Resources
A student characterizes cellular nutrition and classification across various protists and fungi, but frequently conflates primary endosymbiosis, secondary endosymbiosis, and saprotrophic absorptive heterotrophy. Consider three specimens: Specimen 1 is Chlamydomonas (a green alga), Specimen 2 is Phaeodactylum (a marine diatom), and Specimen 3 is Rhizopus (a zygomycete bread mold). (a) State the exact number of bounding membranes enclosing the plastids of Specimen 1 and Specimen 2, and identify which underwent primary versus secondary endosymbiosis. (b) Explain why classifying Specimen 3 as an autotrophic protist or 'primitive non-photosynthetic plant' violates modern phylogenetic and biochemical criteria regarding nutrition and cell wall chemistry.
Answer and steps
Final answer
(a) Specimen 1 (Chlamydomonas) plastids have bounding membranes (primary endosymbiosis of a cyanobacterium); Specimen 2 (Phaeodactylum) plastids have bounding membranes (secondary endosymbiosis of an ancestral red alga). (b) Specimen 3 (Rhizopus) is an obligate absorptive heterotroph (osmotroph) that secretes exoenzymes and absorbs digested nutrients, stores carbon as glycogen (not starch), and synthesizes a cell wall of chitin (polymers of -(1,4)--acetylglucosamine), placing it in kingdom Fungi within Opisthokonta, completely distinct from plants and autotrophic protists.
Steps
Part (a): Plastid Membrane Count and Endosymbiotic Origin
-
Specimen 1: Chlamydomonas (Green Alga)
- Plastid Membranes: Enclosed by membranes.
- Endosymbiotic Event: Primary endosymbiosis. A heterotrophic ancestral eukaryote engulfed a photosynthetic cyanobacterium. Over evolutionary time, the cyanobacterium was reduced to a double-membraned organelle (the inner and outer chloroplast envelopes). Chlamydomonas belongs to the lineage Archaeplastida (Plantae sensu lato).
-
Specimen 2: Phaeodactylum (Marine Diatom)
- Plastid Membranes: Enclosed by membranes.
- Endosymbiotic Event: Secondary endosymbiosis. A heterotrophic eukaryote engulfed an already photosynthetic eukaryotic red alga.
- Origin of the four layers:
- The two innermost membranes represent the original cyanobacterial envelopes.
- The third membrane is the remnant plasma membrane of the engulfed red alga.
- The fourth, outermost membrane is derived from the host's endomembrane system (forming the chloroplast endoplasmic reticulum).
Part (b): Classification of Specimen 3 (Rhizopus)
Classifying Rhizopus as an autotrophic protist or a "primitive non-photosynthetic plant" directly contradicts fundamental biochemical and phylogenetic evidence:
-
Mode of Nutrition:
- Rhizopus is strictly an absorptive heterotroph (an osmotroph or saprotroph). It cannot perform photosynthesis and lacks plastids entirely. Instead of internalizing food or photosynthesizing, it secretes hydrolytic exoenzymes into its organic substrate and absorbs the released low-molecular-weight nutrients through its hyphal membranes.
-
Cell Wall Chemistry:
- Plant and green algal cell walls are constructed predominantly of cellulose (linear polymers of -(1,4)-D-glucose).
- In contrast, the cell wall of Rhizopus is composed primarily of chitin (a fibrous polymer of -(1,4)--acetylglucosamine), a structural polysaccharide shared with arthropod exoskeletons, not plants.
-
Energy Storage and Phylogeny:
- Plants and green algae store excess carbohydrates as starch inside plastids. Rhizopus stores energy as glycogen in the cytoplasm, identical to animal storage.
- Phylogenetically, fungi belong to the supergroup Opisthokonta (sharing a much closer common ancestor with animals than with plants or photosynthetic protists). Grouping Rhizopus with Archaeplastida overlooks this evolutionary divergence.
Common Pitfall: Counting membranes in secondary endosymbionts often trips students up. Remember that each engulfment adds a host vacuolar membrane around the existing outer membrane of the symbiont; in secondary endosymbiosis, an entire eukaryotic cell with a 2-membrane plastid is engulfed, resulting in 3 to 4 total bounding membranes.
Typical errors
01 The student assumes all photosynthetic plastids possess two membranes from the ancestral cyanobacterium, failing to account for the extra membranes acquired during secondary endosymbiosis in diatoms.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
Specimen 1 plastids have membranes and arose by primary endosymbiosis.
- Step 2
Specimen 2 plastids have membranes and arose by primary endosymbiosis.
CorrectSpecimen 2 (Phaeodactylum) plastids have bounding membranes and arose by secondary endosymbiosis of an ancestral red alga.
Diatoms like Phaeodactylum belong to the stramenopiles, which acquired photosynthetic plastids through secondary endosymbiosis (the engulfment of a photosynthetic eukaryote, specifically a red alga). This adds extra surrounding membranes, resulting in a total of bounding membranes (the inner two from the original cyanobacterial envelopes, the third from the engulfed alga's plasma membrane, and the outermost from the host's endomembrane system).
- Step 3
Specimen 3 is an absorptive heterotroph rather than an autotroph. ⟹ Its cell walls consist of chitin rather than plant cellulose, violating plant classification.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly identified that Specimen 1 (Chlamydomonas) has plastid membranes arising from primary endosymbiosis.
You clearly explained that Specimen 3 (Rhizopus) is an absorptive heterotroph with chitin-based cell walls rather than an autotroph with cellulose walls.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou stated that Specimen 2 has plastid membranes and arose by primary endosymbiosis instead of identifying its -membrane secondary endosymbiotic origin.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou generalized the standard double-membrane chloroplast structure of Archaeplastida to all photosynthetic eukaryotes, overlooking that diatoms acquired their plastids via secondary endosymbiosis where an entire eukaryotic red alga was engulfed.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Primary vs. Secondary Endosymbiosis
Primary endosymbiosis (eukaryote + cyanobacterium) yields a plastid with membranes (Archaeplastida: red algae, green algae, land plants, glaucophytes). Secondary endosymbiosis (eukaryote + photosynthetic eukaryote) yields a plastid enclosed by or membranes.
When classifying algae outside Archaeplastida (such as diatoms, brown algae, dinoflagellates, or euglenids), count the additional host and symbiont membranes to identify secondary endosymbiosis.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationIdentify the phylogenetic lineage of Phaeodactylum: it is a diatom (stramenopile/heterokont), not a green or red alga.
Recall the endosymbiotic origin of diatom plastids: an ancestral heterotrophic stramenopile engulfed an autotrophic red alga (secondary endosymbiosis).
Count the resulting membranes: original cyanobacterial plastid envelopes + engulfed red alga plasma membrane + host phagosomal/endomembrane envelope (chloroplast ER) = membranes.
(a) Specimen 1 plastids have bounding membranes (primary endosymbiosis); Specimen 2 plastids have bounding membranes (secondary endosymbiosis). (b) Specimen 3 is an absorptive heterotroph with cell walls of chitin, excluding it from autotrophs and plants.
02 The student confuses the cell wall polymer of fungi with that of plants, asserting that bread mold has cellulose cell walls.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
Specimen 1 plastids have 2 membranes from primary endosymbiosis.
- Step 2
Specimen 2 plastids have 4 membranes from secondary endosymbiosis.
- Step 3
Specimen 3 is an absorptive chemoheterotroph, not an autotroph. Its cell wall contains cellulose like primitive plants, which violates modern fungal classification.
CorrectSpecimen 3 (Rhizopus) is an absorptive heterotroph (osmotroph) rather than an autotroph, and its cell wall is composed of chitin (polymers of -(1,4)--acetylglucosamine), not cellulose.
You correctly identified the heterotrophic nutritional mode, but fungi do not have cellulose cell walls. True fungi, including Rhizopus, synthesize cell walls made of chitin, which chemically and phylogenetically aligns them with Opisthokonta rather than Plantae.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly matched the double-membrane plastid of Chlamydomonas to primary endosymbiosis.
You correctly matched the four-membrane plastid of Phaeodactylum to secondary endosymbiosis.
You correctly identified that Rhizopus is an absorptive heterotroph rather than an autotroph.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou attributed cellulose cell walls to fungi instead of recognizing their characteristic chitinous cell wall.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisConflating fungal cell wall biochemistry with plant cell wall biochemistry. Fungi synthesize chitin (a polymer of -acetylglucosamine), whereas plants and green algae synthesize cellulose (a polymer of -D-glucose).
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Fungal Cell Wall Polymer
True fungi (kingdom Fungi) construct rigid cell walls out of chitin, not cellulose.
Associate cellulose strictly with green plants and algae, and associate chitin with fungi and arthropods.
- Major Storage Carbohydrates
Plants and green algae store energy as starch inside plastids, whereas fungi store energy as glycogen in the cytoplasm.
Use both cell wall chemistry (chitin) and carbon storage (glycogen) to distinguish fungi from plants.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationState that Rhizopus is an obligate absorptive heterotroph (saprotroph) that secretes exoenzymes and lacks plastids entirely.
Specify that the cell wall of Rhizopus is composed of chitin (a polymer of -(1,4)--acetylglucosamine), fundamentally distinguishing it from the cellulose walls of plants.
Note that fungi store carbohydrate reserves as glycogen and belong to the supergroup Opisthokonta, phylogenetically closer to animals than to plants.
(a) Specimen 1 (Chlamydomonas) plastids have bounding membranes (primary endosymbiosis); Specimen 2 (Phaeodactylum) plastids have bounding membranes (secondary endosymbiosis). (b) Specimen 3 (Rhizopus) violates plant classification because it is an absorptive heterotroph (osmotroph) rather than an autotroph, stores excess carbon as glycogen rather than starch, and synthesizes a cell wall primarily composed of chitin rather than cellulose.
03 The student counts only three membranes for secondary plastids by assuming the engulfed eukaryotic plasma membrane was always lost, yielding three rather than four membranes in diatoms.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
Specimen 1 plastids possess membranes resulting from primary endosymbiosis.
- Step 2
Specimen 2 plastids possess membranes resulting from secondary endosymbiosis.
CorrectSpecimen 2 (Phaeodactylum) plastids have bounding membranes and arose from secondary endosymbiosis.
You correctly identified secondary endosymbiosis, but diatoms (stramenopiles) retain four bounding membranes around their plastids, not three.
- Step 3
Specimen 3 exhibits absorptive heterotrophy instead of autotrophic nutrition. Its cell wall is made of chitin, whereas plant walls are made of cellulose.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly identified primary endosymbiosis and the resulting two plastid membranes in Chlamydomonas.
You correctly identified that Phaeodactylum acquired its plastids via secondary endosymbiosis.
You clearly contrasted fungal absorptive heterotrophy and chitinous walls with plant autotrophy and cellulose.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou likely assumed that one of the intervening membranes was lost during secondary endosymbiosis (as occurs in euglenids and most dinoflagellates), overlooking that diatoms and other ochrophytes retain all four layers, including the outermost chloroplast endoplasmic reticulum.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Counting Secondary Endosymbiotic Membranes
In primary endosymbiosis, engulfing a Gram-negative cyanobacterium leaves envelope membranes. In secondary endosymbiosis involving red algae (e.g., diatoms, brown algae), the plastid is surrounded by membranes: original cyanobacterial envelopes, the reduced red algal plasma membrane, and the host's outer endomembrane (chloroplast ER).
When dealing with diatoms, cryptophytes, or haptophytes, account for all four distinct membrane boundaries rather than three.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationRecall the ancestry of ochrophyte (stramenopile) plastids: a heterotrophic eukaryote engulfed an ancestral unicellular red alga.
Count the layers from inside out: (1) inner cyanobacterial envelope, (2) outer cyanobacterial envelope, (3) engulfed red algal plasma membrane, and (4) host phagotrophic/endomembrane vesicle (chloroplast ER).
Because diatoms retain the engulfed alga's plasma membrane and fuse the outer vacuolar membrane with their rough endoplasmic reticulum, the total membrane count is .
(a) Specimen 1: membranes (primary endosymbiosis); Specimen 2: membranes (secondary endosymbiosis). (b) Specimen 3 (Rhizopus) is an absorptive heterotroph (osmotroph) with a cell wall composed of chitin, violating criteria for autotrophs and plants.
Lock it in
How many bounding membranes enclose a plastid derived from primary endosymbiosis, and which lineages possess them?
membranes (inner and outer envelopes from the engulfed cyanobacterium). Found in Archaeplastida: glaucophytes, red algae, and green algae/plants.
Similar question
A photosynthetic flagellate, Euglena gracilis, possesses chloroplasts containing chlorophylls a and b bounded by exactly membranes. State whether this plastid originated from primary or secondary endosymbiosis, and identify the eukaryotic lineage engulfed by the ancestral host.
Answer
Secondary endosymbiosis. The ancestral phagotrophic euglenid engulfed a eukaryotic green alga; one of the surrounding membranes was subsequently lost, leaving bounding membranes.
In the diatom Phaeodactylum, the outermost of the plastid membranes is directly continuous with the host cell's rough endoplasmic reticulum, forming a 'chloroplast ER'. Explain the evolutionary origin of both the outermost and the second outermost membranes of this complex plastid.
Answer
The outermost membrane is derived from the host's endomembrane system (the phagocytic vacuolar membrane that fused with the host rough ER). The second outermost (third from inside) membrane represents the remnant plasma membrane of the engulfed eukaryotic red alga.
An organism displays filamentous hyphae and absorbs nutrients from rotting wood. Biochemical analysis reveals -(1,3)- and -(1,6)-glucans alongside chitin in its cell walls, while phylogenetic analysis places it within Opisthokonta. Contrast its storage carbohydrate and mode of nutrition with that of Chlamydomonas to justify why it cannot be classified as a photosynthetic protist or plant.
Answer
The organism is a fungus: it is an obligate absorptive heterotroph (osmotroph) storing excess carbon as glycogen in the cytosol. In contrast, Chlamydomonas is a photoautotroph with plastids that synthesizes and stores starch within chloroplasts. Fungi lack plastids entirely and share a most recent common ancestor with animals within Opisthokonta, whereas plants belong to Archaeplastida.