Resources
An artificial phospholipid bilayer is prepared to test the selective permeability of unassisted cell membranes to various solutes. The membrane separates two compartments of aqueous solution at . Four test solutes are added at identical initial concentrations of to Compartment A: (1) molecular oxygen (), (2) glycerol (), (3) sodium cations (), and (4) D-glucose (). Rank these four solutes in order of decreasing rate of simple passive diffusion (permeability coefficient, ) across the pure lipid bilayer from highest permeability to lowest permeability, and explain the biophysical basis for the positions of the fastest and slowest solutes.
Answer and steps
Final answer
. Molecular oxygen () exhibits the highest permeability because it is a small, nonpolar diatomic gas that readily dissolves in the hydrophobic hydrocarbon interior of the bilayer ( to ). Sodium cations () exhibit the lowest permeability because an ion has a full electric charge and a tight hydration shell; crossing the hydrophobic core requires a prohibitively high energetic cost (Born charging energy) to strip hydration waters, yielding an extremely low permeability coefficient ( to ).
Steps
Factors Governing Simple Diffusion Across a Lipid Bilayer
An unassisted phospholipid bilayer consists of hydrophilic polar headgroups on the exterior surfaces and a nonpolar, hydrophobic core composed of fatty acyl hydrocarbon chains. In simple passive diffusion, a solute must dissolve into this nonpolar core to traverse the membrane. The rate of diffusion (permeability coefficient, ) depends on two primary molecular properties:
- Charge and Polarity: The hydrophobic core has a very low dielectric constant (). Nonpolar molecules dissolve readily in the core, whereas polar molecules face an energetic barrier, and charged ions face a massive thermodynamic penalty.
- Molecular Size: For uncharged polar molecules, smaller molecules traverse the transient spaces between moving lipid tails much faster than larger molecules.
Classification of the Given Solutes
- Molecular Oxygen (): A small, nonpolar diatomic gas. It partitions favorably into the hydrocarbon tails and diffuses rapidly ().
- Glycerol (, ): A small, uncharged polar molecule with three hydroxyl groups. It can cross the bilayer slowly without transport proteins ().
- D-Glucose (, ): A larger, uncharged polar molecule (hexose ring with five hydroxyl groups). Its larger molecular volume and extensive hydrogen bonding with water make spontaneous entry into the lipid core extremely unfavorable ().
- Sodium Ion (): A fully charged inorganic cation. Despite having a small ionic radius, it coordinates tightly with water molecules to form a large hydration shell.
Permeability Ranking
Combining these properties gives the universal permeability hierarchy for pure lipid bilayers:
Applying this hierarchy to the four test solutes yields:
Biophysical Basis for the Extremes
- Fastest Solute (): Because oxygen lacks net dipole moments and electrical charges, it experiences no electrostatic repulsion or dehydration penalty upon entering the interior of the membrane. It dissolves directly into the hydrophobic acyl chains with a high partition coefficient, crossing virtually unhindered.
- Slowest Solute (): In aqueous solution, the full positive charge of is stabilized by ion-dipole interactions with a shell of water molecules. To traverse the nonpolar membrane interior, the ion would have to be stripped of its hydration shell (high dehydration energy) and transferred into an environment of very low permittivity. The resulting Born charging energy barrier is insurmountable at physiological temperatures, making the bilayer virtually impermeable to unassisted ().
Common Pitfall: Do not rank solutes strictly by molecular weight. While has a lower atomic mass () than glycerol or glucose, its electric charge creates a hydration barrier that makes its permeability several orders of magnitude lower than that of large, uncharged sugars.
Typical errors
01 The student ranks solutes solely by molecular weight or atomic size, erroneously concluding that the monoatomic sodium ion diffuses faster than larger uncharged polar molecules like glucose.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1Correct
You ranked simple diffusion across a pure lipid bilayer strictly by molecular mass. While molecular size matters among uncharged polar molecules, charge and polarity are the primary determinants of permeability across a hydrophobic interior. Fully charged ions like face a massive thermodynamic barrier, making the least permeable solute.
- Step 2Correct
You concluded that diffuses most rapidly due to its small atomic mass. In an aqueous environment, carries a full positive charge and is surrounded by a tight hydration shell. Entering the nonpolar core (dielectric constant ) requires shedding this shell, which carries a prohibitive dehydration and Born charging energy penalty.
- Step 3Correct
You identified as the slowest due to its molecular size. Although diffuses much more slowly than smaller uncharged molecules like glycerol, it is uncharged and still crosses the bilayer orders of magnitude faster than a fully charged ion such as ( for glucose vs. for ).
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly recognized that glycerol crosses a lipid bilayer more rapidly than D-glucose due to differences in molecular size.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeWHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou assumed that membrane permeability is governed primarily by particle mass and steric hindrance, overlooking that an unassisted lipid bilayer's nonpolar hydrocarbon core presents an insurmountable thermodynamic barrier to fully charged ions.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Hierarchy of Membrane Permeability
For an unassisted lipid bilayer: .
Always evaluate charge first, polarity second, and molecular size only when comparing molecules within the same charge and polarity class.
- The Ionic Hydration Barrier
A charged ion in water is stabilized by a strong hydration shell; moving it into the hydrophobic lipid core requires overcoming a very high Born charging energy.
Classify inorganic ions (such as , , and ) as having the lowest passive permeability across a pure lipid bilayer, regardless of their small atomic mass.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationClassify the four solutes by charge and polarity: is small nonpolar, glycerol is small uncharged polar, D-glucose is large uncharged polar, and is a fully charged ion.
Apply the hierarchy to order them: .
Explain the fastest solute: has no net dipole or charge and partitions readily into the nonpolar hydrocarbon tails without an electrostatic penalty.
Explain the slowest solute: has a full electric charge and tight hydration shell; crossing the low-dielectric core requires an insurmountable dehydration energy barrier.
02 The student assumes that because physiological cells rapidly transport glucose and ions via transport proteins, glucose diffuses faster through a pure lipid bilayer than glycerol.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1Correct
You ranked D-glucose ahead of glycerol based on its role as a metabolic fuel. In an artificial protein-free lipid bilayer, diffusion depends solely on biophysical properties (size, polarity, and charge), not biological function. Glycerol () is much smaller than D-glucose () and crosses the hydrophobic core significantly faster.
- Step 2
diffuses fastest because it is a nonpolar gas that passes freely through the hydrophobic membrane interior.
- Step 3
is slowest because charged ions cannot penetrate the hydrophobic core of the bilayer.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly identified molecular oxygen as the fastest-diffusing solute and sodium ions as the slowest-diffusing solute.
You provided accurate biophysical explanations for the high permeability of nonpolar gases and the impermeability of charged ions.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou evaluated permeability through the lens of cellular metabolic importance rather than molecular size and polarity in a protein-free membrane.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisConfusing physiological transport rates in living cells (where glucose transporters facilitate rapid entry) with simple passive diffusion through an artificial, protein-free phospholipid bilayer. In pure lipid bilayers, uncharged polar molecules are ranked strictly by size and number of polar groups, making smaller glycerol cross much faster than larger glucose.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Protein-Free Bilayer vs. Living Cell
An artificial phospholipid bilayer contains no carrier proteins or channels, so biological necessity or metabolic role does not increase diffusion rates.
Always evaluate simple diffusion across pure bilayers using physical properties: charge, polarity, and molecular size.
- Uncharged Polar Solute Size Rule
For uncharged polar molecules, smaller molecules () cross lipid bilayers several orders of magnitude faster than larger polar molecules ().
Compare molecular weight and hydrogen-bonding groups; place smaller polyols like glycerol ahead of hexoses like glucose.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationIdentify the membrane context: the question specifies a pure, protein-free phospholipid bilayer, meaning transport is governed entirely by simple diffusion.
Classify all solutes by the universal hierarchy: small nonpolar molecules small uncharged polar molecules large uncharged polar molecules ions.
Compare glycerol (small uncharged polar, 3 carbons, ) and D-glucose (large uncharged polar, 6 carbons, ); glycerol is smaller and crosses faster.
Assemble the complete ranking: .
03 The student confuses the low permeability of charged ions with passive diffusion of water-soluble molecules, mistakenly believing that nonpolar O2 is repelled by hydrophilic phosphate head groups.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
The exterior surfaces of the bilayer consist of polar, charged phosphate heads.
CorrectThe rate-limiting barrier to simple passive diffusion across a lipid bilayer is the interior hydrophobic core formed by fatty acyl chains, not the polar surface. Nonpolar solutes diffuse most readily, whereas charged ions face an immense thermodynamic barrier.
- Step 2
diffuses fastest because its positive charge allows it to interact favorably with the polar phosphate heads.
Correctdiffuses fastest because it is a small, nonpolar molecule that partitions readily into the nonpolar hydrocarbon interior of the membrane ( to ).
Favorable interaction with outer phosphate heads does not facilitate movement across the membrane; crossing requires dissolving into the nonpolar interior, which is thermodynamically unfavorable for a charged ion.
- Step 3
diffuses slowest because it is hydrophobic and repelled by the polar outer head groups of the bilayer.
Correctdiffuses slowest because it possesses a formal charge and a tight hydration shell, creating a prohibitively high dehydration energy barrier to enter the hydrophobic core ( to ).
Hydrophobic molecules are not blocked by the thin outer polar layer; they pass through easily and partition rapidly into the central hydrocarbon tails, giving the highest permeability coefficient of the group.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly identified that the outer surfaces of a phospholipid bilayer consist of polar, charged phosphate headgroups.
You correctly recognized that molecular oxygen is nonpolar (hydrophobic).
You placed glycerol ahead of D-glucose, correctly recognizing that among uncharged polar solutes, smaller molecules permeate faster than larger ones.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeNo slip occurred; your explanation reflects a consistent underlying conceptual model that diffusion speed depends on binding to the bilayer surface rather than crossing its core.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou treated the polar headgroups on the membrane surface as the primary barrier/affinity determinant for passive diffusion, overlooking that the nonpolar fatty acid core is the true rate-limiting energetic barrier that favors nonpolar molecules and almost completely blocks charged ions.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Identify the Rate-Limiting Barrier
The rate-limiting step in simple diffusion is partitioning into and traversing the hydrophobic interior (fatty acyl core, dielectric constant ), not contacting the hydrophilic headgroups.
Always evaluate how well a solute dissolves in nonpolar hydrocarbon chains rather than how well it interacts with water or polar headgroups.
- Apply the Permeability Hierarchy
Permeability across a pure lipid bilayer decreases in this order: Small nonpolar molecules > Small uncharged polar molecules > Large uncharged polar molecules > Fully charged ions.
Place nonpolar gases first, sort uncharged polar molecules by molecular size, and place fully charged ions last.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationClassify each solute by charge, polarity, and size: is a small nonpolar gas, glycerol is a small uncharged polar molecule, D-glucose is a larger uncharged polar molecule, and is a fully charged ion.
Rank them according to membrane interior solubility: .
Explain the fastest solute: has no charge or dipole moment, allowing it to dissolve directly into the nonpolar hydrocarbon tails with no dehydration penalty.
Explain the slowest solute: carries a formal positive charge stabilized by a hydration shell, and shedding that hydration shell to enter the low-dielectric core requires an insurmountable amount of energy.
. diffuses fastest because it readily dissolves into the hydrophobic core of the bilayer; diffuses slowest due to the massive dehydration energy required for a charged ion to enter the nonpolar core.
Lock it in
What is the general hierarchy of passive permeability for solutes crossing an unassisted phospholipid bilayer?
. Charge and polarity govern permeability before molecular size.
Similar question
Rank the following three solutes in order of decreasing rate of simple passive diffusion across an unassisted phospholipid bilayer: water (), carbon dioxide (), and chloride ions ().
Answer
. is a small nonpolar gas that dissolves readily in the hydrophobic core. is a small, uncharged polar molecule that can transiently cross at a moderate rate. is a fully charged anion with a high hydration penalty, making it the slowest.
Two small molecules, ethanol () and urea (), have comparable molecular weights ( and , respectively). Predict which one has a higher permeability coefficient across a pure lipid bilayer and explain why.
Answer
Ethanol has a higher permeability coefficient. While both are small and uncharged, ethanol has a nonpolar ethyl group and only one hydroxyl group, giving it a higher octanol-water partition coefficient (greater lipophilicity) than urea, which possesses multiple polar amine and carbonyl groups that form extensive hydrogen bonds with water.
A synthetic lipid vesicle (liposome) containing is suspended in an isotonic solution containing at . If a proton ionophore (which selectively transports ) is added to the suspension, explain why net diffusion of rapidly stops even if a concentration gradient of exists.
Answer
Moving without an accompanying counterion creates an opposing membrane electrical potential. Because the pure lipid bilayer remains virtually impermeable to and , the counterions cannot move to neutralize charge buildup, establishing an electrochemical equilibrium that arrests net transport.