Resources
An organism is heterozygous at two unlinked autosomal gene loci, having the genotype . Assume normal chromosome behavior without non-disjunction. (a) In a somatic stem cell undergoing mitotic anaphase, determine the number of distinct cellular poles, the total number of copies of allele present across the whole cell, and the exact allelic genotype segregating to each pole. (b) In a primary spermatocyte undergoing meiosis without crossing over between either locus and its centromere, calculate the theoretical probability that a randomly chosen secondary spermatocyte at prophase II carries both dominant alleles and , and determine the total number of distinct mature gamete genotypes generated by this single meiotic cell.
Answer and steps
Final answer
(a) poles; total copies of allele ; segregating genotype at each pole is . (b) Probability of an secondary spermatocyte is (or ); exactly distinct mature gamete genotypes are produced by that single meiotic cell.
Steps
Part (a): Mitotic Anaphase in a Somatic Cell
- Number of cellular poles: During mitotic division, a bipolar spindle apparatus forms between two centrosomes. Therefore, there are exactly distinct cellular poles toward which chromosomes migrate during anaphase.
-
Total number of copies of allele in the cell:
- Prior to entering mitosis, the diploid cell () duplicates its nuclear DNA during the S phase of interphase.
- Each replicated chromosome consists of two identical sister chromatids. The single original allele replicates into two identical sister chromatids, each carrying an allele.
- Thus, across the entire cell during anaphase, there are total copies of allele (along with copies of , copies of , and copies of ).
-
Allelic genotype segregating toward each pole:
- In mitotic anaphase, the centromeres divide and sister chromatids separate disjoining to opposite poles.
- Because sister chromatids are identical copies, each pole receives one full, identical diploid complement: one copy of , one copy of , one copy of , and one copy of .
- Therefore, the exact genotype migrating toward each pole is .
Part (b): Meiotic Segregation in a Single Primary Spermatocyte
-
Probability of an secondary spermatocyte at prophase II:
- In a primary spermatocyte, homologous chromosomes pair to form bivalents during prophase I. Because the loci are unlinked and no crossing over occurs, homologous chromosome pairs align and segregate independently during anaphase I.
- The two pairs ( and ) can segregate in two equally likely orientations:
- Orientation 1: segregates with , while segregates with .
- Orientation 2: segregates with , while segregates with .
- Each orientation occurs with a probability of ().
- Under Orientation 1, one secondary spermatocyte receives the replicated and chromosomes (carrying alleles and ), and the other receives and .
- Consequently, among the four equally probable secondary spermatocyte outcomes across all possible alignments (, , , and ), the theoretical probability that a randomly chosen secondary spermatocyte possesses both dominant alleles ( and ) is:
-
Distinct mature gamete genotypes from a single meiotic division:
- A common pitfall is confusing the total population-level gametic diversity ( types: ) with the output of a single individual primary spermatocyte.
- In any single primary spermatocyte without crossing over, only one of the two alternative metaphase I alignments takes place:
- If chromosomes align as and , meiosis II separates sister chromatids to produce two sperm and two sperm, yielding distinct genotypes ( and ).
- If chromosomes align as and , meiosis II produces two sperm and two sperm, yielding distinct genotypes ( and ).
- In either scenario, that single meiotic cell yields exactly distinct mature gamete genotypes.
Typical errors
01 The student confuses the population-level gamete variety of a dihybrid organism with the actual outcome of a single meiotic cell, incorrectly concluding that 4 distinct gamete genotypes are produced by one spermatocyte.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
- Step 2
- Step 3
AB, Ab, aB, ab = 4
Correct= 2
You applied the overall organismal gamete repertoire ( types) to an individual meiotic event. In a single primary spermatocyte without crossing over, the homologous pairs can adopt only one specific metaphase I orientation, producing either or . Either way, exactly distinct genotypes are generated, not .
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly tracked sister chromatid replication and disjunction in mitotic anaphase.
You identified the correct diploid set segregating to each pole during somatic cell division.
You calculated the theoretical probability of a specific secondary spermatocyte genotype using independent assortment.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou assumed that all four possible combinations of independent assortment occur simultaneously within one cell, overlooking that a single primary spermatocyte can only execute one physical metaphase I alignment.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Single cell vs. population assortment
A dihybrid organism () makes gamete types across many meiotic cells, but a single primary spermatocyte without crossing over can undergo only one metaphase I orientation.
Always trace the physical segregation of a single bivalent pair: one orientation yields two complementary genotypes, giving exactly distinct gamete types per spermatocyte.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationRecall that without crossing over, a single primary spermatocyte aligns its homologous pairs at metaphase I in one of two mutually exclusive orientations: either pairs with and with , or pairs with and with .
Following anaphase I and cytokinesis, the two secondary spermatocytes carry duplicated chromatids of those separated sets (e.g., and ).
Meiosis II merely separates identical sister chromatids equational-style, resulting in four sperm: two of genotype and two of genotype (or two and two ).
Count the unique types in this set: or .
distinct mature gamete genotypes
02 The student assumes that homologous chromosomes separate in mitosis rather than sister chromatids, leading to an incorrect haploid-like segregation genotype at each pole.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
Cellular poles = Total copies of allele A in cell =
- Step 2
Alleles segregate to opposite poles as and , and Genotype segregating to each pole = or
CorrectGenotype segregating to each pole =
You separated homologous chromosomes ( from , from ) as if this were anaphase I of meiosis. In mitotic anaphase, centromeres split and sister chromatids separate, delivering an identical complete diploid set () to each pole.
- Step 3
Possible secondary spermatocyte types: Probability of receiving both and =
- Step 4
One primary spermatocyte produces distinct gamete genotypes
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly identified that a mitotic cell has two spindle poles and two copies of allele after S-phase replication.
You correctly determined the probability of obtaining an secondary spermatocyte from independent assortment.
You correctly distinguished the gametic output of a single primary spermatocyte from population-level gamete diversity.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou confused mitotic anaphase with meiotic anaphase I, assuming that homologous chromosomes disjoin rather than sister chromatids separating to preserve the full diploid genotype.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Unit of Separation
In mitosis and meiosis II, sister chromatids separate; in meiosis I, homologous chromosome pairs separate.
Check whether the cell division is equational (preserving genotype at both poles) or reductional (halving ploidy).
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationDuring S phase, the cell replicates each chromosome into two identical sister chromatids: two copies of , two copies of , two copies of , and two copies of .
In mitotic anaphase, sister chromatids separate at the centromere and migrate to opposite poles.
Each pole receives one sister chromatid from every chromosome, yielding one copy of , , , and .
(a) poles; total copies of allele ; segregating genotype at each pole is . (b) Probability of an secondary spermatocyte is (or ); exactly distinct mature gamete genotypes are produced by that single meiotic cell.
03 The student misidentifies the ploidy and allele content of secondary spermatocytes, confusing secondary spermatocytes with post-meiosis II haploid gametes and calculating the probability among only 2 alternative poles rather than 4 independent dihybrid combinations.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
Cellular poles = 2 ⟹ Total copies of allele A in cell = 2 ⟹ Genotype segregating to each pole = AaBb
- Step 2
Meiosis I separates homologs, so secondary spermatocytes only receive either A or a ⟹ Probability of secondary spermatocyte carrying both A and B = 1/2
Correct(or )
Because the two gene loci are unlinked, their homologous pairs align and segregate independently during meiosis I. The probability of a secondary spermatocyte receiving dominant allele is , and the independent probability of receiving dominant allele is also . Multiplying these independent events yields , not .
- Step 3
Total distinct gamete genotypes generated by the single cell = 2
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly identified the spindle pole count, total allele copy number, and segregating genotype during mitotic anaphase.
You correctly distinguished a single cell's meiotic output (2 distinct genotypes) from the population-level gamete pool (4 distinct genotypes).
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou tracked the segregation of the first locus () during meiosis I but treated the second unlinked locus () as fully coupled or already accounted for, rather than multiplying their independent segregation probabilities.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Independent Assortment of Unlinked Loci
For unlinked loci in meiosis I, each chromosome pair aligns independently on the metaphase plate; joint probabilities of alleles residing in the same daughter cell multiply: .
Calculate the probability for each gene locus independently ( and ), then multiply them to find the probability of a specific secondary spermatocyte combination.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationIdentify the possible combinations of alleles entering a secondary spermatocyte after meiosis I: , , , and .
Because the two loci are on non-homologous chromosomes and segregate independently: .
The theoretical probability that a randomly chosen secondary spermatocyte carries both alleles and is (or ).
Lock it in
How many distinct gamete genotypes are produced by a single primary spermatocyte of genotype if no crossing over occurs?
genotypes. A single cell adopts only one metaphase I orientation, producing two complementary pairs of identical gametes (e.g., ).
Similar question
A male organism has the genotype with all three gene loci on different, unlinked autosomes. Assuming normal meiosis without crossing over, how many distinct gamete genotypes are generated by: (a) the organism as a whole, and (b) a single primary spermatocyte?
Answer
(a) distinct gamete genotypes for the organism as a whole. (b) Exactly distinct gamete genotypes for a single primary spermatocyte, because one fixed metaphase I alignment segregates homologous chromosomes into two opposite poles, yielding two reciprocal gamete types (each duplicated once in meiosis II, e.g., ).
Consider a primary spermatocyte with genotype where crossing over occurs between locus and its centromere, but no crossing over occurs at locus . How many distinct mature gamete genotypes are generated by this single meiotic cell?
Answer
distinct gamete genotypes (). A single crossover at locus creates non-identical sister chromatids ( and ) on each dyad, so when locus segregates at anaphase I, meiosis II separates the recombinant chromatids to yield four distinct genotypes from this single cell.
In a female mammal of genotype (unlinked genes, no crossing over), what is the total number of distinct functional ovum genotypes produced by a single primary oocyte?
Answer
distinct ovum genotype. A single primary oocyte completes meiosis to produce only one mature functional ovum and polar bodies, so it can only transmit one specific haploid genotype.