Resources

A population of flour beetles (Tribolium castaneum) is introduced into a closed grain silo where adult cannibalism of pupae serves as a density-dependent regulator. The per capita pupal cannibalism rate is modeled by mdd(N)=0.00080Nm_{\text{dd}}(N) = 0.00080 N, where NN is the adult beetle density (individuals per kilogram of grain). Simultaneously, a density-independent fumigation treatment causes an unvarying baseline mortality of mdi=0.12m_{\text{di}} = 0.12 (12%12\%). (a) Calculate the critical adult beetle density threshold N∗N^* at which density-dependent mortality exactly equals density-independent mortality. (b) If the carrying capacity of the silo is defined as the density where combined mortality equals the per capita reproduction rate of r0=0.60r_0 = 0.60, find the carrying capacity KK, and state whether density-dependent or density-independent mortality dominates at KK.

Answer and steps

Final answer

(a) Equating the two rates: 0.00080N∗=0.12  ⟹  N∗=0.120.00080=150 beetles/kg0.00080 N^* = 0.12 \implies N^* = \frac{0.12}{0.00080} = 150\text{ beetles/kg}. (b) At equilibrium carrying capacity KK, total per capita mortality equals reproduction: mdi+mdd(K)=r0  ⟹  0.12+0.00080K=0.60  ⟹  0.00080K=0.48  ⟹  K=600 beetles/kgm_{\text{di}} + m_{\text{dd}}(K) = r_0 \implies 0.12 + 0.00080 K = 0.60 \implies 0.00080 K = 0.48 \implies K = 600\text{ beetles/kg}. At K=600 beetles/kgK = 600\text{ beetles/kg}, mdd=0.00080(600)=0.48m_{\text{dd}} = 0.00080(600) = 0.48 (48%48\%) while mdi=0.12m_{\text{di}} = 0.12 (12%12\%); therefore, density-dependent mortality dominates at carrying capacity, accounting for 0.480.60=80.0%\frac{0.48}{0.60} = 80.0\% of all mortality.

Steps

Part (a): Determining the Critical Density Threshold N∗N^*

A density-dependent factor is an environmental influence whose per capita intensity changes with population density (such as competition, predation, or cannibalism). In contrast, a density-independent factor affects individuals at a constant per capita rate regardless of population density (such as temperature extremes, pesticides, or fumigation).

To find the critical density threshold N∗N^* where density-dependent mortality equals density-independent mortality, set the two per capita rates equal:

mdd(N∗)=mdim_{\text{dd}}(N^*) = m_{\text{di}}

Substitute the given equations:

0.00080N∗=0.120.00080 N^* = 0.12

Solve for N∗N^*:

N∗=0.120.00080=150 beetles/kgN^* = \frac{0.12}{0.00080} = 150\text{ beetles/kg}

Below 150 beetles/kg150\text{ beetles/kg}, the constant fumigation mortality exerts a stronger regulatory effect than pupal cannibalism; above this density, cannibalism becomes the larger source of mortality.


Part (b): Carrying Capacity KK and Dominant Mortality Factor

  1. Calculate the Carrying Capacity (KK):
    At carrying capacity KK, the population stops growing because the combined per capita mortality equals the per capita reproduction rate (r0=0.60r_0 = 0.60):

    mtotal(K)=mdi+mdd(K)=r0m_{\text{total}}(K) = m_{\text{di}} + m_{\text{dd}}(K) = r_0

    Substitute the known values into the equilibrium equation:

    0.12+0.00080K=0.600.12 + 0.00080 K = 0.60

    Subtract the density-independent mortality from both sides:

    0.00080K=0.480.00080 K = 0.48

    Solve for KK:

    K=0.480.00080=600 beetles/kgK = \frac{0.48}{0.00080} = 600\text{ beetles/kg}

  2. Evaluate the Dominant Mortality Source at KK:
    Evaluate the two components of mortality at K=600 beetles/kgK = 600\text{ beetles/kg}:

    • Density-independent mortality: mdi=0.12m_{\text{di}} = 0.12 (12%12\%)
    • Density-dependent mortality: mdd(600)=0.00080⋅600=0.48m_{\text{dd}}(600) = 0.00080 \cdot 600 = 0.48 (48%48\%)

    Comparing the two rates: mdd(K)mtotal(K)=0.480.60=0.80 or 80.0%\frac{m_{\text{dd}}(K)}{m_{\text{total}}(K)} = \frac{0.48}{0.60} = 0.80\text{ or }80.0\%

    Therefore, density-dependent mortality dominates at carrying capacity, contributing four times as much to total mortality as the density-independent factor.

Key Pitfall: Do not confuse total deaths with per capita death rate. Even though absolute numbers of deaths always increase with population size, only density-dependent factors show an increasing proportion (or per capita rate) of deaths as density increases.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student forgets to include baseline density-independent mortality when determining carrying capacity, equating only density-dependent mortality to reproduction.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    mdd(N∗)=mdi  ⟹  0.00080N∗=0.12  ⟹  N∗=150 individuals/kgm_{\text{dd}}(N^*) = m_{\text{di}} \implies 0.00080 N^* = 0.12 \implies N^* = 150\text{ individuals/kg}

  2. Step 2

    mdd(K)=r0  ⟹  0.00080K=0.60  ⟹  K=750 individuals/kgm_{\text{dd}}(K) = r_0 \implies 0.00080 K = 0.60 \implies K = 750\text{ individuals/kg}

    Correct

    mtotal(K)=mdi+mdd(K)=r0  ⟹  0.12+0.00080K=0.60  ⟹  K=600 beetles/kgm_{\text{total}}(K) = m_{\text{di}} + m_{\text{dd}}(K) = r_0 \implies 0.12 + 0.00080 K = 0.60 \implies K = 600\text{ beetles/kg}

    The carrying capacity occurs when the combined (total) per capita mortality equals reproduction. You only accounted for density-dependent mortality mddm_{\text{dd}}, leaving out the baseline fumigation mortality mdi=0.12m_{\text{di}} = 0.12.

  3. Step 3

    mdd(750)=0.60>0.12, so density-dependent mortality dominatesm_{\text{dd}}(750) = 0.60 > 0.12\text{, so density-dependent mortality dominates}

    Correct

    mdd(600)=0.48>mdi=0.12, so density-dependent mortality dominatesm_{\text{dd}}(600) = 0.48 > m_{\text{di}} = 0.12\text{, so density-dependent mortality dominates}

    Your qualitative conclusion that density-dependent mortality dominates is correct, but your calculation used the incorrect carrying capacity K=750K = 750 instead of K=600K = 600.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified and applied the condition where density-dependent mortality equals density-independent mortality in part (a).

You performed accurate algebraic solving to find N∗=150 individuals/kgN^* = 150\text{ individuals/kg}.

You correctly compared the two mortality components to identify which one was larger.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Omission of density-independent mortality in total mortality balance

You equated only mdd(K)m_{\text{dd}}(K) to r0r_0 instead of setting total mortality mdi+mdd(K)m_{\text{di}} + m_{\text{dd}}(K) equal to r0r_0.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Confusing density-dependent mortality with total mortality when setting up zero-net-growth equilibrium conditions. While density-dependent factors regulate population size around carrying capacity, carrying capacity is reached when all sources of mortality combined balance reproduction.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Total Per Capita Mortality
  • Total mortality rate is the sum of density-independent and density-dependent rates: mtotal(N)=mdi+mdd(N)m_{\text{total}}(N) = m_{\text{di}} + m_{\text{dd}}(N).

  • Always sum all mortality sources before setting mortality equal to per capita birth/reproduction rate r0r_0.

Carrying Capacity Equilibrium
  • At carrying capacity KK, net population growth is zero: r0−mtotal(K)=0r_0 - m_{\text{total}}(K) = 0.

  • Set mdi+mdd(K)=r0m_{\text{di}} + m_{\text{dd}}(K) = r_0 and isolate mdd(K)=r0−mdim_{\text{dd}}(K) = r_0 - m_{\text{di}} before solving for KK.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Write the total per capita mortality balance at equilibrium: mdi+mdd(K)=r0m_{\text{di}} + m_{\text{dd}}(K) = r_0.

  2. Substitute the given parameter values: 0.12+0.00080K=0.600.12 + 0.00080 K = 0.60.

  3. Subtract 0.120.12 from both sides: 0.00080K=0.480.00080 K = 0.48.

  4. Divide by 0.000800.00080: K=0.480.00080=600 beetles/kgK = \frac{0.48}{0.00080} = 600\text{ beetles/kg}.

  5. Evaluate mortality at K=600K = 600: mdd(600)=0.00080(600)=0.48m_{\text{dd}}(600) = 0.00080(600) = 0.48 (48%48\%) and mdi=0.12m_{\text{di}} = 0.12 (12%12\%).

  6. Because 0.48>0.120.48 > 0.12, density-dependent mortality dominates at carrying capacity.

Final answer

K=600 beetles/kgK = 600\text{ beetles/kg}; density-dependent mortality dominates.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the definition of total per capita mortality and ensure both baseline (density-independent) and regulatory (density-dependent) terms are included.

  • Practice setting up net-growth equilibrium equations (rnet=b−d=0r_{\text{net}} = b - d = 0) when multiple mortality sources act simultaneously.

  • Complete the three flashcards and practice problems below to master equilibrium calculations.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student misinterprets combined mortality as the product rather than the sum of the independent mortality components when solving for carrying capacity.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    mdd(N∗)=mdi  ⟹  0.00080N∗=0.12  ⟹  N∗=150 individuals/kgm_{\text{dd}}(N^*) = m_{\text{di}} \implies 0.00080 N^* = 0.12 \implies N^* = 150\text{ individuals/kg}

  2. Step 2

    mdd(K)×mdi=r0  ⟹  0.00080K×0.12=0.60  ⟹  0.000096K=0.60  ⟹  K=6250 individuals/kgm_{\text{dd}}(K) \times m_{\text{di}} = r_0 \implies 0.00080 K \times 0.12 = 0.60 \implies 0.000096 K = 0.60 \implies K = 6250\text{ individuals/kg}

    Correct

    mdi+mdd(K)=r0  ⟹  0.12+0.00080K=0.60  ⟹  0.00080K=0.48  ⟹  K=600 individuals/kgm_{\text{di}} + m_{\text{dd}}(K) = r_0 \implies 0.12 + 0.00080 K = 0.60 \implies 0.00080 K = 0.48 \implies K = 600\text{ individuals/kg}

    Combined per capita mortality from concurrent causes is the sum of each separate mortality rate (mtotal=mdi+mddm_{\text{total}} = m_{\text{di}} + m_{\text{dd}}), not their product. Multiplying the rates caused KK to be overestimated tenfold.

  3. Step 3

    mdd(6250)=5.00>0.12m_{\text{dd}}(6250) = 5.00 > 0.12, so density-dependent mortality dominates

    Correct

    mdd(600)=0.00080(600)=0.48>0.12m_{\text{dd}}(600) = 0.00080(600) = 0.48 > 0.12, so density-dependent mortality dominates

    Your qualitative conclusion that density-dependent mortality dominates is correct, but your numerical value of 5.005.00 (500%500\%) stems from your carrying capacity in Step 2. Evaluated at the true carrying capacity K=600 individuals/kgK = 600\text{ individuals/kg}, mdd(600)=0.48m_{\text{dd}}(600) = 0.48 (48%48\%), which still exceeds mdi=0.12m_{\text{di}} = 0.12 (12%12\%).

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified that the threshold N∗N^* occurs where density-dependent mortality equals density-independent mortality.

You carried out the linear equation solving and arithmetic with precise decimal handling.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Additive vs. Multiplicative Mortality Rates

You set the product of the two mortality components equal to the reproduction rate (mdd×mdi=r0m_{\text{dd}} \times m_{\text{di}} = r_0) rather than their sum.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

When two distinct environmental factors concurrently remove individuals from a population, each factor contributes additively to the total per capita death rate (mtotal=mdi+mddm_{\text{total}} = m_{\text{di}} + m_{\text{dd}}). Multiplying mortality rates is a misconception often carried over from independent survival probabilities, and it led here to an impossible per capita mortality rate of 5.005.00 (or 500%500\%).

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Combining Independent Causes of Mortality
  • For concurrent causes of death, the overall per capita mortality rate is the direct sum of the individual per capita mortality rates: mtotal=m1+m2+⋯+mnm_{\text{total}} = m_1 + m_2 + \dots + m_n.

  • Always add concurrent mortality rates when calculating total mortality to balance against the reproduction rate r0r_0.

Biological Sanity Check on Per Capita Rates
  • A per capita mortality proportion over a standardized period cannot exceed 1.01.0 (100%100\%).

  • If a calculated per capita mortality rate exceeds 1.01.0 (such as mdd=5.00m_{\text{dd}} = 5.00), pause and recheck whether rates were mistakenly multiplied or inverted.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Write the equilibrium condition at carrying capacity using additive total mortality: mtotal(K)=mdi+mdd(K)=r0m_{\text{total}}(K) = m_{\text{di}} + m_{\text{dd}}(K) = r_0.

  2. Substitute the known functions and parameters: 0.12+0.00080K=0.600.12 + 0.00080 K = 0.60.

  3. Subtract the constant density-independent mortality: 0.00080K=0.60−0.12=0.480.00080 K = 0.60 - 0.12 = 0.48.

  4. Solve for the carrying capacity: K=0.480.00080=600 beetles/kgK = \frac{0.48}{0.00080} = 600\text{ beetles/kg}.

  5. Evaluate the density-dependent mortality rate at K=600K = 600: mdd(600)=0.00080×600=0.48m_{\text{dd}}(600) = 0.00080 \times 600 = 0.48.

  6. Compare the two rates: because 0.48>0.120.48 > 0.12, density-dependent mortality dominates, representing 0.480.60=80%\frac{0.48}{0.60} = 80\% of all mortality.

Final answer

(a) N∗=150 beetles/kgN^* = 150\text{ beetles/kg}; (b) K=600 beetles/kgK = 600\text{ beetles/kg}, and density-dependent mortality dominates (mdd=0.48m_{\text{dd}} = 0.48 vs. mdi=0.12m_{\text{di}} = 0.12).

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Practice combining multiple mortality and birth factors additively when formulating net growth equations (rnet=r0−∑mir_{\text{net}} = r_0 - \sum m_i).

  • Always check that intermediate per capita rates lie within realistic biological bounds (0≤m≤10 \le m \le 1).

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student miscalculates the decimal division by shifting the decimal point one place too few when determining the threshold density.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    mdd(N∗)=mdi  ⟹  0.00080N∗=0.12m_{\text{dd}}(N^*) = m_{\text{di}} \implies 0.00080 N^* = 0.12

  2. Step 2

    N∗=15 individuals/kgN^* = 15\text{ individuals/kg}

    Correct

    N∗=0.120.00080=150 individuals/kgN^* = \frac{0.12}{0.00080} = 150\text{ individuals/kg}

    When dividing 0.120.12 by 0.000800.00080, you shifted the decimal point by one place too few, writing 1515 instead of 150150.

  3. Step 3

    mdd(K)+mdi=r0  ⟹  0.00080K+0.12=0.60  ⟹  0.00080K=0.48  ⟹  K=600 individuals/kgm_{\text{dd}}(K) + m_{\text{di}} = r_0 \implies 0.00080 K + 0.12 = 0.60 \implies 0.00080 K = 0.48 \implies K = 600\text{ individuals/kg}

  4. Step 4

    mdd(600)=0.48>0.12, so density-dependent mortality dominatesm_{\text{dd}}(600) = 0.48 > 0.12\text{, so density-dependent mortality dominates}

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified the mathematical condition for equating density-dependent and density-independent mortality rates.

You accurately formulated the total mortality balance equation at carrying capacity.

You correctly calculated the carrying capacity and determined which mortality factor dominates at that population density.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Decimal point shift error in decimal division

You miscalculated 0.120.00080\frac{0.12}{0.00080} as 1515 instead of 150150 due to a decimal shift slip.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Dividing small decimal numbers without first converting them into scientific notation or clearing matching powers of ten often leads to dropped or misplaced zeros.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Clear Decimals by Multiplying Powers of Ten
  • To divide decimals ab\frac{a}{b}, multiply both the numerator and denominator by 10k10^k where kk is the number of decimal digits in the denominator.

  • Rewrite 0.120.00080\frac{0.12}{0.00080} as 0.12×100,0000.00080×100,000=12,00080=1,2008=150\frac{0.12 \times 100{,}000}{0.00080 \times 100{,}000} = \frac{12{,}000}{80} = \frac{1{,}200}{8} = 150 before simplifying.

Order of Magnitude Sanity Check
  • Check your quotient against nearby reference values or unit magnitudes to ensure the power of ten is realistic.

  • Notice that 0.00080×10=0.0080.00080 \times 10 = 0.008 and 0.00080×100=0.080.00080 \times 100 = 0.08. Since 0.12>0.080.12 > 0.08, the quotient must exceed 100100.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. N∗=0.120.00080N^* = \frac{0.12}{0.00080}

  2. N∗=12×10−28×10−4=1.5×102=150 individuals/kgN^* = \frac{12 \times 10^{-2}}{8 \times 10^{-4}} = 1.5 \times 10^2 = 150\text{ individuals/kg}

Final answer

(a) N∗=150 individuals/kgN^* = 150\text{ individuals/kg}; (b) K=600 individuals/kgK = 600\text{ individuals/kg}, and density-dependent mortality dominates.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Practice converting small decimal quotients into scientific notation before dividing.

  • Perform quick mental estimation checks on powers of ten after solving linear rate equations.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A fish population in a lake has a density-independent fishing mortality of mdi=0.05m_{\text{di}} = 0.05 and a density-dependent mortality from disease of mdd(N)=0.0005Nm_{\text{dd}}(N) = 0.0005 N, where NN is fish per hectare. If the intrinsic birth rate is r0=0.25r_0 = 0.25, find the carrying capacity KK.

Answer

K=400 fish/hectareK = 400\text{ fish/hectare}. Set total mortality equal to birth rate: mdi+mdd(K)=r0  ⟹  0.05+0.0005K=0.25  ⟹  0.0005K=0.20  ⟹  K=0.200.0005=400m_{\text{di}} + m_{\text{dd}}(K) = r_0 \implies 0.05 + 0.0005 K = 0.25 \implies 0.0005 K = 0.20 \implies K = \frac{0.20}{0.0005} = 400.

02

An aphid population on greenhouse crops has per capita reproduction r0=0.80r_0 = 0.80, density-independent weather mortality mdi=0.20m_{\text{di}} = 0.20, and ladybug predation mortality mdd(N)=0.003Nm_{\text{dd}}(N) = 0.003 N. (a) Find the carrying capacity KK. (b) Determine the percentage of total mortality caused by predation at carrying capacity.

Answer

(a) K=200 aphids/leafK = 200\text{ aphids/leaf}. Set 0.20+0.003K=0.80  ⟹  0.003K=0.60  ⟹  K=2000.20 + 0.003 K = 0.80 \implies 0.003 K = 0.60 \implies K = 200. (b) 75%75\%. At KK, predation mortality is mdd(200)=0.003(200)=0.60m_{\text{dd}}(200) = 0.003(200) = 0.60. Total mortality is 0.800.80. Thus, 0.600.80×100%=75%\frac{0.60}{0.80} \times 100\% = 75\%.

03

A rodent population has constant baseline mortality mdi=0.15m_{\text{di}} = 0.15 and density-dependent territorial mortality mdd(N)=cNm_{\text{dd}}(N) = cN. At carrying capacity K=500 individuals/km2K = 500\text{ individuals/km}^2, density-dependent mortality accounts for exactly 70%70\% of all deaths. Calculate the constant cc and the per capita birth rate r0r_0.

Answer

c=0.0007 km2/individualc = 0.0007\text{ km}^2/\text{individual} and r0=0.50r_0 = 0.50. Since density-independent mortality accounts for the remaining 30%30\%, total mortality is mtotal=0.150.30=0.50m_{\text{total}} = \frac{0.15}{0.30} = 0.50, so r0=0.50r_0 = 0.50. Density-dependent mortality is mdd(K)=0.50−0.15=0.35m_{\text{dd}}(K) = 0.50 - 0.15 = 0.35. Then c(500)=0.35  ⟹  c=0.35500=0.0007c(500) = 0.35 \implies c = \frac{0.35}{500} = 0.0007.

Loading workspace…