Resources
A student dissolves of crystalline calcium chloride () into of pure liquid water inside an insulated constant-pressure calorimeter. The dissolution reaction is , which has an enthalpy of solution . Assume the specific heat capacity of the resulting aqueous solution is equal to that of pure water (), the combined mass of the final solution is , and heat loss to the surroundings is negligible. (a) Calculate the total thermal energy released by the dissolution and the resulting temperature change () of the solution. (b) Couple thermodynamic enthalpy with molecular hydration: explain why the hydration enthalpy () of divalent is substantially more exothermic than that of monovalent , referencing Coulomb's Law and ion charge density.
Answer and steps
Final answer
(a) ; . (b) By Coulomb's Law (), the divalent charge () and smaller ionic radius of yield a much higher charge density than (), generating significantly stronger ion-dipole attractions with water's partially negative oxygen atoms and releasing far greater hydration energy.
Steps
Part (a): Calculating Heat Released and Temperature Change
- Calculate the heat released by the reaction (): The molar enthalpy of solution for calcium chloride is . For of , the change in enthalpy of the system is: Because the dissolution is exothermic, energy is released from the solute into the aqueous solution. The heat gained by the solution () is equal in magnitude and opposite in sign to the system's reaction heat:
- Calculate the temperature change (): Using the calorimetry relation for the solution: Rearranging to solve for : Substitute the given values ( and ):
Common Pitfall: Watch the signs when applying . An exothermic reaction () transfers heat to the solvent, making and resulting in a temperature increase ().
Part (b): Molecular Hydration and Coulomb's Law
- Electrostatic Basis (Coulomb's Law): The electrostatic force of attraction between two charges is described by Coulomb's Law: where is the charge of the ion, is the partial negative charge () on the oxygen atom of a polar water molecule, and is the internuclear distance between the ion and the dipole center.
-
Charge and Radius Comparison:
- Both and are isoelectronic (each having electrons), but has 20 protons compared to 19 protons in .
- The greater nuclear charge of draws its electron cloud inward, giving a smaller ionic radius () than ().
-
Charge Density and Hydration Enthalpy:
- Ion Charge Density: Charge density is defined as the ratio of an ion's charge to its volume (). Because possesses twice the net charge ( vs. ) concentrated in a smaller ionic volume, it has a vastly higher charge density than .
- Ion-Dipole Attractions: The high charge density creates a much stronger electric field, forming significantly stronger ion-dipole attractions with the oxygen atoms () of surrounding water molecules in the primary hydration shell.
- Enthalpy Impact: Stronger electrostatic bonds release more potential energy when formed; hence, the hydration enthalpy () of is substantially more negative (more exothermic) than that of .
Typical errors
01 The student uses only the mass of water (450.0 g) instead of the total solution mass (466.6 g) when calculating ΔT.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
- Step 2Correct
In solution calorimetry, the heat released warms the entire aqueous solution (solute plus solvent). You substituted only the solvent mass () instead of the total solution mass (), which overestimated .
- Step 3
According to Coulomb's Law, attractive force is proportional to . has a charge and smaller ionic radius than , giving it a much higher charge density. Higher charge density leads to stronger ion-dipole attractions with water dipoles, releasing more energy and making more exothermic.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly calculated the total heat transferred using molar enthalpy and mole quantity.
You handled the thermodynamic signs accurately by setting .
You provided an excellent molecular explanation linking Coulomb's Law, ionic charge density, and hydration enthalpy.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou substituted the mass of pure water () instead of the combined solution mass () in .
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisConfusing the initial mass of the solvent () with the total mass of the heated thermal reservoir ().
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Define the Thermal Mass Reservoir
In aqueous calorimetry where a solid solute dissolves, the final solution consists of both the solute and the solvent: .
Always verify whether the problem provides or asks for total solution mass before evaluating .
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationIdentify the total mass being heated: .
Apply the calorimetry equation: .
Compute the final temperature change: .
(a) ( released), ; (b) has higher charge density and smaller radius than , resulting in stronger ion-dipole attractions and a more exothermic .
02 The student neglects the negative sign in q_soln = -q_rxn, yielding a negative temperature change for an exothermic dissolution.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
- Step 2Correct
By conservation of energy in an insulated calorimeter, the heat gained by the solution must equal the heat lost by the reaction (). Because heat was released by the dissolution, the solution absorbs that energy, so must be positive.
- Step 3Correct
Your algebraic setup and arithmetic were correct, but propagating the negative sign from the previous step produced a temperature drop instead of a temperature rise.
- Step 4
By Coulomb's Law, electrostatic attraction is proportional to charge and inversely proportional to the square of distance. has twice the charge ( vs ) and a smaller ionic radius than , resulting in a higher charge density. Stronger ion-dipole interactions with polar water molecules release greater hydration enthalpy, so is more exothermic.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly calculated the heat of reaction by multiplying moles by the molar enthalpy of solution.
You accurately converted kilojoules to joules for calorimetry calculations.
You demonstrated a complete conceptual grasp of Coulomb's Law, ionic radius, charge density, and ion-dipole interactions in part (b).
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou set instead of applying the sign inversion .
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisConfusing system and surroundings sign conventions in calorimetry: an exothermic process releases thermal energy (), which enters the aqueous surroundings and raises its thermal energy (), resulting in .
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- First Law Calorimeter Balance
For an insulated calorimeter, .
Always insert a negative sign when relating the heat absorbed by the solution to the enthalpy change of the chemical reaction.
- Physical Reality Check
Exothermic dissolution () releases heat into the water, warming it up ().
Check the sign of : if a reaction is exothermic, verify that your computed is positive.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationSet up the calorimeter heat balance: .
Solve for the temperature change: .
(a) (or released), ; (b) has double the ionic charge and a smaller radius than , giving it a significantly higher charge density that exerts stronger Coulombic ion-dipole attractions on water molecules and releases substantially more hydration energy.
03 The student attributes the difference in hydration enthalpy solely to ionic radius, claiming K⁺ has weaker hydration because it has a smaller charge density due to larger mass rather than comparing ionic charge.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
- Step 2
By Coulomb's Law, attraction decreases with greater distance between charges. Both ions interact with water, but is heavier and has a larger atomic radius than . Because is larger, water molecules cannot approach as closely, so weaker ion-dipole attraction makes less exothermic.
CorrectBy Coulomb's Law (), electrostatic attraction depends on both charge and distance. Isoelectronic has double the positive charge ( vs. ) and a smaller ionic radius than , resulting in a vastly higher charge density (). This exerts a much stronger electric field, forming stronger ion-dipole attractions with the partial negative oxygen atoms () of water and releasing significantly more hydration enthalpy.
You recognized that has a smaller radius than , but you omitted the central factor: ion charge ( for versus for ). Atomic mass does not govern electrostatic ion-dipole interactions, and charge density must incorporate both net charge and ionic size.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly calculated the reaction enthalpy release and the resulting positive temperature change in part (a).
You correctly identified that Coulombic attraction weakens as the distance between charges increases.
You correctly recognized that has a smaller ionic radius than .
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou focused solely on ionic size (and brought up irrelevant atomic mass) rather than analyzing both the charge numerator () and distance denominator () in Coulomb's Law to explain charge density.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Evaluate Both Variables in Coulomb's Law
Coulombic force is , meaning electrostatic strength depends directly on ion charge as well as inversely on distance.
Always compare the ionic charge () first before comparing ionic radii ().
- Define Charge Density Conceptually
Charge density reflects how concentrated an electric charge is per unit volume (roughly proportional to or ).
State explicitly how higher charge coupled with a smaller radius yields a much higher charge density, strengthening ion-dipole interactions.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationIdentify the charges of both ions: has a charge, whereas has a charge.
Compare their radii and electron configurations: both are isoelectronic with argon (), but has protons versus in , pulling its electron cloud tighter and yielding a smaller radius.
Combine charge and size into charge density: concentrates twice the charge in a smaller ionic volume.
Apply Coulomb's Law (): the charge and smaller separation distance produce vastly stronger ion-dipole attractions with water's oxygen atoms, releasing far more hydration enthalpy (more negative ).
(a) ( released), ; (b) By Coulomb's Law (), the charge and smaller radius of give it a much higher charge density than monovalent , yielding significantly stronger ion-dipole attractions with water and a much more exothermic .
Lock it in
In solution calorimetry involving the dissolution of a solid salt, what mass must be used in ?
. The thermal energy warms or cools the entire resulting solution, not just the pure solvent.
Similar question
A mass of of ammonium nitrate (, molar mass ) is dissolved in of water in an insulated cup calorimeter. The dissolution process absorbs of heat from the solution (). Assuming , calculate the temperature change of the solution.
Answer
. Key steps: Total mass is . Then .
An experiment dissolves of lithium chloride (, molar mass ) with into of water. Taking , compute both with and without accounting for the mass of dissolved , and state the percentage discrepancy caused by ignoring solute mass.
Answer
With solute mass: ; without solute mass: ; discrepancy . Key steps: . Solute mass , so . . Ignoring solute mass gives .
Magnesium ion (, ionic radius ) and sodium ion (, ionic radius ) are both hydrated in aqueous solution. Predict which ion has a more exothermic hydration enthalpy (), and justify your answer quantitatively using the proportional relationship between electrostatic potential energy, ionic charge , and ionic radius .
Answer
has a much more exothermic hydration enthalpy. Key steps: By Coulomb's Law, the electrostatic attraction between an ion and water's dipole is proportional to . For , , whereas for , . The charge density of is nearly three times higher, creating much stronger ion-dipole attractions and releasing significantly more energy upon hydration.