Resources

In a biological conservation program tracking gene flow in salmonids, stocking records report that hatchery-reared juveniles are introduced into a wild tributary at a density of Dmig=450 individuals/kmD_{\text{mig}} = 450\text{ individuals}/\text{km} along a 12 km12\text{ km} reach. Baseline wildlife surveys establish the native population density in that same reach as Dnat=1.35×103 individuals/kmD_{\text{nat}} = 1.35 \times 10^3\text{ individuals}/\text{km}. A diagnostic neutral microsatellite allele has a frequency of phatch=0.800p_{\text{hatch}} = 0.800 in the hatchery stock and pnat=0.150p_{\text{nat}} = 0.150 in the native stream prior to release. Convert the densities to total population sizes, calculate the migration proportion mm, and compute the post-stocking allele frequency p′p' in the stream prior to reproduction.

Answer and steps

Final answer

Nmig=5.40×103N_{\text{mig}} = 5.40 \times 10^3; Nnat=1.62×104N_{\text{nat}} = 1.62 \times 10^4; m=0.250m = 0.250; p′=0.313p' = 0.313

Steps

01

Convert Densities to Total Population Sizes

To determine the total number of individuals for both the native population and the introduced hatchery migrants, multiply each linear density by the reach length (L=12 kmL = 12\text{ km}):

  • Hatchery migrants (NmigN_{\text{mig}}): Nmig=Dmig⋅L=(450 individuals/km)⋅(12 km)=5 400=5.40×103 individualsN_{\text{mig}} = D_{\text{mig}} \cdot L = (450\text{ individuals/km}) \cdot (12\text{ km}) = 5\,400 = 5.40 \times 10^3\text{ individuals}
  • Native population (NnatN_{\text{nat}}): Nnat=Dnat⋅L=(1.35×103 individuals/km)⋅(12 km)=16 200=1.62×104 individualsN_{\text{nat}} = D_{\text{nat}} \cdot L = (1.35 \times 10^3\text{ individuals/km}) \cdot (12\text{ km}) = 16\,200 = 1.62 \times 10^4\text{ individuals}

The total post-release population (NtotalN_{\text{total}}) is: Ntotal=Nnat+Nmig=16 200+5 400=21 600 individualsN_{\text{total}} = N_{\text{nat}} + N_{\text{mig}} = 16\,200 + 5\,400 = 21\,600\text{ individuals}


02

Calculate the Migration Proportion (mm)

In population genetics, the migration rate or gene flow parameter mm represents the fraction of the mixed population that consists of new migrants:

m=NmigNtotal=NmigNnat+Nmigm = \frac{N_{\text{mig}}}{N_{\text{total}}} = \frac{N_{\text{mig}}}{N_{\text{nat}} + N_{\text{mig}}}

Substitute the values: m=5 40021 600=0.250m = \frac{5\,400}{21\,600} = 0.250

Common Pitfall: A frequent error is computing mm as the ratio of migrants to native residents (NmigNnat=5 40016 200≈0.333\frac{N_{\text{mig}}}{N_{\text{nat}}} = \frac{5\,400}{16\,200} \approx 0.333). The parameter mm must represent the fraction of the combined total gene pool contributed by immigration.


03

Compute the Post-Stocking Allele Frequency (p′p')

The new allele frequency in the stream immediately after stocking is a weighted average of the allele frequencies in the two source groups, weighted by their relative contributions:

p′=(1−m)pnat+m⋅phatchp' = (1 - m)p_{\text{nat}} + m \cdot p_{\text{hatch}}

Substitute the values: p′=(1−0.250)(0.150)+(0.250)(0.800)p' = (1 - 0.250)(0.150) + (0.250)(0.800) p′=(0.750)(0.150)+0.2000p' = (0.750)(0.150) + 0.2000 p′=0.1125+0.2000=0.3125≈0.313p' = 0.1125 + 0.2000 = 0.3125 \approx 0.313

Thus, the addition of hatchery fish shifts the neutral allele frequency in the stream from 0.1500.150 up to 0.3130.313.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student calculates migration rate m as the ratio of migrants to the original native population size rather than to the total combined population size.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Nmig=450×12=5400  ⟹  Nnat=1350×12=16200N_{\text{mig}} = 450 \times 12 = 5400 \implies N_{\text{nat}} = 1350 \times 12 = 16200

  2. Step 2

    m=NmigNnat=540016200=0.3333m = \frac{N_{\text{mig}}}{N_{\text{nat}}} = \frac{5400}{16200} = 0.3333

    Correct

    m=NmigNnat+Nmig=540016200+5400=540021600=0.250m = \frac{N_{\text{mig}}}{N_{\text{nat}} + N_{\text{mig}}} = \frac{5400}{16200 + 5400} = \frac{5400}{21600} = 0.250

    You divided the number of migrants by the native population size instead of the total mixed population size. In population genetics, the migration rate mm represents the fraction of the post-migration gene pool contributed by immigrants.

  3. Step 3

    p′=(1−m)pnat+m⋅phatch  ⟹  p′=(1−0.3333)(0.150)+(0.3333)(0.800)=0.1000+0.2666=0.3666p' = (1-m)p_{\text{nat}} + m \cdot p_{\text{hatch}} \implies p' = (1-0.3333)(0.150) + (0.3333)(0.800) = 0.1000 + 0.2666 = 0.3666

    Correct

    p′=(1−0.250)(0.150)+(0.250)(0.800)=0.1125+0.2000=0.3125≈0.313p' = (1-0.250)(0.150) + (0.250)(0.800) = 0.1125 + 0.2000 = 0.3125 \approx 0.313

    You correctly set up and evaluated the gene flow formula, but your final numerical result was affected by the incorrect value of mm from the previous step.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly calculated the total population sizes of the native fish and introduced hatchery fish from the linear densities.

You correctly recalled the weighted-average formula for allele frequency after gene flow: p′=(1−m)pnat+m⋅phatchp' = (1-m)p_{\text{nat}} + m \cdot p_{\text{hatch}}.

You carried out the subsequent arithmetic substitutions and evaluations accurately.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Ratio vs. Proportion Misconception in Migration Rate

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated the migration parameter mm as an odds ratio of migrants to residents (Nmig/NnatN_{\text{mig}} / N_{\text{nat}}) instead of the fractional contribution of migrants to the total post-stocking population (Nmig/(Nnat+Nmig)N_{\text{mig}} / (N_{\text{nat}} + N_{\text{mig}})). Because p′p' is a weighted average between two subgroups of a mixed gene pool, the weights (1−m)(1-m) and mm must sum to 11 and represent proportions of the total gene pool.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Definition of Migration Rate ($m$)
  • In the island-continent and general gene flow models, m=NmigNtotal=NmigNresident+Nmigm = \frac{N_{\text{mig}}}{N_{\text{total}}} = \frac{N_{\text{mig}}}{N_{\text{resident}} + N_{\text{mig}}}.

  • Always compute the total combined population size (Ntotal=Nresident+NmigN_{\text{total}} = N_{\text{resident}} + N_{\text{mig}}) and place it in the denominator when calculating mm.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Compute the total population size after stocking: Ntotal=Nnat+Nmig=16200+5400=21600N_{\text{total}} = N_{\text{nat}} + N_{\text{mig}} = 16200 + 5400 = 21600.

  2. Calculate the true migration fraction: m=NmigNtotal=540021600=0.250m = \frac{N_{\text{mig}}}{N_{\text{total}}} = \frac{5400}{21600} = 0.250.

  3. Substitute m=0.250m = 0.250 into the post-gene-flow allele frequency formula: p′=(1−0.250)(0.150)+(0.250)(0.800)=0.1125+0.2000=0.3125≈0.313p' = (1 - 0.250)(0.150) + (0.250)(0.800) = 0.1125 + 0.2000 = 0.3125 \approx 0.313.

Final answer

Nmig=5.40×103N_{\text{mig}} = 5.40 \times 10^3; Nnat=1.62×104N_{\text{nat}} = 1.62 \times 10^4; m=0.250m = 0.250; p′=0.313p' = 0.313

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the difference between a ratio (A:BA : B) and a proportion (A/(A+B)A / (A + B)) in population genetics models.

  • Practice identifying whether a population genetics formula requires the pre-event population or the combined total population in the denominator.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student reverses the allele frequencies by associating the hatchery frequency with native residents and the native frequency with migrants.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Nmig=450×12=5400  ⟹  Nnat=1350×12=16200  ⟹  Ntotal=21600N_{\text{mig}} = 450 \times 12 = 5400 \implies N_{\text{nat}} = 1350 \times 12 = 16200 \implies N_{\text{total}} = 21600

  2. Step 2

    m=540021600=0.25m = \frac{5400}{21600} = 0.25

  3. Step 3

    p′=(1−m)phatch+m⋅pnat  ⟹  p′=(0.75)(0.800)+(0.25)(0.150)=0.600+0.0375=0.6375p' = (1 - m)p_{\text{hatch}} + m \cdot p_{\text{nat}} \implies p' = (0.75)(0.800) + (0.25)(0.150) = 0.600 + 0.0375 = 0.6375

    Correct

    p′=(1−m)pnat+m⋅phatch=(0.750)(0.150)+(0.250)(0.800)=0.1125+0.2000=0.3125≈0.313p' = (1 - m)p_{\text{nat}} + m \cdot p_{\text{hatch}} = (0.750)(0.150) + (0.250)(0.800) = 0.1125 + 0.2000 = 0.3125 \approx 0.313

    You inverted the source weights in the gene flow model. Native resident fish represent the majority (1−m=0.750)(1 - m = 0.750) of the stream, so (1−m)(1 - m) must multiply pnat=0.150p_{\text{nat}} = 0.150, while migrants represent m=0.250m = 0.250 and must multiply phatch=0.800p_{\text{hatch}} = 0.800.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly converted both linear densities into total population counts.

You correctly calculated the migration proportion mm relative to the total combined population.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Reversed Allele Frequency Weights

You accidentally swapped phatchp_{\text{hatch}} and pnatp_{\text{nat}} in the weighted average formula.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

In gene flow models, mm is the proportion of incoming migrants and (1−m)(1 - m) is the proportion of native residents; pairing (1−m)(1 - m) with the migrant frequency incorrectly inflates the migrant contribution.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Match Population Weights to Subpopulations
  • p′=(1−m)president+m⋅pmigrantp' = (1 - m)p_{\text{resident}} + m \cdot p_{\text{migrant}}

  • Always label (1−m)(1 - m) explicitly as the native/resident weight and mm as the migrant weight before substituting numbers.

Perform a Directional Sanity Check
  • If migrants make up a minority of the population (m<0.50m < 0.50), the new allele frequency p′p' must remain closer to pnatp_{\text{nat}} than to phatchp_{\text{hatch}}.

  • Check whether your calculated p′p' lies closer to the dominant resident subpopulation frequency.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Identify resident and migrant components: resident proportion is (1−m)=1−0.250=0.750(1 - m) = 1 - 0.250 = 0.750 with pnat=0.150p_{\text{nat}} = 0.150; migrant proportion is m=0.250m = 0.250 with phatch=0.800p_{\text{hatch}} = 0.800.

  2. Apply the standard weighted average formula: p′=(1−m)pnat+m⋅phatchp' = (1 - m)p_{\text{nat}} + m \cdot p_{\text{hatch}}.

  3. Substitute values and calculate: p′=(0.750)(0.150)+(0.250)(0.800)=0.1125+0.2000=0.3125p' = (0.750)(0.150) + (0.250)(0.800) = 0.1125 + 0.2000 = 0.3125.

Final answer

p′=0.313p' = 0.313

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the weighted average formula for one-way gene flow, ensuring that each frequency is paired with its respective subpopulation proportion.

  • Practice using a common-sense sanity check: since migrants are only 25%25\% of the stream, the final allele frequency should shift only 25%25\% of the way toward the hatchery frequency.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A lake contains 4 0004\,000 native trout. A fishery releases 1 0001\,000 hatchery-reared trout into the lake. What is the migration proportion mm?

Answer

Ntotal=4 000+1 000=5 000N_{\text{total}} = 4\,000 + 1\,000 = 5\,000. Thus, m=NmigNtotal=1 0005 000=0.20m = \frac{N_{\text{mig}}}{N_{\text{total}}} = \frac{1\,000}{5\,000} = 0.20.

02

An isolated wildflower population has 1 8001\,800 plants with a white-petal allele frequency of pnat=0.10p_{\text{nat}} = 0.10. A windstorm introduces pollen and seeds equivalent to 200200 migrant individuals having an allele frequency of pmig=0.60p_{\text{mig}} = 0.60. Calculate the new allele frequency p′p' in the mixed population.

Answer
  1. Total population: Ntotal=1 800+200=2 000N_{\text{total}} = 1\,800 + 200 = 2\,000.
  2. Migration proportion: m=2002 000=0.10m = \frac{200}{2\,000} = 0.10.
  3. New allele frequency: p′=(1−m)pnat+m⋅pmig=(0.90)(0.10)+(0.10)(0.60)=0.09+0.06=0.15p' = (1 - m)p_{\text{nat}} + m \cdot p_{\text{mig}} = (0.90)(0.10) + (0.10)(0.60) = 0.09 + 0.06 = 0.15.
03

In a forest reserve, a native beetle population has size Nnat=3 000N_{\text{nat}} = 3\,000 with frequency pnat=0.20p_{\text{nat}} = 0.20 for a pesticide-resistance allele. Migrants from an agricultural zone arrive with pmig=0.70p_{\text{mig}} = 0.70. After migration, the allele frequency in the reserve becomes p′=0.325p' = 0.325. Determine the number of migrants NmigN_{\text{mig}} that entered the reserve.

Answer
  1. Use p′−pnat=m(pmig−pnat)p' - p_{\text{nat}} = m(p_{\text{mig}} - p_{\text{nat}}): 0.325−0.20=m(0.70−0.20)  ⟹  0.125=0.50m  ⟹  m=0.250.325 - 0.20 = m(0.70 - 0.20) \implies 0.125 = 0.50m \implies m = 0.25.
  2. Since m=NmigNnat+Nmigm = \frac{N_{\text{mig}}}{N_{\text{nat}} + N_{\text{mig}}}, we have 0.25=Nmig3 000+Nmig0.25 = \frac{N_{\text{mig}}}{3\,000 + N_{\text{mig}}}.
  3. Solving gives 0.25(3 000+Nmig)=Nmig  ⟹  750=0.75Nmig  ⟹  Nmig=1 0000.25(3\,000 + N_{\text{mig}}) = N_{\text{mig}} \implies 750 = 0.75 N_{\text{mig}} \implies N_{\text{mig}} = 1\,000.
Loading workspace…