population of diploid organisms, each individual carries two alleles for a given diallelic gene locus. Therefore, the total number of alleles in the gene pool is:

Total number of alleles=2N=2⋅500=1000\text{Total number of alleles} = 2N = 2 \cdot 500 = 1000

  1. Count the copies of each allele directly:

    • Homozygous individuals (A1A1A_1A_1) carry two copies of A1A_1: 2⋅120=240 copies of A12 \cdot 120 = 240\text{ copies of } A_1
    • Heterozygous individuals (A1A2A_1A_2) carry one copy of A1A_1 and one copy of A2A_2: 260 copies of A1and260 copies of A2260\text{ copies of } A_1 \quad\text{and}\quad 260\text{ copies of } A_2
    • Homozygous individuals (A2A2A_2A_2) carry two copies of A2A_2: 2⋅120=240 copies of A22 \cdot 120 = 240\text{ copies of } A_2
  2. Sum the alleles: Total A1 alleles=240+260=500\text{Total } A_1\text{ alleles} = 240 + 260 = 500 Total A2 alleles=240+260=500\text{Total } A_2\text{ alleles} = 240 + 260 = 500
  3. Determine the frequencies pp and qq: p=f(A1)=5001000=0.500p = f(A_1) = \frac{500}{1000} = 0.500 q=f(A2)=5001000=0.500q = f(A_2) = \frac{500}{1000} = 0.500

(Alternative Check via Genotype Frequencies: f(A1A1)=120500=0.24f(A_1A_1) = \frac{120}{500} = 0.24, f(A1A2)=260500=0.52f(A_1A_2) = \frac{260}{500} = 0.52, and f(A2A2)=120500=0.24f(A_2A_2) = \frac{120}{500} = 0.24. Then p=f(A1A1)+12f(A1A2)=0.24+0.26=0.500p = f(A_1A_1) + \frac{1}{2}f(A_1A_2) = 0.24 + 0.26 = 0.500, and q=1−p=0.500q = 1 - p = 0.500.)


Part (b): Why Phenotypic Plasticity is Not Evolution

  • Unit of Evolution: Biological evolution occurs at the population level over generations, not within an individual organism. Evolution is fundamentally defined as a change in the genetic composition (specifically, allele or genotype frequencies) of a population's gene pool from one generation to the next.
  • Acclimation vs. Genetic Change: An individual plant thickening its cuticle in response to drought demonstrates phenotypic plasticity (physiological acclimation). This response involves modifications in somatic tissue and gene expression during the plant's lifetime.
  • Lack of Heritable Transmission: Because the underlying genomic sequence of the plant's germ cells remains unchanged, these environmentally induced somatic modifications cannot be directly inherited by the offspring as altered alleles. Therefore, the allele frequencies of the gene pool (p=0.500,q=0.500p = 0.500, q = 0.500) remain unaltered by this individual physiological adjustment alone.

Common Pitfall: Conflating individual adaptation/acclimation (phenotypic adjustments made by a single organism during its lifespan) with evolutionary adaptation (heritable shifts in population allele frequencies driven by natural selection across generations).

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student forgets that diploid individuals carry two alleles per locus and divides the total allele counts by N = 500 rather than 2N = 1000, yielding impossible frequencies greater than 1.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Total A1 alleles=2(120)+260=500  ⟹  Total A2 alleles=2(120)+260=500\text{Total } A_1\text{ alleles} = 2(120) + 260 = 500 \implies \text{Total } A_2\text{ alleles} = 2(120) + 260 = 500

  2. Step 2

    p=500500=1.0  ⟹  q=500500=1.0p = \frac{500}{500} = 1.0 \implies q = \frac{500}{500} = 1.0

    Correct

    p=5002(500)=5001000=0.500  ⟹  q=5002(500)=5001000=0.500p = \frac{500}{2(500)} = \frac{500}{1000} = 0.500 \implies q = \frac{500}{2(500)} = \frac{500}{1000} = 0.500

    Because each of the 500500 individuals is diploid, the gene pool contains 2N=2×500=10002N = 2 \times 500 = 1000 total alleles. Dividing by 500500 counts individuals rather than total alleles, which leads to p+q=2.0p + q = 2.0 instead of the required sum of 1.01.0.

  3. Step 3

    Evolution requires genetic changes in a population across generations, whereas phenotypic plasticity is non-heritable adjustment in an individual’s lifetime.\text{Evolution requires genetic changes in a population across generations, whereas phenotypic plasticity is non-heritable adjustment in an individual's lifetime.}

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly calculated the exact count of each allele from the genotype counts.

You clearly articulated that evolution operates on populations across generations rather than on individuals during their lifetime.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Gene pool total allele count omitted

No, this was a conceptual confusion between individual count (NN) and total allele count (2N2N) in a diploid population.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You divided the allele counts by the total number of individuals (N=500N = 500) rather than the total number of alleles in the diploid gene pool (2N=10002N = 1000), producing frequencies that sum to 2.02.0 instead of 1.01.0.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Diploid Allele Pool Size
  • In a diploid population of size NN, every individual carries 22 alleles at a single locus, making the total gene pool size 2N2N.

  • Always multiply the population size by 22 when finding the denominator for allele frequencies in diploid organisms.

Allele Frequency Sum Constraint
  • The sum of all allele frequencies at a single diallelic locus must strictly satisfy p+q=1.0p + q = 1.0.

  • Add your resulting values for pp and qq as an immediate sanity check before moving to the next part.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Determine the total number of alleles in the gene pool: Total alleles=2N=2×500=1000\text{Total alleles} = 2N = 2 \times 500 = 1000.

  2. Calculate p=f(A1)=Total A12N=5001000=0.500p = f(A_1) = \frac{\text{Total } A_1}{2N} = \frac{500}{1000} = 0.500.

  3. Calculate q=f(A2)=Total A22N=5001000=0.500q = f(A_2) = \frac{\text{Total } A_2}{2N} = \frac{500}{1000} = 0.500.

Final answer

(a) p=0.500p = 0.500 and q=0.500q = 0.500; (b) Biological evolution is defined as a change in allele frequencies in a population's gene pool across generations, whereas individual phenotypic plasticity is a non-heritable somatic acclimation during an organism's lifetime that does not change its DNA sequence or allele frequencies.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Multiply the population size NN by the ploidy level (typically 22) before computing allele frequencies.

  • Perform the quick verification p+q=1p + q = 1 on every allele frequency calculation.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student omits the factor of two for homozygotes when counting alleles, treating each individual as contributing only one allele of each type.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Total alleles=2×500=1000\text{Total alleles} = 2 \times 500 = 1000

  2. Step 2

    Number of A1 alleles=120+260=380  ⟹  p=3801000=0.38\text{Number of } A_1 \text{ alleles} = 120 + 260 = 380 \implies p = \frac{380}{1000} = 0.38

    Correct

    Number of A1 alleles=2(120)+260=500  ⟹  p=5001000=0.500\text{Number of } A_1 \text{ alleles} = 2(120) + 260 = 500 \implies p = \frac{500}{1000} = 0.500

    Each homozygous A1A1A_1A_1 plant carries two A1A_1 alleles, so the 120120 homozygotes contribute 2×120=2402 \times 120 = 240 alleles of type A1A_1, not 120120.

  3. Step 3

    Number of A2 alleles=120+260=380  ⟹  q=3801000=0.38\text{Number of } A_2 \text{ alleles} = 120 + 260 = 380 \implies q = \frac{380}{1000} = 0.38

    Correct

    Number of A2 alleles=2(120)+260=500  ⟹  q=5001000=0.500\text{Number of } A_2 \text{ alleles} = 2(120) + 260 = 500 \implies q = \frac{500}{1000} = 0.500

    Similarly, the 120120 homozygous A2A2A_2A_2 plants contribute 2×120=2402 \times 120 = 240 alleles of type A2A_2. Notice also that your frequencies gave p+q=0.38+0.38=0.76p + q = 0.38 + 0.38 = 0.76, whereas diallelic frequencies must always sum to 11.

  4. Step 4

    Evolution is a change in the genetic makeup of a population over generations, not a non-inherited physiological response of an individual during its life.\text{Evolution is a change in the genetic makeup of a population over generations, not a non-inherited physiological response of an individual during its life.}

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly calculated the total number of alleles in the diploid gene pool as 2N=10002N = 1000.

You clearly and accurately explained that evolution occurs in populations over generations rather than through non-inherited physiological responses within an individual's lifetime.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Omission of diploid homozygote factor in allele counting

You forgot to multiply the number of homozygous individuals by 22 when tallying each allele type.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Treating genotype counts as direct allele counts rather than accounting for the biological fact that every diploid homozygote carries two copies of the same allele.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Allele Contribution by Genotype
  • In a diploid organism, each homozygote (A1A1A_1A_1 or A2A2A_2A_2) contributes 22 copies of that allele, while each heterozygote (A1A2A_1A_2) contributes 11 copy.

  • Always write the allele count formula explicitly as NA1=2⋅NA1A1+NA1A2N_{A_1} = 2 \cdot N_{A_1A_1} + N_{A_1A_2} before substituting numbers.

Diallelic Sum Sanity Check
  • For any diallelic gene locus, the allele frequencies must sum exactly to 11 (p+q=1.00p + q = 1.00).

  • Check p+qp + q immediately after calculating frequencies; if the sum is not 11, re-verify your allele counts.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Total A1 alleles=2(120)+260=240+260=500\text{Total } A_1 \text{ alleles} = 2(120) + 260 = 240 + 260 = 500

  2. p=f(A1)=5001000=0.500p = f(A_1) = \frac{500}{1000} = 0.500

  3. Total A2 alleles=2(120)+260=240+260=500\text{Total } A_2 \text{ alleles} = 2(120) + 260 = 240 + 260 = 500

  4. q=f(A2)=5001000=0.500q = f(A_2) = \frac{500}{1000} = 0.500

  5. Verification: p+q=0.500+0.500=1.000\text{Verification: } p + q = 0.500 + 0.500 = 1.000

Final answer

(a) p=f(A1)=0.500p = f(A_1) = 0.500 and q=f(A2)=0.500q = f(A_2) = 0.500; (b) Biological evolution is defined as a change in allele or genotype frequencies in the gene pool of a population over generations, whereas phenotypic plasticity involves somatic acclimation within an individual's lifetime without altering inherited DNA sequences.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Use genotype frequencies as an alternative check: p=f(A1A1)+12f(A1A2)p = f(A_1A_1) + \frac{1}{2}f(A_1A_2).

  • Always perform the p+q=1p + q = 1 check to catch missing factor-of-two errors early.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student misidentifies evolution as any phenotypic adaptation to drought stress, concluding that phenotypic plasticity does count as evolution because it aids survival.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Total alleles=1000  ⟹  Total A1=2(120)+260=500  ⟹  p=5001000=0.50  ⟹  Total A2=2(120)+260=500  ⟹  q=5001000=0.50\text{Total alleles} = 1000 \implies \text{Total } A_1 = 2(120) + 260 = 500 \implies p = \frac{500}{1000} = 0.50 \implies \text{Total } A_2 = 2(120) + 260 = 500 \implies q = \frac{500}{1000} = 0.50

  2. Step 2

    It does represent biological evolution because the plant adapted to drought by growing a thicker cuticle to survive the dry environment.

    Correct

    It does not represent biological evolution because evolution requires a change in allele or genotype frequencies within a population gene pool across generations, whereas cuticle thickening during an organism's lifetime is non-heritable phenotypic plasticity (acclimation).

    You classified individual phenotypic plasticity as biological evolution. An individual's physiological adaptation during its lifespan does not change its DNA sequence or alter allele frequencies in the population.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly calculated the total number of alleles in the diploid population as 2N=10002N = 1000.

You accurately tallied the copies of A1A_1 and A2A_2 from each genotype class.

You correctly solved for the baseline allele frequencies p=0.50p = 0.50 and q=0.50q = 0.50.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Conflating individual acclimation with biological evolution

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You defined biological evolution at the level of an individual organism adjusting to environmental stress rather than as a shift in heritable allele frequencies in a population across generations.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Unit of Evolution
  • Natural selection acts on individuals, but evolution occurs only in populations across generations.

  • Check whether the change is a shift in population gene frequencies over time or merely an adjustment within a single organism's lifetime.

Acclimation vs. Evolutionary Adaptation
  • Phenotypic plasticity changes somatic expression without altering germline allele frequencies.

  • Confirm whether the observed phenotypic change is accompanied by heritable genetic changes in the gene pool.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. State clearly whether an individual's lifetime adjustment constitutes biological evolution: it does not.

  2. Define biological evolution precisely as a change in allele frequencies within a population over generations.

  3. Distinguish the plant's response as non-heritable phenotypic plasticity (acclimation) that leaves genomic DNA sequences and gene pool frequencies unchanged.

Final answer

(a) p=0.500p = 0.500 and q=0.500q = 0.500; (b) Cuticle thickening during an individual plant's lifetime is phenotypic plasticity (physiological acclimation), not biological evolution. Evolution requires a change in the allele or genotype frequencies of a population's gene pool across generations, whereas somatic cuticle adjustments leave the underlying genomic sequence and population allele frequencies unchanged.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Memorize the formal definition of biological evolution: a change in allele frequencies in a population over generations.

  • Practice distinguishing phenotypic plasticity (individual, within-lifetime, non-heritable) from evolutionary adaptation (population-level, transgenerational, heritable).

Lock it in

Similar question

01

In a population of N=400N = 400 diploid wildflowers, flower color is governed by alleles CRC^R and CWC^W. Genotype counts are 100100 CRCRC^RC^R, 200200 CRCWC^RC^W, and 100100 CWCWC^WC^W. Calculate the allele frequencies p=f(CR)p = f(C^R) and q=f(CW)q = f(C^W).

Answer

p=0.500p = 0.500 and q=0.500q = 0.500. Key steps: Total alleles =2N=800= 2N = 800. Copies of CR=2(100)+200=400C^R = 2(100) + 200 = 400, so p=400800=0.500p = \frac{400}{800} = 0.500. Copies of CW=2(100)+200=400C^W = 2(100) + 200 = 400, so q=400800=0.500q = \frac{400}{800} = 0.500.

02

A population of N=1000N = 1000 diploid beetles has 490490 BBBB, 420420 BbBb, and 9090 bbbb individuals. Calculate the allele frequencies p=f(B)p = f(B) and q=f(b)q = f(b), and verify that your frequencies sum to 11.

Answer

p=0.700p = 0.700 and q=0.300q = 0.300. Key steps: Total alleles =2(1000)=2000= 2(1000) = 2000. Copies of B=2(490)+420=1400B = 2(490) + 420 = 1400, so p=14002000=0.700p = \frac{1400}{2000} = 0.700. Copies of b=2(90)+420=600b = 2(90) + 420 = 600, so q=6002000=0.300q = \frac{600}{2000} = 0.300. Verification: p+q=0.700+0.300=1.000p + q = 0.700 + 0.300 = 1.000.

03

In a population of 250250 diploid lizards, a researcher calculates f(D)=0.60f(D) = 0.60. During a single hot summer, many individual lizards change their skin pigment production through physiological acclimation. Does this acclimation immediately alter f(D)f(D)? Explain in terms of the definition of evolution.

Answer

No, f(D)f(D) remains 0.600.60. Physiological acclimation changes somatic gene expression or phenotype within an individual's lifetime without changing germline DNA sequences or allele counts in the gene pool; evolution requires a shift in allele frequencies across generations.

Loading workspace…