Resources

A viral pathogen with transmission coefficient β=0.0025 host−1day−1\beta = 0.0025\text{ host}^{-1}\text{day}^{-1} spreads through a captive colony of fruit bats. Infected individuals either die or recover with permanent immunity at a combined per capita removal rate of γ=0.15 day−1\gamma = 0.15\text{ day}^{-1}. Calculate the critical threshold host density STS_T of susceptible bats required for an epidemic outbreak to occur (impending spread where dIdt>0\frac{dI}{dt} > 0), and state whether an introduction of 2 infected bats into a susceptible group of N=50N = 50 individuals will produce an epidemic.

Answer and steps

Final answer

ST=60 individualsS_T = 60\text{ individuals}; no epidemic occurs because S0=50<STS_0 = 50 < S_T

Steps

01

Condition for Disease Spread

In epidemic modeling, the rate of change in the number of infected individuals (II) over time (tt) depends on the rate of new infections minus the rate at which infected individuals are removed through recovery or mortality:

dIdt=βSI−γI=I(βS−γ)\frac{dI}{dt} = \beta S I - \gamma I = I(\beta S - \gamma)

where:

  • β\beta is the transmission coefficient (β=0.0025 host−1day−1\beta = 0.0025\text{ host}^{-1}\text{day}^{-1})
  • SS is the number of susceptible individuals
  • γ\gamma is the combined per capita removal rate (γ=0.15 day−1\gamma = 0.15\text{ day}^{-1})

For an epidemic to occur, the number of infected individuals must increase initially, meaning the rate of change must be positive:

dIdt>0  ⟹  βS−γ>0\frac{dI}{dt} > 0 \implies \beta S - \gamma > 0


02

Deriving and Calculating the Critical Threshold Host Density (STS_T)

Rearranging the inequality for the susceptible population SS:

S>γβS > \frac{\gamma}{\beta}

The critical threshold density STS_T is the minimum susceptible population size required for disease transmission to exceed removals:

ST=γβS_T = \frac{\gamma}{\beta}

Substitute the given parameter values into the equation:

ST=0.15 day−10.0025 host−1day−1=150025=60 individualsS_T = \frac{0.15\text{ day}^{-1}}{0.0025\text{ host}^{-1}\text{day}^{-1}} = \frac{1500}{25} = 60\text{ individuals}

Thus, at least 6060 susceptible individuals are required for an epidemic outbreak to be sustained.


03

Evaluating the Introduced Group

The colony contains an initial susceptible population of S0=50S_0 = 50 bats. Comparing this value to the critical threshold:

S0=50<ST=60S_0 = 50 < S_T = 60

Substituting S0=50S_0 = 50 back into the infection rate equation:

dIdt=I(0.0025⋅50−0.15)=I(0.125−0.15)=−0.025I<0\frac{dI}{dt} = I(0.0025 \cdot 50 - 0.15) = I(0.125 - 0.15) = -0.025 I < 0

Because dIdt<0\frac{dI}{dt} < 0, each infected bat will, on average, infect fewer than one new host before recovering or dying (R0<1R_0 < 1). Therefore, the infection will decline toward zero, and no epidemic occurs.

Common Pitfall: A common mistake is assuming that any introduction of an infectious agent into a naive population will cause an epidemic. However, pathogen transmission is density-dependent; if the host density is below the critical threshold (S0<STS_0 < S_T), transmission encounters are too infrequent to sustain an outbreak.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 A student inverts the ratio for the threshold host density as β/γ instead of γ/β, yielding an incorrectly tiny threshold density and falsely concluding an epidemic will occur.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    ST=βγ=0.00250.15=0.0167 batsS_T = \frac{\beta}{\gamma} = \frac{0.0025}{0.15} = 0.0167\text{ bats}

    Correct

    ST=γβ=0.15 day−10.0025 host−1day−1=60 batsS_T = \frac{\gamma}{\beta} = \frac{0.15\text{ day}^{-1}}{0.0025\text{ host}^{-1}\text{day}^{-1}} = 60\text{ bats}

    You inverted the threshold density formula. For disease spread, the initial transmission rate must exceed the removal rate: dIdt=I(βS−γ)>0  ⟹  βS>γ  ⟹  S>γβ\frac{dI}{dt} = I(\beta S - \gamma) > 0 \implies \beta S > \gamma \implies S > \frac{\gamma}{\beta}. Therefore, the critical threshold density is ST=γβS_T = \frac{\gamma}{\beta}, not βγ\frac{\beta}{\gamma}.

  2. Step 2

    S=50>0.0167  ⟹  S = 50 > 0.0167 \implies An epidemic will occur.

    Correct

    S0=50<ST=60  ⟹  S_0 = 50 < S_T = 60 \implies No epidemic will occur.

    You followed the correct comparison logic (S>STS > S_T), but because your calculated value of STS_T was inverted, your conclusion was reversed. Since the initial susceptible population (5050) is less than the true threshold (6060), dIdt<0\frac{dI}{dt} < 0 and no epidemic occurs.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You recognized that an epidemic requires the susceptible population size to exceed a threshold density STS_T.

You correctly compared your calculated threshold against the available susceptible host population N=50N = 50.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Inverted algebraic ratio in threshold formula

You actually began by setting up the correct numerical fraction 0.150.0025\frac{0.15}{0.0025}, but you crossed it out and inverted it to βγ\frac{\beta}{\gamma}.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You memorized the ratio of the epidemic parameters without deriving it from the differential equation dIdt=βSI−γI>0\frac{dI}{dt} = \beta S I - \gamma I > 0 or checking the physical units. Because γ\gamma is in day−1\text{day}^{-1} and β\beta is in host−1day−1\text{host}^{-1}\text{day}^{-1}, the quotient γβ\frac{\gamma}{\beta} has units of hosts\text{hosts} (individuals), whereas βγ\frac{\beta}{\gamma} yields hosts−1\text{hosts}^{-1}.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Derive from the rate condition
  • An epidemic grows only when the rate of change of infections is positive: dIdt=(βS−γ)I>0\frac{dI}{dt} = (\beta S - \gamma)I > 0.

  • Solve βS−γ>0\beta S - \gamma > 0 directly for SS: isolate SS by adding γ\gamma to both sides and dividing by β\beta to get S>γβS > \frac{\gamma}{\beta}.

Perform a quick unit check
  • Host density must have units of individuals (hosts).

  • Check the units of your ratio: day−1host−1day−1=hosts\frac{\text{day}^{-1}}{\text{host}^{-1}\text{day}^{-1}} = \text{hosts}. An answer with units of hosts−1\text{hosts}^{-1} or a fraction of an individual (like 0.01670.0167) indicates an inverted ratio.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Start from the spread condition: dIdt=I(βS−γ)>0\frac{dI}{dt} = I(\beta S - \gamma) > 0.

  2. Rearrange to find the critical threshold host density: ST=γβ=0.150.0025=60 individualsS_T = \frac{\gamma}{\beta} = \frac{0.15}{0.0025} = 60\text{ individuals}.

  3. Compare the colony population to the threshold: S0=50<60S_0 = 50 < 60.

Final answer

ST=60 individualsS_T = 60\text{ individuals}; no epidemic occurs because S0=50<STS_0 = 50 < S_T.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Always derive STS_T from βS−γ=0\beta S - \gamma = 0 rather than relying on ungrounded formula recall.

  • Check whether your computed threshold makes biological sense: a threshold host density representing individuals should typically be an integer or integer-scale population size, not a tiny decimal.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 A student mistakenly subtracts the introduced infected bats from the initial susceptible group size or misidentifies the threshold criterion as S > N - I, but more directly, subtracts γ from β (or computes the net rate β - γ) instead of taking their ratio.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    ST=γβ  ⟹  ST=0.150.0025=60 batsS_T = \frac{\gamma}{\beta} \implies S_T = \frac{0.15}{0.0025} = 60\text{ bats}

  2. Step 2

    Total bats=50+2=52\text{Total bats} = 50 + 2 = 52; 52<6052 < 60, but since 2 infected bats enter, an epidemic will occur because infection is already present.

    Correct

    S0=50<ST=60  ⟹  dIdt<0S_0 = 50 < S_T = 60 \implies \frac{dI}{dt} < 0, so no epidemic occurs.

    An epidemic requires the number of infections to grow over time (dIdt>0\frac{dI}{dt} > 0). Because the susceptible population S0=50S_0 = 50 is below the critical threshold ST=60S_T = 60, the infection rate is less than the removal rate, causing the pathogen to fade out rather than spread.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly recalled the threshold density formula ST=γβS_T = \frac{\gamma}{\beta}.

You accurately substituted the numerical rates to find ST=60 batsS_T = 60\text{ bats}.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Misinterpreting Epidemic Threshold Criterion

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You conflated the physical introduction or presence of an infected host with the mathematical definition of an epidemic outbreak (dIdt>0\frac{dI}{dt} > 0), assuming that introducing an infection guarantees disease spread regardless of susceptible host density.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Define an Epidemic Outbreak
  • An epidemic occurs if and only if the rate of new infections exceeds removals, meaning dIdt>0\frac{dI}{dt} > 0 (or R0>1R_0 > 1).

  • Check whether the initial susceptible population S0S_0 strictly exceeds the critical threshold STS_T, not just whether infected individuals exist.

Evaluate Transmission Balance
  • dIdt=I(βS0−γ)\frac{dI}{dt} = I(\beta S_0 - \gamma). When S0<STS_0 < S_T, βS0−γ<0\beta S_0 - \gamma < 0, so dIdt<0\frac{dI}{dt} < 0.

  • Conclude that if S0<STS_0 < S_T, each infected individual transmits the virus to fewer than one new host on average, leading to disease fade-out.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Identify the initial susceptible population size: S0=50 batsS_0 = 50\text{ bats}.

  2. Compare S0S_0 with the critical threshold STS_T: S0=50<60=STS_0 = 50 < 60 = S_T.

  3. Evaluate the epidemic condition: dIdt=I(βS0−γ)=I(0.0025×50−0.15)=−0.025I<0\frac{dI}{dt} = I(\beta S_0 - \gamma) = I(0.0025 \times 50 - 0.15) = -0.025I < 0.

Final answer

ST=60 individualsS_T = 60\text{ individuals}; no epidemic occurs because S0=50<STS_0 = 50 < S_T.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the distinction between disease introduction and sustained epidemic spread.

  • Practice calculating dIdt\frac{dI}{dt} directly using βS0−γ\beta S_0 - \gamma to verify whether infection numbers increase or decrease.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 A student calculates the basic reproduction ratio using total population N plus initial infected or makes an arithmetic error dividing by decimals, calculating 0.15 / 0.0025 = 6 instead of 60, concluding that 50 exceeds the threshold.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    dIdt=βSI−γI>0  ⟹  ST=γβ\frac{dI}{dt} = \beta S I - \gamma I > 0 \implies S_T = \frac{\gamma}{\beta}

  2. Step 2

    ST=0.150.0025=6 batsS_T = \frac{0.15}{0.0025} = 6\text{ bats}

    Correct

    ST=0.150.0025=150025=60 batsS_T = \frac{0.15}{0.0025} = \frac{1500}{25} = 60\text{ bats}

    You substituted the values correctly into the formula, but made an arithmetic place-value error dividing by 0.00250.0025. Shifting the decimal point four places gives 150025=60\frac{1500}{25} = 60, not 66.

  3. Step 3

    S=50  ⟹  50>6, so an epidemic will occur.S = 50 \implies 50 > 6\text{, so an epidemic will occur.}

    Correct

    S=50<60, so no epidemic will occur.S = 50 < 60\text{, so no epidemic will occur.}

    Your comparison logic was consistent with your calculated threshold, but because STS_T should be 6060, the actual susceptible population S=50S = 50 is below the threshold (S<STS < S_T). Therefore, dIdt<0\frac{dI}{dt} < 0 and no epidemic occurs.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified the SIR model outbreak condition dIdt>0\frac{dI}{dt} > 0.

You algebraically solved for the critical host threshold density ST=γβS_T = \frac{\gamma}{\beta}.

You correctly recognized that an epidemic requires S>STS > S_T.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Decimal division place-value error

You computed 0.150.0025\frac{0.15}{0.0025} as 66 instead of 6060, dropping a factor of 1010.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Dividing decimals directly can lead to lost place values. Converting decimals to whole-number fractions by multiplying numerator and denominator by 10410^4 prevents powers-of-ten mistakes.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Clear Decimals First
  • When dividing two decimals, multiply both the numerator and denominator by 10k10^k to eliminate all decimal points before dividing.

  • Write 0.150.0025=0.15×10,0000.0025×10,000=150025=60\frac{0.15}{0.0025} = \frac{0.15 \times 10{,}000}{0.0025 \times 10{,}000} = \frac{1500}{25} = 60.

Outbreak Threshold Test
  • An epidemic requires S0>STS_0 > S_T. If S0<STS_0 < S_T, each infected host transmits to fewer than one other host on average, and the infection dies out.

  • Check S0=50S_0 = 50 against ST=60S_T = 60: since 50<6050 < 60, conclude that no epidemic occurs.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Eliminate decimals: 0.150.0025=0.15×1040.0025×104=150025=60 bats\frac{0.15}{0.0025} = \frac{0.15 \times 10^4}{0.0025 \times 10^4} = \frac{1500}{25} = 60\text{ bats}.

  2. Compare the initial susceptible population S0=50S_0 = 50 to ST=60S_T = 60: S0<STS_0 < S_T.

  3. Since S0<STS_0 < S_T, the initial net transmission rate is negative: dIdt=I(βS0−γ)=I(0.0025×50−0.15)=−0.025I<0\frac{dI}{dt} = I(\beta S_0 - \gamma) = I(0.0025 \times 50 - 0.15) = -0.025 I < 0.

Final answer

ST=60 individualsS_T = 60\text{ individuals}; no epidemic occurs because S0=50<STS_0 = 50 < S_T.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Practice converting decimal quotients into whole-number fractions before simplifying.

  • Verify your final threshold biologically: evaluate βS0−γ\beta S_0 - \gamma directly to confirm whether the net growth rate of infections is positive or negative.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A respiratory virus in a rodent colony has a transmission coefficient β=0.005 rodent−1day−1\beta = 0.005\text{ rodent}^{-1}\text{day}^{-1} and an infected recovery rate γ=0.10 day−1\gamma = 0.10\text{ day}^{-1}. Determine the critical threshold host density STS_T and state whether an epidemic will occur if 3 infected rodents enter a naive population of 25 rodents.

Answer

ST=γβ=0.100.005=20 rodentsS_T = \frac{\gamma}{\beta} = \frac{0.10}{0.005} = 20\text{ rodents}. Since S0=25>ST=20S_0 = 25 > S_T = 20, dIdt>0\frac{dI}{dt} > 0 initially, so an epidemic will occur.

02

A wildlife park manages a herd of 120 antelopes. A blood-borne parasite is introduced with transmission parameter β=0.0008 host−1day−1\beta = 0.0008\text{ host}^{-1}\text{day}^{-1}. If infected antelopes succumb or clear the parasite at a rate γ=0.08 day−1\gamma = 0.08\text{ day}^{-1}, what fraction of the herd must be vaccinated (removed from susceptibility) to prevent an epidemic outbreak?

Answer

The critical threshold is ST=γβ=0.080.0008=100 hostsS_T = \frac{\gamma}{\beta} = \frac{0.08}{0.0008} = 100\text{ hosts}. To prevent an outbreak, susceptible antelopes must remain at or below 100100. Out of 120120 antelopes, at least 120−100=20120 - 100 = 20 must be vaccinated, which is a fraction of 20120=16≈16.7%\frac{20}{120} = \frac{1}{6} \approx 16.7\%.

03

An infectious fungus infects an amphibian population. The per capita transmission rate is β=0.004 host−1week−1\beta = 0.004\text{ host}^{-1}\text{week}^{-1}. Due to clinical treatment, infected frogs recover at rate r=0.06 week−1r = 0.06\text{ week}^{-1} and suffer disease mortality at rate μ=0.02 week−1\mu = 0.02\text{ week}^{-1}. If a wetland contains 22 frogs, determine whether introducing one infected frog can spark an epidemic outbreak.

Answer

The total per capita removal rate is γ=r+μ=0.06+0.02=0.08 week−1\gamma = r + \mu = 0.06 + 0.02 = 0.08\text{ week}^{-1}. The threshold density is ST=γβ=0.080.004=20 frogsS_T = \frac{\gamma}{\beta} = \frac{0.08}{0.004} = 20\text{ frogs}. The initial susceptible population is S0=22−1=21 frogsS_0 = 22 - 1 = 21\text{ frogs}. Since S0=21>ST=20S_0 = 21 > S_T = 20, dIdt>0\frac{dI}{dt} > 0 and an epidemic outbreak can occur.

Loading workspace…