Resources
A sample of human red blood cells is suspended in an aqueous solution containing both sodium chloride (, which fully dissociates into two ions, ) and urea. The cell membrane is freely permeable to urea via facilitated diffusion uniporters (reflection coefficient ), but completely impermeable to and (reflection coefficient ). The cytosol of the erythrocytes has an initial non-penetrating solute osmolarity of and an initial urea concentration of . (a) Calculate the total initial osmolarity of the extracellular solution. (b) Calculate the effective extracellular tonicity (effective osmolarity) that drives long-term steady-state water movement. (c) Predict the net direction of water flow at long-term steady-state equilibrium and the resulting change in cell volume relative to initial baseline.
Answer and steps
Final answer
(a) Total initial external osmolarity: ; (b) Effective extracellular tonicity: ; (c) Net water enters the cell until cytosol osmolarity reaches of non-penetrating solutes; the cell swells to times () its initial volume.
Steps
Part (a): Total Initial Extracellular Osmolarity
1. Identify solute contributions to total osmolarity: Osmolarity measures the total number of solute particles per liter of solution, regardless of whether they can cross the cell membrane: where is the van 't Hoff factor and is the molar concentration.
- For sodium chloride ():
- For urea (a non-dissociating molecule, ):
2. Sum the individual osmolarities:
Part (b): Effective Extracellular Tonicity
1. Distinguish between penetrating and non-penetrating solutes:
- Non-penetrating solutes ( and , reflection coefficient ) cannot cross the lipid bilayer, so they exert a permanent osmotic force that drives net water movement.
- Penetrating solutes (urea, reflection coefficient ) freely diffuse across the red blood cell membrane via uniporters until their concentrations inside and outside the cell equilibrate. As a result, they do not exert an effective long-term osmotic pressure.
2. Calculate effective osmolarity (tonicity):
Part (c): Long-Term Water Movement and Final Cell Volume
1. Determine the tonicity relative to the cell interior:
- Initial intracellular non-penetrating osmolarity .
- Effective extracellular osmolarity .
Because the effective extracellular osmolarity () is lower than the intracellular non-penetrating osmolarity (), the solution is hypotonic.
Common Pitfall: Even though the solution is initially isosmotic to the cell ( vs. ), it is hypotonic because penetrating solutes cannot generate a sustained osmotic gradient.
2. Predict net water flow: Urea diffuses into the erythrocyte until . Meanwhile, water moves down its osmotic gradient into the cell to dilute the higher concentration of trapped non-penetrating intracellular solutes.
3. Calculate the final equilibrium volume: At steady state, the intracellular concentration of non-penetrating solutes must equal the extracellular concentration of non-penetrating solutes ().
Since the total amount of non-penetrating solute inside the cell () remains constant:
Net water enters the erythrocyte until the cytosol non-penetrating osmolarity decreases to , causing the cell to swell to times () of its initial volume.
Typical errors
01 The student treats urea as an effective osmolyte contributing to tonicity, wrongly concluding that total osmolarity determines long-term water flow and that the cell volume will not change.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
- Step 2Correct
You treated urea as an effective osmolyte. Because the cell membrane is freely permeable to urea (reflection coefficient ), urea equilibrates across the bilayer and does not exert an effective osmotic force at steady state. Only non-penetrating solutes (, ) contribute to effective tonicity.
- Step 3
Because the extracellular solution is and intracellular osmolarity is , the solution is isotonic, resulting in no net water flow and no change in cell volume.
CorrectNet water flows into the cell down the osmotic gradient generated by trapped intracellular solutes until internal non-penetrating osmolarity reaches ; final volume is ( of baseline).
Because your effective osmolarity was set to , you concluded the solution is isotonic. In reality, the effective extracellular osmolarity () is lower than the initial intracellular non-penetrating osmolarity (), making the solution hypotonic.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly calculated the total initial osmolarity by applying the van 't Hoff factor for and summing the solute concentrations.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou assumed that total chemical osmolarity governs long-term water movement, overlooking the reflection coefficient () of penetrating solutes like urea. Solutes that freely permeate the membrane equilibrate between compartments and cannot maintain a permanent osmotic gradient.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Osmolarity vs. Tonicity
, where for non-penetrating solutes and for freely penetrating solutes.
Exclude all penetrating solutes () when calculating effective osmolarity and determining tonicity.
- Steady-State Cell Volume
for trapped, non-penetrating solutes.
Equate the intracellular concentration of non-penetrating solutes to the extracellular non-penetrating osmolarity to calculate volume change.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationCalculate the effective extracellular osmolarity by weighting each solute by its reflection coefficient: .
Compare the effective external tonicity () to the intracellular non-penetrating solute concentration (); since , the solution is hypotonic.
Set up conservation of non-penetrating intracellular solutes: , which yields .
(a) ; (b) ; (c) Net water flows into the cell; the cell swells to times () its initial baseline volume.
02 The student forgets that NaCl dissociates into two ions, underestimating both total osmolarity and effective tonicity.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1Correct
You added the molar concentrations directly without multiplying by its dissociation factor (). Because each formula unit of dissociates into two particles ( and ), its contribution is , bringing the total initial osmolarity to .
- Step 2Correct
You correctly identified that penetrating solutes with do not contribute to tonicity, but your numerical answer was affected by omitting the dissociation of in Step 1. The non-penetrating ions contribute .
- Step 3
Because effective extracellular osmolarity () is less than intracellular osmolarity (), water flows into the cells, causing swelling.
CorrectBecause the effective extracellular osmolarity () is less than the intracellular non-penetrating osmolarity (), net water flows into the cell until , swelling the cell to times () its initial volume.
You correctly concluded that the solution is hypotonic and that water enters the cell to cause swelling. However, your comparison used the propagated value of , and you did not compute the quantitative final volume relative to the baseline.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly excluded the penetrating solute (urea) from the effective osmolarity calculation.
You correctly identified the solution as hypotonic relative to the cell cytosol.
You correctly predicted that water enters the cell and causes it to swell.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou treated as an intact single particle rather than multiplying its molar concentration by .
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou confused molarity with osmolarity for strong electrolytes, overlooking the fact that colligative properties and osmotic pressure depend on the total concentration of dissolved particles produced after full ionic dissociation.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Account for Ionic Dissociation
For any solute dissociating into ions, .
Always check the van 't Hoff factor before calculating osmolarity; strong electrolytes like yield multiple solute particles per mole.
- Compute Final Volume via Conservation of Solute
At steady state, for trapped non-penetrating solutes.
Set the final intracellular non-penetrating concentration equal to the extracellular non-penetrating concentration to calculate .
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstrationand , so .
.
Compare effective tonicities: (hypotonic). Water moves in until , so .
(a) ; (b) ; (c) Net water enters the cell; the cell swells to times () its initial volume.
03 The student inverts the osmotic gradient direction, mistakenly stating that water flows down the solute concentration gradient from hypotonic to hypertonic compartments.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
- Step 2
- Step 3
Because the outside solution has a lower effective osmolarity () than the inside (), water flows out of the cell toward the lower solute concentration, causing cell shrinkage.
CorrectBecause the extracellular effective osmolarity () is less than the intracellular non-penetrating osmolarity (), the solution is hypotonic. Water flows into the cell down its water chemical potential gradient until the cytosol osmolarity dilutes to , causing the cell to swell to ( of baseline volume).
You correctly identified that the extracellular solution has a lower effective osmolarity, but you inverted the direction of water movement. In osmosis, water moves from an area of lower solute concentration (hypotonic) to higher solute concentration (hypertonic) to dilute the trapped solutes, so water enters the cell and causes it to swell.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly calculated the total initial osmolarity using the van 't Hoff factor for .
You correctly applied the reflection coefficient to exclude urea from the effective extracellular tonicity calculation.
You correctly compared the extracellular effective osmolarity () to the intracellular non-penetrating osmolarity ().
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou stated that water flows toward the lower solute concentration instead of toward the higher solute concentration.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisConflating solute diffusion with solvent osmosis. Solute molecules diffuse from high to low solute concentration, but water (the solvent) diffuses down its own concentration gradient, meaning water moves from low solute concentration (high water potential) to high solute concentration (low water potential).
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Direction of Osmotic Flow
Water always flows net toward the compartment with the higher concentration of non-penetrating solutes (from hypotonic to hypertonic).
When a solution has lower effective osmolarity than the cell interior, identify it as hypotonic and direct water flow into the cell.
- Equilibrium Cell Volume
At osmotic steady state, trapped non-penetrating solutes satisfy .
Solve for final volume using to determine whether the cell swells () or shrinks ().
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationClassify the extracellular solution relative to the cell: because the external effective osmolarity () is lower than the internal non-penetrating osmolarity (), the solution is hypotonic.
Determine the net direction of water flow: water flows down its chemical potential gradient from the hypotonic solution into the hypertonic cell interior.
Calculate the final steady-state volume using conservation of intracellular non-penetrating solutes: , which yields .
(a) Total initial external osmolarity: ; (b) Effective extracellular tonicity: ; (c) Net water enters the cell until cytosol non-penetrating osmolarity reaches ; the cell swells to times () its initial volume.
Lock it in
What is the fundamental difference between osmolarity and tonicity?
Osmolarity counts all dissolved solute particles per liter regardless of membrane permeability, whereas tonicity depends solely on the concentration of non-penetrating solutes.
Similar question
A red blood cell with an initial internal non-penetrating osmolarity of is placed in a solution containing glycerol (penetrating, ) and (, non-penetrating, ). Calculate: (a) total initial osmolarity, (b) effective tonicity, and (c) the final steady-state volume relative to baseline.
Answer
(a) . (b) . (c) Because effective external osmolarity equals internal non-penetrating osmolarity (), the solution is isotonic; final volume remains ().
A mammalian cell with an intracellular non-penetrating solute concentration of is placed into an extracellular solution of (assumed , non-penetrating, ) and ethanol (penetrating, ). If the extracellular concentration is then diluted by half with pure water, what is the new equilibrium cell volume relative to initial volume?
Answer
After dilution, , so effective non-penetrating osmolarity is . At equilibrium, , so ( of baseline volume).
An erythrocyte ( non-penetrating solutes, initial volume ) is suspended in an aqueous solution containing (, ), glucose (non-penetrating in this specific cell line, ), and urea (penetrating, ). If red blood cells lyse when their volume expands beyond , determine whether lysis occurs at long-term equilibrium.
Answer
Effective non-penetrating osmolarity (urea contributes ). Final volume is . Since , the cell exceeds its maximal hemolytic volume and lyses.